Old World Cheese Shop Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 180 votes
Old World Cheese Shop Logo

Choose My State

FL

Old World Cheese Shop Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


DrinksDrinks

Canned Soda

$0.93

Bottled Water

$1.00

Fountain Drink

$1.40

Arizona Ice Tea

$2.00

Boylan's Cream Soda

$1.50

Made with cane sugar.


SaladsSalads

Greek Salad

$6.50

Lettuce, hard boiled eggs, tomato, green pepper, olives, feta cheese and potato salad.

Chef Salad

$6.50

Ham, turkey, roast beef, imported cheese and seasonal vegetables on fresh greens.

Tossed Salad

$4.95

Salad greens and seasonal vegetables.

Stuffed Tomato

$6.50

Choice of chicken salad, tuna or ham salad. Choice of potato salad or Marconi salad.

Caesar Salad

$4.95

Served with cheese, mushrooms and croutons.

Taco Salad

$6.50

Choice of beef or chicken, includes tortilla chips, black olives, onions, refried beans, cheese and salsa.

Homemade Salad Plate

$5.95

Chicken salad, tuna and macaroni salad on a bed of lettuce with a hard boiled egg, tomato and fruit cup or cottage cheese.


Specialty SandwichesSpecialty Sandwiches

The Ultimate

$6.75

Thinly sliced rare roast beef, melted brie cheese served on croissant, topped with creamy horseradish dressing.

Hot Pastrami

$6.75

Absolutely delicious with dark mustard on rye or pumpernickel.

Corned Beef

$6.75

Absolutely delicious with dark mustard on rye or pumpernickel.

Sherwood Forest

$6.75

Juicy corned beef, spicy hot pastrami, our own creamy Cole slaw and Russian dressing on pumpernickel bread.


Grilled SandwichesGrilled Sandwiches

Friar Tuck

$6.75

A grilled triple Decker made with ham, sliced breast of turkey, Genoa salami, dill pickle, fjordland cheese and golden dressing on pumpernickel bread.

Maid Marian

$6.75

Turkey, ham, bacon, pickle, fjordland cheese, all piled high on an onion roll, then grilled to perfection.

King Rubin

$6.95

Our great hot corned beef, fjordland cheese, German sauerkraut, dark mustard or Russian dressing on pumpernickel bread, grilled.

Tink-the-tinker

$6.75

Mounds of ham, bacon, melted fjordland cheese, topped with our homemade spicy hot-sweet tinker sauce, grilled on rye.

Muffeletta

$6.75

Salami, ham, provolone cheese, then covered with our own delicious olive salad, served on a grilled onion roll.

Nottingham Castle

$6.95

Double layer of fjordland cheese, breast of turkey, ham, salami, roast beef, thinly sliced onion, tomato, pickle and olive salad on an onion roll, then grilled to perfection.

Rocky's Road

$6.75

Roast beef, turkey breast, bacon, fjordland cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and golden dressing, grilled on an onion roll.

Have You Tried Our Cuban Sandwich

$6.50

Grilled to perfection with pork, ham, salami, pickle, mustard, mayo and fjordland Swiss cheese.


Cold SandwichesCold Sandwiches

Robin Hood

$6.75

Three slices of pumpernickel bread, delicious sliced breast of turkey, ham, bacon, fjordland cheese, lettuce, tomato, topped with our own golden dressing.

Little John

$6.75

Delicious rare roast beef, thinly-sliced sweet onion and tomato, topped with our own creamy horseradish dressing on pumpernickel.

Prince John

$6.75

Thinly-sliced rare roast beef, accented by coleslaw and Russian dressing between two slices of sourdough rye bread.

Tinkerbelle

$6.75

Delightfully delicious roast beef, marinated mushrooms, bacon with savory garlic sauce on pumpernickel bread.

Sheriff of Nottingham

$8.25

Roast beef, turkey, ham, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing, piled high on five slices of pumpernickel bread.

Chick-or-EE

$6.50

Our homemade chicken salad, ham, lettuce and tomato on pumpernickel bread with our funny honey dressing.

Alan-a-Dale

$5.75

Fresh egg salad, smothered with ham, crispy lettuce and tomato, served on pumpernickel bread.


PitasPitas

This is Italian

$6.50

Pita stuffed with lettuce, tomato, ham, salami, onion, provolone cheese with vinegar and oil dressing.

St. Pitas Berg

$6.25

Sliced breast of turkey, fjordland cheese, lettuce, tomato and our own golden dressing, served in a pita pocket.

Pita Fhonda

$6.25

Award winning tuna salad, crispy shredded lettuce, topped with tomato, in pita bread.

Pita, Pita, Punkin Eata

$6.25

Fresh chicken salad with slivered almonds, lettuce and tomato served in pita bread.


Veggie LoversVeggie Lovers

Too Mutch

$5.95

Mounds of sprouts, tomato, onion, thinly-sliced pickle, green pepper and fjordland cheese between two slices of sourdough rye. Dressed with our golden dressing.

Garden of Edam

$5.95

Crunchy sprouts, tomato, guacamole, topped with melted cheese, served on whole wheat bread.


Sides

Side of Macaroni Salad

$0.89

Side of Potato Salad

$0.89

Side of Coleslaw

$0.89


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading