Natoli's Deli & Pizzeria Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 165 votes
Natoli's Deli & Pizzeria Logo

Choose My State

NJ

Natoli's Deli & Pizzeria Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Breakfast SandwichesHave 1 Egg Or 2 For The Same Price

Egg Sandwich

$2.50

Taylor Ham & Egg

$3.95

Bacon & Egg

$3.95

Ham & Egg

$3.95

Pastrami & Egg

$4.95

Sausage & Egg

$3.95


Breakfast PlattersServed Mon - Fri 7am - 10:30am, Sat - Sun 7am - 12:30pm

Eggs Home Fries & Toast

$4.95

Eggs Home Fries & Toast

$6.50

with bacon, sausage, taylor ham or ham

Pastrami

$6.95

French Toast

$4.50

French Toast

$6.50

with bacon, sausage, taylor ham or ham

Pastrami

$6.95

Order Of Home Fries

$2.95


Appetizers

Mussels Marinara

$5.95

black shell

Calamari

$7.95

rings only the above items are available with medium, sweet or hot sauce

Buffalo Wings

$11.95 - $6.95

Homemade Rice Balls

$4.95

with sauce

Chicken Wedges

$5.25 - $6.95

Mozzarella Sticks

$4.25

Homemade Garlic Bread

$2.50

Homemade Garlic Bread

$3.50

with melted mozzarella

Garlic Knots

$0.75 - $2.50

Raw Vegetable Platter

$25.00 - $40.00

assorted crisp veggies cut snack size with a creamy garlic dip

Cheese Platter

$30.00 - $55.00

an assortment of domestic cheese cubed served with grapes and crackers

Chicken Finger & Mozzarella Sticks Platter

Price may varies

our own special chicken tenderloin strips fried golden brown with mozzarella sticks and your choice of dipping sauces

Italian Deluxe Antipasto Platter

$5.99

proscuitto with bread sticks, genoa salami, soppressata, pepperoni, imported provolone, imported capicola, home made fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, mushrooms, hot peppers, sliced cherry peppers,

Jumbo Buffalo Chicken Wings

$35.00

savory chicken wings deeply marinated in a tasty sauce, served with blue cheese dressing


Salads

Chef Salad

$6.50 - $8.95

Tossed Salad

$3.95 - $5.95

Tossed Salad

$6.95 - $9.95

with tuna salad

Tossed Salad

$6.95 - $9.95

with chicken salad

Tossed Salad

$6.95 - $9.95

with shrimp salad

Tossed Salad

$6.75 - $9.95

with egg salad

Tossed Salad

$6.95 - $9.95

with grilled chicken

Tossed Salad

$9.95

with fried calamari

Italian Antipasto

$8.95

N.B.A Salad

$4.95

with grilled chicken

Caesar Salad

$4.95

Caesar Salad

$7.95

with grilled chicken

Fresh Wet Mozzarella

$7.95

with olive oil & fresh tomatoes

Garden Salad

$18.00 - $30.00

lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumbers, carrots, red cabbage, black & green olives, house dressing

Fresh Fruit Platters

$30.00 - $50.00

fresh honeydew, watermelon, cantaloupe, grapes, strawberries, oranges & kiwi seasonal

Mozzarella & Tomato Salad

$30.00 - $50.00

fresh mozzarella made daily, with sliced tomatoes garnished with basil & 100% olive oil

Antipasto Salad

$35.00 - $60.00

bed of lettuce, ham, proscuitto, imported cappicola, proscuittini, genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone, marinated mushroom, roasted peppers, black & green olives


Fresh Homemade Pasta SaladsMade Daily Please Call For Our Pasta Salad Of The Day Available By The Pound, Over Salad Or As A Sandwich Topping

Roasted Peppers

Price may varies

Sliced Cherry Peppers

Price may varies

Hot Stuffed Peppers

Price may varies

with prosciutto & imported provolone, or with anchovy, bread crumbs & spices

Marinated Mushrooms

Price may varies

Potato Salad

Price may varies

Noodle Salad

Price may varies

Cole Slaw

Price may varies

Sundried Tomatoes

Price may varies


Hot SandwichesServed On A Half Of Italian Bread

Sausage Parmigiana

$7.25

Sausage Peppers & Onions

$6.95

Fried Shrimp

$8.50

with lettuce, tomato & mayo

Shrimp Parmigiana

$8.25

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana

$8.50

Veal Peppers & Onions

$8.50

Eggplant Parmigiana

$6.95

Mozzarella Melt

$4.95

Chicken Parmigiana

$7.25

Chicken Cutlet

$6.75

grilled or fried with lettuce, tomato & mayo

Meatballs

$6.50

Meatball Parmigiana

$7.25

Meatballs Peppers & Onion

$7.25

Sausage

$6.50


Burgers ETCServed From 2:30 To Close 8oz Hand Packed Burger With Pickles, Lettuce, Tomato & Served With Fries

Burger Platter

$6.95

Cheese Burger Platter

$7.95

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$7.75

grilled or fried with lettuce, tomato & bleu cheese

Genuine Philly Steak Sandwich

$5.95

with peppers & onion

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich

$6.95

with peppers & onion


Desserts

Black & White Cookies

$1.25

Rice Pudding

$2.00

Chocolate Pudding

$2.00

Banana Pudding

$2.00

Cheesecake

$2.25

Cannolis

$2.25

Fresh Fruit Salad

$2.00 - $4.00

in season

Assorted Ice Creams

Price may varies

varying prices

Assorted Cookie Trays

Price may varies

Brownies

Price may varies

Italian Pastries

Price may varies

Home Made Cannolis

Price may varies

Rice Pudding

Price may varies

Cheese Cake

Price may varies

Perugina Chocolates

Price may varies


Pizzeria SpecialtiesRegular Slice $2.25, Sicilian Slice $2.50, White Slice $2.95

Plain Pizza Pie

$11.99 - $6.99

Plain Pizza Pie

$13.99 - $7.99

extra cheese

Plain Pizza Pie

$13.99 - $7.99

with sausage

Plain Pizza Pie

$13.99 - $7.99

with anchovy

Plain Pizza Pie

$13.99 - $7.99

with mushroom

Plain Pizza Pie

$14.99 - $8.99

with eggplant

Plain Pizza Pie

$17.99 - $8.99

with chicken

Plain Pizza Pie

$13.99 - $7.99

with pepperoni

Plain Pizza Pie

$13.99 - $7.99

with pepper

Plain Pizza Pie

$13.99 - $7.99

with onions

Plain Pizza Pie

$13.99 - $7.99

with meatballs

Special Pie

$11.95 - $19.95

Regular Pie

$15.95 - $9.95

1/2 special

White Pie Tomato

$17.99 - $9.95

White Pie Spinach

$10.95 - $18.95

Veggie Pie

$10.95 - $9.95

Hawaiian

$10.95 - $18.95

Cheese Steak Pizza

$17.95 - $9.95

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$10.95 - $18.95

Margarita Pizza

$14.95 - $9.95

Sicilian Pie

$16.95

Calzone

$7.95

with sauce

Sausage, Pepperoni Or Chicken Roll

$6.95

with sauce


Specialty Pasta EntreesServed From 11am To Closing

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$9.95

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$12.95

with meat sauce

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$12.95

with meatballs

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$12.95

with sausage

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$14.95

with veal parmigiana

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$12.95

with eggplant parmigiana

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$13.95

with chicken parmigiana

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$14.95

with shrimp parmigiana

Homemade Manicotti

$8.95

Homemade Manicotti

$10.95

with meat sauce

Homemade Manicotti

$10.95

with meatballs

Homemade Manicotti

$10.95

with sausage

Homemade Manicotti

$13.95

with veal parmigiana

Homemade Manicotti

$11.95

with eggplant parmigiana

Homemade Manicotti

$12.95

with chicken parmigiana

Homemade Manicotti

$13.95

with shrimp parmigiana

Stuffed Shells

$8.95

Stuffed Shells

$10.95

with meat sauce

Stuffed Shells

$10.95

with meatballs

Stuffed Shells

$10.95

with sausage

Stuffed Shells

$13.95

with veal parmigiana

Stuffed Shells

$10.95

with eggplant parmigiana

Stuffed Shells

$12.95

with chicken parmigiana

Stuffed Shells

$13.95

with shrimp parmigiana

Cheese Ravioli

$8.95

Cheese Ravioli

$10.95

with meat sauce

Cheese Ravioli

$10.95

with meatballs

Cheese Ravioli

$10.95

with sausage

Cheese Ravioli

$13.95

with veal parmigiana

Cheese Ravioli

$10.95

with eggplant parmigiana

Cheese Ravioli

$12.95

with chicken parmigiana

Cheese Ravioli

$13.95

with shrimp parmigiana

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$6.95

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$8.95

with meat sauce

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$9.95

with clam sauce

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$8.45

parmigiana

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$8.95

with meatballs

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$8.95

with sausage

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$12.95

with veal parmigiana

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$9.95

with eggplant parmigiana

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$10.95

with chicken parmigiana

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$12.95

with shrimp parmigiana

Spaghetti Or Linguini

$7.95

with garlic & oil

Baked Ziti Or Penne

Price may varies

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$7.95

with tomato sauce

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$10.95

with meat sauce

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$10.95

with meatballs

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$10.95

with sausage

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$13.95

with veal parmigiana

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$10.95

with eggplant parmigiana

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$11.95

with chicken parmigiana

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$13.95

with shrimp parmigiana

Baked Ziti Or Penne

$8.95

with broccoli, oil & garlic

Pasta Alfredo

$8.95

with spaghetti, penne, linguini or ziti

Cajun Or Broiled Salmon

$8.95

4oz over pasta or salad


Homemade SpecialtiesAvailable All Day, Every Day

Penne Ala Vodka

$8.95

Penne Ala Vodka

$10.95

with grilled chicken

Chicken Vegetable

$2.45 - $3.45

Pasta Fagioli

$2.45 - $3.45


Old Favorites

Turkey Club

$5.95

Grilled Cheese

$3.95

BLT

$4.95

Peanut Butter & Jelly

$2.95


Delicatessen SandwichesRR / Hero / Jumbo. All Cold Sandwiches Are Available On Wraps & Charged Like Heroes

Prosciuttini

$4.75 - $6.50

Ham

$4.25 - $6.00

Spiced Ham

$4.00 - $5.75

Taylor Ham

$4.50 - $6.25

Black Forest Ham

$4.75 - $6.50

Turkey Breast

$4.50 - $6.25

Chicken Breast

$5.00 - $6.75

Bologna

$4.00 - $5.75

Hard Salami

$4.50 - $6.25

Virginia Ham

$4.75 - $6.50

Genoa Salami

$5.00 - $6.75

Pepperoni

$4.25 - $6.00

Roast Beef

$5.00 - $6.75

Capicola

$5.50 - $7.25

Prosciutto

$5.50 - $7.50

Swiss Cheese

$4.00 - $5.75

American Cheese

$4.00 - $5.75

Fresh Mozzarella

$4.50 - $6.25

Soppressata

$5.75 - $7.50

Muenster Cheese

$4.00 - $5.75

Provolone Cheese

$4.00 - $5.75

Tuna Salad

$4.75 - $6.50

Pastrami

$5.00 - $6.50

Shrimp Salad

$5.00 - $6.75

Chicken Salad

$5.00 - $6.75

Liverwurst

$4.00 - $5.75


Garnishings

Onions

$0.20

Lettuce

$0.20

Tomatoes

$0.20

Bacon

$1.00

Roasted Peppers

$0.30

Hot Or Sweet Peppers

$0.30

Sundried Tomatoes

$1.00

Cheese On A Round Roll

$0.50

Cheese On A Hero

$0.75

Fresh Mozzarella On A Round Roll

$1.00

Fresh Mozzarella On A Hero

$1.50


Monday

Hot Pastrami

$5.45 - $6.95

Steak Sandwich

$3.75 - $5.25

Cheese Steak

$4.25 - $6.00

Small Pea Soup

$2.45

Large Soup

$3.45

French Fries

$2.25


Tuesday

1/4 Lb Big Burger

$3.75

Cheese Burger

$4.50

Chili Dog

$3.95

Italian Hot Dog

$4.95

Hot Pastrami

$5.45 - $6.95

Hot Roast Beef

$5.45 - $6.95

Beef Barley Soup

$2.45 - $3.45

French Fries

$2.25


Wednesday

Sausage Peppers & Onions

$5.75 - $7.25

Meatloaf

$5.45 - $6.95

Hot Pastrami

$5.45 - $6.95

Chicken Noodle

$2.45 - $3.45

French Fries

$2.25


Thursday

Meatballs

$5.45 - $6.95

Hot Pastrami

$5.45 - $6.95

Stuffed Shells & Meatballs Platter

$6.95

Cream Or Broccoli

$2.45 - $3.45


Friday

Steaks

$3.75 - $5.25

Cheese Steak

$4.25 - $6.00

Homemade Fish Cakes

$3.25 - $4.75

Filet Of Flounder

$4.95 - $6.95

Hot Pastrami

$5.45 - $6.95

French Fries

$2.25

Chowder

$2.45 - $3.45

Pizza Night

Price may varies

something free with your pizza every friday


Monday $23.99

Chicken Cacciatore, 2 Order Of Pasta

Price may varies

baked ziti, linguini, penne or spaghetti

Large Tossed Salad

Price may varies

Italian Dinner Bread

Price may varies


Tuesday $21.99

Chicken Parmigiana, 2 Orders Of Pasta

Price may varies

baked ziti, linguini, penne or spaghetti

Large Tossed Salad

Price may varies

Italian Dinner Bread

Price may varies


Wednesday $23.99

Hot Roast Beef

Price may varies

with brown gravy

Macaroni & Cheese

Price may varies

1 Lb Of Potato Salad Or Cole Slaw

Price may varies


Thursday $21.99

Chicken Parmigiana, 2 Orders Of Pasta

Price may varies

baked ziti, linguini, penne or spaghetti

Large Tossed Salad

Price may varies

Italian Dinner Bread

Price may varies


Fresh Produce

Oranges

Price may varies

Apples

Price may varies

Bananas

Price may varies

Lemons

Price may varies

Eggplant

Price may varies

Iceberg Lettuce

Price may varies

Romaine Lettuce

Price may varies

Spanish Onion

Price may varies

Bermuda Onions

Price may varies

Cucumbers

Price may varies

Green Peppers

Price may varies

Potatoes

Price may varies


Fresh Meats

Sweet Sausage

Price may varies

Chop Meat

Price may varies

Breaded Chicken Cutlets

Price may varies

Raw Chicken Cutlets

Price may varies


Homemade Sauces

Marinara

Price may varies

pint or quart

Spaghetti

Price may varies

pint or quart


Frozen Pasta Products

Ravioli

Price may varies

cheese, meat or lobster

Tortellini

Price may varies

meat or cheese

Manicotti

Price may varies

Cavatelli

Price may varies


BreakfastsPer Person

Rise & Shine Breakfast

$1.99

coffee, tea & sanka service, 10 people minimum

Eye Opener Breakfast

$8.99

scrambled eggs, bacon or sausage toast & home fried potatoes, coffee, tea & sanka, juice & paper goods, 20 people minimum

Continental Breakfast

$5.49

assorted danish, muffins & bagels, butter, cream cheese & jelly, coffee, tea & sanka, assorted juices, paper goods, 10 people minimum

The Hearty Breakfast

$10.99

scrambled eggs, bacon & sausage, french toast, home fries, assorted bagels or toast coffee, tea & sanka, juice & paper goods, 20 people minimum


Luncheons

#1. Finger Sandwich Platter

$55.00

roast beef, ham & swiss, turkey breast on white or rye topped with cole slaw

#2. Finger Sandwich Platter

$55.00

genoa salami, prosciutto & pepperoni topped with lettuce & tomato

#3. Finger Sandwich Platter

$55.00

corned beef, pastrami & turkey breast on rye topped with cole slaw & russian dressing

Super Long Heroes

$16.00

3ft, 4ft, 5ft, or 6ft (5 inches wide), ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, proscuitto, proscuttini, imported capicola, turkey breast, swiss cheese, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, salt pepper, oregan


Specialty Soups $2.25Per Person. Available Upon Request

Spilt Pea Soup

Price may varies

French Onion Soup

Price may varies

Cream Of Broccoli

Price may varies

Cream Of Potato

Price may varies

Pasta Fagioli

Price may varies


Party PlattersServes 10

The Standard

$40.00

roast beef, ham, turkey breast, genoa salami & choice of 2 cheeses

The Italian

$45.00

proscuitto, cappicola, sopressata, ham & imported provolone


Assorted Pasta SaladsLb

Penne Pasta

$6.99

sun dried tomatoes, roasted peppers, black olives, red onions, basil, garlic, oregano, salt, pepper, balsamic vinegar olive oil

Summer Wind

$5.99

baby shells, snow pea pods, sliced carrots, broccoli, dill cream sauce

Tortellini Salad

$6.99

meat tortellini, sweet peppers, bermuda red onions, black olives, fresh basil, oregano, oil & vinegar

Tri Colored Pasta

$6.99

tri colored pasta, salami, provolone, black olives, bermuda red onions, sweet peppers, olive oil, balsamic vinegar

Bianca Boccocini

$6.99

radiatore pasta, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, diced tomatoes, garlic, olive oil

Afternoon Delight

$6.99

cavatelli, spinach, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, white wine, garlic & olive oil

Catch Of The Day

$7.49

tongol tuna, diced tomatoes, sliced carrots, bermuda red onion, tarragon leaf, garlic vinegar & olive oil


All Hot Buffet CateringIncludes

Tossed Salad

Price may varies

lettuce, tomato, onions, green and black olives, house dressing

Caesar's Salad

Price may varies

your choice of one the following

Italian Giardiniera Mix

Price may varies

Baked Baby Whole Potatoes

Price may varies

Steamed Veggies

Price may varies

Stuffed Shells

Price may varies

Baked Ziti

Price may varies

Lasagna

Price may varies

Manicotti

Price may varies

Saffron Rice

Price may varies

Eggplant Parmigiana

Price may varies

Eggplant Rollatini

Price may varies

Stuffed Cabbage

Price may varies

Italian Meatballs

Price may varies

Penne Ala Vodka

Price may varies

Buffalo Chicken Wings

Price may varies

Hot Roast Beef & Gravy

Price may varies

Swedish Meatballs

Price may varies

Kielbasa & Sauerkraut

Price may varies

Batter Dipped Chicken

Price may varies

Mussels In Marinara

Price may varies

Sausage Peppers & Onions

Price may varies

Ham Hawaiian

Price may varies

Pepper Steak

Price may varies

Chicken Marsala

Price may varies

Chicken Francaise

Price may varies

Chicken Picatta

Price may varies

Chicken Parmigiana

Price may varies


Cold Buffet Catering $6.99Per person. 10 Person Minimum

Fresh Roast Beef

Price may varies

Domestic Boiled Ham

Price may varies

Genoa Salami

Price may varies

Pepperoni

Price may varies

Turkey Breast

Price may varies

Swiss Cheese

Price may varies

American Cheese & Provolone Cheese

Price may varies

Potato Salad

Price may varies

Cole Slaw & Macaroni Salad

Price may varies

Kosher Dill Pickles

Price may varies

Green Olives

Price may varies

Black Olives

Price may varies

Italian Giardiniera

Price may varies

Rolls

Price may varies

Rye Bread

Price may varies

Onion Rolls

Price may varies

Pumpernickel Rolls

Price may varies

Plates

Price may varies

Napkins

Price may varies

Forks & Knives

Price may varies

Mayonnaise & Mustard

Price may varies


Hot & Cold Buffet Catering

Fresh Roast Beef

Price may varies

Domestic Boiled Ham

Price may varies

Genoa Salami

Price may varies

Pepperoni

Price may varies

Turkey Breast

Price may varies

Swiss Cheese

Price may varies

American Cheese & Provolone Cheese

Price may varies

Potato Salad

Price may varies

Cole Slaw & Macaroni Salad

Price may varies

Kosher Dill Pickles

Price may varies

Green Olives

Price may varies

Black Olives

Price may varies

Italian Giardiniera

Price may varies

Rolls

Price may varies

Rye Bread

Price may varies

Onions Rolls

Price may varies

Pumpernickel Rolls

Price may varies

Plates

Price may varies

Napkins

Price may varies

Forks & Knives

Price may varies

Mayonnaise & Mustard

Price may varies


Hot & Cold Buffet Catering $13.99Per Person 20 Person Minimum. Choice Of Any Three Entrees Extra Charge $1 Per Person, Extra Charge $1 Per Hot Choice Above 3

Penne Ala Vodka

Price may varies

Stuffed Shells

Price may varies

Baked Ziti

Price may varies

Lasagna

Price may varies

Manicotti

Price may varies

Saffron Rice

Price may varies

Eggplant Parmigiana

Price may varies

Stuffed Cabbage

Price may varies

Mussels In Marinara

Price may varies

Hot Roast Beef In Gravy

Price may varies

Buffalo Wings

Price may varies

Chicken Parmigiana

Price may varies

Eggplant Rollatini

Price may varies

Italian Meatballs

Price may varies

Swedish Meatballs

Price may varies

Sausage Peppers & Onion

Price may varies

Batter Dipped Chicken

Price may varies

Kielbasa & Sauerkraut

Price may varies

Ham Hawaiian

Price may varies

Pepper Steak

Price may varies

Chicken Marsala

Price may varies

Chicken Francaise

Price may varies

Chicken Picatta

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading