Lobster Roll Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 112 votes
Lobster Roll Logo

Choose My State

NY

Lobster Roll Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Mixed Green Salad

$5.75

Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing.

Clams on the Half Shell*

$

Six Fresh cold water raw clams from certified packers.

Shrimp Cocktail

$16.95

Six large shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce.

The Finest Steamers & Broth

$

(Full Quart). The South Fork classic "soft shell" clam.

Mussels Marinara

$12.95

A full quart! Plump mussels, served with Paul's zesty marinara sauce.

Plump Mussels

$12.95

A full quart! Steamed in their own bag and served with herbed garlic butter

Seafood Nachos

$15.95

A big plate of tortilla chips dressed with seafood chili, melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, scallions and tangy salsa.

Clams Casino

$

Clams on the half shell broiled in a herbed-garlic butter sauce and topped with bacon.

Crab Cake Appetizer

$10.95

Grilled and served with our homemade remoulade sauce.

Puffers

$

Choice of 1/2 Order OR Full Order. Boneless, mild fish, fried in our special tempura batter and served with our homemade remoulade sauce.

Fried Clam Strips

$14.95

Crispy strips of tender deep sea clams fried to crunchy perfection. Served with tartar sauce.

Fish-n'-Chips (minus the fries)

$14.95

Pure white coldwater cod dipped in tempura batter and fried to crunchy perfection! Served with tartar sauce.

Fried Calamari

$14.95

Lightly seasoned and served with Paul's own homemade zesty marinara sauce.

Chicken Fingers

$8.95

Chicken breast fried crispy & golden. Served with BBQ sauce.

Battered Onion Rings

$8.95

Sweet large onions fried golden brown.

Mixed Green Salad

$5.75

Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing

Clams on the Half Shell*

$

Six Fresh cold water raw clams from certified packers

Shrimp Cocktail

$16.95

Six large shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce

The Finest Steamers & Broth

$

The South Fork classic "soft shell" clam. (Full Quart)

Mussles Marinara

$12.95

A full quart! Plump mussels, served with Paul's zesty marinara sauce

Plump Mussels in Herbed Garlic Butter

$12.95

A full quart! Steamed in their own bag and served with herbed wine sauce

Seafood Nachos

$15.95

A big plate of tortilla chips dressed with seafood chili, melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, scallions and tangy salsa

Clams Casino

$

Clams on the half shell broiled in a herbed-garlic butter sauce and topped with bacon

Fried Chicken Tenders

$8.95

Homemade Hearty Manhattan Seafood Chowder

$17.95

Our own tomato-based soup, loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops and cod

Paul's Famous Seafood Chili

$14.95

A spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans, topped with melted cheddar cheese, sour cream and scallions, served with tortilla chips


Chowder & Bisque

Homemade Creamy New England Chowder

$6.75 - $17.95

Our trademark creamy soup made with lots of clams.

Homemade Hearty Manhattan Seafood Chowder

$6.75 - $17.95

Our own tomato-based soup, loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops & cod.

Homemade Lobster Seafood Bisque

$8.50 - $19.95

A hearty blend of lobster, shrimp and scallops with a touch of sherry...rich and creamy.


Lobster SaladAll served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

The Hot Lobster Roll

$ - $2.50

Tasty chunks of hot lobster meat served in drawn butter, with toasted hot dog buns on the side and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

The "Classic" Lobster Roll

$ - $2.50

Lobster Slider

$ - $2.50

A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

Lobster Bowl

$ - $2.50

One scoop on a small tossed salad.

Lobster Platter

$ - $2.50

Two scoops on a large salad with fries.


Shrimp SaladAll served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

The "Classic" Shrimp Roll

$14.95

Shrimp Slider

$7.50

A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

Shrimp Bowl

$18.95

One scoop on a small tossed salad.

Shrimp Platter

$23.95

Two scoops on a large salad with fries.


White Albacore TunaAll served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

The "Classic" Tuna Roll

$9.95

Tuna Slider

$5.95

A mini version of our "Classic" roll.

Tuna Bowl

$12.95

One scoop on a small tossed salad.

Tuna Platter

$17.95

Two scoops on a large salad with fries.


"pub" Sandwich SpecialtiesAll items served on a roll with crispy crinkle-cut fries and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

Char-broiled Swordfish Steak

$

Lightly marinated select swordfish steak, on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

Char-broiled Tuna Steak*

$

Fresh tuna loin steak on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

Broiled Flounder Filet

$

Fresh flounder served on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

Grandma's Old Fashioned Grilled Crabcake

$13.95

"Blue claw" crabcakes served on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

Fried Flounder Filet

$

Breaded, deep fried on a toasted roll with, lettuce & tomato.

Fried Clam Strips

$11.95

Crispy strips of cold-water deep sea clams fried & piled on a toasted roll.

Fried Soft-Shell Crab

$15.95

The Chesapeake Bay favorite, fried crispy on a toasted roll with lettuce & tomato.

Char-broiled Beefburger*

$12.95

Traditional burger made from angus beef, with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.

Char-broiled Turkeyburger

$12.95

Served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.

Grilled Veggieburger

$12.95

A healthful blend of select veggies, delicately seasoned, with lettuce, tomato and a pickle.

Char-broiled Chicken Breast

$12.95

Herbed chicken cutlet on a toasted roll, with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.

Golden Grilled Cheese

$7.95 - $9.95

The old "standby" grilled golden brown and served with a pickle.

All Beef Sabrett's Hot Dog

$7.95

Grilled classic on a buttery toasted roll, served with a pickle.


Specialties

Fish 'n' Chips

$18.95

Atlantic cold water cod dipped in tempura batter and fried to crunchy perfection! Served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, crispy crinkle-cut fries and zesty tartar sauce. Malt vinegar

Puffers 'n' Chips

$

Fried in our special tempura batter and served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, crispy crinkle-cut fries & our homemade remoulade sauce.

Paul's Famous Seafood Chili

$14.95

A spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans, topped with melted cheddar cheese, sour cream and scallions. served with tortilla chips.

Grandma's Crabcakes

$23.95

Grilled premium Blue Claw crabmeat, bread crumbs spices and herbs.

Steamed Whole Lobsters (1 1/4 lb.)

Price may varies

Market Price.

Steamed Whole Lobsters (3 lb.)

Price may varies

Market Price.


Broiled Selections

Jumbo Shrimp

$22.95

Six tender shrimp broiled "Scampi Style."

Salmon Filet

$

Prepared with a garlic herb sauce. ***Prepared Oreganata Style: Add $1.00

Filet of Flounder

$

Fresh boneless filet broiled in butter. ***Prepared Oreganata Style: Add $1.00

Scallops

$25.95

Sweet, tender sea scallops in a mild garlic-herbed sauce.

Our Fresh Catch of the Day

$

Jumbo Shrimp

$22.95

Six tender shrimp broiled "Scampi Style"

Salmon Filet

$

Prepared with a garlic herb sauce

Filet of Flounder

$

Fresh boneless filet broiled in butter

Scallops

$25.95

Sweet, tender sea scallops in a mild garlic-herbed sauce

Broiled Seafood Combination

$24.95

Large shrimp, scallops and flounder


Char-broiled SelectionsAll entrée platters are served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, and your choice of crispy crinkle-cut fries, roasted new potatoes, salad or corn on the cob

Swordfish Steak

$

Center cut steak marinated in herbed wine sauce.

Tuna Steak*

$

Select loin-cut steak lightly marinated in herbed wine sauce.

Combo*

$

A tasty combination of fresh char-broiled tuna and swordfish steak.

Chicken Cutlet Platter

$17.95

Pure white meat chicken filets brushed with herbed wine sauce.

Black Angus Shell Steak*

$27.95

A boneless, hand cut, premium 16 oz. shell steak cooked to your specifications.


Stuffed Selections

Baked Stuffed Flounder

$24.95

A house favorite! Crabmeat stuffing with mild melted cheese. Finished with a herbed wine sauce.

Baked Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp

$24.95

Crabmeat stuffing, baked to perfection.


Fried Selections

Fried Clam Strips

$17.95

Crispy strips of cold water deep sea clams fried golden.

Fried Sea Scallops

$25.95

Lightly dusted and fried to perfection.

Golden Fried Shrimp

$20.95

Large shrimp, butterflied, lightly breaded and fried golden.

Fried Filet of Flounder

$

Lightly breaded, fresh boneless filet.

Fried Soft Shell Crabs

$25.95

The original Chesapeake Bay favorite! Two jumbo crabs lightly battered and fried.


Combinations

Puffer 'n' Fish 'n' Chips

$

We combined two of our most popular favorites just for you! Moist cod and mild boneless blowfish, with tartar and remoulade sauce.

Captain's Fried Combination

$24.95

Breaded shrimp, scallops, and flounder , with tartar and cocktail sauce

Broiled Seafood Combination

$24.95

Large shrimp, scallops and flounder served with scampi butter.

First Mates Fried Combination

$24.95

Breaded shrimp, clam strips, and flounder, with tartar and cocktail sauce


Entree Salad PlattersAgenerous portion of your favorite entree served on top of fresh greens. Served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw and your favorite salad dressing. Creamy Ranch, Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette or Bleu Cheese (add 50¢)

Marinated Char-Broiled Tuna Steak*

$

Marinated Char-Broiled Swordfish

$

Combo (Tuna and Sword)*

$

Broiled Jumbo Shrimp "Scampi Style"

$22.95

Broiled Marinated Chicken Breast Filet

$17.95

Broiled Salmon Filet

$

Marinated Char-Broiled Tuna Steak

$

Marinated Char-Broiled Swordfish

$

Combo (Tuna and Sword

$

Broiled Jumbo Shrimp "Scampi Style"

$22.95

Broiled Marinated Chicken Breast Filet

$17.95

Broiled Salmon Filet

$

*Gluten Free Roll Available On Request

$1.00


Extras

Crispy "Crinkle-Cut" Fries

$4.95

Homemade Creamy Cole Slaw

$3.00

made fresh daily, a 1/2 lb.

Tossed Salad

$5.75

Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing.

Sweet Corn on the Cob

$2.50

local when available.

Battered Onion Rings

$8.95

Sweet large onions fried golden brown.

Roasted New Potatoes

$4.95

Lightly seasoned.

Sweet Potato Fries

$6.50

Roasted New Potatoes

$4.95

Lightly Seasoned

Side of our Homemade Creamy Cole Slaw

$3.00

Mom's original recipe - made fresh daily, a full 1/2 lb

Tossed Salad

$5.75

Fresh greens with your choice of salad dressing

Sweet Corn on the Cob (local when available)

$2.50

Sweet Potato Fries

$6.50

Served with honey mustard.

Crispy "Crinkle Cut" French Fries

$4.95


Nostalgic Specialty Drinks

Chocolate Egg Cream

$3.95

Daniel's Frozen Lemonade

$4.95

Shirley Temple

$2.95

IBC Root Beer (by the bottle)

$2.50

Cherry Coke

$2.95

Root Beer Float

$6.50

Old Fashioned Malted Milshake

$6.50

Vanilla Milkshake

$6.50

Chocolate Milkshake

$6.50

Strawberry Milkshake

$6.50

Chocolate Egg Cream

$3.95

Like the old days!

Daniel's Frozen Lemonade

$3.95

Shirley Temple

$2.95

IBC Root Beer

$2.50

In the bottle

Root Beer Float

$6.50

Vanilla Milkshake

$6.50

Strawberry Milkshake

$6.50

Chocolate Milkshake

$6.50


"Pub" Sandwich SpecialtiesAll items served on a Gluten-Free roll with corn on the cob, crinkle cut french fries, or a small tossed salad and a 1/4 lb. of our "homemade" creamy cole slaw

Char-broiled Swordfish Steak

$

Lightly marinated select swordfish steak, on a toasted roll with lettuce and tomato

Char-broiled Tuna Steak*

$

Fresh tuna loin steak on a toasted roll with lettuce and tomato

Broiled Flounder Filet

$

Served on a toasted roll with lettuce and tomato

Char-broiled Turkeyburger

$13.95

Served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato and a pickle

Char-broiled Beefburger*

$13.95

The traditional burger made from angus beef, served with lettuce, tomato and a pickle

Grilled Veggieburger

$13.95

A healthful blend of select veggies, delicately seasoned with lettuce, tomato and a pickle

Char-broiled Chicken Breast

$13.95

Herbed chicken cutlet served on a toasted roll, with lettuce, tomato and a pickle


Our Famous Homemade Lobster SaladOur famous lobster salad is made with 100% pure cold water lobster meat, using the same recipe we created over 45 years ago! NO fillers, NO preservatives!

The "Classic" Lobster Roll

$ - $2.50

with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw.

Lobster Slider

$

A mini version of our "Classic" roll with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

Lobster Bowl

$

One scoop on a small tossed salad with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

Lobster Platter

$

Two scoops on a large salad with fries and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

The Hot Lobster Roll

$ - $2.50

Tasty chunks of hot lobster meat served in drawn butter, with (2) toasted gluten free buns on the side and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw


Homemade Shrimp Saladwith a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

The "Classic" Shrimp Roll

$15.95

The "Classic" Shrimp Roll Slider

$8.50

A mini version of our "Classic" roll

Shrimp Bowl

$18.95

One scoop on a small tossed salad.

Shrimp Platter

$23.95

Two scoops on a large salad with fries or roasted new potatoes


White Albacore Tuna Saladwith a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

The "Classic" Tuna Roll

$10.95

The "Classic" Tuna Roll Slider

$6.95

A mini version of our "Classic" roll

Tuna Bowl

$12.95

One scoop on a small tossed salad with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw

Tuna Platter

$17.95

Two scoops on a large salad with fries and a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw


Char-Broiled Selections

Swordfish Steak

$

Center cut steak marinated in garlic and herbs

*Tuna Steak

$

Select loin-cut steak lightly marinated in garlic and herbs.

*Combo

$

A tasty combination of fresh char-broiled tuna and swordfish steak.

Chicken Cutlet Platter

$17.95

Pure white meat chicken filets brushed with garlic herb sauce.

Black Angus Shell Steak

$27.95

A boneless, hand cut, premium 16 oz. shell steak, cooked to your specifications.


Steamed Whole LobstersAll served with a 1/4 lb. of our homemade creamy cole slaw, and your choice of small salad, corn on the cob, or roasted new potatoe

1 1/4 LB Steamed Whole Lobster

$

3 LB Steamed Whole Lobster

$


Gluten-free Dessert Selection

Vanilla, Chocolate or Cinnamon Ice Cream

$5.95

Gluten-free Chocolate Cupcake

$4.95

Topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting


For Land SharksServed with choice of french fries, corn on the cob, or roasted new potatoes

Burger

$7.95

All American on a bun

Frank

$7.50

Kosher hot dog on a bun

Grilled Chicken Fingers

$7.95

Fried Chicken Fingers

$7.95

Gluten Free Fried Chicken Fingers

$7.95

Grilled Cheese

$7.25


For Sea CrittersServed with choice of french fries, corn on the cob, or roasted new potatoes

Fried Shrimp

$8.95

Fried Filet of Flounder

$

Broiled Filet of Flounder

$

Fish-n-Chips

$7.95

Clam Strips-n-Chips

$8.95

Lobster Salad Slider

$12.95

Shrimp Salad Slider

$9.95

Tuna Salad Slider

$8.50

*Gluten Free Rolls Available

$1.00


Old Stand Bys!Includes a fountain beverage of your choice: Soda, Fruit Punch, Lemonade or Milk

Pasta-n-Butter

$6.50

Pasta-n-Marinara Sauce

$6.50

Mac 'n' Cheese

$6.50

Chowder-n-Crackers

$5.50

MIlk

$2.00

Chocolate Milk

$2.95


Draft Beers

Lobster Ale

$7.00

Montauk Offland IPA

$7.00

Brooklyn Summer Ale

$7.00

Blue Moon

$7.00

Peroni

$7.00

Sam Adams Boston Lager

$7.00


By The Bottle

Corona Lite

$7.00

Dog Fish 60 Minute IPA

$7.00

Corona Extra

$7.00

Budweiser

$6.50

Miller Lite

$6.50

St. Pauli Girl - Non Alcoholic

$7.00

Dog Fish Tweason Ale - Gluten Free

$7.00


White

Chardonnay

$8.00 - $32.00

Long Island Wine Selection

$9.00 - $36.00

House Pinot Grigio

$8.00 - $32.00

Premium Pinot Grigio

$9.00 - $36.00


Red

Merlot

$8.00 - $32.00

Rosé

$8.00 - $32.00

Pinot Noir

$8.00 - $32.00


Margaritas

Classic Margarita

$9.00

Cuervo Floater

$2.00

Strawberry Margarita

$9.00

Raspberry Margarita

$9.00

Mango Margarita

$9.00

Ocean Blue Margarita

$12.00

Blood Orange Margarita

$12.00

Pomegranate Margarita

$12.00

Andrea's Guilt Free Margarita

$12.00

(No not just for women) Cuervo, Cointreau, citrus juices, no sugar added


Daiquiris

Classic Daquiri

$9.00

Myers Dark Rum Floater

$2.00

Strawberry Daiquiri

$9.00

Raspberry Daiquiri

$9.00

Peach Daiquiri

$9.00

Mango Daiquiri

$9.00

Pomegranate Daquiri

$9.00


Coladas

Piña Colada

$9.00

Myers Dark Rum Floater

$2.00

Strawberry Colada

$9.00

Raspberry Colada

$9.00

Mango Colada

$9.00

Peach Colada

$9.00


Martinis

Classic Martini

$10.00

Strawberry Martini

$11.00

Mango Martini

$11.00

Raspberry Martini

$11.00

Pomegranate Martini

$11.00

Chocolate Martini

$12.00

Vodka infused with créme de cacao and Godiva chocolate liqueur

Coconut Martini

$11.00

Parrot Bay Coconut Rum blended with vodka

Liquid Keylime Heaven

$12.00


Bellinis

Classic Peach Bellini

$9.00

Strawberry Bellini

$9.00

Raspberry Bellini

$9.00

Mango Bellini

$9.00

Pomegranate Bellini

$9.00


Other Drinks

Mimosa

$9.00

Bloody Mary

$9.00

Bloody Maria

$9.00

With Tequilla


Specialty Cocktails

Napeague Stretch

$16.00

Our versions of Long Island Ice Tea

Frozen Bacardi Mojito

$12.00

A refreshing rum cocktail with mint & lime flavors (or on the rocks)

The 19th Hole

$9.00

A blend of our homemade ice tea and pink lemonade with vodka

Captain Morgan Punch

$12.00

Our secret recipe

Summer Splash

$10.00

Our signature rum punch

Loaded Corona

$12.00

Spiked with a shot of Bacardi Limon

Classic Cosmopolitan

$12.00

Pomegranate Cosmopolitan

$12.00

Patron Pink Lemonade

$14.00


Fruit PiesAll deep dish pies are made with ripe, luscious fruit piled in a flaky crust and baked until golden brown and fragrant. all pies served warm. ask your server for today's selection

Raspberry

$6.50

Strawberry Rhubarb

$6.50

Apple Crumb

$6.50

Peach

$6.50

in season

Blueberry

$6.50

in season

No Sugar Added Fruit Pies

$7.50

Ask your server for today's selection

A La mode

$2.75

Add Ice Cream to any of our pies!


Ice Cream (2 Scoops)

Premium Vanilla Bean

$6.50

(2 Scoops)

Premium Cinnamon

$6.50

(2 Scoops)

Preium Vanilla Bean, Chocolate, or Strawberry Milkshake

$6.50

Andrea's Smore's Hot Fudge Sundae

$8.95

Hot, creamy rich homemade chocolate fudge and melted gooey marshmallows piled atop graham cracker cookies...topped with 2 scoops of premium vanilla bean ice cream, mounds of whipped cream...rainbow s

A La mode

$2.75

Add Ice Cream to any of our pies, cakes or cupcakes!


Specialty Pies and CakesAsk your server for today's selection

Frozen Key Lime Pie

$6.50

Tangy and refreshing

Pecan Pie

$6.95

Velvety rich and packed with pecans

Toll House Pie

$6.95

Lots of chocolate morsels and walnuts

Andrea's Chocolate Obsession Cake

$6.95

A rich dense "chocolatey" cake topped with velvety smooth creamy chocolate ganache frosting a must for chocolate lovers served warm with whipped cream

A La mode

$2.75

Add Ice Cream!


Andera's Cupcake Corner

Vanilla Cupcake

$4.50

Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting

Chocolate Cupcake

$4.50

Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting

Black & White Cupcake

$4.50

Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting

White & Black Cupcake

$4.50

Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting

Oreo Cupcake

$4.50

Devil's food cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting, and oreo cookies

Coconut Cream

$4.50

Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade coconut cream frosting

Shark Attack Cupcake

$4.50

Vanilla cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade vanilla buttercream frosting decorated with a gummy shark & mini swedish fish

Andrea's JUMBO Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.95

Fresh Baked and oh so yummy!

A la Mode

$2.75

Add Ice Cream!


Gluten-free Selection

Gluten-free Chocolate Cupcake

$4.95

Chocolate cupcake topped with Andrea's homemade chocolate ganache frosting


Appetizer Selections

Shrimp Cocktail

$16.95

Crab Cake

$11.95

Tossed Salad

$5.75

Choice of 2 dressings: Ranch, Vinaigrette, Thousand Island


Chowder SelectionsChoice of 2

New England - Style Clam Chowder

$6.75

Manhattan - Style Clam Chowder

$6.75

Lobster Seafood Bisque

$8.50


Entree SelectionsAll Entree selections come with homemade coleslaw. All Entree choices available gluten free add $1

Classic Lobster Roll - Our Famous Lobster Salad

$24.95

"Hot" Lobster Roll - Lobster Meat in Drawn Butter

$26.95

Shrimp Salad Roll - Whole Shrimp Salad

$17.95

Vegetarian Burger - Grilled "Veggie" Burger

$12.95

with your choice of French Fries or Potato Chips


Desserts

Andrea's Homemade Pie

$6.50

Cupcakes

$4.75

Gluten Free Cupcakes

$5.50

Coffee/Tea/Soda

$2.50


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading