Menu With Price > Menu > Good & Plenty To Go

Good & Plenty To Go Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 80 votes
Good & Plenty To Go Logo
Deli Food

Choose My State

NY

Good & Plenty To Go Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Pre-Theatre Comfort SoupsEvery day we offer a different homemade soup. The selection below gives just an idea, since we make our delicious soups from the freshest ingredients available. In the warm months, we also offer a cold gazpacho daily.

Potato Leek

Price may varies

Carrot Ginger

Price may varies

Lentils & Ginger

Price may varies

Black Bean

Price may varies

Corn Chowder

Price may varies

Mushroom Barley

Price may varies

Cream Of Broccoli

Price may varies

Cream Of Tomato

Price may varies

Three Sisters

Price may varies

(butternut squash, corn, white bean).

Chicken Salads

Tarragon Chicken Salad

Price may varies

Chicken Salad

Price may varies

with pecans and currants.

Smoky Chicken Salad

Price may varies

with bacon & sweet red peppers.

Curry & Chutney Chicken Salad

Price may varies

Asian Chicken Salad

Price may varies

Grilled Chicken

Price may varies

served on greens or pasta.

Pasta Salads

Bowtie Pasta

Price may varies

with corn, cranberries & baby greens in a balsamic vinaigrette.

Pesto Pasta With Peas

Price may varies

Penne

Price may varies

with oven-roasted fresh mozzarella & black olives.

Vegetable Salads

Avocado Salad

Price may varies

Hearts Of Palm Salad

Price may varies

Asparagus Salad

Price may varies

Mixed Greens, Peppers And Cherry Tomatoes

Price may varies

Greek Salad

Price may varies

Tuna Salad

Price may varies

Delectable Theatre District SandwichesThey include baby greens, a choice of our special house-made dressings such as basil mayonnaise and balsamic vinaigrette, and add-ons such as roasted spicy onions & tomatoes.

Rave Review Herb-Sauce

Price may varies

marinated chicken breast.

Standing Ovation Ham & Cheese

Price may varies

Smash Hit Tuna Salad

Price may varies

(our good and plenty top seller).

Festive Italian Antipasto Delight

Price may varies

(an all star cast of meats and cheese).

Tour De Force Turkey Delight

Price may varies

Repertory Theatre Chicken Salad

Price may varies

(see salads; this changes every day).

Critics Favorite Roast Beef

Price may varies

Really Good Egg Salad

Price may varies

Off-Broadway SandwichesThey are on our specially-made pan bagnats (french rolls), and are available individually, or with soup and chips.

Southern Fried Catfish

Price may varies

(friday only).

Southern Fried Chicken Tenders

Price may varies

(monday, wednesday, friday and saturday only).

Lunch & Dinner Meals - Comfort Foods & Regional Dishes

Special Rub Roast Chicken

Price may varies

Southern Fried Chicken Tenders

Price may varies

Sassy Chicken

Price may varies

(chicken cutlet with the tang of tomato & jalapeno).

Chicken Baked With Lemon & Olives

Price may varies

Grilled Chicken With Herb Mayonnaise

Price may varies

Chicken Parmesan With Spaghetti

Price may varies

Mango Chicken Wings

Price may varies

Savory Roasted Turkey Breast

Price may varies

Turkey Meatloaf With Onion Glaze

Price may varies

Scrumptious Turkey Chili

Price may varies

Turkey Meatballs In Our House-Made Barbecue Sauce

Price may varies

Old Fashioned Meatloaf

Price may varies

with home-made tomato sauce.

Our ShepherdÂ’s Pie

Price may varies

a fireside favorite.

New Orleans Jambalaya

Price may varies

(the real thing).

EileenÂ’s Own Barbecue Beef

Price may varies

as good as it gets.

Baked Ham Glazed

Price may varies

with bourbon & brown sugar.

Roast Pork Tenderloin

Price may varies

with house-made barbecue glaze.

Oven Roasted Tilapia

Price may varies

with tomatoes and herbs.

Cornmeal-Crusted Southern Fried Catfish

Price may varies

Roasted Salmon With Ginger Soy Glaze

Price may varies

Salmon Cakes

Price may varies

as mother might have made them.

Pasta

Price may varies

with fresh sauteed salmon & fennel.

Lunch & Dinner Meals - South Of The Border

Tamale Pie

Price may varies

Grilled Chicken Quesadillas

Price may varies

with spicy onions & jack cheese.

Tortilla Flats

Price may varies

(layers of flour tortillas, vegetarian or with chicken, between beans, tomatoes, cheese, vegetarian chili).

Texas Chili

Price may varies

Incredible Enchiladas, Empanadas, Tacos

Price may varies

Astonishing Side Dishes

WorldÂ’s Tastiest Rice

Price may varies

(basmati rice with roasted mushrooms, carrots & onion).

Unbelievable Macaroni & Cheese

Price may varies

(baked with three great cheeses).

Perfect Mashed Potatoes

Price may varies

(made with scallions, butter & cream).

Vegetable Of The Day

Price may varies

(the freshest seasonal vegetables).

Fresh Garden Market Greens

Price may varies

Desserts - Melt-In-Your-Mouth CookiesPick from this selection of our cookies, crisps, puddings and cakey delights.

Maple Frosted

Price may varies

Orange Frosted

Price may varies

All-Spice

Price may varies

Chocolate Chip

Price may varies

Chocolate Chocolate Chip

Price may varies

Oatmeal Raisin

Price may varies

Peanut Butter

Price may varies

Desserts - Delicious Seasonal Fruit CrispsWith crumble topping.

Apple

Price may varies

Peach

Price may varies

Blueberry

Price may varies

Desserts - Exceptional Familiar Puddings

Banana

Price may varies

Butterscotch

Price may varies

Chocolate

Price may varies

Desserts - Wonderful Cakey Delights

Brownies

Price may varies

Peanut Butter Brownies

Price may varies

Lemon Squares

Price may varies

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands