Otro Cinco Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 78 votes
Otro Cinco Logo

Choose My State

NY

Otro Cinco Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


DrinksDrinks

Tropicana Orange Juice

$2.50

Martinelli Apple Juice

$3.50

Virgil's Cola

$3.50

Virgil's Root Beer

$3.50

Cranberry Juice

$2.50

Lemonade

$3.50

Soda

$2.25

San Pellegrino

$2.50

Coconut Water

$3.75

Mt. Valley Spring Water

$3.50

Perrier Sparkling Water

$2.50

Jarritos

$2.50


Coffee and EspressoCoffee and Espresso

Coffee

$2.00 - $3.00

Espresso

$2.00

Americano

$2.00

Red Eye

$3.25

Cup of fresh coffee with a double shot of espresso.

Macchiato

$3.25

Shot of espresso with a dollop of foamed milk.

Cappuccino

$3.75

Espresso and foamed milk.

Latte

$3.75 - $4.75

Espresso and steamed milk.

Cafe Mocha

$3.75 - $4.75

Espresso and steamed milk with hot chocolate.

Vanilla Latte

$4.25 - $5.25

Espresso and steamed milk with vanilla flavor and a pinch of cinnamon.

Caramel Latte

$4.25 - $5.25

Espresso and steamed milk with caramel flavor.

Hot Chocolate

$3.00 - $3.50


BreakfastBreakfast

2 Eggs with Toast

$4.50

3 Eggs with Toast

$5.00

Torta

$6.75

Sliced with ranchero sauce.

Breakfast Sandwich

$5.50

With egg and cheese.

Rosalita

$6.75

Hard-boiled eggs, roasted peppers, tomato slices and bread.

Huevos Rancheros

$7.75

Breakfast Burrito

$7.75

Two eggs or vegan tofu scramble with home fries, cheese, salsa and sour cream.

Sinatra

$9.00

Fried eggs, beans, rice, avocado, roasted tomato and peppers.

Miami Special

$9.00

Tofu scramble, beans, spinach and avocado.

Migas

$9.00

Scrambled eggs, strip of corn tortilla, beans and potatoes.

Breakfast Tacos

$7.75

Fried eggs, beans, cilantro, cheese, salsa and a side of ranchero sauce.

Yogurt Parfaits

$5.50

Fresh Fruit

$5.50


SoupSoup

Spanish Onion and Potato Soup

$4.50 - $6.75

Soup of the Day

$5.50 - $7.25


SaladsSalads

Chicken Avocado and Corn Salsa Salad

$11.25

With tomato threads, queso fresco cheese, orange chipotle vinaigrette.

House Greens Salad

$7.75

With cucumber, tomato, chick peas, carrots and artichoke.

Taco Salad

$12.25

Mixed greens, chips, beans, avocado, tomatillo salsa, queso fresco and three grilled shrimp.

V8 Salad

$9.00

Spinach, tomato, cucumbers, artichoke, corn, carrots, chick peas and hard-boiled egg with garlic lemon parsley dressing.

Lobster Salad

$19.00

Over mixed greens with shredded carrots, corn, tomato and tortilla threads with creamy avocado and ginger dressing.

Fresa Salad

$13.50

Spinach, mixed greens, strawberries, almonds and sliced avocado with sweet orange chipotle dressing.


TapasTapas

Mussels

$7.75

With sherry cream and tomato.

Mini Mushroom and Spinach Quesadilla

$6.75

Clams

$6.75

With green sauce, potato and fresh mushroom.

Garlic Shrimp

$7.75

Crispy Calamari

$10.00

With cumin, salt, pepper and lemon saffron mayo.

Flash-Fried Shishito Peppers

$6.75

Patatas Bravas

$6.75

Crispy potatoes with smoked paprica mayo.

Octopus

$9.00

With black bean and harissa oil.

Melted Membrillo and Goat Cheese Toast

$7.75

Sauteed Kale and Spinach

$7.75

With raisin and pinenut sherry.

Crispy Sardines

$9.00

With lemon and saffron roll.

Olives with Goat Cheese

$7.75


TacosTacos

Sauteed Mushroom and Spinach Tacos

$6.75 - $10.00

With red chile sauce. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.

Crispy Tofu Tacos

$6.75 - $10.00

With shredded carrots, pickled onion and BBQ sauce. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.

Mahi Tacos

$10.00 - $13.50

Sauteed or crispy mahi with habanero XXX sauce. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.

Shredded Chicken Tacos

$7.75 - $11.25

With red chile sauce. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.

Shrimp Tacos

$9.00 - $12.25

Sauteed or crispy shrimp with orange and chipotle pepper sauce. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.

Lobster Tacos

$15.00 - $19.00

With corn salsa and avocado ginger mayo. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.

Vegetable Mix Tacos

$5.00 - $8.00

With zucchini, peppers, corn, onion, carrots and chipotle mayo. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.

Black Bean and Avocado Tacos

$6.75 - $10.00

With red chile sauce. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.

Crispy Catfish Tacos

$10.00 - $13.50

With pickled onion and chipotle mayo. Made with corn tortillas and served with cabbage slaw, salsa and fresh cilantro.


BurritosBurritos

Shrimp Burrito

$12.25

With avocado, tomatillo salsa, rice, cheese, cabbage and orange chipotle sauce.

Chicken Burrito

$7.75

With rice, beans, cheese, salsa and sour cream.

Catfish Burrito

$12.25

With yellow rice, cabbage slaw, pickled onion, chipotle mayo, cheese and salsa.

Bean and Cheese Burrito

$7.25

With rice, salsa and sour cream.

Mushroom and Spinach Burrito

$9.00

With beans, salsa, cheese, brown rice and sour cream.

Crispy Tofu Burrito

$10.00

With brown rice, cabbage, salsa, avocado, shredded carrots and BBQ sauce.

La Paz Burrito

$11.25

With steamed quinoa, mushroom, spinach, corn, salsa and black beans wrapped in a gluten-free tortilla with green sauce.

Lobster Burrito

$15.75

With cabbage slaw, corn, salsa, rice and ginger avocado mayo.

Otro Cinco Special Burrito

$11.25

With sauteed veggies, zucchini, carrots, peppers, onion, corn, brown rice, black beans, salsa and orange pepper sauce.

Mahi Burrito

$13.50

With habanero XXX sauce, cabbage, chipotle mayo, rice, avocado and tomatillo sauce.


QuesadillasQuesadillas

Chicken Quesadilla

$9.00

Made with shredded jack cheddar cheese.

BBQ Chicken Quesadilla

$10.00

Made with shredded jack cheddar cheese.

Catifish Quesadilla

$12.25

With red chile sauce and shredded cabbage. Made with shredded jack cheddar cheese.

Shrimp Quesadilla

$13.50

With green sauce and shredded cabbage. Made with shredded jack cheddar cheese.

Mushroom and Spinach Quesadilla

$10.00

Made with shredded jack cheddar cheese.

Otro Cinco Special Quesadilla

$9.00

With sauteed veggies. Made with shredded jack cheddar cheese.

Sonora Quesadilla

$10.00

Avocado, black beans, cabbage, salsa and chipotle mayo. Made with shredded jack cheddar cheese.


PlatesPlates

Chipotle BBQ Shrimp Plate

$18.00

With sauteed spinach, slaw, black beans and steamed quinoa.

Mahi Plate

$20.00

With habanero, avocado and tomatillo salsa, sauteed greens and yellow rice.

Crispy Tofu Plate

$13.50

With orange chipotle sauce, salad, black beans and brown rice.

Super Cinco Plate

$15.70

Steamed quinoa, black beans, avocado and tomatillo salsa with sauteed Otro mixed vegetables.


PaellaPaella

Mariscos Paella

$25.75

Clams, mussels, shrimp and calamari. Served with calasparra rice, fresh snap peas, saffron broth, onions and peppers. This dish takes 30 minutes to prepare.

Chicken and Green Olive Paella

$24.75

Served with calasparra rice, fresh snap peas, saffron broth, onions and peppers. This dish takes 30 minutes to prepare.

Vegetarian Paella

$22.50

Spinach, zucchini, mushrooms, onions and peppers. Served with calasparra rice, fresh snap peas, saffron broth, onions and peppers. This dish takes 30 minutes to prepare.


SidesSides

Avocado Slices

$3.50

Habanero Sauce

$2.00

Brown Rice

$3.00

Yellow Rice

$3.00

Steamed Quinoa

$3.00

Beans

$3.00

Steamed Tortillas

$2.50

Chips

$2.00

Side Salad

$3.50

Steamed Spinach

$5.00

Crispy Shrimp

$6.00

Catfish Strips

$6.00

Shredded Chicken

$3.00

Goat Cheese

$3.00

Cornbread with Orange and Chipotle Butter

$3.00

Chips and Salsa

$3.75

Chips and 3 Salsas

$9.00

Avocado, fresh tomato and corn.

Cabbage Slaw

$3.00

Made fresh daily with cilantro and lime.

Fried Potatoes

$4.00 - $7.00

Corn Salsa

$3.00 - $5.00

Tomatilla Salsa

$3.00 - $5.00

Salsa

$2.00 - $5.00

Sour Cream

$2.00 - $3.25

House Made Pickled Jalapenos

$2.00 - $3.50

Chips with Avocado and Tomatillo Salsa

$6.75


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading