Grandma's Secrets Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 131 votes
Grandma's Secrets Logo
Desserts
Bakery & Pastries

Choose My State

NY

Grandma's Secrets Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Cake Prices

8" Round

$50.00

15 slices

10" Round

$75.00

25 slices

12" Round

$150.00

50 slices

14" Round

$200.00

70 slices

16" Round

$250.00

100 slices

18" Round

$350.00

125 slices

Heart Shaped

Price may varies

Heart Shaped

$100.00

25 slices

Heart Shaped

$150.00

45 slices

7x9 Sheet

$75.00

20 slices

13x9 Sheet

$100.00

40 slices

8" Square

$100.00

40 slices

10" Square

$150.00

50 slices

12" Square

$200.00

70 slices

14" Square

$250.00

100 slices

16" Square

$350.00

125 slices


Pies(15 Slices)

Sweet Potato Pie

$40.00

flavored with cinnamon, nutmeg & brown sugar. cooked until it melts in your mouth

Pumpkin Pie

$45.00

traditional holiday favorite, plain, or with sour cream topping

Apple Pie

$40.00

thinly sliced apples smothered in butter, cinnamon, nutmeg, white and brown sugar

Apple Pie

$50.00

with walnuts and raisins

Peach Cobbler

$50.00

thickly sliced peaches in a heavy brown sugar, butter and cinnamon syrup, filled and topped with flaky crust. ask about additional sizes

Pecan Pie

$50.00

loaded with pecans in a cinnamon and brown sugar filling

Fruit Pie

$50.00

blueberries, cherries, or strawberries in sweet sauce, topped by a flaky lattice crust

Cream Pie

$30.00

creamy filling in a thin pie shell, topped with homemade whipped cream. chocolate, banana or lemon

Georgia Peach Pie

$35.00

thinly sliced peaches baked in a custard, covered with a thin flaky crust

Key Lime Pie

$35.00

classic lime filling on a graham cracker crust, topped with homemade whipped cream

Coconut Custard Pie

$30.00

creamy custard laced with coconut in a thin pie shell

Boston Creme Pie

$40.00

an old fashioned favorite, sure to please. classic yellow cake, vanilla custard filling, milk chocolate covering.


Pie BitesSingle Servings In A Baking Cup, 24 To A Set.

Sweet Potato

$50.00

Fruit

$60.00

Peach Cobbler

$75.00


Cupcakes

Vanilla, Chocolate, Or Yellow

$50.00

buttercream frosting

Yellow

$75.00

coconut meringue icing

Red Velvet

Price may varies

Red Velvet

$60.00

buttercream frosting

Red Velvet

$75.00

lemony cream cheese frosting

Diabetic

$60.00

chocolate w/chocolate drizzle

German Chocolate

$75.00

coconut and walnut topping

Carrot Cake

Price may varies

Carrot Cake

$60.00

buttercream frosting

Carrot Cake

$75.00

cream cheese frosting

Vegetarian

$75.00

vanilla w/vanilla frosting

Sweet Potato

$4.00

lemony cream cheese frosting.


Dietary(15 Servings)

Diabetic Chocolate Lovers Cake

$60.00

moist chocolate cake topped with a chocolate glaze

Diabetic New York Cheesecake

$60.00

reduced calorie cheesecake on a vanilla cookie crumb crust

Diabetic New York Cheesecake

$65.00

also available in chocolate

Diabetic Key Lime Pie

$50.00

reduced calorie lime filling in a reduced calorie crust

Diabetic Pineapple Upside Down Cake

$50.00

moist yellow cake topped with pineapples and glaze

Diabetic Pumpkin Pie

$35.00

reduced calorie classic filling in a reduced calorie crust

Diabetic Sweet Potato Pie

$35.00

reduced calorie classic filling in a reduced calorie crust

Vegan/Vegetarian

$100.00 - $75.00

soy milk, soy butter, egg white substitute. available in french vanilla only

Gluten-Free

$100.00 - $150.00

vanilla & chocolate

Gluten-Free

$25.00

for carrot cake


Chocalicious(15 Slices)

German Chocolate Cake

$75.00

moist german chocolate cake, topped by a coconut and walnut frosting.

Mississippi Mud Cake

$75.00

moist chocolate cake, filled with coconut, pecans, topped & layered with marshmallow cream, & drizzled with chocolate icing

Chocolate Lovers Cake

$50.00

moist, double layer chocolate cake, topped and layered with milk chocolate frosting

German Sweet Chocolate Pie

$45.00

cool, creamy, sweet, chocolate filling on a graham cracker crust.

White Chocolate Cake

$75.00

your choice white whisper cake or golden velvet cake, topped with milk chocolate or white chocolate buttercream frosting


Everyday Cakes

Yellow Cake

Price may varies

moist, buttery layer cake, topped with milk chocolate frosting (also available in lemon)

Yellow Cake

$50.00

15 slices

Yellow Cake

$75.00

25 slices

Carrot Cake

Price may varies

tender spice cake, double layer, blended with raisins, walnuts, shredded carrots, topped with a cream cheese frosting

Carrot Cake

$75.00

15 slices

Carrot Cake

$100.00

25 slices

Pineapple Upside Down Cake

Price may varies

moist yellow cake topped with a brown sugar and pineapple glaze.

Pineapple Upside Down Cake

$60.00

25 slices

Strawberry Shortcake

Price may varies

1890’s teacake, smothered in fresh strawberries in sweet sauce, topped with homemade whipped cream.

Strawberry Shortcake

$60.00

25 slices

Coconut Layer Cake

Price may varies

moist, triple layer cake, covered by a burnt sugar icing, topped with coconut flakes

Coconut Layer Cake

$75.00

12 slices

Coconut Layer Cake

$125.00

25 slices

Red Velvet Cake

Price may varies

classic southern style cake. this moist rich flavor is sure to bring back fond memories. also available in white velvet

Red Velvet Cake

$75.00

15 slices

Red Velvet Cake

$100.00

35 slices

Red Velvet Cake

$125.00

50 slices

New York Cheesecake

$75.00

cool creamy cheesecake on a graham cracker crust.

New York Cheesecake

$100.00

with fruit topping

Chocolate Cheesecake

$90.00

decadent full serving chocolate, or creamy cheesecake loaded with chocolate chips, both on an oreo cookie crust.

Autumn Cheesecake

$100.00

ny style cheesecake topped with apple slices bathed in butter, cinnamon, and pecans.

Grandma’s Ice Cream Cakes

Price may varies

your choice frozen filling (black cherry, strawberry, vanilla, chocolate, pistachio) on a ritz cracker crust, topped with homemade whipped cream and black walnuts


Treats

Brownies

$40.00

chewy, fudge style, melt in your mouth, chocolicious

Brownies

$50.00

with walnuts

Brownies

$60.00

with pecans

Brownies

$10.00

add cool, creamy handmade whipped cream

Lemon Bars

$45.00

rich, tangy bars, sprinkled with powdered sugar

Linzer Bars

$50.00

your choice apricot or raspberry jam

Coconut Dream

$60.00

packed with brown sugar, coconut & walnuts

Triple Layer Cookie Bars

$60.00

coconut filling over graham cracker crust, with chocolate peanut butter topping

Lemon Ambrosia Bars

$50.00

brown sugar, coconut and pecan filling, topped with lemon icing


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading