Island Creek Oyster Bar Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 447 votes
Island Creek Oyster Bar Logo
Local/Organic
Seafood
Gastropub
Brunch

Choose My State

MA

Island Creek Oyster Bar Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Lunch

Grilled Faroe Island Salmon

$18.00

mustard spaetzle, grilled corn, spinach

Sirloin Steak Sandwich

$16.00

peppers and onions, sriracha fries

Lobster Knuckle BLT

$17.00

brioche, ward’s farm tomatoes, basil aïoli

Colorado Angus Burger

$15.00

grafton cheddar, house-cured bacon, fries

Smoked Bluefish Pâté Sandwich

$14.00

house made pickles, horseradish crème fraîche


Shore Food

Ethel’s Lobster Roll

$25.00

kettle chips, cole slaw, rosemary roll

Fish & Chips

$19.00

beer batter, malt vinegar aïoli

Fried Fish Sandwich

$15.00

spicy tartar, old bay fries

Fried Ipswich Clams

$28.00 - $15.00

tartar sauce

Ethel’s Lobster Roll

$25.00

kettle chips, cole slaw, rosemary roll

Fish & Chips

$19.00

beer batter, local fish, malt vinegar aïoli

Fried Fish Sandwich

$15.00

spicy tartar, old bay fries

Fried Oyster

$27.00 - $15.00

chesapeake bay, tartar sauce


For The Table

Sparrow Arc Farm Greens

$13.00

cherry tomatoes, grilled corn, vermont feta, shallot dijon vinaigrette

Faroe Island Salmon Tartare

$13.00

* cucumber, sesame, lime

No Shell Prince Edward Island Mussels

$10.00

white wine cream, garlic, shallots, parsley

Crispy Oyster Slider

$4.00

brioche roll, lime chile aïoli

Lobster Bisque

$11.00

brown butter lobster knuckles

Crispy Fish Tacos

$12.00

grilled corn salsa, spiced crema

Buttermilk Biscuit

$5.00

Hand-Cut Fries

$5.00

Cole Slaw

$5.00

Old School Baked Beans

$5.00

Roasted Red Potatoes

$5.00

Roasted Crimini Mushrooms

$7.00

Brown Butter Cauliflower

$7.00

Spicy Broccoli Rabe

$7.00

Fruit Plate

$11.00

greek yogurt

Baby Arugula Salad

$11.00

red currant mostarda, spiced walnuts, ricotta, shallot dijon vinaigrette

Broccoli Soup

$10.00

cheddar croutons

Smoked Bluefish Pâté

$13.00

* rye crisps, pickled vegetables

Crispy Oyster Slider

$4.00

brioche roll, lime chile aïoli

Crispy Head On Stoughton Shrimp

$16.00

smoked paprika aïoli

Freshly Baked Pastry Basket

$15.00

chocolate almond bear claw, vanilla bean brioche, carrot parsnip muffin, chocolate roll, poppy seed fig pound cake


Daily Roasts

Jim’s Organic Coffee

Price may varies

Chemex Coffee Selection

Price may varies

Mexican Altura Chiapas

$5.00

Kenya Aa Kia Ora Estate

$5.00

Sumatra Takengon

$5.00

Traditional Drip Coffee

Price may varies

Guatemala Santiago Atitlan

$3.00

Chemex Coffee Selection

$5.00

sumatra takengon

Mexico Altura Chiapas

$5.00

Costa Rica La Amistad Farm

$5.00

Traditional Drip Coffee

Price may varies

Guatemala Santiago Atitlan

$4.00


Baked Goods & Sides

Buttermilk Biscuit

$4.00

Hand-Cut Fries

$4.00

Sriracha Fries

$5.00

Cole Slaw

$3.00

Kettle Chips

$4.00

Old School Baked Beans

$5.00

Housemade Wheat Toast

$2.00

Home Frie

$3.00

Bacon

$4.00

Hand Cut French Fries

$4.00

Old School Baked Beans

$5.00

Buttermilk Biscuit

$5.00

Chocolate Almond Bear Claw

$4.00

Carrot Parsnip Muffin

$4.00

Vanilla Bean Brioche

$4.00

Chocolate Roll

$4.00

Poppy Seed Fig Pound Cake

$4.00


Today, We Are Drinking

2013 Ameztoi 'Rubentis'

$14.00

getariako txakolina rosé notes of strawberry back by lime zest

Brewdog 5am Saint

$7.00

herbs and grapefruit to refresh

Orchard Spritz

$11.00

a reminder of summer’s sunny past


Oysters Made In Duxbury*

Island Creek

$2.50

duxbury ma, skip bennett

Row 34

$3.50

duxbury ma, skip bennett

Rocky Nook

$2.50

kingston ma,, greg barker

Ichabod Flat

$3.00

plymouth ma, don wilkinson

Spring Creek

$3.50

barnstable ma, scott and tina laurie

Wellfleet

$3.00

wellfleet ma, william ‘chopper’ young

Menemsha

$3.50

chilmark ma, tim broderick

Island Creek

$2.50

duxbury ma, skip bennett

Peter's Point

$3.00

onset ma, dennis pittsley and robert tourigny

Chatham

$3.00

chatham ma, stephen wright

Island Creek

$2.50

duxbury ma, skip bennett

Peter's Point

$3.00

onset ma, dennis pittsley and robert tourigny

Moon Shoal

$3.50

barnstable ma, jonathan martin


Oysters From New England*

Howlands Landing

$2.50

kingston ma, bill driver

Beach Point

$3.00

barnstable ma, mark begley

Sunken Meadow

$3.00

eastham ma, mary-kate paravasini

East Beach Blonde

$3.00

charlestown ri, nick pappa and jim arnoux

Howland's Landing

$2.50

kingston ma, bill driver

Rocky Nook

$3.00

kingston ma, greg barker

Ichabod Flat

$3.00

plymouth ma, don wilkinson

Beach Point

$3.00

barnstable ma, mark begley

Spring Creek

$3.00

barnstable ma, scott and tina laurie

Moon Shoal

$3.50

barnstable ma, jonathan martin

Wellfleet

$3.00

wellfleet ma, william'chopper'young

Sunken Meadow

$3.00

eastham ma, mary-kate paravasini

Chilmark

$3.50

menemsha ma, tim broderick

Rocky Nook

$2.50

kingston ma, greg barker

Ichabod Flat

$3.00

plymouth ma, don wilkinson

Beach Point

$3.00

barnstable ma, mark begley

Spring Creek

$3.00

barnstable ma, scott and tina laurie

Chatham

$3.00

chatham ma, stephen wright

Wellfleet

$3.00

wellfleet ma, william'chopper'young


Oysters From Our Friends*

Cedar Island

$3.00

point judith ri, john and cindy west

Northern Cross

$2.50

smith island va, tim rapine

Fluke Crudo

$12.00

orange, sesame, lime

Hog Island

$4.00

tomales bay ca, john finger

Hama Hama

$4.00

lilliwaup wa, adam and lissa james

Striped Bass Ceviche

$10.00

carrot, scallion, fresno, lemon

Scallop Ceviche

$12.00

red onion, jalapeño, mint, blood orange

Sunken Meadow

$3.00

eastham ma, mary-kate paravasini

Chilmark

$3.50

menemsha ma, tim broderick

Hog Island

$4.00

tomales bay ca, john finger

Striped Bass Ceviche

$10.00

bell pepper, radish, carrot, lemon

Fluke Ceviche

$12.00

cucumber, scallion, mint, lime


Shell Fish From New England

1/2 Maine Lobster

$16.00

cousin mark

Littleneck

$2.00

* wellfleet ma

Shrimp Cocktail

$3.50

Shellfish Platter

$88.00

*


Apps

No Shell Prince Edward Island Mussels

$11.00

lemongrass, fresno, chorizo

No Shell Prince Edward Island Mussels

$10.00

white wine cream, parsley

Faroe Island Salmon Tartare

$13.00

* cucumber, sesame, lime

Smoked Bluefish Pâté

$13.00

* rye crisps, pickled vegetables

Yellowfin Tuna Poke

$14.00

* jalapeño, soy, sesame, nori

Pan Fried Maine Crab Cake

$16.00

sparrow arc farm radish, cara cara orange

Crispy Oyster Slider

$4.00

brioche roll, lime chile aïoli

Crispy Striped Bass Collar

$15.00

sweet chili sauce, scallion, coriander aïoli

Steamed Littleneck Clams

$14.00

icob bacon, rosemary fennel broth, scallion butter

Chilmark Oyster Stew

$13.00

fennel cream, toasted brioche


Salad

Baby Arugula Salad

$11.00

spiced walnuts, radish, ricotta, shallot dijon vinaigrette

Baby Iceberg Lettuce

$12.00

bacon, crispy shallots, great hill blue cheese


Fried

Fish Sandwich

$15.00

spicy tartar, old bay fries

Fish & Chips

$19.00

beer batter, malt vinegar aïoli

Fried Oysters

$16.00 - $31.00

chesapeake bay tartar sauce

Crispy Head On Stoughton Shrimp

$15.00

smoked paprika aïoli


Soup

Clam Chowder

$11.00

hand dug clams, buttermilk biscuits, house-cured bacon

Lobster Bisque

$11.00

brown butter lobster knuckles

Broccoli

$10.00

osetra caviar crème fraîche


Cousin Mark’s Lobster

Ethel's Lobster Roll

$25.00

kettle chips, cole slaw, rosemary roll

Lobster Roe Noodles

$34.00

braised short rib, lobster, oyster mushrooms, pecorino


From The Land

Roasted Chicken

$25.00

anson mills polenta, prosciutto, caramelized onions

Grilled New York Strip Steak

$36.00

* roasted red potatoes, mushrooms, red wine sauce

Colorado Angus Burger

$16.00

* house-cured maple bacon, grafton cheddar, fries


Today’s Fish Selection

Cape Cod Bluefish

$26.00

marfax beans, waldoboro turnip, smoked onions

Maryland Striped Bass

$32.00

ricotta gnocchi, roasted parsnip, chorizo

Grilled Faroe Island Salmon

$28.00

mustard spaetzle, icob tasso ham, steelhead roe

Mrs. Bennett’s Seafood Casserole

$25.00 - $42.00

Steelhead Trout

$27.00

black lentils, niçoise olives, golden raisin

Bedford Monkfish

$31.00

short rib tortellini, sparrow arc farm carrots, swiss chard

Arctic Char

$27.00

baby artichoke, red potatoes, toasted almond

Crispy Whole Black Bass

$32.00

shiitake mushrooms, fresno, broccoli rabe


Tonight We Are Drinking $12To Get Naughty With Some Hot Toddy's Tonight's Kitchen Lineup: Raw Bar... Jorge And Eduardo, Garde Manger... Christian, Hot Apps... J.P., Fish... Erick And Jacob, Grill... Hugo, Fry... Lucas, Pastry... Stef.

Hot Toddy

Price may varies

an essential remedy for what ails you

Brasília Toddy

Price may varies

pure comfort sugarcane, honey, lavender

Dutch Remedy

Price may varies

teetotallers aside, rooibos, lemon, st. germain


Shellfish From New England

1/2 Maine Lobster

$16.00

cousin mark

Littleneck

$2.00

* wellfleet ma

Shrimp Cocktail

$3.50

Shellfish Platter

$88.00

*

Shrimp Cocktail

$2.50

1/2 Maine Lobster

$14.00

cousin mark

Littleneck

$1.50

* wellfleet ma

Shellfish Platter

$80.00

*


Brunch

House-Made Baked Beans

$11.00

slab bacon, fried egg

Scrambled Eggs

$10.00

home fries, wheat toast, bacon

Lobster Omelette

$17.00

scallions, pecorino

Egg White Frittata

$12.00

broccoli, shiitake mushrooms, herbed goat cheese

Pickled Egg Salad Sandwich

$12.00

ciabatta, icob bacon

Challah French Toast

$10.00

caramelized banana, toasted peanuts

Colorado Angus Burger

$14.00

house cured maple bacon, grafton cheddar, fries

Short Rib Hash

$16.00

caramelized onion, poached egg, horseradish crème fraîche


Today, We Are Drinking $12

Fallen Leaves

Price may varies

zesty cinnamon and honey kissed with bubbles

Kir Royal

Price may varies

the most classic of the sparkling cocktails

Salt Wash

Price may varies

tarragon celery and juniper savory and sweet


Dessert

New England Cheese

Price may varies

daily changing accompaniments

Daily Sorbet Or Ice Cream

$8.00

churned in-house

Brandy Soaked Butter Cake

$10.00

winter citrus, mint

Gingerbread Donuts

$10.00

cranberries, candied orange

Banoffee Pie

$10.00

dulce de leche, banana

Black Bottom Peanut Pie

$10.00

frozen yogurt,bitter caramel

Chocolate Panna Cotta

$10.00

pistachio, olive oil, sea salt


Jim’s Organic Coffee $5

Mexico

Price may varies

altura chiapas

Costa Rica

Price may varies

la amistad farm

Sumatra Takengon

Price may varies


Traditional Drip $4

Guatemala Atitlan

Price may varies

Together Decaf

Price may varies


Rare Tea Company

Whole Leaf Green

$4.00

Earl Grey

$5.00

Wild Rooibos

$4.00

Sri Lankan Lemongrass

$6.00

English Peppermint

$4.00


Hot Drinks $12

Hot Buttered Rum Cider

Price may varies

spiced luxury vanilla, herbsaint

Alpine Coffee

Price may varies

kill the chill fig rye, ginger

Dutch Remedy

Price may varies

teetotallers aside rooibos, lemon, st. germain

Brasília Toddy

Price may varies

pure comfort sugarcane, honey, lavender

Pomelo Puro

Price may varies

great escape pisco portón, grapefruit, sage


Draft Beer

Icob Pils

$7.00

easthampton, ma. pilsner, lagered with love! by will shelton batch #9

Boulevard Brewing Pop-Up IPA

$7.00

kansas city, mo. ipa, session style porch-pounder

La Chouffe

$10.00

achouffe, belgium. belgian golden ale, pleasantly fruity, coriander, spice

Brewery Ommegang Rare Vos

$10.00

cooperstown, ny. amber ale, reward your victories!

Maine Beer Company King Titus

$10.00

portland, me. porter, malt, roasted chocolate, vanilla

Brooklyn Brewery Sorachi Ace

$8.00

new york, ny. saison americain, lemongrass and floral notes backed by earthy malt

Night Shift Brewing Smolder

$10.00

boston, ma. stout, from our friends; cherrywood smoked, espresso and maple


Session Beer

Narragansett Lager

$6.00

rochester, ny. tall boy can of american lager, "old reliable" official beer of the sox from 1944-1975

Abita Light

$6.00

new orleans, la. light lager, light beer from our friends down on the bayou

Cerveza Pacifico Clara

$6.00

mazatlán, mexico. mexican pilsner, surfer's delight

Reissdorf Kölsch

$8.00 - $75.00

köln,germany. kölsch, dry but not bitter. a beer for everyone!

Sankaty Light

$6.00

nantucket, ma. light lager, full flavored beer, to honor that powerful lighthouse

Schneider And Sohn Edel Weiss

$10.00

kelheim, germany. hefeweizen, certified organic old-school wheat

Schneider And Sohn Aventinus

$10.00

kelheim, germany. weizenbock, full flavor of ripe fruit, clove and caramel

Left Hand Brewing Milk Stout

$7.00

longmont, co. milk/sweet stout. creamy hints of roasted coffee and cocoa


Ale Beer

21st Amendment Bitter American

$6.00

cold springs, mn. extra pale ale, please no crying... full flavor and bold hops

Avery Brewing Co. India Pale Ale

$6.00

boulder, co. ipa, hop freaks unite! rocky mtn. water floral bouquet

Avery Brewing Co. Ellie’s Brown Ale

$6.00

boulder, co. english brown ale, trust us, even with a dog on the label, excellent

21st Amendment Back In Black

$7.00

cold springs, mn. black ipa, independence from the tyranny of the expected

Punk IPA

$7.00

fraserburgh, scotland. ipa, american style ipa citrus, pine apricot

Hardcore IPA

$8.00

fraserburgh, scotland. double ipa, not for the faint of heart!

Libertine Black Ale

$7.00

fraserburgh, scotland. black ipa, bright yet smokey espresso, cacao

5am Saint

$7.00

fraserburgh, scotland. red ale, herbs and grapefruit to refresh

Brooklyn Brewery Local 2

$18.00

new york, ny. belgian strong dark ale, faint chocolate and cherry, backed by citrus


Belgian Beer

Pretty Things Jack D’or

$12.00

westport, ma. saison americain, hybrid of old world style with new world adventurism

Saison Dupont

$9.00

tourpes, belgium. farmhouse ale, simply the way saison should be: lush, lively

Saison Dupont Foret

$18.00

tourpes, belgium. farmhouse ale, bio-dynamic light orange and funky tartness

Tripel Karmeliet

$9.00

buggenhout, belgium. belgian tripel, malty, with a touch of honey and vanilla. herbaceous


Mocktails $6

Abigail’s Delight

Price may varies

house soda of fresh pineapple and homemade orgeat

Lizzie Swizzle

Price may varies

layered and cold sweet and sour

Wags #2

Price may varies

house-made pomegranate syrup, fresh lemon, effervescent


Specialty

Icob Soda

$6.00

spicy ginger beer, winter citrus, spiced fennel

Mint Iced Tea

$3.00

mem tea’s moroccan mint

Sprecher’s

$4.00

root beer, cream soda, orange dream

Clausthaler

$4.00

frankfurt, germany


Champagne

NV Raventós I Blanc ‘la Vida Al Camp’ Cava Penedés

$13.00

NV Aubry Brut Premier Cru Jouy-Les-Reims

$25.00


White

13 Pierre-Henri Gadais ‘Saint-Fiacre’ Muscadet Sèvre Et Maine

$12.00

13 Domaine De La Bregeonnette Gros-Plant Du Pays Nantais

$13.00

13 Domaine Mas Lavail ‘Terre D’ardoise’ Carignan Blanc Roussillon

$12.00

13 Can Feixes ‘Blanc Selecció’ Penedès

$11.00

11 Simonnet-Febvre ‘Cuvée Icob’ Sauvignon Blanc Saint-Bris

$12.00

13 Librandi Ciró

$12.00

12 Icob & Banshee Chardonnay Sonoma Coast CA

$13.00

07 Edi Simèiè Rebula Goriska Brda Slovenia

$15.00

12 Weingut Biegler Rotgipfler Thermenregion

$12.00

12 Leitz ‘Cuvée Icob’ Riesling Rheingau

$11.00

10 Altura Ansonaco Isola Del Giglio

$19.00


Red

11 Lioco Indica Mendocino County CA

$14.00

13 Agrintesa Sangiovese Rubicone

$12.00

12 Loimer ‘Fred’ Zweigelt Niederösterreich

$14.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading