Menu With Price > Menu > Little Pie Company

Little Pie Company Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 165 votes
Little Pie Company Logo
Desserts
Bakery & Pastries

Choose My State

NY

Little Pie Company Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Fresh Pies(5") / (8") / (10"). All Of Our Pies Are Handmade From Scratch Using Only The Finest Ingredients. Pies By The Slice $4, A La Mode $1.50.

Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie

$8.00 - $23.00

our signature pie is made with fresh granny smith apples

Three-Berry Pie

$23.00 - $30.00

strawberries, blueberries and raspberries combined

Mississippi Mud Pie

$30.00 - $8.00

our triple chocolate treat featured on the food network

Pumpkin Pie

$18.00 - $25.00

seasonal. delicately spiced, traditionally american

Sugarless Apple Pie

$30.00

all natural without any artificial sweeteners. 24 hour advanced notice required

Old-Fashioned Apple Pie

$23.00 - $30.00

traditionally spiced golden delicious apples in a domed crust

Florida Key Lime Pie

$8.00 - $23.00

smooth and piquant filling with a graham cracker crust

Banana Coconut Cream Pie

$23.00 - $30.00

fresh bananas and coconut cream

Southern Pecan Pie

$8.00 - $30.00

fresh bananas and coconut cream

Homemade Cakes

Applesauce Carrot Cake

$35.00 - $12.00

light yet superbly rich and moist

Red Velvet Cake

$12.00 - $23.00

a mild chocolate cake with a little buttermilk and cream cheese icing

Decadent Cupcakes

$3.00

vanilla, chocolate, red velvet and applesauce carrot, cookies & cream, mocha cream chocolate, coconut

Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake

$12.00 - $35.00

belgian chocolate & dutch cocoa in our family recipe!

Creamy New York Cheese Cake

$5.00 - $32.00

creamy, yet slightly dense

Other Desserts

Oven-Fresh Muffins

$3.00

blueberry, corn, banana nut, cinnamon, raisin bran, orange, apple cinnamon, oatmeal

Sour Cream Coffee Cake

$4.00

w/ apple filling

Fresh Apple Turnovers

$3.00

Piping-Hot Chicken Pot Pie

$8.00

Beverages

$2.00

coke, diet coke, sprite & boylan sodas

Hand Spun Milk Shakes

$5.00

vanilla, chocolate or strawberry

Bread Loaves

$18.00

banana nut, lemon pound

Bread Loaves

$3.00

by the slice

Brownies & Bars

$3.00

plain, walnut

Home-Baked Cookies

$1.50

chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, ginger

Bassetts Ice Cream

$2.50 - $3.50

vanilla, chocolate, strawberry

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands