Old Key Lime House Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 116 votes
Old Key Lime House Logo
Seafood

Choose My State

FL

Old Key Lime House Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Dessert

Homemade Key Lime Pie

$6.00

Creme Brule Cheesecake

$6.00

Ultimate Chocolate Cake

$6.00


Appetizers & Salads

Chilled Gazpach

$5.00

Chilled Shrimp Gazpacho

$7.00

Maine Lobster Bisque

$7.00

New England Clam

$6.00

Fire Roasted Escargot

$10.00

Escargot and mushrooms in a basil scampi butter with garlic bread stick

Fresh Peel-N-Eat Gulf Shrimp

$12.00

A half pound served hot or cold

Ocean Fresh Fish Fingers

$9.00

Today's Fresh catch with tartar sauce

Crabmeat Stuffed Mushrooms

$10.00

Mushroom caps overflowing with crab meat and topped with parmesan cheese

Buffalo Chicken Wings

$8.00

Ten jumbo wings Served Mild, medium or hot with celery and blue cheese

Quesadilla Grande

$10.00 - $9.00

Cheddar and jack cheese, tomatoes, sour cream and salsa on the side

Crispy Island Calamari

$10.00

Crispy crunchy with marinara sauce

Spinach and Artichoke Dip

$10.00

Spinach and Artichokes with jack and cheddar cheese, tricolor tortilla chips

Warm Blue Crab Dip

$10.00

A spicy combination of crab meat, cream cheese and seasonings

South Of The Border Nachos

$9.00 - $10.00

Jack and cheddar cheese, chili,jalapenos and tomatoes served with sour cream salsa and guacamole

Hickory Smoked Fish Dip

$10.00

Served in a fried tortilla shell with diced tomatoes, jalapenos and Bermuda onion served with saltines

Classic Caesar Salad

$7.00 - $10.00

Blackened Sea Bass

$12.00

Tortilla Chicken Salad

$10.00

Mixed greens, roasted chicken, tortilla chips, roasted red peppers, black beans, black olives, jack & cheddar cheese, sundried tomatoes with an avocado-ranch dressing

Key West Seafood Salad

$14.00

Mixed baby greens, shrimp, crab meat, hearts of palm, asparagus, tomato, black olives and cantaloupe with a side of mango vinaigrette dressing

Roasted Chicken BLT Salad

$12.00

Mixed greens, roasted chicken, applewood smoked bacon, and diced tomatoes and sourdough croutons in a caesar and roasted chive vinaigrette


FavoritesSandwiches have a choice of side and served on seven grain kaiser roll

Tacos

$9.00 - $10.00

Two soft tacos served with lettuce, tomato, jack cheddar cheese and sour cream

Fresh Mahi Sandwich

$12.00

Grilled, blackened or fried

Crab Cake Sandwich

$12.00

Jumbo lump crab no fillers, served broiled or fried

Fried Shrimp Basket

$10.00 - $18.00

Southern fried gulf shrimp

Island Style Wraps

Price may varies

Tropical Mango Chicken Salad

$10.00

With lettuce and tomato on seven grain bread

Chicken & Brie Sandwich

$10.00

Blackened chicken with sauteed onions and brie cheese

Seabass Sandwich

$10.00

Grilled, fried or blackened.

Herb Chicken Sandwich

$9.00

Grilled chicken with tomato bruschettti and cilantro sauce

Black Angus Burger

$7.00

Add $1.00 for cheese or bacon

Fish & Chips Basket

$10.00


Classics

Mahi Maid Island Style

$19.00

Fresh mahi mahi baked with tomatoes, bermuda onion, green onions, peppers, roasted garlic, sherry, fresh basil, lemon pepper, and white wine

Roasted Cedar Plank Salmon

$19.00

Fresh Salmon roasted on aged cedar and brushed with honey mustard finished with a tropical key lime beurre blanc

Key Lime Margarita Chicken

$16.00

Roasted marinated breast topped with a toasted panko bread crumb crust served with key lime bue blanc

Crab Stuffed Gulf Shrimp

$21.00

Gulf shrimp stuffed with seasoned crab meat and oven roasted

Macadamia Crusted Fish

$21.00

Fresh white fish crusted in toasted macadamias finished with a tropical key lime beurre blanc

Key Lime Coconut Shrimp

$21.00

Gulf shrimp served golden brown with papaya chutney

Roasted Atlantic Salmon

$19.00

Fresh atlantic salmon oven roasted and topped with a tomato bruchetta

Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna

$21.00

Hawaiia naki tuna crusted in toasted sesame seeds and pan seared served with wasabi and asian hoisin sauce

Maryland Style Crab Cakes

$26.00

Jumbo lump crab meat seasoned and Served broiled or fried

Florida Lobster Tail

$26.00

One half pound tail served with drawn butter and fresh lemon

Fresh Hand Cut Sirloin

$21.00

10 Ounce center cut seasoned with steak house spices and pan seared

Garlic Lovers Scampi

$19.00

Gulf shrimp sauteed in garlic, butter, fresh basil and seasonings over linguini served with a garlic bread stick

Key West Shrimp & Scallops

$19.00

Gulf shrimp and sea scallops sauteed with seasoned garlic and herb butter

Coconut Crusted Fish

$19.00

Fresh white fish coconut crusted with a tropical key lime beurre blanc


Sides

Seasoned Vegetables

$3.00

Fresh Fruit

$3.00

Basket of Fries

$4.00

Rice

$2.00

Garbe Bread Sticks

$2.00

Mashed Potatoes

$3.00

Black Beans & Rice

$2.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading