Menu With Price > Menu > Nina's Custard

Nina's Custard Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 121 votes
Nina's Custard Logo
Ice Cream

Choose My State

NY

Nina's Custard Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Artic Swirls

Vanilla Custard

$3.09 - $3.70

with your choice of two ingredients: M&M's, reese's, heath bar, nestles crunch, snickers, oreo's, cookie dough, chocolate chips, peanut butter cup or fruit

Lemon Ice with Strawberries

$3.09 - $3.70

Sundaes

Sundaes

$2.74 - $3.29

hot fudge, hot caramel, strawberry, cherry, pineapple, blueberry, peach, peanut butter, butterscotch, raspberry, marshmallow, fat free chocolate

Cream

$0.40

Nuts

$0.40

Specialty Sundaes

Turtle Sundae

$3.39 - $3.89

vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, hot caramel, cream and chopped pecans

Reese's Sundae

$3.39 - $3.89

vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, peanut butter, cream and reese's pieces

Mexican Sundae

$3.39 - $3.89

vanilla custard topped with chocolate, cream and Mexican nuts

Grasshopper

$3.39 - $3.89

vanilla custard, chocolate syrup, mint sauce, cream and chocolate chips.

Caramel Apple

$3.39 - $3.89

custard, caramel, chopped apples and cream

Brownie Sundae

$3.39 - $3.89

vanilla custard, hot fudge, brownie and cream.

Banana Split

Custard with Strawberries, Pineapple, Chocolate, a Banana and Cream

$4.39 - $4.74

Custard with Hot Fudge, Caramel, Chocolate, a Banana and Cream.

$4.39 - $4.74

Packed to Go

Nina Bars

$2.09

vanilla custard with fudge, spanish nuts, on a stick, dipped in chocolate

Turtle Bars

$2.09

vanilla and chocolate custard with carmel, fudge, pecans, on a stick, dipped in chocolate

Pints

$2.90

yogurt/WOW cow 0.35 extra

Quarts

$4.45

yogurt/WOW cow 0.35 extra

Ice Cream Sandwich

$1.35 - $6.75

Sandwiches

Hot Dog

$2.15

Cheese Dog

$2.50

Footlong

$3.25

Cheese Footlong

$3.75

Kosher Dog

$3.05

Hamburger (1/4 Lb.)

$2.59

Cheeseburger (1/4 Lb.)

$2.89

Grilled Chicken Sandwich or BBQ

$4.10

includes lettuce, tomato, mayo

Chicken Burger

$3.99

includes lettuce, tomato, mayo

Chicken Fingers

$3.90

Tuna Sandwich

$3.59

includes lettuce, tomato, mayo

Garden Burger

$3.40

includes lettuce, tomato, mayo

Fish Sandwich

$3.95

includes lettuce, tomato, mayo. Homemade hot sauce, ketchup, mustard relish, onions, pickls, mayo, BBQ sauce, sweet & sour, honey dijon

Kids Mealsincludes small fry, small drink, and fun fruit

Hot Dog

$3.30

Hamburger

$3.85

Chicken Fingers

$3.90

Mama Rose's

Minestrone Soup or Soup of Day

$2.75

Mama Rose's Salad

$3.35

romaine, mixed greens and iceberg lettuce with chopped egg, Swiss cheese and homemade dressing.

House Salad

$3.35

1,000 Island, blue cheese, ranch, low fat Italian, no fat catalina, no fat raspberry vinaigrette, no fat honey dijon, no fat 1,000 Island

House or Mama's Salad with Grilled Chicken

$5.65

Side Orders

Curly Q's or Criss Cut

$1.85

Sweet Potato Fries

$3.20

Onion Rings

$2.19

Macaroni or Potato Salad

$1.75

Coleslaw

$1.75

Potato Chips

$0.55

Drinks

Drinks

$1.34 - $1.59

coke, diet coke, cherry coke, lemonade, rootbeer, loganberry, ice tea, fruit punch, sprite, Mr. Pibb, orange.

Cappuccino

$1.69

Coffee, Tea, or Hot Chocolate

$1.10

Slush

$1.25 - $1.75

cherry, blue raspberry or weekly flavor

Snapple, Crystal Lt, or Powerade

$1.69

Spring Water

$1.59

Floats

Floats

$2.39 - $2.99

coke, diet coke, cherry coke, rootbeer, sprite, Mr. Pibb, orange

Shake & Soda's

$2.39 - $2.99

vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cherry, loganberry, raspberry, banana, strawberry/banana, pineapple, orange, mint, or coffee

Malted Shakes (Extra)

$0.35

Ice

Lemon Ice

$1.84 - $2.19

Cones Custard

$1.84 - $2.59

vanilla, chocolate, twist, weekly special

Cone Wow Cow

$1.95 - $2.70

Wow Cow Flavor, Vanilla/WOW Cow Twist (2 Scoops)

$2.40

hard ice cream/yogurt

Wow Cow Flavor, Vanilla/WOW Cow Twist (3 Scoops)

$2.85

hard ice cream/yogurt

Wow Cow Flavor, Vanilla/WOW Cow Twist (4 Scoops)

$3.20

hard ice cream/yogurt

Waffle Cones (Custard)

$2.55

Waffle Cones (Wow Cow)

$2.75

Waffle Cones (Hard)

$3.20

Sprinkles

$0.35

rainbow or chocolate

Dip Tops

$0.40

chocolate, cherry, peanut butter

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands