Menu With Price > Menu > Gotham New York Bagels & Eats

Gotham New York Bagels & Eats Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 100 votes
Gotham New York Bagels & Eats Logo
Deli Food
Sandwiches
Bagels

Choose My State

WI

Gotham New York Bagels & Eats Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

BreakfastServed all day. Your choice of a bagel or bread.

Butter

$1.25

One Egg

$2.75

Two Eggs

$3.75

Plain Cream Cheese Or Tofu

$2.50

Flavored Cream Cheese Or Tofu

$3.00

Egg & Cheddar

$3.25

Pastrami & Egg

$4.75

Sausage, Egg & Cheddar

$5.00

Thick Cut Bacon, Egg & Cheddar

$4.25

Cold Smoked Salmon & Cream Cheese

$6.75

The “G”

$4.00

your choice of bagel with hot capocollo, egg and cheddar

Double Your “G”

$6.00

The “V”

$4.75

scallion tofu, roasted poblano peppers, tomato, arugula and avocado on a bagel

Gotham Signature Sandwiches

Long-Guy-Land

$7.75

house roasted turkey breast, roth kase fontina, arugula, tomato and mayo

Brighton Beach

$9.25

smoked alaskan salmon, caper cream cheese, watercress, red onion and tomato

Spanish Harlem

$7.75

shredded, roasted pork shoulder, hot capocollo ham, melted baby swiss, pickles and dijon mustard

Massapequa

$8.00

roasted chicken breast, roasted red pepper, arugula, fontina & pesto

Gotham Signature Sandwiches 1Served on rye bread with deli mustard, coleslaw and a pickle.

Williamsburg

$9.75

piled-high pastrami

Dyker Heights

$9.75

piled-high corned beef

Build Your Own SandwichIncludes bagel or bread with butter, mayo, dijon, or deli mustard. Arugula, baby spinach, tomato, roasted poblanos, or roasted red bell peppers $1.00, onions, cucumbers, pickles, pesto or jelly $0.75.

Hot Smoked Salmon Or Whitefish Salad

$7.25

Turkey Breast

$5.75

chicken cutlet, tuna, chicken or egg salad, eggplant, genoa salami

Flavored Cream Cheese Or Tofu

$2.25

add a topping.

Capocollo, Egg, Plain Cream Cheese Or Tofu

$1.75

Fontina, Swiss, Provolone, Cheddar, Avocado, Watercress Or Bacon

$1.50

Peanut Butter

$1.25

SaladsPer pound.

Whitefish Salad

$15.00

Chicken Salad

$10.75

Egg Salad

$8.00

Deli Salad

$7.00

Tuna Salad

$10.75

olive oil/lemon-based or mayonnaise-based

Gotham To Go

New York Dozen

$11.00

13 bagels in a brown bag

Hell’s Kitchen

$19.75

new york dozen with two 8 oz. spreads serves 12-15 people pick-up only

Riverside Park

$60.00

cold smoked salmon and cream cheese platter with a new york dozen, two 8 oz. spreads, watercress, red onion, tomato and capers serves 12-15 people

Midtown

$60.00

build your ownnew york dozen, three 1 lb. portions of: turkey, chicken salad, tuna salad, egg salad, eggplant crisps or genoa salami (3 lbs. total), arugula, tomato, red onion, pickles, mayo and deli

Park Avenue

$8.50 - $11.50

signature half sandwiches, with deli salad, kettle chips, and can soda or bottled water (10 person minimum)

MeatsPer pound.

Gotham Signature Pastrami

$18.00

Gotham Signature Corned Beef

$18.00

Cold Smoked Salmon

$25.00

Turkey Breast

$10.75

roasted in the house

...

Single Bagel Or Bialy

$1.00

Cream Cheese 8 Oz

$5.50

Cream Cheese

$11.00

per pound

Kosher Dill Pickle

$1.00

Deli Salad

$1.75 - $3.50

Kettle Chips

$1.25

Protein Soup Of The Day

$4.50

Vegetarian Soup Of The Day

$4.50

Fruit Salad

$3.25

Fruit Tray

$25.00 - $55.00

Beverages & Bagels

Hand Rolled Bagels

Price may varies

plain, whole wheat honey, cinnamon raisin, salt, sesame, everything, onion, garlic, poppy, egg, super egg everything, pumpernickel, bialy.

Bread Options

Price may varies

sourdough, whole wheat, multi-grain, rye, hero roll.

Cream Cheese & Tofu

Price may varies

plain, smoked salmon, olive, chimichurri, caper, walnut raisin, scallion, vegetable, plain tofu, scallion tofu, vegetable tofu

Coffee Hot Or Iced

$1.75 - $2.75

Tea

$1.50 - $2.50

Coffee To Go

$15.00

3 qt./serves 15

Milk

$1.50

Snapple

$1.75

Vitamin Water

$2.00

Soda

$1.25

12 oz. cans

Poland Spring Bottled Water

$1.25

Freshly squeezed orange or grapefruit

$3.00

Cranberry/Lavender Or Spicy Pineapple/Mint

$3.00

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands