Katie O'Donnell's Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 185 votes
Katie O'Donnell's Logo
Bar Food
Irish
Fish & Chips

Choose My State

PA

Katie O'Donnell's Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Skewers

$9.25

chicken or beef on a skewer with teriyaki sauce

Shrimp On A Skewer

$9.75

with teriyaki sauce.

Jumbo Nachos

$10.50

tortilla chips with a cheese sauce, cheddar cheese, tomatoes, jalapenos, and scallions served with a side of sour cream & salsa

Jumbo Nachos

$3.00

add beef, spicy pulled chicken or pulled pork

Single Serve Nachos

$7.50

just a smaller portion of our signature jumbo nachos.

Single Serve Nachos

$3.00

add beef, spicy pulled chicken or pulled pork

Boneless Chicken Wings

$9.50

100% boneless chicken breast tossed in the sauce of your choice

Katie's Chicken Wings

$9.50 - $18.50

Jumbo Chicken Wings

$28.50 - $14.95

Wing Sauces

Price may varies

guinness bbq, hot, bourbon brown sugar, cajun dry rub, or grandma kate’s

Quesadillas

$7.95

cheddar cheese, jalapenos, lettuce, and tomato

Quesadillas

$3.00

add beef, spicy pulled chicken or pulled pork

Chicken Fingers

$9.25

tender chicken strips served with honey mustard

Potato Skins

$7.95

hollowed out potatoes loaded with bacon and cheddar cheese topped with scallions and served with sour cream.

Potato Skins

$3.00

add shredded spicy chicken, pulled pork, or beef

Beer Battered Onion Rings

$7.50

crispy beer battered onion rings served with spicy ranch

Mozzarella Sticks

$8.95

hot and gooey inside. crisp and golden outside. served with marinara sauce.

Combination Platter

$12.95

katie’s sampler of mozzarella sticks, potato skins, onion rings, and chicken fingers

Bruschetta

$8.75

toasted crostini with a herb goat cheese spread topped with tomato and basil

Philly Cheesesteak Egg Rolls

$9.95

the name says it all, cheesesteak in an egg roll

Fried Green Beans

$7.95

lightly breaded and fried green beans served with a creamy horseradish sauce

Southern Fried Pickles

$8.50

lightly breaded and fried pickles served with our secret dill sauce

Sweet Potato Fries

$7.75

lightly fried and served with a sweet potato pie sauce

Spinach And Artichoke Dip

$12.75

Prime Rib Fondue

$10.50

perfectly cooked prime rib sliced thin in a savory cheese sauce with sautéed peppers and onions served with homemade pita chips

Katie’s Specialty Steamed Clams

$11.50

1 dozen little neck clams steamed with greens in a wine and butter broth with a kiss of garlic. served with grilled bread

Crab Stuffed Mushroom Caps

$10.50

mushrooms stuffed with jumbo lump crab imperial topped with blended cheese

Fried Calamari

$10.50

fresh calamari fried and served with marinara

Mussels

$10.50

marinara or white wine served with grilled bread

Lobster Mac And Cheese

$11.50

not much to say other than yum

Crab Balls

$9.75

fresh lump crab meat panko bread and fried served with cocktail sauce

Buffalo Shrimp

$9.75

tossed in cholula hot sauce topped with bleu cheese crumbles

Steamer Shrimp

$13.50

over two dozen fresh white tiger shrimp steamed, seasoned, and served hot with cocktail sauce


Soups & SaladsAdd Chicken To Any Salad $4, Add Shrimp To Any Salad $5

Lobster Bisque

$5.95

French Onion

$5.95

Cream Of Mushroom

$4.75

Loaded Potato

$4.75

House Salad

$3.75

mixed greens, grape tomatoes, red onions, croutons, and house dressing

Classic Caesar Side Salad

$4.75

Entrée Salad

$6.25

Cobb Salad

$10.50

mixed greens with bacon, grilled chicken, hardboiled egg, tomatoes, and bleu cheese crumbles with our house dressing

Cucumber And Tomato Salad

$7.50

fresh cucumbers and onions in our secret family recipe white wine and mayonnaise dressing with juicy tomato's

Spinach Salad

$9.95

baby spinach with red onions, grape tomatoes, bacon, fresh mozzarella, mandarin oranges, and toasted walnuts in our homemade sherry vinaigrette

Buffalo Bleu Wedge

$10.50

iceberg wedge topped with buffalo chicken bites and topped with bleu cheese crumbles, tomatoes, and celery

Taco Salad

$10.50

tortilla bowl, ground beef or shredded chicken, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream, and jalapenos with sour cream and salsa

Soup And Salad Meal

$7.95

choice of cream of mushroom or potato soup with a side house or side caesar salad just


SandwichesAll Sandwiches Come With Homemade Katie O' Chips Or Upgrade To Cucumber Salad Or Steak Fries For $2 More.

Turkey Club

$9.95

whole turkey breast cooked fresh and sliced thin. served with lto and bacon on your choice of white, wheat, or rye

Chicken Panini

$9.25

fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, chicken breast, and sundried tomatoes pressed and grilled on panini bread

Prime Rib Panini

$10.50

prime rib, cheddar cheese, and horseradish sauce pressed and grilled on panini bread

BLT

$8.99

crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of white, wheat, or rye.

Dave G’s Cheesesteak

$9.95

classic philly cheesesteak with sautéed peppers, onions, mushrooms and american cheese.

Cheese Steak

$9.25

classic philly cheesesteak

Chicken Cheesesteak

$9.75

with american cheese

Chicken Cheesesteak

$1.00

make it a buffalo chicken cheese steak with hot sauce, american cheese, and bleu cheese dressing

Corned Beef Or Turkey Sandwich

$10.50

your choice of either corned beef or turkey, sliced thin and piled high on your choice of white, wheat, or rye. topped with swiss cheese and served with your choice of coleslaw or sauerkraut and 1,00

Crab Cake Sandwich

$12.50

6oz of loaded crab cake served with a side of tartar sauce

Beer Battered Fish Sandwich

$9.50

beer battered fresh cod served with tartar sauce

Barnyard Chicken

$9.50

fresh chicken breast topped with bacon, cheddar, and homemade guinness bbq sauce

Blackened Chicken

$9.50

fresh chicken breast seasoned with cajun spices and topped with cheddar cheese

Tuscan Chicken

$9.50

fresh chicken breast topped with sautéed spinach and provolone cheese

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$9.50

pieces of fresh chicken breast and romaine lettuce, tossed in caesar dressing and parmesan cheese served in a spinach wrap.

Prime Rib Sandwich

$11.50

fresh sliced prime rib topped with provolone cheese and frizzled onions

French Dip

$9.75

hot roast beef topped with swiss cheese and served with au jus for dipping

Chicken Parmesan

$9.50

fresh chicken breast, breaded and lightly fried then loaded with marinara and provolone cheese.


Half Pound BurgersOur Burgers Are Made With A ½ Lb. Of Fresh Ground Sirloin, Served On A Buttery Baked Brioche Roll, With Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, And Pickle With Katie O’s Seasoned Chips. All Burgers Come With Homemade Katie O' Chips Or Upgrade To Cucumber Salad Or Steak F

Kiltless Burger

$8.95

nothing fancy here just a plain burger, no cheese

Big O Burger

$10.95

half pound burger slathered with homemade guinness bbq sauce, topped with crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, and frizzled onions.

Cranberry Turkey Burger

$11.95

fresh ground turkey burger, never frozen! topped with mashed potatoes, stuffing, and a cranberry orange relish

Casey G.’s Cheese Burger

$9.75

half pound burger with your choice of cheese: swiss, american, cheddar, provolone, or bleu cheese

Eddie B’s Swissroom Burger

$10.50

half pound burger topped with mushrooms, onions, and swiss cheese

Black And Bleu Burger

$10.50

half pound burger blackened with cajun seasoning and topped with bleu cheese crumbles

Big Gip Burger

$11.95

half pound burger topped with peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, frizzed onions, bacon and ranch dressing

Atkins Burger

$9.95

the healthy way to enjoy a burger, just a plain half pound burger with no bun or chips instead a side house salad

Bob’s Crabby Pants Burger

$13.95

half pound burger topped with our signature homemade crab balls, sautéed onions and swiss cheese with a side of tartar sauce

The Tom Dooley Burger

$13.95

half pound burger topped with guinness bbq pulled pork, cheddar cheese, and frizzled onions

Katie’s Corned Beef Burger

$14.95

half pound burger topped with homemade corned beef, swiss cheese, and your choice of coleslaw or sauerkraut

The Dubliner

$12.25

half pound burger topped with katie o’s steak fries, hard fried egg, crispy bacon, and cheddar cheese


Smoked Meats

Smoked Pastrami Sandwich

$10.95

our pastrami is made in house from our corned beef. we smoke it and rub it with cracked black pepper and coriander served with swiss cheese on your choice of white, wheat or rye. served hot or cold w

Guinness Pulled Pork

$9.50

pulled pork smothered in homemade guinness bbq sauce topped with frizzled onions.

Smoked St. Louis Style ½ Rack Of Ribs

$13.75

½ rack of ribs smothered in guinness bbq sauce with your choice of 2 sides

Beer Can Smoked Chicken

$12.95 - $17.95

lancaster farm raised whole chicken hickory smoked for four hours and slowly infused with beer then lightly finished with our homemade guinness bbq sauce. served with 2 sides.


Entrees

Chicken Cordon Bleu

$15.95

chicken breast stuffed with prosciutto and provolone cheese with your choice of 2 sides.

Katie O’s Pub Steak

$19.95

our signature pub steak marinated in our secret blend of spices with your choice of 2 sides.

Guinness Stew

$17.95

beef tips and roasted vegetables braised in guinness served with garlic mash.

Sheppard’s Pie

$15.75

ground sirloin, vegetables, and garlic mash topped with frizzled onions

Fish And Chips

$15.75

guinness beer battered fresh cod served with steak fries and a side of tartar sauce

Bill E’s Jumbo Butterfly Shrimp

$17.95

panko breaded jumbo shrimp served with your choice of two sides.

Prime Rib

$21.95 - $27.95

seasoned with our house made rub, slow roasted and hand cut to order. drizzled with au jus and topped with frizzled onions. served with your choice of two sides.

Buttered Broiled Tilapia

$15.95

buttered broiled fresh tilapia topped with chesapeake crab meat and served with your choice of 2 sides

Foley’s Twin Crab Cakes

$21.50

6oz loaded crab cakes served with marinated chilled asparagus

Seafood Combo

$24.95

our signature combination of fresh seafood including tiger shrimp, bay scallops, crab stuffed mushroom caps, farm raised tilapia, and wild caught mussels. served with garlic mashed potatoes and sauté

Pot Of Gold

$24.95

katie o’s steamer pot filled with fresh seafood including tasty crab legs, fresh bay scallops, tiger shrimp and wild caught clams and mussels. with hearty yukon gold potatoes and jersey corn on the c

Feeling Hungry

$2.99

add a side house salad to any entree for just


Pasta

Seafood Fra Diablo

$18.95

mussels, jumbo shrimp, and clams in a homemade spicy marinara sauce over linguini

Shrimp And Asparagus Penne

$15.95

jumbo shrimp and asparagus in a homemade vodka cream sauce over penne pasta.

Chicken Florentine

$14.95

slices of fresh chicken breast topped with sautéed baby spinach and provolone cheese in an alfredo sauce over linguini

Chicken Alfredo

$14.95

slices of fresh chicken breast with broccoli in a creamy alfredo sauce over fettuccini

Chicken Parmesan

$15.95

whole chicken breast lightly breaded and fried smothered in marinara and provolone cheese over a bowl of linguini

Mussels

$16.50

1lb of fresh mussels with basil and diced tomatoes in marinara or garlic white wine sauce over fettuccini pasta


Try Our Famous Potatoes

Katie’s Potatoes 3 -Ways

$12.95

combination basket of crinkle cut french fries, knockout chips, and k.o. steak fries with your choice of 2 cheese sauces. plain american cheese sauce. irish bangers in american cheese sauce. bacon in

K.O. Guinness Potatoes

$10.50

irish potato skins filled with our famous guinness stew

Katie O Basket Of Chips

$5.25

katie’s homemade knockout potato chips served with homemade vegetable & ranch dip


Sides $3.75

Cucumber & Tomato Salad

Price may varies

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Price may varies

Baked Potato

Price may varies

Pasta

Price may varies

Linguini

Price may varies

penne or fettuccini in marinara or alfredo

Sauteed Zucchini

Price may varies

Carrots

Price may varies

Broccoli

Price may varies

Asparagus

Price may varies

Coleslaw

Price may varies

Frizzled Onions

Price may varies


Kids Menu $6.95For Kids 10 And Under. Includes Soda, Milk Or Juices And Refills.

Chicken Fingers And French Fries

Price may varies

Grilled Cheese And French Fries

Price may varies

Mozzarella Sticks And Fries

Price may varies

Pasta

Price may varies

with butter sauce

Macaroni And Cheese

Price may varies

Pasta

Price may varies

with grilled chicken & butter sauce


Summer Drinks

Fireball Razzyade

Price may varies

fireball whiskey and raspberry lemonade with fresh fruit

Katie O Sunshine

Price may varies

frozen peach daiquiri with rum and grenadine. a house favorite

Island Rum Punch

Price may varies

dark rum, captain morgan, grand marnier, grenadine, orange, pineapple and lime juice

Sandy Bottom

Price may varies

captain morgan, triple sec, lime and pineapple juice with fresh fruit


Draft Beers

Miller Lite

Price may varies

Sam Adams Seasonal

Price may varies

Smithwicks

Price may varies

Yuengling Lager

Price may varies

Victory Hop

Price may varies

Corona Light

Price may varies

Blue Moon

Price may varies

Coors Light

Price may varies

Hopfish IPA

Price may varies

Guiness

Price may varies

Harp

Price may varies

Bud

Price may varies

Bud Light

Price may varies

Hoegaarden

Price may varies

Stella

Price may varies

Angry Orchard

Price may varies


Bottle Beers

Miller Lite

Price may varies

Miller High Lite

Price may varies

Bud

Price may varies

Bud Light

Price may varies

Bud Light Lime

Price may varies

Rolling Rock

Price may varies

Heineken

Price may varies

Michelob Ultra

Price may varies

Mikes Lemonade

Price may varies

Bass Ale

Price may varies

Murphy's Red Ale

Price may varies

Coors Light

Price may varies

Corona

Price may varies

Corona Light

Price may varies

Yuengling

Price may varies

Yuengling Light

Price may varies

MGD

Price may varies

MGD 64

Price may varies

Amstel Light

Price may varies

Twisted Tea

Price may varies

Twisted Tea Light

Price may varies

Twisted Tea H/H

Price may varies

Redds Apple Ale

Price may varies

Land Shark

Price may varies

Yards Brawler

Price may varies

Woodchuck Cider

Price may varies

Leffe

Price may varies

O'doul's

Price may varies

Magners Cider

Price may varies

Shock Top Seasonal

Price may varies

Magic Hat #9

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading