Italian Carry Out Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 81 votes
Italian Carry Out Logo
Italian
Pizza
Sandwiches

Choose My State

NY

Italian Carry Out Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

French Fries

$2.30 - $4.50

Choice of either battered or seasoned waffle fries

ICO French Fries

$3.30 - $6.50

Tossed in our ICO sauce served with a side of spaghetti sauce

Buffalo French Fries

$3.30 - $6.50

Tossed in choice of wing sauce served with a side of bleu cheese

Homemade Hand Dipped Onion Rings

$3.40 - $6.60

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

$6.25

Served with a side of spaghetti sauce

Chicken Fingers (5)

$7.50

Served with choice of wing sauce on the side

Breaded Mushrooms

$6.25

Served with a side of ranch dressing

Garlic Knots (4)

$2.50

Garlic knots served with a side of spaghetti sauce

Garlic Bread

$2.75

Butter & garlic spread over Ithaca bakery french bread

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$3.50

Garlic bread with melted mozzarella cheese


SaladsGarden salads are made fresh with a blend of romaine hearts and mixed greens. Dressing: ICO house, ico bleu cheese, italian, ranch, 1,000 island & raspberry vinaigrette. Add feta, crumbly bleu, mozzarella or provolone cheese $1.25, add turkey, ham, pe

Garden Salad

$3.25 - $5.75

Romaine hearts, mixed greens, cucumber, red onion, tomato and pepperoncini

Greek Salad

$5.00 - $8.50

Feta cheese and kalamata olives served on our garden salad with ICO dressing

ICO Delight

$5.25 - $8.50

Garden salad with a scoop of choice of either tuna or chicken salad on top

Antipasto

$9.00

Salami, pepperoni, capicola, provolone and black olives

Chef

$9.00

Turkey, ham and provolone cheese on our garden salad

Fresh Spinach

$9.00

Fresh baby spinach, red onions, crumbly bleu cheese topped with candied walnuts

Buffalo Chicken

$9.00

Breaded chicken tossed in choice of wing sauce

Grilled Chicken

$9.00

Marinated grilled chicken on our garden salad served with ICO dressing


PastaNana's homemade jumbo meatballs one $2.00, two $4.00. Substitute garlic bread for bread & butter plain $1.50 w/ cheese $2.35, add a garden salad small $2.00, large $4.50

Spaghetti

$8.00

Large portion of spaghetti served with a small bread & butter

Penne

$8.00

Large portion of penne pasta served with a small bread & butter

Cheese Tortellini

$11.00

A full portion of ricotta cheese stuffed tortellini served with a small bread & butter

Cheese Ravioli

$11.00

Ricotta stuffed ravioli’s served with a small bread & butter

Homemade Meat Lasagna

$12.00

Our family’s special recipe with ground beef and Italian sausage

Manicotti (4)

$11.00

Pasta sheets rolled up with ricotta cheese

Stuffed Shells (5)

$11.00

Pasta shells stuffed with ricotta cheese

Child's portion of Penne or Spaghetti

$4.00

Does not include bread & butter


DinnersEach dinner comes with two sides: Select one from each group below. First side: Spaghetti or penne pasta. Second side: French fries, side salad, garlic bread or garlic knots

Eggplant Parmesan

$12.00

Breaded eggplant with melted mozzarella cheese & homemade spaghetti sauce

Chicken Parmesan

$13.00

Breaded chicken with melted mozzarella cheese & homemade spaghetti sauce

Veal Parmesan

$14.00

In house breaded veal with melted mozzarella cheese & homemade spaghetti sauce


Cold Subs or SandwichesSubs are served on ithaca bakery french bread - Sandwiches available on half sub roll, round roll, white, wheat or rye bread. Vegetables: Lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, dill pickles, black olives & fresh green peppers. Condiments: Mayo, musta

Veggie

$4.00 - $6.00

Comes with choice of vegetables from the list above

Turkey, Ham, Tuna or Chicken Salad

$5.25 - $7.50

Served with choice of condiments & veggies

Mixed Meat

$5.25 - $7.50

Turkey, ham and salami combined for a delicious cold sub

Italian Mix

$5.50 - $8.25

Salami, capicola, pepperoni and provolone cheese. Classic Italian cold cut

Roast Beef

$5.50 - $8.25

Our in house roasted beef served with provolone cheese

BLT

$5.50 - $8.25

Bacon, lettuce & tomato, toasted on choice of bread


Hot Sandwiches or Subs

Chicken Parmesan

$5.75 - $8.25

Classic parmesan sub made with breaded chicken

Eggplant Parmesan

$5.50 - $8.00

Classic parmesan sub made with breaded eggplant

Meatball Parmesan

$6.00 - $8.50

Classic parmesan sub with our nana's homemade meatballs

Veal Parmesan

$9.00

Freshly pounded and breaded veal, sauce & mozzarella cheese

Chicken Tender

$5.25 - $7.75

Breaded chicken strips served with mayo, lettuce and tomato

Chicken Wing

$5.50 - $8.00

Chicken strips in your choice of wing sauce with bleu cheese

Philly Cheese Steak

$8.50

Beef cheese steak with green peppers, onions and American cheese

Sausage, Peppers & Onions

$5.50 - $8.00

Grilled hot Italian sausage with green peppers and onions

Hamburger

$6.00 - $8.00

Black angus hamburger served with choice of fixings

Tullyburger

$6.50 - $8.50

Black angus burger served with lettuce, tomato, onions & mayo

Grilled Chicken

$6.00 - $8.50

Marinated grilled chicken with mayo, lettuce & tomato

Fish

$6.25 - $9.25

Fried fish on a roll with tartar sauce & choice of toppings


PizzasOld Italian style pizza made with hand stretched dough and our family’s traditional pizza sauce spread over slices of whole milk mozzarella cheese. Plain cheese pizzas are made with cheese on top. Calzones include ricotta cheese

Cheese Pizza

$8.75 - $21.00

Our family’s pizza sauce with mozzarella cheese

Veggie

$12.00 - $27.50

Freshly cut green peppers, onions & mushrooms

Carnivore

$13.00 - $31.00

Pepperoni, sausage, bacon & ham

BBQ Chicken

$13.00 - $30.25

Chicken, BBQ sauce, bacon and shredded cheese

Supreme

$13.00 - $30.00

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, onions & mushrooms

Bahama Mama

$11.00 - $26.50

Sliced ham and pineapple, classic hawaiian

Chicken Wing

$12.25 - $28.25

Breaded chicken with choice of wing sauce

Flying Squirrel

$13.50 - $30.75

Chicken wing pizza with philly cheese steak

Toppings Selections

Price may varies

extra dough medium & large only $2.00, 1st tier: Pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, spinach, tomatoes, pineapple, olives, broccoli calzone $1.05, medium 14" $1.35, larg


White PizzasOld Italian style pizza made with hand stretched dough and our family’s traditional pizza sauce spread over slices of whole milk mozzarella cheese. Plain cheese pizzas are made with cheese on top. Calzones include ricotta cheese

White Garlic

$9.00 - $20.50

Mozzarella cheese topped with our garlic olive oil

Fortunato

$10.25 - $25.00

Sliced tomatoes and our fresh basil & garlic olive oil

Legend

$10.75 - $25.75

White garlic with our blend of 4 delicious cheeses

Popeye

$11.75 - $27.00

Fresh tomatoes, baby spinach & feta cheese

The Joey

$12.25 - $28.75

Double dough, pepperoni, Italian sausage and extra cheese

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$13.00 - $29.25

Breaded chicken, bacon & ranch dressing


WingsOur wings are cooked to order, a little on the crispy side. Sauces: Mild, medium, hot, BBQ, chipotle BBQ, golden, extra I.C.O. bleu cheese or ranch $0.85, extra wing sauce (served on the side) $0.85

One Dozen Wings (12)

$9.00

A dozen wings tossed in choice of wing sauce

Boneless Buffalo Fingers (5)

$9.00

Boneless chicken fingers tossed in choice of wing sauce. Each order served with choice of homemade bleu cheese or ranch dressing


Something SpecialOnly available as full sub

Flying Squirrel

$9.00

Our chicken wing sub with philly cheese steak

Chicken Supreme

$8.50

Breaded chicken strips on a roll with 1,000 Island dressing & grilled ham & swiss

Beef Italiano

$8.50

Beef, melted provolone, mayo, lettuce and tomato on garlic bread

Chicken Ranch

$8.75

Breaded chicken strips tossed in chipotle BBQ, with ranch, swiss and a few breaded onions

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$8.75

Breaded chicken strips, ranch dressing, swiss cheese & bacon

Hot Sicilian

$8.75

Italian mix toasted with spicy mustard, roasted reds, green peppers and onions

Pizzaburger

$8.25

Grilled hot Italian sausage topped with melted mozzarella and our Nana's spaghetti sauce


Something Special - AOnly available as sandwich

ICO Burger

$5.50

A burger made from our nana’s meatballs with lettuce, tomato, mozzarella and a few onions rings

ICO Dog

$3.50

Our famous hotdog with cream cheese, relish, mustard, ketchup and American cheese


Specials

Two Slice Special

$5.00

Two slices of cheese pizza & a 16 oz. fountain soda

Slice, Salad & Soda

$6.00

One slice of cheese, a small garden salad & a 16 oz. soda

Carry Out Combo

$23.00

One large cheese pizza, one dozen wings & a 2-liter of soda

Two Pies Combo

$23.00

One large cheese & one medium cheese pizza

Family Combo

$45.00

Two large cheese pizzas, two dozen wings & two 2-liters of soda

Sheet Combo

$36.00

One sheet cheese pizza & two dozen chicken wings

Friday Fish Fry

$13.00

Served with a half pound of fries, coleslaw & a cup of tartar sauce


Slice Pizza

Plain Cheese Slice

$2.50

Each additional topping: $0.25


Sub Extra or Sides

Grilled Peppers

$0.85

Onions, mushrooms or banana peppers add one or all

Extra Chicken (Breaded or grilled)

$1.25 - $2.00

Extra Cheese

$0.85 - $1.25

Bacon

$1.00 - $1.50

Garlic Sub Roll

$0.50 - $0.75


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading