Island Way Grill Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 135 votes
Island Way Grill Logo

Choose My State

FL

Island Way Grill Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Salads

Island Way House

$3.50

Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, jicama, radish, carrots, roasted pumpkin seeds, asiago cheese, rice wine vinaigrette. Add maytag blue cheese $2.5

Island Way House with Entree

$2.90

Wedge

$5.90

Iceberg lettuce, nueske bacon, red onion, maytag blue cheese dressing, tomato vinaigrette

The Island Caprese Stack

$6.90

Beefsteak tomatoes, mozzarella, fresh basil, with balsamic drizzle,

Kale Caesar

$7.90

With eggs and bacon

Arugula Salad with Roasted Beets

$7.90

Warm goat cheese croutons, aged balsamic vinaigrette

Butter Lettuce and Grilled Mango Salad

$7.90

Butter lettuce, fresh Florida mango, red onion, candied pecans, citrus vinaigrette


Rice & Pasta Bowls

Pan-Seared Fresh Catch

Price may varies

Pan-Sauteed Shrimp

$19.90

Pan-Seared Scallops

$24.90

Portobella Mushroom Cap

$17.90

Wood Fire-Grilled Chicken Breast

$18.90

Pan-Sauteed Seafood Combo

$25.90

Wood Fire Grilled Rustic Vegetables

$17.90

Rustic Vegetables, Portobella & Goat Cheese

$19.90


Fish & SeafoodServed with fresh market vegetables

Salmon en Papillote

$16.90

Jasmine rice, Asian vegetables and herbs with our signature Island Way sauce cooked in parchment paper.

Florida Keys Fire-Roasted

$19.90

Lobster Tails

$36.90

Wasabi mashed potatoes

Szechwan Pepper-Crusted Tuna

$25.90

Teriyaki glazed. wasabi mashed potatoes

Jumbo Lump Crabcakes

$19.90

Citrus remoulade, pineapple salsa, wasabi mashed potatoes

Mixed Seafood Grill

$25.90

Blackened fresh catch, jumbo lump crabcake oscar and shrimp tempura. Wasabi mashed potatoes

Alaskan King Crab Legs

$49.90

1 1/4 lb Alaskan king crab legs, wood fire-grilled. wasabi mashed potatoes

Shrimp Scampi

$19.90

Sauteed shrimp, garlic, white wine and butter over the finest italian linguine

Shrimp Tempura

$19.90

Jasmine rice, asian cocktail, soy dipping sauce

Coconut Shrimp

$19.90

Coconut crusted shrimp, orange ginger sauce


Fire & Ice Shellfish

Shellfish Tower

$36.90

9 Oysters, 9 shrimp and 9 clams

Shellfish Tower with Alaskan King Crab Legs

$24.50

Shellfish Tower with Oysters Rockefeller

$12.50

Shellfish Tower with Clams Casino

$7.90

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (3 Shrimp)

$7.50

Horseradish cocktail sauce, wasabi aioli

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (6 Shrimp)

$13.90

Horseradish cocktail sauce, wasabi aioli

Clams (3 Clams)

$3.30

Clams (6 Clams)

$6.50

Clam Pot

$12.50

Dozen clams steamed in island herbs

Clams Casino

$7.90

Thai High Mussels

$9.90

Spicy coconut milk broth, garlic, thai basil

Oysters Rockefeller

$12.50

Half-dozen, topped with artichokes, spinach, bacon and parmesan

Oysters

$12.50

Simply raw, priced per three, cocktail sauce, horseradish, sake ginger mignonette

Chef’s Featured Boutique Oysters

$6.90

Blue Point

$6.90

One of the most well known oysters

York River

$4.50


LandServed with fresh market vegetables and wasabi mashed potatoes

Bone-In Pork Chop

$19.90

Bourbon sugar cane glazed, wood fire-grilled, BBQ caramelized onions

Volcano Island Meatloaf

$12.90

Tumbleweed onions, finished with soy balsamic reduction drizzle

Chicken Sand Key

$14.90

Thinly pounded, stuffed with fresh spinach and mozzarella, finished with lemon butter sauce


Land & SeaServed with fresh market vegetables and jasmine rice

Surf & Turf

$39.90

Florida keys fire-roasted lobster tail, filet mignon

Reef & Beef

$23.90

Tempura shrimp and a filet mignon k-bob

Filet Oscar

$29.90

Crowned with king crab meat, grilled asparagus, and topped with citrus hollandaise


SteaksAll our steaks are cut here from USDA prime and top choice Midwestern beef, aged five to six weeks in our temperature controlled aging room. Steaks come with wasabi mashed potatoes or east-west fries

New York (3/4 lb)

$29.90

T-Bone Korean BBQ (1 1/4 lb.)

$29.90

1 lb Porterhouse

$24.90

11/2 lb Porterhouse

$32.90

2 lb Porterhouse

$39.90

Rib Eye Bone-In (1 1/4 lb.)

$37.90

Top Sirloin (1/2 lb.)

$15.90

Top Sirloin (3/4 lb.)

$16.90

Filet Mignon Bone-In (1 lb.)

$44.90

Filet Mignon (1/3 lb.)

$23.90

Filet Mignon (1/2 lb.)

$29.90

Filet Mignon (3/4 lb.)

$35.90


Just Caught

Island Way

Price may varies

Our signature preparation wok-seared in ginger oil. Garlic, onion, pepper, tomato, thai curry sauce. Jasmine rice

Wood Fire-Grilled or Blackened

Price may varies

Citrus butter, wasabi mashed potatoes, market vegetables

Pacific Rim

Price may varies

Pan-seared in ginger oil, orange-ginger reduction, served over crab infused jasmine rice with cilantro oil finish

Panko-Crusted

Price may varies

Panko crusted pan sauteed, a squeeze of fresh lime, a pinch of fresh parsley, with wasabi mashed potatoes

Pan-Roasted Stuffed

Price may varies

Stuff your catch with shrimp, roasted red peppers, citrus hollandaise, with wasabi mashed potatoes add $4.90

Oscar

Price may varies

Jumbo lump crab, asparagus & citrus hollandaise, with wasabi mashed potatoes add $5.90


Small Plates

Crab Bisque

$5.90

Edamame

$5.90

Thai sweet chili butter sauce, maldon sea salt

Seared Scallops

$10.90

Galangal, black vinegar. Sweet citrus sauce

Handcrafted Tostadas

$7.20

Pulled chicken, roasted peppers and onions, blue cheese aioli

Jalapeno Grouper Fritters

$8.90

Island sweet chili dipping sauce

Tuna Ceviche

$7.90

Ginger, soy, lime, jalapeno, cilantro and grape seed oil

Calamari

$9.50

Fresh fried, sweet & sour sauce, crispy vegetables & cashews

Wok Fried Soft Shell Crabs

$12.90

Lemongrass-red curry aioli

Coconut Shrimp

$12.90

Coconut encrusted shrimp, orange-ginger sauce

Asian Crab Spring Roll

$12.90

Asian vegetables, fresh herbs. Chinese mustard, plum sauce

Sashimi Salad

$10.90

Wakame, seasoned squid and sunomono salad. topped with chef’s choice of marinated sashimi and flying fish roe

Shrimp Tempura

$9.90

Horseradish cocktail, soy-sake dipping sauce

Beef Carpaccio

$14.90

Prime tenderloin, truffle oil, capers, arugula and grape tomatoes

Szechwan Seared Tuna

$14.90

Soy dipping sauce, wakame, soy-balsamic reduction

Jumbo Lump Crabcake

$9.90

Citrus remoulade

Frankie’s Tuna

$14.90

Tempura fried roll of tuna, kani-kama, cream cheese, vegetables

Florida Roll

$12.90

Spicy tuna, shrimp, kani kama, cream cheese, tempura fried, eel sauce, flying fish roe


Supper Club MenuAll early dinners include french baguette, island house salad or crab bisque, and a chef’s dessert

Our Signature Preparation Island Way Salmon

$14.90

Wok seared in ginger oil. garlic, onion, pepper, tomato, thai curry sauce. Island rice

Salmon Rosette

$14.90

Fresh salmon stuffed with our blue crab stuffing, oven baked and served with a crab veloute, wasabi mashed potatoes

Wok Stir-Fry

$14.90

Choice of beef or shrimp. With asian vegetables over jasmine rice

Filet Mignon K-Bob

$14.90

Wood fire grilled with peppers & onions on a bed of island rice

Shrimp Tempura

$14.90

Cocktail sauce, wasabi mashed potatoes

Chicken Rockefeller

$14.90

Stuffed with spinach, applewood-smoked bacon, cheddar-jack cheese, topped with citrus hollandaise sauce, wasabi mashed potatoes

Shrimp Scampi Linguine

$14.90

Shrimp, garlic, white wine, butter over linguine

Jumbo Lump Crab Cake

$14.90

Citrus remoulade, wasabi mashed potatoes

Seafood Imperial

$14.90

Fresh catch and shrimp in a crab cream sauce, oven baked, wasabi mashed potatoes

Thai High Mussels

$14.90

In a spicy coconut milk broth over linguine with garlic and thai basil

Seafood Alfredo

$14.90

Key west pink shrimp, fresh catch, lump crab tossed with button mushrooms and linguine, in parmesan cream sauce

Sweet and Sour Stir Fried Pork or Shrimp

$14.90

With pineapple, onions, mixed bell peppers over jasmine rice

Volcano Island Meatloaf

$14.90

Soy balsamic reduction drizzled, tumbleweed onions, wasabi mashed potatoes

Onion Crusted Salmon

$14.90

Toasted onions, white wine, key lime juice and whole butter. wasabi mashed potatoes

Filet Mignon Medallions

$14.90

Rich marsala and mushroom sauce over wasabi mashed, market vegetables. Add shrimp scampi $3.00

Just Caught Catch

$14.90

Chef’s prepared selection from our own fleet of dayboats


Sushi Bar

Tuna

$6.90 - $5.90

Yellowtail (Hamachi)

$6.80 - $5.80

Salmon (Sake)

$4.90 - $4.70

Shrimp (Ebi)

$5.40 - $4.90

Kani-Kama

$5.60 - $4.40

Octopus (Tako)

$5.90 - $5.40

Eel (Unagi)

$5.90 - $5.60

Smoked Salmon

$5.80 - $4.90

Conch

$5.90 - $4.90

Smelt Roe (Masago)

$5.40 - $4.90

Rainbow Tobiko (Flying Fish Roe)

$5.80 - $4.90

Salmon Roe (Ikura)

$5.90 - $4.90

Sea Urchin (Uni)

$6.90 - $5.90

White Tuna (Escolar)

$6.90 - $5.90

Miso Soup

$3.90

Edamame

$4.20

Quail Eggs

$3.90 - $2.50

Sushi Appetizer

$11.90

5 Pcs nigiri, chef’s choice

Sashimi Appetizer

$14.90

3 Kinds of fish, 9 pieces, chef’s choice

Sushi Jo

$21.90

10 Pieces chef’s choice nigiri & tuna roll

Sashimi Jo

$32.00

18 Pieces, chef’s choice

Seasoned Squid Salad

$4.90

Seaweed Salad (Wakame)

$5.90

Sashimi Salad

$10.90

Wakame, cucumber sunumono, seasoned squid, chef’s sashimi, flying fish roe


MakimonoRolled sushi with sesame seeds

Tekka Tuna

$4.90

Kappa (Cucumber)

$4.40

Tekkyu

$5.40

Tuna & cucumber

California

$5.50

Avocado, cucumber & kani-kama

Arizona

$6.40

Yellowtail, scallion & smelt roe

Unakyu

$6.50

Eel, cucumber & eel sauce

Clearwater

$5.50

Tempura grouper, onion & mayo

Mexico

$6.40

Tempura shrimp, mayo, avocado & smelt roe

Futomaki

$6.90

Vegetarian

Spicy Tuna

$5.90

Tuna & cucumber

Bagel

$5.90

Smoked salmon, cucumber & cream cheese

Soft Shell Crab

$7.90

Cucumber, kani-kama, smelt roe, spicy mayo

Rainbow Roll

$12.90

Kani-kama, cucumber, salmon, tuna, whitefish and avocado


Special House Rolls

Firecracker

$13.90

Baked dynamite, gobo, onion, sriracha, topped with tempura crunch, eel sauce, smelt roe, spicy mayo

Florida Roll

$12.90

Spicy tuna, shrimp, kani-kama, cream cheese, tempura fried. eel sauce, flying fish roe

Frankie’s Tuna

$14.90

Tuna, cream cheese, gobo, asparagus & kani-kama, tempura fried, topped with smelt roe, scallions, eel sauce

Tempura Eel

$9.90

Broiled eel, kani-kama, cream cheese, asparagus, battered & tempura fried, eel sauce

Island Way Roll

$12.90

Kani-kama, cream cheese, topped with avocado, baked dynamite, scallion, smelt roe & eel sauce

Philly Roll

$5.90

Tuna, cream cheese & smelt roe

Dragon

$11.90

Kani-kama, asparagus, cream cheese, topped with avocado, broiled eel, eel sauce

Tuna Sun

$9.90

Kani kama, cream cheese, asparagus, gobo, avocado - wrapped in tuna garnished with eel sauce, spicy mayo & wasabi tobiko

Suzy Q

$7.90

Kani-kama, asparagus, gobo, avocado, spicy mayo with smelt roe

Kamakazi

$9.90

Baked salmon, kani-kama, cream cheese, scallion, masago with spicy mayo & eel sauce

Atomic

$9.90

Baked white fish, cream cheese, kani-kama, scallion, smelt roe with spicy mayo & eel sauce

Today’s Special Sushi Roll

Price may varies


Shareable Sides

Truffle Mac & Cheese

$5.90

Wood Fire-Grilled Brussel Sprouts with Bacon

$12.90

Grilled Asparagus

$5.90

With orange zest and shaved asiago cheese

Tempura Vegetables

$6.90

Green peppercorn aioli


Desserts

Ginger Creme Brulee

$5.90

Candied ginger garni

Warm Espresso Chocolate Cake

$5.40

Citrus mascarpone cream. Served ala mode, add $2.3

Working Cow Home Made Ice Cream

$4.40

Island Way Cheesecake

$6.90

White Chocolate Banana Malt Mousse

$4.90

Key Lime Pie

$5.90

Toasted macadamia nut crust

Chef’s Dessert Sampler

$9.90

Creme brulee, warm espresso chocolate cake, key lime pie

Drunken Ice Cream

$9.50


Coffee Bar

Espresso

$2.80

Cappuccino

$3.50

Cafe Mocha

$3.90

Cafe Buffet

$6.50

Cafe Bermuda

$6.50

Tia maria, gosling’s black seal


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading