Mara's Homemade Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 104 votes
Mara's Homemade Logo

Choose My State

NY

Mara's Homemade Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Live Cajun Crawfish Boil, lb

$12.00

Flown in live from Louisiana, boiled in our authentic Cajun spiced boil lip burning spicy. Make it deluxe with corn on the cob for an additional $5.

Crab Cake Appetizer

$12.00

1 cake, crabby with a brust of spicy flavor, garnished with a fried pickle, served with Mara's Remoulade sauce.

Spicy Fresh Artichoke (GF)

$9.00

Cooked in our Cajun spicy boil until tender, served with Remoulade sauce

Shishito Peppers

$8.00

Blistered Japanese peppers drizzled with truffle oil, dusted with sea salt.

Watermelon Feta Salad

$12.00

Fresh watermelon, feta and red onion on mixed greens with Mara's poppyseed dressing

Spinach Oyster Salad

$14.00

Baby spinach, red onion, spiced pecans tossed with Mara's Italian dressing, topped with 3 fried Louisiana oysters


Seafood Selections

Soft Shell Crabs

$28.00

2 jumbo crabs sauteed in garlic butter, served on rice pilaf (GF Sauteed Greens, add $3) OR fried and dressed on an po'boy sandwich

Lobster Roll (GF,*), Lobster BLT

$23.00 - $25.00

Mara's light mayo lobster salad on a buttered roll (GF,* on lettuce leaf) OR on herb buttered Texas toast with bacon, lettuce and tomato; each served with choice of no-mayo cole slaw, hand cut French

Lobster Clambake

$40.00

1 1/2 - 2 lbs lobster, 1 lb mussels, 1 dz Little Neck clams steamed in our wine, champagne and garlic broth

Strawberry Scallops (GF)

$31.00

4 sea scallops pan seared, served on a bed of carrot and zucchini spaghetti sauteed with mushrooms in herb butter, served with a strawberry 4 Roses Bourbon glaze

Killer Shrimp

$24.00

Half pound shell on jumbo Gulf shrimp simmered in an herb and spice water based broth, served with bread to dunk.

Shrimp Feast

$33.00

1 lb fresh Gulf shell-on shrimp prepared 4 different ways

Crabcake Dinner

$28.00

2 crab cakes each garnished a fried pickle, served with choice of Jambalaya OR Crawfish Etouffee (* with Jambalaya

Whole Crisp Branzino

$28.00

Baked crisp, served on sauteed collard greens with a lemon, white wine sauce

Char-grilled

$27.00

Served on a bed of sauteed collard greens tossed with Cajun corn and diced fresh tomatoes.

Blackened Swordfish

$27.00

served on a bed of sauteed collard greens tossed with Cajun corn and diced fresh tomatoes (* Olive Oil for greens)

Baked Redfish

$26.00

Redfish fillet baked with a sundried tomato, pecan pesto, garnished with guacamole, served with roasted Brussels sprouts.

Blackened Redfish

$26.00

Gulf redfish fillet rubbed with our special blend of spices, blackened, served over sauteed collard greens


Land Selections

Shishito Goat Cheese burger

$15.00

Chipotle ketchup, blistered Shishito peppers, red onion, lettuce, poppyseed dressing.

Beef Ribs

$19.00

Seasoned and smoked, served with choice of two sides and jalapeno cornbread OR Texas Toast.

Cajun Marinated NY Strip Steak

$34.00

Marinated in Abita Turbo Dog beer, Creole seasoning and honey, char-grilled, served with caramelized onions and mushrooms and choice of garlic mashed potatoes OR hand cut French fries


Seasonal Desserts

Fresh Strawberry Almond Pie

$8.00

Banana Caramel Creme Pie

$8.00

Banana Chocolate Bread Pudding with Banana Rum Ice Cream

$11.00

Fresh Peach Cobbler

$8.00

Strawberry Oreo Rye Ice Cream

$6.00

Banana Rum Ice Cream

$6.00

Peach 4 Roses Bourbon Ice Cream

$6.00


DessertsAll whole pies and cakes may be ordered with at least a day's notice.

Bluegrass Pie

$9.00

Pecan pie with chocolate and bourbon in the filling

Chocolate Cream Pie

$9.00

An Oreo cookie crust filled with dark chocolate mousse, topped with freshly whipped cream

Key Lime Pie

$7.00

A graham cracker crust filled with a balance of sweet and tart

Coconut Cream Pie

$8.00

An Animal Cracker cookie crust filled with creamy coconut custard topped with meringue and toasted coconut. Check availability.

Strawberry Jalapeno Ice Cream

$6.00

Josh's homemade creation

Vanilla Ice Cream

$3.00

Rich and creamy, homemade

Fresh Fruit Cobbler

Price may varies

Seasonal selections. Check availability. Price varies

Banana Chocolate Bread Pudding

$9.00

Check availability.

Beignets

$6.00

Mara's Homemade French doughnuts dusted with powdered sugar. Not available for take out

Chocolate Soufflé

$10.00

A flourless, dark chocolate soufflé accompanied by a dark chocolate sauce

Bananas Fosterq

$9.00

Bananas simmered in brown sugar, cinnamon, butter, banana liqueur, flamed in rum, then poured over vanilla ice cream.

Red Velvet Cake

$8.00

A densely textured light chocolate cake with a cream cheese, pecan, coconut, cherry filling and butter cream icing. Check availability.

Chocolate Pecan Cake

$9.00

A dark chocolate fudge cake, richly decadent with a dark chocolate glaze, topped with pecans

Traditional Pecan Pie

$7.00

A flakey butter crust filled with pecan pie, the traditional southern way.

Fresh Strawberry Almond Pie

$9.00

An almond graham cracker crust filled with fresh strawberries, served with freshly whipped cream.

Blueberry Crumb Pie

$7.00

Fresh blueberries baked in a flaky butter crust topped with streizel.

Banana Pudding Cheesecake

$9.00

The merging of the North and the South's favorites in one scrumptious dessert. A Vanilla Wafer crust with bananas folded into the cheesecake, then topped with caramelized bananas and garnished with a


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading