Menu With Price > Menu > New York Prime

New York Prime Menu and Prices

4.7 based on 257 votes
New York Prime Logo
Steak

Choose My State

FL GA SC

New York Prime Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Appetizers

Oysters on the Half Shell (6)

$14.50

we serve only large farm raised oysters from government inspected waters

Oysters Rockefeller (4)

$14.00

topped with spinach, parmesan and bacon

Charbroiled Oysters

$14.00

Broiled in garlic butter, parmesan, breadcrumbs and pepper

Stone Crabs

$

(in season)

Shrimp

$17.50

colossal u-7 to u-10's with cocktail or remoulde sauce

Seafood Platters

$

a selection of our appetizers for 4 or more people

Lobster Cocktail Remoulade

$

Baked Shrimp

$18.50

colossals with garlic butter, parmesan and bread crumbs

New York Prime's Classic Shellfish Bisque

$11.00

Jumbo Lump Crab Meat

$18.50

cocktail or remoulade sauce

Carpaccio

$14.00

prime beef tenderloin

New York Style Thick Cut Sizzling Bacon

$6.00

By the slice served with Brooklyn French

USDA Prime SteaksAll of our Steaks, Including Filets, are Aged 28 Days and Prepared "Pittsburgh-style" with a Charred Exterior

Petite New York Strip

$39.00

New York Strip

$49.50

Bone-in Rib Steak

$58.00

Sliced Edge Of Rib Steak

$37.50

with onion straws

Center Cut Filet

$59.50

barrel cut

Petite Filet

$43.00

barrel cut

Porterhouse for Two

$97.50

Chopped Steak of Prime, Aged Beef

$29.50

Triple Cut Lamb Chops

$49.50

Double Rib Veal Chop

$49.00

Garlic Chicken

$23.50

Salmon

$29.00

topped with sauteed portobello mushrooms

Pan Sauteed Redfish with Crabmeat

$

Sea Bass

$

Live Lobster

$

3 to 13 lbs.

Stone Crabs

$

large, jumbo or colossal (october 15 - may 15)

SaladsSlightly smaller sizes available

Beefsteak Tomatoes And Onions

$12.00

served with "Brooklyn french" dressing

Hearts of Lettuce with Sliced Tomato

$12.00

New York Prime's Chopped Italian Salad

$12.00

onions, tomatoes, red, yellow and green peppers, hearts of palm, anchovies, almonds, olive oil and bleu cheese

Caesar

$12.00

SidesAvailable in individual and table sizes

Creamed, Steamed or Garlic Spinach

$12.00

Sauteed Mushrooms

$12.00

Sauteed Onions

$12.00

Asparagus With Hollandaise

$12.00

Southwest Creamed Corn

$11.00

Onion Straws

$12.00

Onion Rings

$12.00

Steak Cut French Fries

$12.00

1/2 Onion Rings and 1/2 Fries

$13.00

Hash Browns

$12.00

Lyonnaise

$13.00

hash browns with onions

Cheese Mashed Potatoes

$11.50

Giant Baked Potato - 1 Pound Loaded

$7.50

fresh bacon, chives, sour cream and butter

Fettuccine Alfredo "The Recipe"

$13.50 - $19.50

DessertsLarge portions suitable for two or more

Cheesecake

$11.00

Shipped direct from the Carnegie Deli

Cinnamon Walnut Apple Pie

$11.00

Served with vanilla ice cream

White Chocolate Banana Cream Pie

$12.00

Key Lime Pie

$10.00

Seasonal Berries with Cream

$

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$8.00

Served with vanilla ice cream

Gigantic Chocolate Cake

$28.00

All of our desserts are big - this table size dessert is gigantic! Served with vanilla ice cream

The Saturday Sundae (Serves 4)

$

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Heath Bars, Butterfingers, chocolate chips, pecans, almonds, chocolate sauce, whipped cream and a cherry on top

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands