Old Fifth Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 87 votes
Old Fifth Logo
American
Pizza
Gastropub

Choose My State

IL

Old Fifth Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Old Fifth Special

The Fifth Ward

$27.00 - $23.00

thin crust, pepperoni, sausage, ham, apple-wood smoked bacon, salami with mozzarella, parmesan, provolone

Holden’s Heater

$22.50 - $19.00

thin crust, pizza sauce hot with chili flakes, spicy italian sausage, and topped with giardiniera

Double Decker Pepperoni

$25.00

the old fifth special sauce, stacked! of course only available in 16" anything smaller just wouldn’t be enough

Kentucky Pizza-Q

$21.00 - $25.00

thin crust, uncle dougie’s bbq pulled pork, chihuahua, aged cheddar, roasted peppers, red onion and cilantro

Low Fat Veggie

$19.00 - $22.50

for the health conscious - thin crust, ricotta, skim-milk mozzarella, onion, green peppers, mushrooms


Create Your Masterpiece

Crust - Thin

$13.45 - $15.95

Crust - Double Decker

$17.95 - $22.45

Cheese

Price may varies

regular or low fat. yes, old fifth special cheese blend comes in a reduced fat version

Meats

$1.95 - $2.35

large slice pepperoni, italian sausage, apple-wood smoked bacon, turkey sausage

Veggies

$1.95 - $2.35

fresh green peppers, fresh jalapenos, black olives, tomato, basil, cremini mushrooms, onions, baby spinach, garlic rubbed crust

Genius

$2.50 - $2.95

chevre goat cheese, roasted pork shoulder, prosciutto, grilled chicken, salami, grilled artichokes


Tasty Treats

House Batched Smore’s

$9.00

fresh graham crackers, home made marshmallow, raspberries, mint and chocolate sauce

Griddled Nutella Pound Cake

$8.00

vanilla ice-cream, toasted hazelnuts and a nutella-caramel sauce

Crushed Chocolate

$6.00

(gf). crushed milk chocolate, semi-sweet & belgium chocolates with roasted salted nuts


Snacks

Orange And Extra Virgin Olive Oil Marinated Olives

$7.00

pit-in olives, orange peel, fresh thyme, extra virgin olive oil, toasted baguette

Truffle Fries

$4.00

(gf). fresh cut fries, parmesan, fresh herbs, truffle aioli

Jalapeño Fries

$4.00

(gf). fresh cut fries, jalapeños, queso fresco

Loaded Fries

$9.00

(gf). shredded aged white cheddar, braised oxtail

Salty Nuts And Dry Fruits

$6.00

(gf). almonds, pecans, pistachios, peanuts, dried cherries, blueberries, currants, apricots

Charcuterie And Cheese Plate

$16.00

assorted meats, artisanal cheeses, crunchy baguette, gherkins, italian parsley, whiskey mustard, seasonal marmalade


Shared Bar Bites

Brazilian Nachos

$13.00

(gf). slow roasted pork shoulder, fried tortillas, aged white cheddar, chihuahua cheese, avocado puree, brazilian black beans, pico de gallo, jalapeno, confit of onions, chipotle-lime sauce, shredded

Chicken Wings

$10.00

choice of hot, chili-soy or ancho-bourbon bbq sauce

50/50 Sliders

$12.50

fifty/fifty blend of apple-wood bacon and grass fed beef, aged white cheddar, roma tomato, crispy onion

Apple-Wood Bacon And Blue Cheese Sliders

$12.50

grass fed beef blended with point reyes blue cheese and apple-wood smoked bacon, baby arugula, roma tomato, black pepper aioli

Formerly Known As "Tots"

$9.00

(gf). potato "tot" stuffed, apple-wood smoked bacon and reny picot camembert cheese, black pepper aioli. so good, you may not want to share!

Pancetta Cavatappi & Cheese

$9.00

béchamel, aged white cheddar, gruyere and parmesan, pancetta, cavatappi pasta

Hefeweizen Hummus

$10.00

puree of chick peas with hw reduction, lemon juice, garlic, tahini and olive oil; with english cucumber, baby carrots, asparagus, breakfast radish, grilled flat pita

Seared Ahi Tuna

$15.00

ahi tuna, napa cabbage slaw, daikon sprouts, pickled ginger, fried pickled ginger, wasabi, lime-sriracha sauce


HandheldsServed With House Fries Except For Fish Tacos

Ancho-Bourbon Pulled Pork

$12.50

slow roasted pork shoulder, ancho- bourbon bbq sauce, urban slaw, on a pretzel bun

The "BCS"

$12.50

blackened chicken, crisp romaine, aged white cheddar, avocado, tomatoes, chipotle aioli, ciabatta round

Blackened Fish Tacos

Price may varies

chipotle aioli, flour tortilla, lemon vinaigrette, white cabbage, corn and black bean salsa, pico de gallo.

Blackened Fish Tacos

$13.00

tilapia

Blackened Fish Tacos

$23.00

halibut


BurgersServed With House Fries Except For Fish Tacos Add A Fried Egg For $2

The Old Fifth Burger

$14.00

special blend all beef 8 oz. burger, aged white cheddar, horseradish sauce, crispy onions, baby arugula, tomatoes, brioche burger bun

You’re My Boy Bleu

$14.00

special blend all beef 8 oz. burger, point reyes blue cheese, apple-wood smoked bacon, baby arugula, tomato, black pepper aioli, brioche burger bun

B.Y.O. Cheese Burger

$12.50

special blend all beef 8 oz. burger, turkey, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, onions, & choice of cheese white and yellow cheddar, provolone, mozzarella, swiss, brioche or pretzel buns

B.Y.O. Cheese Burger

$3.50

bison add

The Broad Shoulder Burger

$15.00

special blend all beef 8 oz. burger, sharp yellow cheddar cheese, slow roasted pork shoulder, ancho-bourbon bbq sauce, urban slaw, chipotle aioli, pretzel bun


Perhaps A SaladAdd Grilled Or Blackened Chicken $5, Salmon $6, Tuna $8

Caesar Salad

$9.50

parmesan, garlic brioche croutons, caesar dressing

House Salad

$10.50

(gf). baby greens, point reyes blue cheese, candied pistachios, pear tomatoes, carrot, cucumber, balsamic vinaigrette

Asian Salad

$10.50

napa cabbage and romaine, red peppers, green onions, carrots, daikon radish, english cucumber, peanuts, sesame seeds, daikon sprouts, sesame-soy dressing

Truffled Beet Salad

$10.50

(gf). red beets, baby beets, chevre goat cheese, orange, baby greens, basil, red onions citrus-truffle vinaigrette

Baby Spinach Salad

$10.50

(gf). baby spinach, red quinoa, grilled artichokes, roasted red peppers, grilled asparagus, fine herbs, pear tomatoes, sherry vinaigrette

Southwest Salad

$9.50

romaine, corn and black bean salsa, avocado drizzle, pear tomatoes, red peppers, green onion, corn tortilla, apple-wood smoked bacon, chipotle ranch dressing


Entrees Not To Forget

Whiskey Glazed Salmon

$22.00

(gf). scottish salmon, whiskey glaze, french green beans, roasted shallots, fine herbs

St. Louis Style Ribs

$25.00 - $17.00

pork ribs, uncle dougies’ bbq sauce, urban slaw, house fries. half or full slab

New York Strip Steak

$40.00

prime beef, whiskey butter, yukon potato mashies, veal demi glace, crispy onions, herbs. steaks are dipped in whiskey during the grilling process

Tuna Au Poivre

$28.00

(gf). ahi tuna, black peppercorns, sautéed spinach, pinot noir reduction, pomme paille, basil oil


Sides (GF)

House Fries

$3.50

French Beans

$3.50

with roasted shallot

Urban Slaw

$2.50

Steamed Broccoli

$2.50

Yukon Gold Potato Mashies

$3.50


Beverages

Coke

$2.25

Diet Coke

$2.25

Sprite

$2.25

Sprite Zero

$2.25

Lemonade

$2.25

Iced Tea

$2.25

Orange Juice

$2.25

Cranberry Juice

$2.25

Club Soda

Price may varies

Water

Price may varies

Coke

$2.25

Diet Coke

$2.25

Sprite

$2.25

Sprite Zero

$2.25

Lemonade

$2.25

Iced Tea

$2.25

Orange Juice

$2.25

Cranberry Juice

$2.25

Club Soda

Price may varies

Water

Price may varies


Protein & SideAll Items Include Fresh Cut Skinny House Fries. Side Swap: Substitute Fries For Seasonal Fruit Or Veggies. Add $1

Mini Burger

Price may varies

grass fed beef with or w/o american cheese

Crispy Chicken Strips

Price may varies

Grilled Cheese

Price may varies


Light Bites

Truffle Fries

$4.00

fresh cut fries, parmesan, fresh herbs, truffle aioli

Jalapeño Fries

$4.00

fresh cut fries, jalapeños, queso fresco

Loaded Fries

$9.00

shredded aged white cheddar, braised oxtail

Brazilian Nachos

$13.00

slow roasted pork shoulder, fried tortillas, aged white cheddar, chihuahua cheese, avocado puree, brazilian black beans, pico de gallo, jalapeno, confit of onions, chipotle-lime sauce, shredded lettu

Chicken Wings

$10.00

choice of hot, chili-soy or ancho-bourbon bbq sauce

50/50 Sliders

$12.50

fifty/fifty blend of apple-wood bacon and grass fed beef, aged white cheddar, roma tomato, crispy onion

Apple-Wood Bacon And Blue Cheese Sliders

$12.50

grass fed beef blended with point reyes blue cheese and apple-wood smoked bacon, baby arugula, roma tomato, black pepper aioli

Formerly Known As "Tots"

$9.00

potato "tot" stuffed, apple-wood smoked bacon and reny picot camembert cheese, black pepper aioli. so good, you may not want to share!


Sweets

House Batched Smore’s

$9.00

fresh graham crackers, home made marshmallow, raspberries, mint and chocolate sauce

Crushed Chocolate

$6.00

crushed milk chocolate, semi-sweet & belgium chocolates with roasted salted nuts


Bourbons

Old Fashioned

$11.00

buffalo trace bourbon, demerara syrup, angostura bitter’s

Manhattan

$12.00

koval bourbon, sweet vermouth, bitters

Old Fifth

$13.00

four roses bourbon, walnut liqueur, apricot liqueur, lime juice and jamaican bitters

High Plains Drifter

$12.00

eagle rare 10yr single barrel, stirrings ginger liqueur, velvet falernum, fresh lemon juice, egg white


Other Whiskey $12

Whiskey Smash

Price may varies

prichard’s tennessee whiskey, demerara syrup, fresh lemon juice

Scofflaw

Price may varies

templeton rye, noilly prat dry vermouth, pom grenadine, fresh lemon juice

Proper Sazarac

Price may varies

bulleit rye whiskey, demerara syrup, peychaud’s bitters, absinthe rinse


Guest Cocktail

Clover Club

$12.00

tanqueray dry gin, house made pomegranate grenadine, fresh lemon juice, egg white


IPA & Pale Ales

Anti-Hero

$7.00

revolution

Dunegräs

$7.00

greenbush

Mirrorpond

$6.00

deschutes

Double Jack

$9.00

firestone walker

Modus Hoperandi

$7.00

ska

Daisy Cutter

$6.00

half acre

Dale’s Pale Ale

$6.00

oskar blues

Sidekick

$5.00

two brothers

Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

$5.00


Amber, Wheat & Lagers

Eliot Ness

$7.00

great lakes

Blue Moon Belgian White

$5.00

Coors Light

$4.50

Krankshaft Lager

$5.00

metropolitan


Porter & Stouts

Milk Stout Nitro

$6.00

left hand

Black Butte

$6.00

deschutes

Edmund Fitzgerald

$5.00

great lakes

Guinness

$6.00

Porter

$6.00

founders

Satin Solstice

$7.00

central waters


Unique Blends

80-Acre Hoppy Wheat

$6.00

boulevard

Hennepin

$7.00

ommegang

Iniquity

$7.00

southern tier

Kentucky Bourbon Ale

$7.00

Lil Sumpin Sumpin

$6.00

lagunitas

Midas Touch

$9.00

dogfish head

Dirty Bastard

$8.00

founder’s

Robert The Bruce

$5.00

three floyd’s

Oak Aged Pale (Sour Ale)

$9.00

petrus

Sublimely Self Righteous

$9.00

stone

Summer Shandy

$5.00

leinenkugel’s

Sweet Action (Cream Ale)

$6.00

six point


Ciders

Vandermill Apple Cider

$8.00

Crispin Original

$6.00


Wheat & Lagers

Goose Island 312

$6.00

Allagash White

$6.00

Hacker-Pschorr Weisse

$6.00

Miller High Life

$4.00


Gluten Free $5

New Grist

Price may varies

lakefront

Prairie Path

Price may varies

two brothers


Non-Alcoholic

Kaliber

$4.00


Bubbles

NV Tommasi Prosecco Brut, Valdobbiadene

$11.00


Whites

Bricco Riella Moscato D’asti, Italy

$8.00

2012 Riff Pinot Grigio, Trentino

$8.00

2011 Mohua Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough

$10.00

2011 Raymond Chardonnay, California

$10.00

2012 Amalaya Torrontes Riesling, Salta

$8.00

2011 Batasiolo Gavi, Piemonte

$10.00


Rose

2012 Crios Malbec Rose, Mendoza

$10.00


Reds

2011 Castle Rock Pinot Noir, Willamette Valley

$10.00

2010 La Ginestra Chianti, Tuscany

$9.00

2011 Decero Malbec, Mendoza

$11.00

2011 Milbrandt Cabernet Sauvignon, Columbia Valley

$12.00

2010 Aia Vecchia 'Lagone', Tuscany

$12.00

2011 Langmeil Shiraz, Barossa Valley

$12.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading