Old Homestead Steakhouse Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 292 votes
Old Homestead Steakhouse Logo
Steak

Choose My State

NJ NV

Old Homestead Steakhouse Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Colossal Crab Cake

$27.00

Blue lump crab, mustard sauce

Crisp Calamari

$22.00

Marinara, tartar sauce

Seared Foie Gras*

$27.00

Belgian waffle, seasonal preserve

The Meatball

$22.00

Marinara, ricotta cheese

Oysters Rockefeller*

$25.00

Smoked bacon, Pernod, béarnaise

Thick-Cut Applewood Smoked Bacon

$24.00

(3) Thick slices

Seared Rare Yellow Fin Tuna*

$25.00

Avocado poppers, wasabi pea purée


Chilled Seafood

Old Homestead Seafood Platter

$85.00 - $170.00

Maine lobster, king crab, shrimp, oysters

Golden Osetra Caviar 1 oz.*

$

Fresh-Shucked Oysters East & West*

$25.00

King Crab Leg

$28.00

Colossal Shrimp Cocktail*

$29.00

House cocktail sauce, "atomic" horseradish

Colossal Lump Crabmeat Cocktail

$25.00


Soups and Salads

Maine Lobster Bisque

$19.00

Lobster, whipped crème fraîche

Steakhouse Wedge

$18.00

Crispy iceberg lettuce, Maytag blue cheese, bacon

Roasted Heirloom Beets

$20.00

Arugula, goat cheese, apple cider vinaigrette

French Onion Soup

$17.00

Sweet onions, Gruyère crouton

"Yvette's" Caesar

$18.00

Garlic croutons, classic dressing

Vine-Ripened Tomatoes with Basil

$20.00

Fresh mozzarella cheese

"Kitchen Sink" Salad

$20.00

Shrimp, salami, bacon, avocado, tomato, hearts of palm, blue cheese crumbles, Champagne vinaigrette


Steaks

Black Angus Beef Filet Mignon*

$50.00 - $60.00

Bone-In Filet Mignon 16 oz.

$72.00

Sherry Brothers New York Strip 14 oz.

$60.00

Bone-In New York Strip 16 oz.

$68.00

Rib Eye Steak 16 oz.

$68.00

The "Gotham" Rib Eye Steak on the Bone 24 oz.

$82.00

"Lollipop" Rib Eye 38 oz.

$125.00

Bone-In Porterhouse 34 oz.

$125.00

Japanese "A5" Wagyu*

$160.00 - $280.00

Beef strip loin

American Wagyu*

$100.00


Homestead Specialties

Wild-Caught Atlantic Salmon*

$42.00

Grilled corn succotash, cherry tomatoes

Whole Dover Sole

$80.00

De-boned tableside

Diver Scallops*

$45.00

Fennel purée, ruby red grapefruit

Old Homestead Burger*

$30.00

10 oz. dry-aged "Pat LaFrieda" burger seared in an 800°F, 50-year-old seasoned cast iron pan, brioche bun toasted in foie gras butter, aged Tillamook Cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, duck fat frie

Live Maine Lobster*

$69.00

Broiled or steamed 2.5 lb.

Dry-Aged Pork Tomahawk*

$59.00

Wild mushrooms, roasted apple butter

Colorado Rack of Lamb*

$58.00

Mascarpone polenta, peppernade chimichurri

Petaluma Chicken*

$37.00

Fingerling potatoes, green beans

Potato Gnocchi

$42.00

Shaved black truffles, seasonal vegetables


Surf & Turf

8 oz. Filet Mignon Oscar-Style*

$89.00

14 oz. New York Strip, Jumbo Shrimp Scampi*

$90.00

8 oz. Filet Mignon, Maine Lobster Tail*

$95.00

14 oz. New York Strip, Alaskan King Crab*

$85.00


Sides

Grilled Asparagus

$15.00

Roasted Mushrooms

$15.00

Green Beans Almondine

$14.00

Sautéed Spinach

$14.00

Bacon Creamed Spinach

$14.00

Mac & Four Cheese

$15.00

Sautéed Broccolini

$14.00

Lobster Mac & Cheese*

$26.00

Beer-Battered Onion Rings

$14.00


Potatoes

Duck Fat Fries

$14.00

Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes

$14.00

Gnocchi with Truffle Butter

$14.00

Baked Idaho Potato

$14.00

Cheddar Potato Gratin

$14.00

Truffle Mashed Potatoes

$23.00


Add to Your Steak

Pan-Seared Foie Gras*

$21.00

Truffle Butter

$9.00

Melted Blue Cheese Crumble

$5.00

Onion and Bacon

$5.00

House-Made Steak Sauces

$5.00

Béarnaise, bordelaise, peppercorn, horseradish cream

Old Homestead Sauce Flight*

$15.00

Try all four sauces


Desserts

Seasonal Berries and Cream

$13.00

With hand-selected house-made almond nougatine

Big Fat Chocolate Cake

$13.00

Delicious chocolate cake with layers of ganache and more

Old Homestead's World-Famous Cheesecake

$13.00

New York-style classic cheesecake

Crème Brûlée

$13.00

Rich vanilla custard with a caramelized sugar crust

Cast Iron "Baked" Chocolate Chip Cookie

$13.00

With house-made vanilla bean ice cream, coconut and caramel sauces

Doughnut Bread Pudding

$13.00

With vanilla bean ice cream with peanut brittle

Warm Apple Cobbler

$13.00

With cinnamon ice cream and bourbon anglaise

Key Lime Pie

$16.00

With white chocolate cream and raspberry-lime coulis


Port/Sherry

Ruby Port, Warre's Warrior

$11.00

Port (Vintage Character), Fonseca Bin 27

$12.00

Tawny Port, Fonseca 10 Year

$15.00

Sherry, Lustau East India Solera (Medium Sweet Oloroso)

$15.00

Late Bottled Vintage Port, Dow's 2006

$20.00

Tawny Port, Taylor Fladgate 20 Year

$20.00

Colheita Tawny Port, Niepoort 1998

$22.00


Dessert Wines

White Blend, Kracher Cuvée Beerenauslese, Austria 2008

$16.00

Ice Wine, Inniskillin Vidal, Niagara 2007

$30.00

Sauternes Style, Far Niente Dolce, Napa Valley 2006

$40.00


Dessert Bottles

White Blend, Kracher Cuvée Beerenauslese, Austria 2008 (375ml)

$64.00

Colheita Tawny Port, Niepoort 1998 (375ml)

$69.00

Ice Wine, Inniskillin Vidal, Niagara, Canada 2007 (375ml)

$122.00

Sauternes Style, Far Niente Dolce, Napa Valley 2006 (375ml)

$163.00

Sauternes, Château D'yquem, Sauternes 1996 (750ml)

$900.00


Flights

Grand Marnier Tasting Flight

$65.00

1 ounce of each - served neat. Grand Marnier, Grand Marnier 100 year, Grand Marnier 1880

Exploring Scotch Styles Flight

$45.00

Enjoy a unique opportunity to sample three different styles of the world's best Scotch whiskies (1 ounce of each - served neat). Auchentoshan | The Glenlivet 18 year | Lagavulin 16 year

The Macallan Scotch Flight

$95.00

Experience a fleeting chance to sample three different ages of The Macallan Scotch whisky before they discontinue the age-labeled product (1 ounce of each - served neat)

Whiskey Flight

$85.00

A tasting of three totally different whiskies from around the world (1 ounce of each - served neat). Jameson Vintage Reserve | Crown Royal XR | Johnnie Walker Blue Label


Brandy/Cognac

Hennessy VS

$11.00

Rémy Martin VSOP

$14.00

Pomme Prisonnière Calvados Pays D'auge

$19.00

Hine Triomphe

$35.00

Rémy Martin XO

$35.00

Kelt XO

$40.00

Hennessy Paradis

$95.00

Kelt Petra

$100.00

Rémy Martin Louis Xiii (2 Ounces)

$325.00


Tequila

Herradura Silver

$12.00

Patrón Silver

$13.00

Sauza Tres Generaciones Añejo

$13.00

Herradura Double Barrel Reposado Caesars Select

$14.00

Patrón Reposado

$14.00

Patrón Añejo

$15.00

Deleón Diamante

$15.00

Cuervo Reserva De La Familia Platino

$18.00

Clase Azul Platino

$19.00

Deleón Reposado

$19.00

Don Julio 1942

$33.00

Gran Patrón Platinum

$46.00

Cuervo Reserva De La Familia Añejo

$29.00

Deleón Añejo

$125.00


La Colombe Coffee Roasters

Louisiane Coffee

Price may varies

Monte Carlo Decaffeinated Coffee

Price may varies

Nizza Espresso

Price may varies

Coffee

Price may varies

Decaf

Price may varies

Espresso

Price may varies

Steamed Beverages

Price may varies


Green Tea & Oolong Tea

Genmai Cha

Price may varies

certified organic pear tree green & jasmine green oolong


Black Tea

Keemun

Price may varies

china estate

White Tip Darjeeling

Price may varies

india estate 1st and 2nd flush

Imperial English Breakfast

Price may varies

ceylon estate

Decaf English Breakfast

Price may varies

co2 processed

Flowery Earl Grey & Lapsang Souchong

Price may varies

pine needle smoked chinese black tea

Masala Black Tea Chai

Price may varies


Herbal Tea

Certified Organic Chamomile Flowers Harmony

Price may varies

peppermint leaves, chamomile flowers, orange blossoms, and allspice--find peace in a teacup


Fruit Tisanes

Mountain Berry

Price may varies

saskatoon berries, currants, raisins & blueberries

Old Blue Eyes

Price may varies

blue corn flower petals, apples, caramel & vanilla

Nobo Whole Fruit

Price may varies

wild strawberries, blackberries & raspberries


Premium White Tea Service

Certified Organic Flowering Jasmine Pearl

Price may varies


Specialty$16

Old Homestead Salted Caramel Latte

Price may varies

Godiva White Chocolate liqueur, Stolichnaya Salted Caramel vodka, butterscotch schnapps and Illy coffee

Old Homestead Irish Coffee

Price may varies

Jameson Irish whiskey, Baileys Irish Cream liqueur and Illy coffee topped with whipped cream and a drizzle of green crème de menthe

Old Homestead Espresso Martini

Price may varies

Stolichnaya Vanil vodka, Kahlùa, Godiva White Chocolate liqueur and Illy espresso

Gaby's Coffee

Price may varies

Godiva Milk Chocolate liqueur, amaretto, Illy coffee and Baileys Irish Cream liqueur

Old Homestead Espresso Manhattan

Price may varies

Jack Daniel's Tennessee Honey, Frangelico and Illy espresso


Illy Gourmet Coffee and Espresso

Coffee

$5.00

Decaf Coffee

$5.00

Espresso Single

$5.00

Espresso Double

$7.00

Decaf Espresso

$6.00

Decaf Espresso Double

$7.00


Mighty Leaf Teas

English Breakfast

$5.00

Earl Grey

$5.00

Earl Grey Decaf

$5.00

Green Tea Jasmine Mist

$5.00

Chamomile Citrus

$5.00

Orchid Oolong

$5.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading