Menu With Price > Menu > Nick's Tomato Pie

Nick's Tomato Pie Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 62 votes

Choose My State

FL NY

Nick's Tomato Pie Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Nick's Raw Bar & Appetizers

Clams on a 1/2 Shell (8)

$12.95

Little Neck Clams

$14.95

"A Bowl Full" Red or White Sauce or Sauteed

Clams Casino or Oreganato (8)

$10.99

Fresh Maine Mussels

$10.99

"A Bowl Full" Red or White Sauce or Provencale Sauce

Fresh Mozzarella

$6.75

Served w/ marinara sauce

Bruschetta

$6.99

Sliced and baked ciabatta bread, topped with herbs, marinated tomatoes & basil

Eggplant Rollatini

$7.50

w/ Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta Stuffed Meatballs

$7.50

Parmigiana

Mozzarella Caprese

$9.95

Sliced tomato and fresh Mozzarella

Calamari

$8.95

Monterey squid seasoned, lightly floured & fried

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (Minimum 3)

$2.50

Antipaso Alla Famiglia*

$14.99

Mozzarella Caprese, Prosciutto, roasted peppers, salami, olives, calamari, clams casino & clams oreganato. "Great For Sharing"

Antipasto Di Casa*

$10.99

Prosciutto, fresh Mozzarella, roasted peppers & tomato, salami, olives

Garlic Bread

$3.95 - $4.95

Soups

Del Giorno

$4.50 - $6.50

Pasta Fagioli

$4.50 - $6.50

Fresh Vegetables

Sauteed Spinach

$4.50

Sauteed Broccoli

$4.50

Salad BowlsAdd Gorgonzola Cheese to any salad - $6.95

Gorgonzola Salad

$10.95

Radicchio, arugula and endive with tomatoes, basil & our special Gorgonzola dressing

The Guido Caesar Salad

$9.99

Spinach Cranberry Salad

$10.50

Joe "Mow the Lawn" Green Salad

$6.95

Nick's Romano Salad

$14.95

Chopped greens topped with chicken Milanese, creamy Italian parmesan dressing, chopped eggs, bacon, tomatoes, green onions & cucumbers

Nick's Tomatoe Pies

Nick's Tomatoe Pie*

$11.50 - $14.50

Tomatoe, mozzarella

Di Casa

$14.50

3 color peppers and onion

Quattro Formaggi

$14.50

4 cheeses

Vegetarian

$14.99

Eggplant, 3 color peppers, broccoli and fresh tomatoe

Pasta of Your Choice

Capellini

Price may varies

"Angel Hair" The most delicate pasta

Penne Rigate (Mostaccioli)

Price may varies

"Pencil Points" A thin tubular pasta

Linguine

Price may varies

"Small tongues", really a spaghetti but the shape of a narrow flat noodle

Fettuccine

Price may varies

"Small Ribbons", the famous noodle that has been responsible for the fortunes of restaurants

Rigatoni

Price may varies

"Ridges or Groves" A large tabular pasta

Spaghetti

Price may varies

Thin pasta introduced to Italy by Marco Polo

Tortellini - add $2 to sauce price

Price may varies

Cheese stuffed

Ravioli - add $2 to sauce price

Price may varies

Cheese stuffed

Gnocchi - add $2

Price may varies

Whole Wheat Pasta - add $1

Price may varies

Gluten-Free Pasta - add $2

Price may varies

Sauce of Your ChoiceAll Pasta with (2) meatballs, or (2) sausages or grilled chicken breasts - $3.95

Aglio & Olio

$12.95

Fresh garlic and extra virgin olive oi

Marinara or Fra Diavolo

$14.50

Plum tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, basil and white wine. Crushed red pepper in Fra Diavolo

Alla Vodka*

$17.99

Plum tomatoes, prosciutto, parmigiano, cream and a hint of vodka

Bolognese

$16.99

Meat sauce with fresh basil

Nick's Favorite

$14.95

Penne, aglio & olio style w/ broccoli. Choice of crumbled sausage or chicken

Fresh Shucked Clam Sauce

$19.99

Red or White Sauce, chopped clams, virgin olive oil, wine, parsley and garlic over linguini. Whole clam garni. (6)

Add As You Wish (To Any Entree)

Peas

$1.00

Capers

$1.50

Cream Sauce

$1.00

Chopped Garlic

$1.00

Crumbled Sausage

$1.75

Fresh Tomatoe

$1.99

Mushrooms

$1.99

Melted Mozzarella

$1.99

Anchovies

$1.99

Olives

$1.99

Bell Peppers

$1.99

Eggplant

$1.99

Shrimp

$1.99

Broccoli

$1.99

Sundried Tomatoes

$2.25

Prosciutto

$3.25

Roasted Peppers

$1.99

Artichokes

$2.99

Main

Gnocchi Alla Nick's (Nyaw-Key)

$18.95

Homemade potato dumplings sauteed with marinara sauce, butter, and parmigiano cheese

Grilled Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onions

$16.95

In a light tomatoe sauce

Pasghetti & Meatballs

$5.95

Nick's Chick Strips

$6.95

with french fries or Pasghetti

Mac & Cheese

$5.95

With Garlic Bread

Hershey's Chocolate Milk

$0.75

Kids Kup Soda

$1.25

Steamed Broccoli & Carrots

$1.50

Ravioli

$5.95

Cheese filled pasta pillows

Kid's Nick's Tomatoe Pie

$6.95

Grilled Cheese & French Fries

$5.95

Kid's Salad

$2.95

Comes with Ranch Dressing

Great French Fries

$1.95

Baked Pasta

Manicotti

$13.00

Lasagna "Ala Nicola"

$15.95

Baked Ziti "NTP Style"

$15.95

Sausage, meatball, bell peppers, onion, 3 cheese & chopped tomato

Parmigiana"Parmigiana" items are lightly dusted with Italian crumbs, sauteed in olive oil and topped with marinara sauce, mozzarella and Parmesan cheese

Veal

$19.95

Chicken Breast

$16.95

Eggplant Parmigiana or Rollatini*

$14.95 - $16.95

Shrimp

$18.95

Chicken at Nick's

Roasted Pollo "NTP Style"*

$15.95

Our house specialty with vegetable, roasted potatoes or pasta

Chicken Scarpariello*

$18.99

Bone-in with sliced sausage, pepperoncini, potato, & capers in a vinegar wine sauce

Chicken Florentine

$17.50

Fresh spinach, provolone & tomatoe in a light red sauce

Chicken Marsala

$16.95

Mushroom and marsala wine sauce

Grilled Chicken Breast Parmigiana

$17.50

Chicken Milanese

$16.95

Lightly breaded and sauteed w/ mixed greens, and marinated tomato

Top Round of Veal

Marsala

$23.00

Mushrooms and wine sauce

Francese

$23.00

Lemon, butter & wine sauce

Piccata

$23.00

Lemon, butter, wine sauce & capers

Saltimbocca

$23.00

Fresh sage & prosciutto served on a bed of spinach with fontina cheese

Florentine*

$23.00

Fresh spinach, 3 cheeses & tomato

Veal Milanese

$23.00

Lightly breaded and sauteed w/ mixed greens and marinated tomato

The Fish Market

Shrimp Scampi

$18.95

In traditional sauce served w/side of linguine with scampi sauce

Zuppa di Pesce

$26.95

Shrimp, mussels, clams, calamari, lobster and plum tomatoes, with a hint of balsamic vinegar and fresh herbs served over a bed of linguine with fresh marinara sauce

Florida Snapper

Francese Style

$19.95

w/side of capellini tossed with vegetables

Blackened

$19.95

Broiled

$19.95

With white wine & lemon butter

Jumbo Shrimp

Fra Diavolo or with Marinara Sauce

$18.95

Over linguine

Francese

$18.95

Lemon, butter & white wine sauce w/side of vegetable-tossed pasta

The Stock YardAll items served on a sizzling platter with choice of pasta del Giorno or Potato del Giorno and sauteed onions & mushrooms, and "Mow the Lawn Salad"

N.Y. Strip - Pan Seared

N.Y. Strip - Gorgonzola

N.Y. Strip - Peppercorn

From Nick's Hoagie ShopAdd Fries to any Hoagie $2.95

Meatball Hoagie

$10.95

Parmigiana style. Choice of soup or "Mow The Lawn" salad

Sausage Hoagie

$10.95

Parmigiana style or grilled peppers & onions. Choice of soup or "Mow The Lawn" salad

Coffee Specialties

Espresso

$3.25

This dark rich coffee adds a perfect final touch to a great meal

Irish Coffee

$7.75

Coffee with Irish whiskey topped with green Creme de Menthe and whipped cream

Cappuccino

$4.95

Fresh, steaming espresso, topped with steamed milk, rich and frothy

Italian Coffee

$7.75

Coffee and Amaretto topped with whipped cream

Ginny's Bake Shop

Cannoli

$4.95

Italian pastry shell stuffed with ricotta cheese and Italian liqueur

Tiramisu

$5.95

Enjoy this Italian favorite made with fresh cream, lady fingers, and imported Italian liqueurs

Toni's Torta Ricotta Cheesecake

$5.95

New Yok Style Cheesecake

$5.95

Florida Key Lime Pie (In season)

$5.95

Traditional Key West Style

Cold Zabaglione

$5.95

A heavenly concoction of whipped cream, marsala wine and brandy with fresh strawberries & chocolate

Ice Cream

$3.50

Stacked Brownie Fudge Sundae

$4.75

Janet's Surprise

Price may varies

Ask your server what we have tonight. (priced accordingly)

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.