Lefty's Tavern Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 59 votes
Lefty's Tavern Logo

Choose My State

NJ

Lefty's Tavern Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Starters

Beer Battered Onion Rings

$5.00

served with horseradish sauce

Chicken Fingers

$8.00

served with bbq or honey mustard

Lettuce Wraps

$9.00

marinated chicken, carrots, red onion, & lettuce leaves. with thai peanut & sesame ginger sauces

Clams Casino

$9.00

six calms topped with peppers, onions & bacon

Buffalo Calamari

$11.00

drizzled with spicy wing sauce with blue cheese crumbles.

Wings

$9.00

breaded or naked; hot, mild, honey bbq, asian, or mango jalapeno; served with bleu cheese & celery

Shrimp Al Ajillo

$14.00

succulent shrimp in a spicy garlic marinara with crumbled blue cheese over toasted italian bread

Drunken Mussels or Mussels Marinara

$9.00

served with garlic toast points

Fried Calamari

$10.00

served with marinara sauce

Hand Breaded Mozzarella

$8.00

served with marinara sauce

Clams on the 1/2 Shell

$7.00 - $12.00

Crab Dip

$13.00

hot & cheesy with a little spice served with crostini

Drunken Clams

$13.00

in a garlic wine broth

Broccoli Cheddar Bites

$9.00

broccoli, bacon & cheddar served with horseradish sauce

Nachos

$9.00

topped with cheddar cheese, black olives, chili, lettuce, tomato, onion & jalapeno. served with salsa & sour cream

Quesadilla

$8.00 - $10.00

bell peppers, onions, tomatoes, jalapeno, & cheddar cheese. served with salsa, sour cream & black olives

Fish Tacos

$10.00

blackened grouper dressed with chipotle slaw in warm corn tortillas

Baked Mac & Cheese

$9.00

decadent macaroni and cheese loaded with lump crab meat

Pulled Pork Nachos

$10.00

topped with bbq pulled pork, cheddar cheese, black olives, lettuce, tomato, onion, jalapeno with salsa and sour cream

Reuben Dip

$9.00

all your favorite reuben flavor & ingredients in a fun to eat dip served with grilled rye

Stuffed Portabella

$10.00

grilled portabella, zucchini, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic drizzle, mixed greens


Homemade Soups & Chili

Chili

$5.00

served with melted cheddar cheese & tortilla chips

French Onion Soup

$5.00

topped with provolone cheese & baked to a golden brown

Lobster Bisque

$5.00 - $7.00

Soup of the Day

$4.00 - $5.00

Manhattan Clam Chowder

$5.00 - $7.00

critics choice winner at lbi chowderfest!


Salads

Southwest Salad

$9.50 - $10.00

in a tortilla bowl with mixed greens, corn salad, black beans, tortilla strips, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, & onion. served with southwest ranch

Oriental Salad

$9.50 - $10.00

mixed greens served with mandarin oranges, crunchy noodles, almonds & asian dressing

House Salad

$5.00 - $10.00

mixed greens, tomatoes, onions & bell peppers

Caesar Salad

$7.00 - $10.00

crisp romaine & homemade croutons tossed with our creamy caesar dressing

Cobb Salad

$10.50

mixed greens, tomato, onion, avocado, bacon, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese crumbles

Spinach & Strawberry Salad

$11.00

baby spinach, fresh strawberries, avocado, toasted almonds, bleu cheese crumbles, poppy seed vinaigrette


Sandwichesserved with french fries, seasoned fries, or coleslaw. onion rings, sweet potato fries, or salad $2 (extra).

Corned Beef Reuben

$10.50

pastrami sauerkraut, melted swiss cheese & russian dressing on grilled rye bread

Chicken Roma Panini

$10.00

roasted red peppers, provolone cheese & a balsamic reduction

French Dip

$10.00

hot roast beef on garlic toast. served with aus jus

Salmon Blt

$11.00

grilled filet of salmon topped with bacon, tomato & mixed greens. served on 8 grain toast

Pulled Pork

$10.00

shredded slow roasted pork in a tangy homemade bbq sauce. served on a kaiser roll

Hot Open Face Turkey or Roast Beef

$10.00

served with gravy & mashed potato

Grouper Reuben

$11.50

fried filet of grouper on grilled rye with coleslaw, russian dressing & melted swiss

Cordon Bleu Panini

$10.00

grilled chicken breast with ham, melted swiss, & honey dijon on panini bread

Veggie Panini

$10.00

breaded eggplant, roasted red peppers, spinach, mushrooms, balsamic drizzle

Cheese Steak

$10.00

sauteed onions & choice of cheese. add some extras to fancy it up!!

Blackened Tuna & Avocado

$14.50

sushi grade tuna, cajun spiced, avocado, bacon, wasabi mayo, 8 grain bread


Build Your Own Burgers, Turkey Burgers or ChickenOn Brioche. served with french fries, seasoned fries, or coleslaw. onion rings, sweet potato fries, or salad $2 (extra).

Build Your Own Burgers, Turkey Burgers or Chicken

$7.50

1/2 lb. certified angus beef burgers, turkey burger, grilled or fried chicken fillet cutlet...Add your own choice of toppings for additional charge...Don't see a topping you'd like?? Just ask..

Cheese a

$1.50

american, provolone, cheddar, swiss, mozzarella, bleu, goat

Toppings a

$0.75

sauteed onions, green peppers, frizzled onions, sauteed mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes, jalapenos, fried egg

Toppings B

$1.50

bacon, ham, pork roll, roasted red peppers, chili, Avocado

Sauces

$0.50

marinara, bbq, mild, hot, honey bbq, asian, honey hot, mango jalapeno


Signature BurgersOn Brioche. served with french fries, seasoned fries, or coleslaw. onion rings, sweet potato fries, or salad $2 (extra).

Jersey Burger

$11.00

pork roll, cheese & an over easy egg

Fit Burger

$9.50

turkey burger with avocado on 8 grain

Southwest Burger

$11.00

cheddar, jalapenos, bacon & frizzled onions

Bacon Blue

$11.00

crisp bacon, blue cheese, bbq sauce

Lefty's Chicken

$11.00

grilled chicken, sun dried tomatoes, goat cheese & mixed greens drizzled with a balsamic reduction

Portabella Mushroom Burger

$12.00

beef burger, grilled portabella mushroom cap, bacon, swiss


Entreesall entrees served with choice of dinner salad or soup of the day. lobster bisque, manhattan clam chowder, or caesar salad available for an additional $2

12 Oz. Ny Strip Steak

$23.00

a leaner cut, the ny strip consists of a muscle that does little work, making the meat particularly tender, though not as tender as the nearby rib eye

16 Oz. Rib Eye Steak

$26.00

well marbled, the ribeye takes its name from the "eye" of fat in the center and the generous ribbon of fat on the edge. this marbling is what makes a ribeye juicy & flavorful

Veal Chop Milanese

$28.00

12oz french cut, pounded and breaded, fresh spinach, tomato, red onion, fresh mozzarella, red wine vinaigrette

Grilled or Breaded Pork Chops

$18.00

served with a side of applesauce

Add a Signature Sauce to your steaks & chops

$3.00

Au Poivre, Red Wine Demi-glace, Chipotle BBQ, Sriracha Compound Butter

Chicken Marsala

$18.00

lightly floured chicken breast, sauteed with portabella mushrooms & marsala wine

Chicken Sorrento

$19.00

sauteed chicken breast layered with grilled eggplant, prosciutto, & mozzarella cheese, red wine tomato sauce

Chicken Francaise

$18.00

breast of chicken lightly coated with egg batter then sauteed in a creamy butter & white wine sauce

Chicken Parmesan

$18.00

tender chicken breast breaded & fried, topped with marinara sauce, mozzarella & parmigiana cheeses served over linguini

Penne Ala Vodka

$16.00

penne pasta sauteed in a rich creamy pink vodka sauce

Chicken Taverna

$19.00

breaded chicken breast & eggplant, roasted red peppers, provolone, creamy tomato vodka sauce


Seafood Selectionsall entrees served with choice of dinner salad or soup of the day. lobster bisque, manhattan clam chowder, or caesar salad available for an additional $2

Flounder Tropical

$19.00

coconut encrusted flounder over mixed greens, topped with mango salsa & drizzled with chef's special sauce

Broiled Seafood Combination

$35.00

flounder, shrimp, local scallops, lobster tail

Horseradish Encrusted Salmon

$19.00

encrusted with horseradish & oriental bread crumbs served with a tomato basil cream sauce

Black & White Sesame Tuna

$21.00

encrusted with black & white sesame seeds pan seared & served over mixed green with wasabi & ginger drizzle

Shrimp Scampi

$19.00

tender shrimp sauteed in a creamy garlic butter sauce over angel hair

Fried Shrimp

$19.00

hand breaded & fried golden brown, served with cocktail or tarter sauce

Fried / Broiled Scallops

$21.00

LOCAL delicately broiled or lightly breaded & fried golden brown served with cocktail or tarter

Shrimp & Scallops Medley

$21.00

sauteed with sundried tomatoes, fresh spinach & artichoke hearts in alight cream sauce over linguini

Cioppino

$23.00

mussels, calms, shrimp, scallops & calamari in a light tomato broth over linguini

Honey Bbq Salmon

$20.00

sweet and smoky glaze resting over rice with mango salsa

Sesame Scallops

$24.00

LOCAL Black & White Sesame encrusted Sea Scallops, mango & avocado salad, fries avocado, chipotle bbq

Linguini in Clam Sauce Red or White

$17.00

tender whole and chopped clams sauteed in a creamy white wine garlic sauce or i a rich red tomato sauce.

Lemon Dijon Flounder

$19.00

herb encrusted, lemon-dill beurre blanc

Twin Lobster Tails

$37.00

twin 6oz Broiled Brazilian lobster tails, drawn butter


Home-Style Favoritesall entrees served with choice of dinner salad or soup of the day. lobster bisque, manhattan clam chowder, or caesar salad available for an additional $2

Shrimp & Mussels Saganaki

$19.00

hearty greek seafood stew with fresh tomato & feta cheese. served in a crusty bread bowl, sprinkled with fresh herbs & drizzled with extra virgin olive oil

"Her Mom's" Schnitzel & Spaetzle

$17.00

chicken cutlet served over german pasta with mushroom brown gravy, chunky applesauce & green beans

"Thanksgiving Day" at Our House

$16.00

roast turkey, stuffing cheesy mashed, brussels sprouts, sweet potatoes, gravy & home-style cranberry sauce

"His Mom's" Peaches & Pork Chops

$19.00

breaded & fried boneless chops smothered & baked with a caramelized peach sauce served with cheesy mashed potatoes & green beans


Mainincludes soup or salad, coffee or hot tea & dessert. all entrees include a potato & vegetable or pasta

Fried Flounder

$12.99

Roasted Turkey

$10.99

with stuffing & gravy

Chicken Scampi

$11.99

over linguini

Cheese Ravioli

$11.99

with vodka cream sauce

Breaded Pork

$10.99

Chop Steak

$10.99

with sauteed mushrooms, onions & gravy

Chicken

$11.99

choice of francaise, marsala or parmesan

Mussels Marinara Or Mussels Scampi

$13.99

served over linguini

Broiled Seafood Combination

$15.99

flounder, shrimp & scallops

10 Oz. Sirloin Steak

$14.99

Newburgh Casserole

$15.99

shrimp & scallops sauteed in a creamy sherry lobster broth

Herb Crusted Grouper

$13.99

Tilapia Florentine

$11.99

stuffed with spinach & feta


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading