Menu With Price > Menu > Lobster Roll > NY > Amagansett > PO Box 1320, Amagansett, NY

Lobster Roll Prices in Amagansett, NY 11930

4.5 based on 112 votes
Lobster Roll Logo
PO Box 1320, Amagansett, NY
(631) 267-3740
Lobster Roll Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Appetizers

Mixed Green Salad

Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing.

$5.75

Clams on the Half Shell*

Six Fresh cold water raw clams from certified packers.

$

Shrimp Cocktail

Six large shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce.

$16.95

The Finest Steamers & Broth

(Full Quart). The South Fork classic "soft shell" clam.

$

Mussels Marinara

A full quart! Plump mussels, served with Paul's zesty marinara sauce.

$12.95

Plump Mussels

A full quart! Steamed in their own bag and served with herbed garlic butter

$12.95

Seafood Nachos

A big plate of tortilla chips dressed with seafood chili, melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, scallions and tangy salsa.

$15.95

Clams Casino

Clams on the half shell broiled in a herbed-garlic butter sauce and topped with bacon.

$

Crab Cake Appetizer

Grilled and served with our homemade remoulade sauce.

$10.95

Puffers

Choice of 1/2 Order OR Full Order. Boneless, mild fish, fried in our special tempura batter and served with our homemade remoulade sauce.

$

Fried Clam Strips

Crispy strips of tender deep sea clams fried to crunchy perfection. Served with tartar sauce.

$14.95

Fish-n'-Chips (minus the fries)

Pure white coldwater cod dipped in tempura batter and fried to crunchy perfection! Served with tartar sauce.

$14.95

Fried Calamari

Lightly seasoned and served with Paul's own homemade zesty marinara sauce.

$14.95

Chicken Fingers

Chicken breast fried crispy & golden. Served with BBQ sauce.

$8.95

Battered Onion Rings

Sweet large onions fried golden brown.

$8.95

Mixed Green Salad

Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing

$5.75

Clams on the Half Shell*

Six Fresh cold water raw clams from certified packers

$

Shrimp Cocktail

Six large shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce

$16.95

The Finest Steamers & Broth

The South Fork classic "soft shell" clam. (Full Quart)

$

Mussles Marinara

A full quart! Plump mussels, served with Paul's zesty marinara sauce

$12.95

Plump Mussels in Herbed Garlic Butter

A full quart! Steamed in their own bag and served with herbed wine sauce

$12.95

Seafood Nachos

A big plate of tortilla chips dressed with seafood chili, melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, scallions and tangy salsa

$15.95

Clams Casino

Clams on the half shell broiled in a herbed-garlic butter sauce and topped with bacon

$

Fried Chicken Tenders

No description available

$8.95

Homemade Hearty Manhattan Seafood Chowder

Our own tomato-based soup, loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops and cod

$17.95

Paul's Famous Seafood Chili

A spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans, topped with melted cheddar cheese, sour cream and scallions, served with tortilla chips

$14.95

Chowder & Bisque

Homemade Creamy New England Chowder

Our trademark creamy soup made with lots of clams.

$6.75 - $17.95

Homemade Hearty Manhattan Seafood Chowder

Our own tomato-based soup, loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops & cod.

$6.75 - $17.95

Homemade Lobster Seafood Bisque

A hearty blend of lobster, shrimp and scallops with a touch of sherry...rich and creamy.

$8.50 - $19.95

Lobster Salad

The Hot Lobster Roll

Tasty chunks of hot lobster meat served in drawn butter, with toasted hot dog buns on the side and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

$ - $2.50

The "Classic" Lobster Roll

No description available

$ - $2.50

Lobster Slider

A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

$ - $2.50

Lobster Bowl

One scoop on a small tossed salad.

$ - $2.50

Lobster Platter

Two scoops on a large salad with fries.

$ - $2.50

Shrimp Salad

The "Classic" Shrimp Roll

No description available

$14.95

Shrimp Slider

A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

$7.50

Shrimp Bowl

One scoop on a small tossed salad.

$18.95

Shrimp Platter

Two scoops on a large salad with fries.

$23.95

White Albacore Tuna

The "Classic" Tuna Roll

No description available

$9.95

Tuna Slider

A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

$5.95

Tuna Bowl

One scoop on a small tossed salad.

$12.95

Tuna Platter

Two scoops on a large salad with fries.

$17.95

"pub" Sandwich Specialties

Char-broiled Swordfish Steak

Lightly marinated select swordfish steak, on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

$

Char-broiled Tuna Steak*

Fresh tuna loin steak on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

$

Broiled Flounder Filet

Fresh flounder served on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

$

Grandma's Old Fashioned Grilled Crabcake

"Blue claw" crabcakes served on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

$13.95

Fried Flounder Filet

Breaded, deep fried on a toasted roll with, lettuce & tomato.

$

Fried Clam Strips

Crispy strips of cold-water deep sea clams fried & piled on a toasted roll.

$11.95

Fried Soft-Shell Crab

The Chesapeake Bay favorite, fried crispy on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

$15.95

Char-broiled Beefburger*

Traditional burger made from angus beef, with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.

$12.95

Char-broiled Turkeyburger

Served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.

$12.95

Grilled Veggieburger

A healthful blend of select veggies, delicately seasoned, with lettuce, tomato and a pickle.

$12.95

Char-broiled Chicken Breast

Herbed chicken cutlet on a toasted roll, with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.

$12.95

Golden Grilled Cheese

The old "standby" grilled golden brown and served with a pickle.

$7.95 - $9.95

All Beef Sabrett's Hot Dog

Grilled classic on a buttery toasted roll, served with a pickle.

$7.95

Specialties

Fish 'n' Chips

Atlantic cold water cod dipped in tempura batter and fried to crunchy perfection! Served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, crispy crinkle-cut fries and zesty tartar sauce. Malt vinegar

$18.95

Puffers 'n' Chips

Fried in our special tempura batter and served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, crispy crinkle-cut fries & our homemade remoulade sauce.

$

Paul's Famous Seafood Chili

A spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans, topped with melted cheddar cheese, sour cream and scallions. served with tortilla chips.

$14.95

Grandma's Crabcakes

Grilled premium Blue Claw crabmeat, bread crumbs spices and herbs.

$23.95

Steamed Whole Lobsters (1 1/4 lb.)

Market Price.

Steamed Whole Lobsters (3 lb.)

Market Price.

Broiled Selections

Jumbo Shrimp

Six tender shrimp broiled "Scampi Style."

$22.95

Salmon Filet

Prepared with a garlic herb sauce. ***Prepared Oreganata Style: Add $1.00

$

Filet of Flounder

Fresh boneless filet broiled in butter. ***Prepared Oreganata Style: Add $1.00

$

Scallops

Sweet, tender sea scallops in a mild garlic-herbed sauce.

$25.95

Our Fresh Catch of the Day

No description available

$

Jumbo Shrimp

Six tender shrimp broiled "Scampi Style"

$22.95

Salmon Filet

Prepared with a garlic herb sauce

$

Filet of Flounder

Fresh boneless filet broiled in butter

$

Scallops

Sweet, tender sea scallops in a mild garlic-herbed sauce

$25.95

Broiled Seafood Combination

Large shrimp, scallops and flounder

$24.95

Char-broiled Selections

Swordfish Steak

Center cut steak marinated in herbed wine sauce.

$

Tuna Steak*

Select loin-cut steak lightly marinated in herbed wine sauce.

$

Combo*

A tasty combination of fresh char-broiled tuna and swordfish steak.

$

Chicken Cutlet Platter

Pure white meat chicken filets brushed with herbed wine sauce.

$17.95

Black Angus Shell Steak*

A boneless, hand cut, premium 16 oz. shell steak cooked to your specifications.

$27.95

Stuffed Selections

Baked Stuffed Flounder

A house favorite! Crabmeat stuffing with mild melted cheese. Finished with a herbed wine sauce.

$24.95

Baked Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp

Crabmeat stuffing, baked to perfection.

$24.95

Fried Selections

Fried Clam Strips

Crispy strips of cold water deep sea clams fried golden.

$17.95

Fried Sea Scallops

Lightly dusted and fried to perfection.

$25.95

Golden Fried Shrimp

Large shrimp, butterflied, lightly breaded and fried golden.

$20.95

Fried Filet of Flounder

Lightly breaded, fresh boneless filet.

$

Fried Soft Shell Crabs

The original Chesapeake Bay favorite! Two jumbo crabs lightly battered and fried.

$25.95

Combinations

Puffer 'n' Fish 'n' Chips

We combined two of our most popular favorites just for you! Moist cod and mild boneless blowfish, with tartar and remoulade sauce.

$

Captain's Fried Combination

Breaded shrimp, scallops, and flounder , with tartar and cocktail sauce

$24.95

Broiled Seafood Combination

Large shrimp, scallops and flounder served with scampi butter.

$24.95

First Mates Fried Combination

Breaded shrimp, clam strips, and flounder, with tartar and cocktail sauce

$24.95

Entree Salad Platters

Marinated Char-Broiled Tuna Steak*

No description available

$

Marinated Char-Broiled Swordfish

No description available

$

Combo (Tuna and Sword)*

No description available

$

Broiled Jumbo Shrimp "Scampi Style"

No description available

$22.95

Broiled Marinated Chicken Breast Filet

No description available

$17.95

Broiled Salmon Filet

No description available

$

Marinated Char-Broiled Tuna Steak

No description available

$

Marinated Char-Broiled Swordfish

No description available

$

Combo (Tuna and Sword

No description available

$

Broiled Jumbo Shrimp "Scampi Style"

No description available

$22.95

Broiled Marinated Chicken Breast Filet

No description available

$17.95

Broiled Salmon Filet

No description available

$

*Gluten Free Roll Available On Request

No description available

$1.00

Extras

Crispy "Crinkle-Cut" Fries

No description available

$4.95

Homemade Creamy Cole Slaw

made fresh daily, a 1/2 lb.

$3.00

Tossed Salad

Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing.

$5.75

Sweet Corn on the Cob

local when available.

$2.50

Battered Onion Rings

Sweet large onions fried golden brown.

$8.95

Roasted New Potatoes

Lightly seasoned.

$4.95

Sweet Potato Fries

No description available

$6.50

Roasted New Potatoes

Lightly Seasoned

$4.95

Side of our Homemade Creamy Cole Slaw

Mom's original recipe - made fresh daily, a full 1/2 lb

$3.00

Tossed Salad

Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing

$5.75

Sweet Corn on the Cob (local when available)

No description available

$2.50

Sweet Potato Fries

Served with honey mustard.

$6.50

Crispy "Crinkle Cut" French Fries

No description available

$4.95

Nostalgic Specialty Drinks

Chocolate Egg Cream

No description available

$3.95

Daniel's Frozen Lemonade

No description available

$4.95

Shirley Temple

No description available

$2.95

IBC Root Beer (by the bottle)

No description available

$2.50

Cherry Coke

No description available

$2.95

Root Beer Float

No description available

$6.50

Old Fashioned Malted Milshake

No description available

$6.50

Vanilla Milkshake

No description available

$6.50

Chocolate Milkshake

No description available

$6.50

Strawberry Milkshake

No description available

$6.50

Chocolate Egg Cream

Like the old days!

$3.95

Daniel's Frozen Lemonade

No description available

$3.95

Shirley Temple

No description available

$2.95

IBC Root Beer

In the bottle

$2.50

Root Beer Float

No description available

$6.50

Vanilla Milkshake

No description available

$6.50

Strawberry Milkshake

No description available

$6.50

Chocolate Milkshake

No description available

$6.50

"Pub" Sandwich Specialties

Char-broiled Swordfish Steak

Lightly marinated select swordfish steak, on a toasted roll with lettuce and tomato

$

Char-broiled Tuna Steak*

Fresh tuna loin steak on a toasted roll with lettuce and tomato

$

Broiled Flounder Filet

Served on a toasted roll with lettuce and tomato

$

Char-broiled Turkeyburger

Served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato and a pickle

$13.95

Char-broiled Beefburger*

The traditional burger made from angus beef, served with lettuce, tomato and a pickle

$13.95

Grilled Veggieburger

A healthful blend of select veggies, delicately seasoned with lettuce, tomato and a pickle

$13.95

Char-broiled Chicken Breast

Herbed chicken cutlet served on a toasted roll, with lettuce, tomato and a pickle

$13.95

Our Famous Homemade Lobster Salad

The "Classic" Lobster Roll

with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

$ - $2.50

Lobster Slider

A mini version of our "Classic" roll with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

$

Lobster Bowl

One scoop on a small tossed salad with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

$

Lobster Platter

Two scoops on a large salad with fries and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

$

The Hot Lobster Roll

Tasty chunks of hot lobster meat served in drawn butter, with (2) toasted gluten free buns on the side and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

$ - $2.50

Homemade Shrimp Salad

The "Classic" Shrimp Roll

No description available

$15.95

The "Classic" Shrimp Roll Slider

A mini version of our "Classic" roll

$8.50

Shrimp Bowl

One scoop on a small tossed salad.

$18.95

Shrimp Platter

Two scoops on a large salad with fries or roasted new potatoes

$23.95

White Albacore Tuna Salad

The "Classic" Tuna Roll

No description available

$10.95

The "Classic" Tuna Roll Slider

A mini version of our "Classic" roll

$6.95

Tuna Bowl

One scoop on a small tossed salad with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

$12.95

Tuna Platter

Two scoops on a large salad with fries and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

$17.95

Char-Broiled Selections

Swordfish Steak

Center cut steak marinated in garlic and herbs

$

*Tuna Steak

Select loin-cut steak lightly marinated in garlic and herbs.

$

*Combo

A tasty combination of fresh char-broiled tuna and swordfish steak.

$

Chicken Cutlet Platter

Pure white meat chicken filets brushed with garlic herb sauce.

$17.95

Black Angus Shell Steak

A boneless, hand cut, premium 16 oz. shell steak, cooked to your specifications.

$27.95

Steamed Whole Lobsters

1 1/4 LB Steamed Whole Lobster

No description available

$

3 LB Steamed Whole Lobster

No description available

$

Gluten-free Dessert Selection

Vanilla, Chocolate or Cinnamon Ice Cream

No description available

$5.95

Gluten-free Chocolate Cupcake

Topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting

$4.95

For Land Sharks

Burger

All American on a bun

$7.95

Frank

Kosher hot dog on a bun

$7.50

Grilled Chicken Fingers

No description available

$7.95

Fried Chicken Fingers

No description available

$7.95

Gluten Free Fried Chicken Fingers

No description available

$7.95

Grilled Cheese

No description available

$7.25

For Sea Critters

Fried Shrimp

No description available

$8.95

Fried Filet of Flounder

No description available

$

Broiled Filet of Flounder

No description available

$

Fish-n-Chips

No description available

$7.95

Clam Strips-n-Chips

No description available

$8.95

Lobster Salad Slider

No description available

$12.95

Shrimp Salad Slider

No description available

$9.95

Tuna Salad Slider

No description available

$8.50

*Gluten Free Rolls Available

No description available

$1.00

Old Stand Bys!

Pasta-n-Butter

No description available

$6.50

Pasta-n-Marinara Sauce

No description available

$6.50

Mac 'n' Cheese

No description available

$6.50

Chowder-n-Crackers

No description available

$5.50

MIlk

No description available

$2.00

Chocolate Milk

No description available

$2.95

Draft Beers

Lobster Ale

No description available

$7.00

Montauk Offland IPA

No description available

$7.00

Brooklyn Summer Ale

No description available

$7.00

Blue Moon

No description available

$7.00

Peroni

No description available

$7.00

Sam Adams Boston Lager

No description available

$7.00

By The Bottle

Corona Lite

No description available

$7.00

Dog Fish 60 Minute IPA

No description available

$7.00

Corona Extra

No description available

$7.00

Budweiser

No description available

$6.50

Miller Lite

No description available

$6.50

St. Pauli Girl - Non Alcoholic

No description available

$7.00

Dog Fish Tweason Ale - Gluten Free

No description available

$7.00

White

Chardonnay

No description available

$8.00 - $32.00

Long Island Wine Selection

No description available

$9.00 - $36.00

House Pinot Grigio

No description available

$8.00 - $32.00

Premium Pinot Grigio

No description available

$9.00 - $36.00

Red

Merlot

No description available

$8.00 - $32.00

Rosé

No description available

$8.00 - $32.00

Pinot Noir

No description available

$8.00 - $32.00

Margaritas

Classic Margarita

No description available

$9.00

Cuervo Floater

No description available

$2.00

Strawberry Margarita

No description available

$9.00

Raspberry Margarita

No description available

$9.00

Mango Margarita

No description available

$9.00

Ocean Blue Margarita

No description available

$12.00

Blood Orange Margarita

No description available

$12.00

Pomegranate Margarita

No description available

$12.00

Andrea's Guilt Free Margarita

(No not just for women) Cuervo, Cointreau, citrus juices, no sugar added

$12.00

Daiquiris

Classic Daquiri

No description available

$9.00

Myers Dark Rum Floater

No description available

$2.00

Strawberry Daiquiri

No description available

$9.00

Raspberry Daiquiri

No description available

$9.00

Peach Daiquiri

No description available

$9.00

Mango Daiquiri

No description available

$9.00

Pomegranate Daquiri

No description available

$9.00

Coladas

Piña Colada

No description available

$9.00

Myers Dark Rum Floater

No description available

$2.00

Strawberry Colada

No description available

$9.00

Raspberry Colada

No description available

$9.00

Mango Colada

No description available

$9.00

Peach Colada

No description available

$9.00

Martinis

Classic Martini

No description available

$10.00

Strawberry Martini

No description available

$11.00

Mango Martini

No description available

$11.00

Raspberry Martini

No description available

$11.00

Pomegranate Martini

No description available

$11.00

Chocolate Martini

Vodka infused with créme de cacao and Godiva chocolate liqueur

$12.00

Coconut Martini

Parrot Bay Coconut Rum blended with vodka

$11.00

Liquid Keylime Heaven

No description available

$12.00

Bellinis

Classic Peach Bellini

No description available

$9.00

Strawberry Bellini

No description available

$9.00

Raspberry Bellini

No description available

$9.00

Mango Bellini

No description available

$9.00

Pomegranate Bellini

No description available

$9.00

Other Drinks

Mimosa

No description available

$9.00

Bloody Mary

No description available

$9.00

Bloody Maria

With Tequilla

$9.00

Specialty Cocktails

Napeague Stretch

Our versions of Long Island Ice Tea

$16.00

Frozen Bacardi Mojito

A refreshing rum cocktail with mint & lime flavors (or on the rocks)

$12.00

The 19th Hole

A blend of our homemade ice tea and pink lemonade with vodka

$9.00

Captain Morgan Punch

Our secret recipe

$12.00

Summer Splash

Our signature rum punch

$10.00

Loaded Corona

Spiked with a shot of Bacardi Limon

$12.00

Classic Cosmopolitan

No description available

$12.00

Pomegranate Cosmopolitan

No description available

$12.00

Patron Pink Lemonade

No description available

$14.00

Fruit Pies

Raspberry

No description available

$6.50

Strawberry Rhubarb

No description available

$6.50

Apple Crumb

No description available

$6.50

Peach

in season

$6.50

Blueberry

in season

$6.50

No Sugar Added Fruit Pies

Ask your server for today's selection

$7.50

A La mode

Add Ice Cream to any of our pies!

$2.75

Ice Cream (2 Scoops)

Premium Vanilla Bean

(2 Scoops)

$6.50

Premium Cinnamon

(2 Scoops)

$6.50

Preium Vanilla Bean, Chocolate, or Strawberry Milkshake

No description available

$6.50

Andrea's Smore's Hot Fudge Sundae

Hot, creamy rich homemade chocolate fudge and melted gooey marshmallows piled atop graham cracker cookies...topped with 2 scoops of premium vanilla bean ice cream, mounds of whipped cream...rainbow s

$8.95

A La mode

Add Ice Cream to any of our pies, cakes or cupcakes!

$2.75

Specialty Pies and Cakes

Frozen Key Lime Pie

Tangy and refreshing

$6.50

Pecan Pie

Velvety rich and packed with pecans

$6.95

Toll House Pie

Lots of chocolate morsels and walnuts

$6.95

Andrea's Chocolate Obsession Cake

A rich dense "chocolatey" cake topped with velvety smooth creamy chocolate ganache frosting a must for chocolate lovers served warm with whipped cream

$6.95

A La mode

Add Ice Cream!

$2.75

Andera's Cupcake Corner

Vanilla Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting

$4.50

Chocolate Cupcake

Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting

$4.50

Black & White Cupcake

Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting

$4.50

White & Black Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting

$4.50

Oreo Cupcake

Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting, and oreo cookies

$4.50

Coconut Cream

Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade coconut cream frosting

$4.50

Shark Attack Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting decorated with a gummy shark & mini swedish fish

$4.50

Andrea's JUMBO Chocolate Chip Cookie

Fresh Baked and oh so yummy!

$2.95

A la Mode

Add Ice Cream!

$2.75

Gluten-free Selection

Gluten-free Chocolate Cupcake

Chocolate cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting

$4.95

Appetizer Selections

Shrimp Cocktail

No description available

$16.95

Crab Cake

No description available

$11.95

Tossed Salad

Choice of 2 dressings: Ranch, Vinaigrette, Thousand Island

$5.75

Chowder Selections

New England - Style Clam Chowder

No description available

$6.75

Manhattan - Style Clam Chowder

No description available

$6.75

Lobster Seafood Bisque

No description available

$8.50

Entree Selections

Classic Lobster Roll - Our Famous Lobster Salad

No description available

$24.95

"Hot" Lobster Roll - Lobster Meat in Drawn Butter

No description available

$26.95

Shrimp Salad Roll - Whole Shrimp Salad

No description available

$17.95

Vegetarian Burger - Grilled "Veggie" Burger

with your choice of French Fries or Potato Chips

$12.95

Desserts

Andrea's Homemade Pie

No description available

$6.50

Cupcakes

No description available

$4.75

Gluten Free Cupcakes

No description available

$5.50

Coffee/Tea/Soda

No description available

$2.50

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading