James Sheeley House Restaurant Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 115 votes
James Sheeley House Restaurant Logo
Pub Food

Choose My State

WI

James Sheeley House Restaurant Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Mozzarella Wonton Wraps

Price may varies

Strips of fresh mozzarella and ham wrapped in a delicate wonton skin and fried to a golden brown. Our fire-roasted tomato sauce complements this unique starter.

Seafood-Stuffed Mushroom Caps

Price may varies

Oven-roasted mushroom caps filled with a mixture of seafood, cheese, fresh herbs and spices; paired with a sage aioli.

Buffalo Wings

Price may varies

Chicken wings served in our own tangy buffalo sauce with a side of homemade bleu cheese dressing.

Sheeley House Nachos

Price may varies

Warm tortilla chips layered with your choice of grilled chicken or seasoned ground beef, piled high with onions, cheeses, red bell peppers and jalapenos. served with sour cream and salsa.

Crab Cakes

Price may varies

House made crab cakes served with red cabbage slaw and laced with a toasted cumin sauce.

Anna Sheeley's Creamy Spinach Fondue

Price may varies

A creamy blend of spinach, onion, white wine, and cream cheese served with toasted pita points.

Shrimp Cocktail

Price may varies

Traditional boiled shrimp served chilled with cocktail sauce and crackers.

Baked French Onion Soup

Price may varies

Our homemade traditional french soup topped with french bread and swiss cheese.

Cheesy Potato Boats

Price may varies

Baked potato skins stuffed with bacon, peppers, onions, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.


SandwichesSandwiches are offered with soup or a small salad as a substitute for the french fries. sandwiches include lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle

Caesar Chicken Wrap

Price may varies

Grilled chicken breast wrapped in a pita with mixed greens, parmesan cheese, tomatoes and caesar dressing. served with french fries.

Prime Rib Sandwich

Price may varies

Thinly sliced prime rib stacked high on french bread and served with french fries and au jus.

Chicken Breast Sandwich

Price may varies

A tender chicken breast grilled over an open flame served with french fries.

Sheeley House Burger

Price may varies

One-half pound of locally-procured ground sirloin, grilled to your liking and served with french fries. additions available upon your request.

Blt

Price may varies

Smoked bacon, lettuce and tomato piled high on marbled rye bread. served with french fries and mayo.

Caesar Salad

Price may varies

Fresh romaine lettuce and assorted greens tossed in caesar dressing and topped with croutons, tomatoes and parmesan cheese.


EntreesAll of the sheeley house meats are usda. Choice cuts grilled to your liking.

Filet Mignon

Price may varies

8 Ounce of our most tender steak grilled to perfection and served with garlic-mashed potatoes and a cabernet infused brown sauce.

Chef's Sirloin

Price may varies

A 12 ounce usda choice top butt sirloin, lightly seasoned, grilled to your liking on an open flame and served with roasted red potatoes.

Rib Eye Steak

Price may varies

Trimmed and seasoned, grilled and topped with sauteed onions and mushrooms. our house-made garlic mashed potatoes accompany this favorite.

Penne Pasta With Chicken

Price may varies

Chicken breast and vegetables sauteed in garlic butter, grilled, then served on penne pasta in a light cream sauce.

Sheeley House Prime Rib

Price may varies

Slow-roasted and seasoned rib eye roast served with au jus, and the traditional baked potato.

Linguini Pasta Marinara

Price may varies

Rich italian tomato sauce served over flat pasta noodles tossed in olive oil. accompanied by garlic bread.

Shrimp Scampi

Price may varies

Six shrimp sauteed lightly in butter, garlic, cream and a splash of chardonnay wine. our seasoned white and wild rice blend accompanies this favorite.

Cashew Crusted Walleye

Price may varies

Lightly breaded with japanese breadcrumbs and crushed cashews, pan-fried and amaretto glazed. served with garlic mashed potatoes and lemon.

Cedar Smoked Salmon

Price may varies

Cold water salmon fillet broiled with cedar wood and served with our honey-bbq sauce, roasted red potatoes and lemon.

Broiled Orange Roughy

Price may varies

A delicate, flaky and rich deep ocean fish baked in butter and served with our seasoned white and wild rice and lemon.

Raspberry-Balsamic Chicken

Price may varies

Chicken breast topped with a sweet and tangy sauce and served with seasoned white and wild rice blend.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading