Menu With Price > Menu > Old Mill Inn

Old Mill Inn Menu and Prices

3.8 based on 140 votes
Old Mill Inn Logo

Choose My State

NY PA

Old Mill Inn Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Soups

Soup of the Day

$7.00

Freshly made from seasonal ingredients

Award Winning Clam Chowder

$8.00

Salads

North Fork Green

$8.00

Satur farm mesclun, wickham’s cucumber & tomato, red onion, roasted garlic balsamic dressing

Fig & Goat Cheese

$13.00

Satur farm mesclun, praline walnuts, catapano chevre, caramelized shallot & sherry vinaigrette

Baby Beet & Wickham’s Apple

$13.00

Greens, shaved fennel, onion, grapeseed oil, apple cider reduction

Small Plates

Pommes Frites

$7.00

Tomato or chipotle ketchup, yellow pepper ketchup & aioli

Crab Cake

$13.00

Crispy crab cake, yogurt & cucumber relish

Clams Bill McCoy

$9.00

6 Little neck’s, broiled w/ bread crumbs and herbs

Fried Peconic Bay Calamari

$12.00

Crispy calamari, marinara sauce

Clams on the Half Shell

$8.00 - $15.00

Little necks w/ cocktail sauce & lemon

Oysters on the Half Shell

$12.00 - $18.00

Steamed Mussels

$14.00

Steamed Mussels Belgian-Style

$15.00

From The Sea

Fish & Chips

$14.00

Fried beer-battered fresh cod filet w/ fries

Fritto di Mare

$17.00

Mixed fried seafood platter w/ fries, aioli

Luncheon Salads

Grilled Chicken & Horseradish

$15.00

Greens, wickham’s apple, cucumber, beet, creamy horseradish dressing

Shrimp Cobb

$16.00

Bacon, blue cheese, grilled local corn, wickham’s tomato, latham’s cucumber, radish, onion & baby mixed lettuces

Grilled Tuna

$16.00

Tuna steak over a salad of local tomato, radish, onion, corn & mixed baby lettuces, roasted garlic balsamic

Sandwiches Board

Flounder

$14.00

Breaded filet, lettuce, tomato, parker house roll

Tuna Burger

$16.00

6 oz. Fresh tuna filet, ginger or cucumber relish, wasabi mayo, brioche bun

Lobster Roll

$18.00

New england classic: Lobster salad on a bun

Grilled Chicken

$15.00

Chicken breast, tomato, greens, mozzarella, green mayo, parker house roll

Burger

$13.00

8 oz. Pineland farms1 natural beef, tomato, brioche bun, homemade chipotle ketchup, served with coop’s hand-cut fries and a pickle. cheese, bacon, sauteed onions $1.00 extra each

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands