Nantucket Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 63 votes
Nantucket Logo
Pizza

Choose My State

MI

Nantucket Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Everyday Breads

San Francisco Sourdough

Price may varies

A nantucket original! our sourdough is extremely tangy and has a chewy crust you won’t forget

Three Cheese & Garlic

Price may varies

Cheddar cheese, asiago cheese, reggiano parmesan, and garlic fill the tasty white bread

Brioche

Price may varies

Classic french bread overwhelmed with butter and eggs

Ancient Grain Sourdough

Price may varies

Millet, flaxseed, rye, amaranth, quinoa, and spelt are milled into a wonderful flour blend which we mix with our organic wheat flour and one of our sourdough started. Has a beautiful crust and a natu

Multigrain

Price may varies

This super light bread has has 11 grains. A thick crust, accompanied by a light interior, packed with grains great toasted

Polish Rye

Price may varies

A traditional polish rye. Made with over 50% rye flour, our very classic European sour starter, this polish delicacy is dense and packed with delicious little caraway seeds

Assorted Baguettes

Price may varies

Either our classic french baguette or a tasty multigrain baguette

Kameelian Sourdough

Price may varies

We combine all of our sour starters in this one! Light, airy, tangy, crusty

Cranberry Walnut

Price may varies

Cranberries, walnuts, whole wheat, multigrain, local honey videtich apiaries

Pretzels

Price may varies

Soft german pretzels, dipped in our food grade lye solution for maximum color and flavor. You can’t find these anywhere in grand rapids but here

Ciabatta

Price may varies

Our crusty and aerated ciabatta is now available everyday

Assorted Bagels

Price may varies

These dense and crusty delights are made by hand in house every day! Cinnamon raisin, or rosemary or our house blended


Daily Bread Schedule

French Bread Reggiano Parmesan

Price may varies

Monday

Six Grain

Price may varies

Cinnamon raisin pecan sourdough tuesday

Nine Grain Jalapeno Cheddar

Price may varies

Wednesday

Bacon Sourdough

Price may varies

Thursday

Italian Semolina Marbled Rye

Price may varies

Pumpernickel rye, six grain, challah, chocolate challah

Hard Rolls

Price may varies

Bunduckies, cinnamon raisin, vienna, old world sourdough saturday

Spent Grain

Price may varies

Nutty wheat, ezekial Sunday


Organic Sourdough Schedule

Baker Special

Price may varies

Monday

Five Seed

Price may varies

Tuesday

Baker Special

Price may varies

Wednesday

Quinoa Red, White, and Black

Price may varies

Thursday

Chia Seed

Price may varies

Friday

Roasted Garlic & Parmesan

Price may varies

Saturday

Maple Cherry Flaxseed

Price may varies

Sunday


Brioche Schedule

Brioche Schedule

Price may varies

Monday, tuesday, wednesday, thrusday, friday, saturday, sunday


Cakes & Specialty Tortes6 inch serves 4-6, 8 inch serves 8-12, 10 inch serves 14-18, 1/4 sheet serves 15-20, 1/2 sheet serves 30-40, full sheet serves 72-80

Strawberry Slammer

Price may varies

White cake layered with fresh strawberries and chantilly cream. Finished with white butter cream and sugared almonds on the sides

Domino

Price may varies

Alternating three layers of white and chocolate cake with one layer white chocolate mousse and one layer chocolate mousse. Finished with white butter cream and chocolate curls on the sides.

Tall Dark and Handsome

Price may varies

Chocolate cake layers with a thin vanilla cheesecake layer in the center and a dark chocolate mousse filling between the tiers. Iced in a thin layer of chocolate butter cream and then covered in gana

German Chocolate Cake

Price may varies

Chocolate cake layered with our traditional German chocolate filling. Finished with chocolate butter cream and toasted coconut on sides

Chocolate Strawberry Slammer

Price may varies

Chocolate cake layered with fresh strawberries and Chantilly cream. Finished with chocolate butter cream and dark chocolate curls on the sides

Carrot Cake

Price may varies

Three layers of moist carrot cake with carrots, nuts, and spices. Finished in cream cheese icing and walnuts on the sides

Lady in Red

Price may varies

White cake layers with a thin vanilla cheesecake layer in the center and a raspberry mousse filling between the tiers. The entire cake is iced in butter cream with white chocolate vermicelli on the s

Candy Striper (Seasonal)

Price may varies

Chocolate cake layers with a thin vanilla cheesecake layer in the center and a peppermint mousse and creme de menthe mousse filling between the tiers. The entire cake is iced in butter cream and then

Divinity

Price may varies

Chocolate cake layered with our decadent chocolate mousse. Finished with chocolate butter cream and dark chocolate curls on the sides

Chocolate Raspberry Rapture

Price may varies

Chocolate cake layered with fresh raspberries and raspberry mousse. Finished with chocolate butter cream with dark chocolate curls up the sides

Chocolate Flourless Cake

Price may varies

A wonderfully light chocolate cake. Finished with chocolate rum glaze.

Build Your Own Cake or Torte

Price may varies

Choose from carrot cake, chocolate, vanilla, or combo. Fillings: chocolate mousse, white chocolate mousse, ganache, strawberry mousse, raspberry mousse. Finishes: chocolate ganache, chocolate butter


CheesecakesAll cheesecakes require a minimum 48 hour notice. 6 inch serves 4-6, 8 inch, serves 8-12, 10 inch serves 14-16

Tall Dark and Handsome

Price may varies

Chocolate cake layers with a thin vanilla cheesecake layer in the center and a dark chocolate mousse filling between the tiers. Iced in a thin layer of chocolate butter cream and then covered in gana

Espresso

Price may varies

A rich-flavored espresso cheesecake with a graham cracker crust.

Blood Orange

Price may varies

Flavorful blood orange concentrate infused in this luscious cheesecake with a graham cracker crust.

Vanilla Bean

Price may varies

Real vanilla beans infused with a traditional New York-style cheesecake, with a graham cracker crust.

Peanut Butter Cup

Price may varies

A rich, creamy cheesecake with peanut butter pieces folded in. Supported by a graham cracker crust.

Chocolate Mayan

Price may varies

A dark chocolate cheesecake infused with cinnamon and cayenne pepper on an Oreo crust.

Martha’s Mayhem

Price may varies

Vanilla cheesecake marbled with a rich, chocolate cheesecake with an oreo cookie crumb crust.

Chocolate Hazelnut

Price may varies

Chocolate hazelnut cheesecake with an oreo cookie crust. Finished with a chocolate design.

Bailey’s

Price may varies

Made with flavorful Bailey’s Irish cream on top of a graham cracker crust.

Strawberry

Price may varies

A true strawberry flavored cheesecake with strawberries throughout on a graham cracker crust.

Raspberry Roundhouse

Price may varies

Vanilla cheesescake marbled with a raspberry filling on a graham cracker crust.

Key Lime

Price may varies

Key lime flavored cheesecake with a graham cracker crust bottom, topped with our fantastic chantilly cream and lime zest.


Fresh PiesAll pies require a minimum 48 hour notice

Tall Dark and Handsome

Price may varies

Chocolate cake layers with a thin vanilla cheesecake layer in the center and a dark chocolate mousse filling between the tiers. Iced in a thin layer of chocolate butter cream and then covered in gana

Fruit Pies

Price may varies

Choose from apple, cherry, blueberry, or peach double crust or dutch style. We also offer seasonal fruit pies

Other Pies

Price may varies

Choose from key lime, pecan, or pumpkin. 8 traditional slices.


Pastry Bars

Fudge Toffee Brownie

Price may varies

Made with the highest quality chocolate, this brownie is rich and decadent and filled with toffee

Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Bar

Price may varies

Chocolate chip cookie bottom topped with peanut butter filling and reese’s peanut butter cup pieces.

Kameelian Bar

Price may varies

Sweetened condensed milk with hazelnut liquor, coconut, chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, and walnuts all mixed together atop a graham cracker crust.

Trail Mix Bars

Price may varies

Our oatmeal raisin cookie dough, jampacked with cranberries, sunflower seeds and walnuts

Lemon Zinger Bar

Price may varies

Lemon filling atop a shortbread crust dusted with powdered sugar and decorated with confectionery sugar. Great for a refreshing treat on a hot summer day

Granola Bar

Price may varies

Our granola bar is a remake of the traditional chewy chocolate chip granola bar. Filled with chocolate chips, peanut butter, steel cut oats, pumpkin seeds, flax seed and cranberries


Assorted Pastries

Muffins

Price may varies

Choose from blueberry, double chocolate muffin, or health muffin. Also inquire about our daily specialty muffin

Other Tarts

Price may varies

Choose from key lime or lemon meringue

Frosted Cupcakes

Price may varies

Choose your size, quantity and flavor

Scones

Price may varies

Choose from cranberry almond, chocolate chip, or our savory scone of the day

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries

Price may varies

Large strawberries dipped in your choice of white, milk or dark Chocolate

Chocolate Mousse Cups

Price may varies

Choose from raspberry, strawberry, chocolate, or white chocolate

Fresh Fruit Tarts

Price may varies

Our sweet and crispy butter tart shell filled with cream and assorted fresh fruits

Tuxedo Strawberries

Price may varies

Handsome, tasty little strawberries wearing a tuxedo. What could be more delightful


Cookies

Everything Cookies

Price may varies

Pecan, almonds, walnuts, oatmeal, chocolate, cherries, coconut, and love

M & M

Price may varies

Soft, chewy sugar cookie filled with milk chocolate M & M’s

Classic Chocolate Chip

Price may varies

Theeeeee classic chocolate chip

Snickerdoodles

Price may varies

Our snicker doodle is a soft chewy cinnamon sugar cookie that is rolled in cinnamon sugar to ensure perfect sweetness

Peanut Butter

Price may varies

Peanut butter, sugar, eggs, flour, vanilla

Molasses

Price may varies

Spicy and chewy

Oatmeal Raisin

Price may varies

Healthy and sweet packed with steel cut oats and overwhelmed with juicy raisins


Our Pizza Menu

Extra Special

Price may varies

Six toppings make this one a classic pepperoni, fresh Italian sausage, red onions, fresh mushrooms, Kalamata olives and green peppers.

Styx

Price may varies

Our traditional pizza crust, brushed with garlic olive oil, seasoned with spices and sprinkled with our specialty mozzarella cheese blend served with a side of our house made red sauce.

Red Devil

Price may varies

A combination of pepperoni, sun-dried tomatoes, red onion, roasted red pepper, and a sprinkle of fresh Parmesan over our mozzarella cheese blend.

Fairhaven

Price may varies

A vegetarian pie with fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives and sun dried tomatoes.

The Union

Price may varies

Our honey wheat crust covered with our own creamy alfredo sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh basil, grilled chicken and finished with toasted sliced almonds and goat cheese.

Martha’s Deluxe

Price may varies

Rich and flavorful, this pizza features fresh Italian sausage, green olives, red onions, roasted pine nuts, artichoke hearts, our mozzarella cheese blend and complimented by a sprinkle of robust gorg

TRI Works

Price may varies

A meat lovers dream featuring fresh Italian sausage, pepperoni, and bacon

Chicken Pesto

Price may varies

A pie with bright, pure flavors basil pesto base, red onions, fresh mushrooms and grilled chicken

Sicilian

Price may varies

An authentic southern Italian favorite with spiced sausage, raisins, toasted pine nuts, red onions, fresh mozzarella, a dusting of sea-salt and freshly ground black pepper.

The Lyon

Price may varies

A creation of roasted potato, spinach, roasted red pepper, fresh sausage, Gorgonzola and a dusting of cajun seasoning.

The Mike

Price may varies

Feeling adventurous. Let our pizza masters surprise you with something delicious! Remember to let us know if you are a carnivore, vegetarian or vegan

Stinking Rose

Price may varies

A delight for those who love garlic. This one has double garlic, fresh mushrooms, red onions, and a dusting parmesan cheese. Add bacon or sausage for only a dollar

Margarita

Price may varies

A traditional pie with a thin crust, garden fresh basil and our fresh mozzarella.

Pete’s Dragon

Price may varies

A garlic olive oil base, sun dried tomatoes, red onion, prosciutto, our mozzarella cheese blend, a pesto drizzle and a dash of gorgonzola to mix things up a bit

Tree Star

Price may varies

Enjoy this fresh vegetarian pie with garlic, spinach, summer squash, zucchini, broccoli, red onion, feta cheese as well as a dash of sea salt and pepper.


Create Your Own MasterpieceAdd $1.00 per additional item

Veggies

Price may varies

Artichoke hearts, basil, garlic, green olives, green pepper, jalapenos, kalamata olives, mushrooms, onions, pepperoncinis, pineapple, red pepper, roasted pine nuts, roasted potato, spinach, sun-dried

Cheeses

Price may varies

Asiago, feta cheese, fresh mozzarella, goat cheese, gorgonzola, mozzarella blend, parmesan

Meats

Price may varies

Anchovies, bacon, pepperoni, cajun chicken, chicken, fresh sausage, ham, prosciutto, cajun shrimp, shrimp, spicy sausage


Nautucket Baking Co Pizzas

The Original

$6.99

A classic cheese pizza on our crispy Neapolitan style crust

Extra Special

$13.99

Six toppings make this one a classic. Pepperoni, fresh Italian sausage, onions, fresh mushrooms, kalamata olives, and green peppers.

Martha’s Deluxe

$13.99

Rich and flavorful, this pizza features fresh sausage, green olives, red onion, artichoke hearts, pine nuts, our mozzarella cheese blend and complimented by a sprinkle of a robust gorgonzola.

Try Works

$12.99

A meat lovers pie with fresh Italian sausage, pepperoni and bacon.

Stinking Rose

$9.99

A delight for those who love garlic. This one has double garlic, fresh mushrooms, red onion and a dusting of parmesan cheese. Add bacon or sausage for only a dollar.

Red Devil

$9.99

A combination of pepperoni, sun-dried tomatoes, red onion, roasted red pepper and a sprinkle of fresh parmesan over our mozzarella cheese blend.

Chicken Pesto

$11.99

A pie with bright, pure flavors, basil pesto base red onions, fresh mushrooms and grilled chicken.

Margarita

$8.99

A traditional Italian pie with thin crust, garden fresh basil and our fresh mozzarella.

Fairhaven

$11.99

A vegetarian pie with fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives and sun-dried tomatoes.

Sicilian

$11.99

An authentic Southern Italian favorite, with spiced sausage, raisins, toasted pine nuts, red onion, fresh mozzarella, a dusting of sea salt and freshly ground black pepper.

Pete’s Dragon

$11.99

A garlic olive oil base, sun dried tomatoes, red onion, prosciutto, our mozzarella cheese blend, a presto drizzle and a dash of gorgonzola to mix things up a bit

The Union

$11.99

Our whole wheat crust covered with homemade creamy alfredo sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, grilled chicken and finished with toasted almond slices and goat cheese.

The Lyon

$11.99

A creation of roasted potato, spinach, roasted red pepper, fresh sausage, gorgonzola and a dusting on cajun seasoning

The Volcano

$12.99

A hawaiian traditional pie with a kick. This tri-meat pizza of pepperoni, ham, and bacon brings you back to the island with the sweetness of pineapple, the heat of jalapenos and a splash of Sriracha

The Mike

$12.99

Feeling adventurous. Let our pizza masters surprise you with something delicious. Remember to let us know if you are a carnivore, vegetarian or vegan.

Tree Star

$11.99

Enjoy this fresh vegetarian pie with garlic, spinach, summer squash, zucchini, broccoli, red onion, feta cheese and a dash of sea salt and pepper.

Styx

$7.99

Our traditional pizza crust, brushed with garlic olive oil, seasoned with spices and sprinkled with our specialty mozzarella cheese blend. Served with a side of our house made red sauce.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading