Menu With Price > Menu > Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 101 votes
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream Logo
Ice Cream

Choose My State

IN

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Ices

Blue Moon

Price may varies

Cherry

Price may varies

Lemon

Price may varies

Mango

Price may varies

Sour Green Apple

Price may varies

Watermelon

Price may varies

Main Menu

Hand Packed Quarts & Pints

Price may varies

Choose from over 50 delicious flavors of our homemade ice cream, yogurt, sherbets, ices, and fat-free no sugar added ice cream to take home

Handel Pops

Price may varies

A generous scoop of Handel's homemade ice cream covered in our rich, dark, gourmet chocolate served on a stick! Handel's serves four flavors at all times: vanilla, chocolcate, mint chocolate chip and

Handel's Hurricane

Price may varies

Soft vanilla ice cream with your choice of inclusions such as butterfinger, chocolate chip cookie dough, heath bar, m&m's, nerds, nestle's crunch, oreo, peanut butter cup, reese's pieces, snickers, f

Handel's Banana Split

Price may varies

Shaped with vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream in a row. Smothered with crushed red maraschino cherries, crushed pineapple, real strawberries, surrounded by bananas and topped with a mound o

4 Scoop Sampler

Price may varies

Pick any 4 flavors

Sundaes - Specialty Sundaes

Price may varies

Vanilla ice cream, with your choice of toppings that include caramal, marshmallow, pineapple, strawberry, cherry, peanut butter, chocolate syrup, vanilla syrup or hot fudge seasonal toppings availabl

Sundaes - Seasonal Favorites

Price may varies

Vanilla ice cream, with your choice of toppings that include caramal, marshmallow, pineapple, strawberry, cherry, peanut butter, chocolate syrup, vanilla syrup or hot fudge seasonal toppings availabl

Frozen Hot Chocolate

Price may varies

Our new frozen hot chocolate is a gourmet blend of cocoa, milk, and ice blended into a cool, refreshing, chocolate drink topped with whipped cream

Lowfat Yogurt

Chocolate

Price may varies

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Price may varies

Coffee

Price may varies

Peach

Price may varies

Peanut Butter

Price may varies

Black Raspberry

Price may varies

Strawberry

Price may varies

Vanilla

Price may varies

Sherbets

Black Raspberry

Price may varies

Lemon

Price may varies

Lime

Price may varies

Orange

Price may varies

Pineapple

Price may varies

Pink Champagne

Price may varies

Red Raspberry

Price may varies

Strawberry Margarita

Price may varies

Fat-Free, No Sugar Added Ice Cream

Banana Fudge

Price may varies

Butter Pecan

Price may varies

Caramel Fudge

Price may varies

Caramel Ripple

Price may varies

Chocolate Ripple

Price may varies

Coffee

Price may varies

Coffee Chocolate Ripple

Price may varies

Double Caramel Ripple

Price may varies

Strawberry

Price may varies

Strawberry Banana

Price may varies

Strawberry Fudge

Price may varies

Vanilla

Price may varies

Ice Cream FavoritesIces: Blue moon, cherry, lemon, mango, sour green apple, watermelon

Banana

Price may varies

Banana Cream Pie

Price may varies

Banana's Foster

Price may varies

Black Cherry

Price may varies

Black Raspberry

Price may varies

Black Raspberry Chunk

Price may varies

Black Walnut

Price may varies

Blueberry Cheesecake Chunk

Price may varies

Blueberry Cobbler

Price may varies

Blue Moon

Price may varies

Buckeye

Price may varies

Butter Fudge

Price may varies

Butter Pecan

Price may varies

Butter Toffee

Price may varies

Butterscotch Ripple

Price may varies

Cake Batter

Price may varies

Caramel Apple

Price may varies

Caramel Cashew

Price may varies

Caramel Latte

Price may varies

Caramel Pretzel Crunch

Price may varies

Cheesecake with Oreo

Price may varies

Cherry Cordial

Price may varies

Cherry Vanilla

Price may varies

Chocoholic Chunk

Price may varies

Chocoholic Peanut Butter Ripple

Price may varies

Chocolate

Price may varies

Chocolate Almond

Price may varies

Chocolate Cake Batter

Price may varies

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Price may varies

Choc. Chocolate Chip Cheesecake Chunk

Price may varies

Chocolate Malt with Caramel

Price may varies

Chocolate Marshmallow

Price may varies

Chocolate Oreo

Price may varies

Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie

Price may varies

Chocolate Peanuts and Caramel

Price may varies

Chocolate Pecan

Price may varies

Chocolate Raspberry Truffle

Price may varies

Chunky Chocolate Chip

Price may varies

Chunky Mint Chocolate Chip

Price may varies

Cinnamon

Price may varies

Cinnamon Pecan

Price may varies

Cinnamon Sticky Bun

Price may varies

Coconut Creme Pie

Price may varies

Coconut Almond Fudge Ripple

Price may varies

Coconut Pineapple

Price may varies

Coffee

Price may varies

Coffee Chocolate Chip

Price may varies

Cotton Candy

Price may varies

Deep Dish Apple Pie

Price may varies

Dolce de Leche

Price may varies

Eggnog

Price may varies

Elvis

Price may varies

Fudge Ripple

Price may varies

Funky Monkey

Price may varies

German Chocolate Cake

Price may varies

Graham Central Station

Price may varies

Grape

Price may varies

Handel's All Heart

Price may varies

Hazelnut

Price may varies

Heavenly Hash

Price may varies

Key Lime Pie

Price may varies

Lemon

Price may varies

Lemon Meringue Pie

Price may varies

Mango

Price may varies

Maple Walnut

Price may varies

Mint Chocolate Chip

Price may varies

Mocha Almond Fudge Ripple

Price may varies

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Price may varies

Orange Dream Cream

Price may varies

Orange Pineapple

Price may varies

Fresh Peach

Price may varies

Peanut Brittle

Price may varies

Peanut Butter

Price may varies

Peanut Butter and Jelly

Price may varies

Peanut Butter Parfait

Price may varies

Peppermint Stick

Price may varies

Pineapple

Price may varies

Pistachio

Price may varies

Praline Pecan

Price may varies

Pumpkin Pecan

Price may varies

Pumpkin Ripple

Price may varies

Raspberry Cheesecake Chunk

Price may varies

Red Velvet

Price may varies

Rum Raisin

Price may varies

S'mores

Price may varies

Snappy Turtle

Price may varies

Spouse Like a House

Price may varies

Strawberry

Price may varies

Strawberry Cheesecake Chunk

Price may varies

Thin Mint

Price may varies

Tin Lizzy

Price may varies

Tin Lizzy Cheesecake Chunk

Price may varies

Tiramisu

Price may varies

Toasted Almond

Price may varies

True Blue Bubble Gum

Price may varies

Twixter

Price may varies

Vanilla

Price may varies

Vanilla with Oreo

Price may varies

Vanilla with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

Price may varies

Vanilla Caramel Truffle

Price may varies

Vanilla Turtle

Price may varies

Olde Fashioned FavoritesFountain sodas and ice cream floats, made with any flavor pepsi drink product. malted milk shakes, concocted with any flavor of ice cream or yogurt. boston coolers, built with our famous vanilla ice cream blended with mug rootbeer. freeze, handel's homema

Smoothies

Price may varies

Consist of our delicious sherbet blended with fruit and topped off with whipped cream. flavors include strawberry banana, strawberry razberry, pina-coolada, plus a special flavor of the month

Cones & Waffle Bowls

Price may varies

Handel's always has a fresh supply of cones to choose from, whether it's a traditional cake cup cone, sugar cone, or our larger than life waffle cone. try our new waffle bowl, good for just a scoop o

Homemade Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

Price may varies

Cakes

Price may varies

Our two layer cakes consist of a chocolate or yellow cake on the bottom, a thick layer of deep dark chocolate fudge in the center, and your favorite ice cream or yogurt on the top. Serves 14-16. Our

Pies

Price may varies

Our pies consist of an oreo cookie or graham cracker crust, a layer of deep dark rich fudge or buttery caramel, then fill with your favorite flavor of ice cream or yogurt. serves 6-8

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands