Maggie & Molly's Bakery Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 144 votes
Maggie & Molly's Bakery Logo
Bakery

Choose My State

CO

Maggie & Molly's Bakery Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Breakfast

Blueberry Muffins

$24.00

one dozen fresh muffins made with sour cream and real blueberries.

Blueberry Scones

$12.00

six scones made with fresh blueberries.

Buttermilk Spice Muffins

$24.00

one dozen fresh muffins made with buttermilk and cinnamon.

Cherry Oat Scones

$10.00

six fresh scones made with dried cherries, oatmeal and real butter

Cinnamon Rolls

$15.00

a tin of seven savory cinnamon rolls with lots of royal icing

Pumpkin Muffins

$24.00

one dozen yummy and moist pumpkin muffins. perfect for an autumn breakfast

Raspberry Scones

$10.00

six homemade tasting raspberry scones in classic square shape

Sour Cream Crumb Cake

$24.00

a moist, tasty classic sour cream crumb cake

Sweet Bread Braid

$25.00

a pleasing breakfast for just about any morning. when it's made fresh and just for you, it tastes like nothing else!


Cakes and Cupcakes

Assortment of Cupcakes

$24.00

can't decide? then order an assortment of one dozen of maggie & molly's bakery's best selling cupcakes!

Autumnal Hydrangea Cupcakes

$24.00

these are our popular hydrangea cupcakes, but now you can get them in pretty autumn colors.

Carrot Cake

$35.00

the tastiest and most moist carrot cake you've ever tasted.

Carrot Cupcakes

$24.00

one dozen moist and yummy tasting carrot cupcakes with cream cheese frosting.

Chocolate Cupcakes with Seven Minute Frosting

$24.00

one dozen chocolate cupcakes with classic seven minute frosting.

Chocolate Cupcakes with Sprinkles

$24.00

one dozen tasty chocolate cupcakes topped with chocolate buttercream frosting and loads of colorful sprinkles.

Chocolate Pound Cake with Vanilla Glaze

$35.00

this cake was inspired by our favorite restaurant in charleston, s.c. it's a moist chocolate pound cake with lots of creamy vanilla glaze. a true delicacy!

Coconut Ball Cupcakes

$24.00

one dozen white cupcakes topped with fresh buttercream and lots of flaked sweet coconut.

Coconut Cake

$35.00

elegant, tasty, sweet and chock full o' coconut. we make our coconut cake with white cake

Cookies and Cream Cupcakes

$24.00

our favorite ice cream...our favorite cupcake. lots of creamy vanilla buttercream piled on top of a chocolate cupcake then sprinkled with crushed chocolate wafer. oh, boy!

Flower Iced Cupcakes

$24.00

one dozen chocolate or white cupcakes decorated with lightly tinted royal icing and a pretty flower on top.

Frosted Angel Food Cake

$30.00

frosted angel food cake. you've never tasted angel food cake until you've tasted this one!

Halloween Cupcakes

$24.00

one dozen cupcakes decorated with royal icing to resemble the creepiest of halloween cobwebs.

Halloween Cupcakes with Buttercream

$24.00

one dozen delicious cupcakes with vanilla and chocolate buttercream and topped with halloween sprinkles.

Hydrangea Cupcakes with Buttercream Frosting

$24.00

one dozen cupcakes topped with a delicate buttercream frosting. our hydrangea cupcakes are one of our most popular items.

Italian Cream Cake

$35.00

this cake is a white cake with coconut and then cream cheese frosting with coconut and lots of walnuts. why it's called italian is not clear to us...this is about as southern of a recipe as you can g

Lemon Cupcakes

$24.00

one dozen lemon cupcakes topped with lemon buttercream. our newest flavor!

Luscious Chocolate Cake

$35.00

rich, luscious chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream frosting

Old Fashioned Spice Cupcakes

$24.00

yummmm...the tastes of fall. that includes cinnamon, allspice and freshly group nutmeg.

Peanut Butter Cupcakes

$24.00

our newest flavor! this cupcake puts the ""mmmmm"" in moist. one dozen cupcakes made with organic peanut butter and topped with a dark chocolate frosting.

Petit Fours

$35.00

so lovely and delicate! our petit fours are made from a special white cake and can include a raspberry filling or icing if you'd prefer.

Pumpkin Bundt Cakes

$18.00

six fresh pumpkin bundt cakes with brown butter icing. these cakes are a unique and unforgettable combination

Red Velvet Cake

$35.00

a beautiful, tasty and extremely moist cake. ours is a traditional red velvet cake with a tint of chocolate and lots of cream cheese frosting.

Red Velvet Rose Cupcakes

$24.00

classic southern dessert and a maggie & molly's bakery specialty! one dozen red velvet cupcakes with cream cheese frosting presented to resemble a lovely cream colored rose

Seven Inch Chocolate Cake

$25.00

we can make all of our cakes in the seven inch size for a smaller gathering. this cake serves 6 - 8 people.

Sheet Cake

$75.00

yes, we do sheet cakes in all of our cake varieties. this size cake serves 25 - 35 people

Yellow Cupcakes with Chocolate Buttercream

$24.00

many people say that yellow cake is their absolute favorite. we know why...it's the buttah!


Catering

Assortment of Cupcakes

$24.00

can't decide? then order an assortment of one dozen of maggie & molly's bakery's best selling cupcakes

Baby Shower Cookies

$24.00

one dozen adorable sugar cookies for a baby shower or to celebrate a new arrival.

Gingerbread Cookies

$75.00

one hundred gingerbread dragonfly cookies decorated with royal icing

Large Cookie Tray

$50.00

a lovely assortment of our favorite cookies.

Large Cookie and Cupcake Tray

$65.00

a large tray of assorted cupcakes and cookies. serves 20 to 30 people

Large Pastry Dessert Tray

$80.00

we believe we make the prettiest and most interesting pastry trays around.

Medium Cookie Tray

$35.00

enough cookies to serve 11 to 20 people

Medium Cupcake and Cookie Tray

$45.00

serves 11 - 20 people.

Petit Fours

$35.00

so lovely and delicate! our petit fours are made from a special white cake and can include a raspberry filling or icing if you'd prefer.

Sheet Cake

$75.00

yes, we do sheet cakes in all of our cake varieties. this size cake serves 25 - 35 people

Wedding Cake Sugar Cookies

$24.00

one dozen of our special sugar cookies shaped like a wedding cake.


Cookies

Baby Boy and Girl Sugar Cookies

$24.00

one dozen pink and/or blue butter sugar cookies - perfect for a child's birthday or a baby shower.

Baby Shower Cookies

$24.00

one dozen adorable sugar cookies for a baby shower or to celebrate a new arrival.

Black and White Cookies

$24.00

the classic new york cookie!

Brown Cow Chocolate Cookies

$24.00

how now brown cow?? these are our special chocolate sugar cookies decorated with royal icing in the funky colors of the day.

Butterfly Sugar Cookies

$24.00

one dozen classic butter sugar cookies decorated with royal icing.

Caterpillar Sugar Cookies

$24.00

eat me! no...eat me! these happy to see you sugar cookies are not only adorable. they taste great, too. one dozen per order.

Cherry & Lemon Biscotti

$15.00

two dozen dried cherry and lemon homemade biscotti. you've never tasted biscotti like this!

Chewy Pecan Brownies

$20.00

one dozen chewy, chocolate brownies scattered with pecans and a dribbling of chocolate glaze

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$18.00

one dozen chocolate chip cookies filled with lots of high quality chocolate chips.

Chocolate Walnut Cookies

$18.00

a maggie & molly's exclusive!

Denver Bronco Sugar Cookies

$24.00

yea! we are so ready for some football...one dozen sugar cookies designed like (sorta like) the denver bronco helmet

Flower Power Sugar Cookies

$24.00

peace, baby! one dozen brightly colored sugar cookies made fresh and with lots of creamy butter.

Gingerbread Autumn Leaves

$24.00

two dozen sweet, tangy gingerbread cookies hand decorated like autumn leaves

Halloween Gingerbread Cookies

$24.00

gingerbread cookies for halloween parties and gift giving.

Large Cookie Tray

$50.00

a lovely assortment of our favorite cookies

Lemon Squares

$18.00

one dozen lemon squares made fresh with real lemons.

Linzer Cookies

$24.00

one dozen melt in your mouth cookies made from a classic linzer recipe perfected in old europe. each cookie is actually two cookies pressed together between sweet raspberry preserves

Medium Cookie Tray

$35.00

enough cookies to serve 11 to 20 people.

Mini Chocolate Sugar Cookies

$24.00

a tasty and interesting twist on the classic sugar cookie. the chocolate sugar cookie tastes a bit like a chocolate wafer.

Mini Spring Sugar Cookies

$24.00

the mini version of our classic sugar cookies. you get 24 sweet, buttery cookies shaped like flowers and decorated with royal icing.

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

$18.00

one dozen traditional oatmeal cookies with lots and lots of fresh, tasty raisins.

Oatmeal and Cherry Cookies

$18.00

one dozen buttery and chewy oatmeal cookies with lots of dried cherries.

Peanut Butter Cookies

$18.00

one dozen classic homemade peanut butter cookies

Snickerdoodle Cookies

$18.00

one dozen snickerdoodle cookies made with butter and dusted with cinnamon and sugar.

Sugar Drop Cookies

$18.00

one dozen of the old fashion buttery sugar drop cookies topped with lots of shimmery sugar.

Wedding Cake Sugar Cookies

$24.00

one dozen of our special sugar cookies shaped like a wedding cake


Holiday and Seasonal Items

Autumnal Hydrangea Cupcakes

$24.00

these are our popular hydrangea cupcakes, but now you can get them in pretty autumn colors.

Classic Cherry Pie

$25.00

our classic sour cherry pie made with a flaky, buttery crust

Denver Bronco Sugar Cookies

$24.00

yea! we are so ready for some football...one dozen sugar cookies designed like (sorta like) the denver bronco helmet.

Gingerbread Autumn Leaves

$24.00

two dozen sweet, tangy gingerbread cookies hand decorated like autumn leaves.

Halloween Cupcakes

$24.00

one dozen cupcakes decorated with royal icing to resemble the creepiest of halloween cobwebs.

Halloween Cupcakes with Buttercream

$24.00

one dozen delicious cupcakes with vanilla and chocolate buttercream and topped with halloween sprinkles

Halloween Gingerbread Cookies

$24.00

gingerbread cookies for halloween parties and gift giving

Old Fashioned Spice Cupcakes

$24.00

yummmm...the tastes of fall. that includes cinnamon, allspice and freshly group nutmeg.

Pecan Mini Pies

$18.00

gooey...gooey...gooey. six individual pecan pies made using fresh pecans and lots of cane syrup

Pecan Pie

$25.00

simply the best pecan pie you've ever tasted

Pumpkin Bundt Cakes

$18.00

six fresh pumpkin bundt cakes with brown butter icing. these cakes are a unique and unforgettable combination

Pumpkin Muffins

$24.00

one dozen yummy and moist pumpkin muffins. perfect for an autumn breakfast.


Pies and Pastries

All American Apple Pie

$25.00

the classic american dessert - apple pie. our pie is made with lots of granny smith apples and a little extra cinnamon and nutmeg.

Blueberry Pie

$25.00

we love blueberries and we can't seem to stop adding more to this pie!

Classic Cherry Pie

$25.00

our classic sour cherry pie made with a flaky, buttery crust

Classic Pumpkin Pie

$25.00

a sweet, classic pumpkin pie perfect for your holiday table. the crust is flaky, buttery and even pretty.

Coconut Cream Pie

$25.00

one of our favorites! lots of sweet coconut mixed into a sweet custard and topped with a tree topping meringue

Fruit Mini Pies

$18.00

six fruit mini pies that you can mix or match. flavors include peach, blueberry and apple.

Fruit Turnovers

$20.00

one dozen delicious mini or six large turnovers filled with the fruits of your choice. an excellent dessert choice.

Large Pastry Dessert Tray

$80.00

we believe we make the prettiest and most interesting pastry trays around.

Lemon and Chocolate Tarts

$20.00

such a pretty, fun dessert! each tart is filled with lemon curd or freshly made chocolate pudding.

Mini Chocolate Eclairs

$20.00

one of our favorite pastries! the classic dessert with pastry cream and chocolate icing.

Pecan Mini Pies

$18.00

gooey...gooey...gooey. six individual pecan pies made using fresh pecans and lots of cane syrup.

Pecan Pie

$25.00

simply the best pecan pie you've ever tasted

Sweet Dark Cherry Pie

$25.00

a variation on the traditional george washington pie - this is a pie made with sweet, dark cherries.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading