Gatsby's Pub Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 179 votes
Gatsby's Pub Logo

Choose My State

IN

Gatsby's Pub Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Mushrooms

$7.25

Fresh cut button mushrooms dipped in Gatsby's special batter then deep fried to perfection

Supreme Nachos

$7.99

Tortilla chips loaded with your choice of chicken, beef, chili or white bean chili, then smothered with cheese, jalapenos, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, scallions and black olives

Cheese Fries

$6.25

Delicious fries covered with your choice of shredded Monterrey Jack and cheddar or nacho cheese topped off with diced tomatoes, bacon bits and scallions for supreme flavor

Wings (6, 12, 18)

$15.49 - $5.99

Regular or boneless sweet and Sticky or Spicy Hot, you'll love them all your choice of hot, mild, hot garlic, honey BBQ, sweet Thai chili, or teriyaki. Served with celery and your choice of ranch or

Chicken Cordon Bleu Tenders

$7.99

Four hand breaded chicken breast tenders topped with Gatsby's special cordon bleu sauce and scallions

Twice Baked Potato Skins

$6.95

Baked potato scooped out and topped with cheese, bacon and scallions then baked again to enhance flavors

Kettle Chips

$4.99

A thinly sliced whole potato fried to perfection, lightly seasoned and served with your choice of dipping sauce. Extra sauce $0.50

Calamari

Price may varies

Calamari rings are breaded and fried until golden for a delightful appetizer.

Butterflied Shrimp (6, 12)

$10.29 - $6.29

Delicious breaded and butterflied shrimp served with cocktail sauce, or tossed in our hot or mild sauce.

Battered Onion Rings

$5.95

Sweet onions battered, fried and piled high in a basket

Crab & Artichoke Dip

$7.25

A delicious blend of mozzarella cheese, crab, scallions and artichoke hearts. Served with warm toasted pita

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

$7.25

A blend of cheese, spinach, artichoke hearts and seasonings served with tortilla chips

Garlic Breadsticks

$4.95

Four soft breadsticks, served warm with marinara. Add cheese sauce for an additional $0.75

Chips and Salsa

$4.25

Fresh made salsa and tortilla chips

Mozzarella Sticks

$4.25

Six crunchy, breaded mozzarella cheese sticks served with zesty marinara dipping sauce


SaladsThousand island, bleu cheese, ranch, honey mustard, house, italian, hot bacon, greek, caesar, french and balsamic all served with your choice of a pita of a breadstick, ask your served about half portion salads

Chicken Salad

$8.79

Chicken grilled, breaded, or buffalo style tossed with shredded cheese, diced tomato, and onion. Then placed on a fresh bed of greens

Dinner Salad

$4.50

Fresh greens mixed with tomato, cucumber, blended cheese and croutons. With pita or breadstick

Teriyaki Salad

$8.79

Crisp greens topped with grilled teriyaki chicken or salmon filet, wonton noodles, diced tomato and mandarin oranges

Spinach Salad

$7.29

Fresh spinach piled high and topped with bacon, red onion, egg, mushrooms, and hot bacon dressing on the side

Caesar Salad

$7.79

Romaine lettuce, black olives, onion, croutons, tomato and parmesan cheese topped with our very own creamy Caesar dressing. Add chicken breast or salmon filet for only $1.79

Cobb Salad

$9.29

Grilled chicken tossed with bleu cheese crumbles, sunflower seeds, onion, tomato, egg and bacon

House Salad

$7.79

Crispy greens, cucumbers, tomato, bacon, and thin tortilla noodles tossed in Gatsby's very own house dressing. Add a breast of chicken or salmon filet for only $1.79

Crusted Romano Chicken Salad

$8.79

A fresh chicken breast breaded with our very own Romano seasoning set atop a bed of fresh greens, tomato, egg, bacon, tortilla strips Parmesan cheese, and scallions

Chef Salad

$8.79

A refreshing mix of turkey, ham, bacon, onion, tomato, cheese and egg all on a mound of fresh lettuce

Taco Salad

$7.29

Lettuce, tomato, grilled onions and peppers. Topped with black olives and shredded pepper jack cheese and your choice of chicken or beef

Greek Salad

$7.99

Romaine lettuce, with cucumber, feta cheese, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini, and onions with house made greek dressing


SoupsServed with crackers

House Chili

$3.25 - $4.25

White Bean Chili

$3.25 - $4.25

French Onion

$3.25 - $4.25

Soup de Jour

$3.25 - $4.25


Quesadillas

Four Cheese

$7.29

A grilled tortilla folded and stuffed with Cheddar, Monterrey Jack and Colby cheeses

Spinach and Artichoke

$8.49

Mozzarella cheese, fresh spinach, onion and chopped artichoke hearts

Grilled Steak or Chicken

$9.29 - $8.29

Grilled steak or chicken with Cheddar and Monterey jack cheeses, jalapenos, black olives, red and yellow peppers and onion

Crab and Artichoke

$8.49

A delicious blend of mozzarella cheese, our house crab dip and chopped artichokes


Wraps

Chicken

$7.99

Our delicious chicken breast, seasoned your way cajun, grilled or buffalo tossed with fresh lettuce, tomato, a blend of cheese and onion all wrapped in a warm flour tortilla

Greek Wrap

$7.99

Romaine lettuce with cucumber, feta cheese, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini and onions with house made greek dressing

Chicken Caesar

$7.99

Warm breaded chicken, crispy romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, garlic croutons and creamy Caesar dressing, wrapped in a warm flour tortilla

Southwest Chicken

$7.99

Our delicious crispy chicken breast, tossed with fresh lettuce, tomato, cheese, onion and homemade southwest sauce, all wrapped in a warm flour tortilla

Chef's Salad Wrap

$7.99

A refreshing mix of turkey, ham, bacon, onion, tomato, cheese, egg and fresh lettuce

Chicken Fajita

$7.99

Grilled chicken, sauteed peppers, onions and tomato lightly seasoned and served in a warm flour tortilla

Gatsby's Veggie

$7.25

Fresh cucumber, tomato, cheese, avocado, carrots, celery, and onions mixed with shredded lettuce and Gatsby's house dressing, wrapped in a warm flour tortilla


Fall Plates

Chicken Cordon Bleu

$13.29

A breaded chicken breast, ham and Swiss cheese over penne pasta with our own alfredo sauce

Chicken Parmesan

$12.99

Chicken breast breaded with our own romano mix then topped with mozzarella cheese and a zesty marinara sauce, served over a bed of penne pasta

Chicken Primavera

$12.49

Fresh spinach and diced tomato tossed with penne then bathed in light cream sauce and crowned with a grilled chicken breast

Pasta Diablo

$13.29 - $14.99

Our signature Pasta Diablo is prepared with penne pasta in a spicy, creamy red sauce with your choice of chicken or shrimp

Grilled Salmon

$12.95

Grilled salmon filet served with a side salad, your choice of side dish and Texas toast

Sirloin Steak

$13.99

A juicy, tender sirloin cooked to order and served with choice of a side and Texas toast. Try it black and bleu, cajun style or French onion and mozzarella

Teriyaki Chicken

$11.99

A premium charbroiled chicken breast with sweet teriyaki sauce and grilled pineapple served with broccoli, rice and your choice of soup or salad


Sandwiches

Chicken

$8.29

Grilled or breaded chicken breast with your choice of toppings served on a fresh Kaiser roll. Try it Cajun, buffalo, or hickory style

Pork Tenderloin

$8.29

Served breaded grilled or cajun style with your choice of toppings. Add cheese $0.50

Cuban

$8.79

Sliced ham, turkey and pork piled high with tomato, onion, Swiss cheese and mayo, served on a pressed hoagie roll

Ham and Cheese Sub

$7.49

Sliced ham and your choice of cheese served hot or cold with shredded lettuce, tomato, mayo and onion on your choice of hoagie or wrap

Crusted Romano Chicken

$8.29

This house favorite has a fresh chicken breast breaded with our secret seasonings and served with your choice of toppings on a fresh Kaiser roll

Club

$8.79

Sliced turkey and ham mounded on top of lettuce, tomato, Swiss and American cheeses, bacon and mayo. Served on your choice of bread or in a wrap

Pastrami

$8.29

Fresh sliced hot pastrami stacked high and topped with Swiss cheese and served on toasted rye bread

Philly

$8.29

Thinly sliced Philly steak or sliced chicken smothered in sauteed onion, mushrooms and provolone cheese stacked high on a fresh hoagie roll

Pulled BBQ Pork

$7.79

Slow roasted BBQ pork topped with blended shredded cheeses and served piping hot on a fresh Kaiser roll

French Dip

$8.29

Thinly sliced beef piled high on a toasted hoagie roll and topped with Provolone cheese, served with au jus for dipping

Reuben

$8.49

Corned beef piled high and topped with Swiss cheese and kraut, served on toasted Rye bread with thousand island dressing on the side

BLT

$6.99

This triple stack is loaded with bacon, lettuce, mayo and tomato and served on your choice of toasted bread or in a wrap

Fish Sandwich

$8.49

Tasty Haddock filet served grilled or beer battered with lettuce, tomato and onion on a toasted Kaiser roll


Burgers

BBQ Burger

$8.29

1/2 Lb patty cooked to order served with BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese and topped with an onion ring served on a kaiser roll

Bacon and Egg Burger

$8.29

1/2 Lb burger cooked to order and topped with crispy bacon, Cheddar cheese and a fried egg

The Stand-by Burger

$7.50

1/2 Lb burger cooked to order and topped with crispy lettuce, ripe tomato, pickle, onion and mayo. Add cheese $0.50

Build Your Own Burger

$8.29

1/2 Patty cooked to order and served with 3 toppings of your choice. Toppings include: mushrooms, bacon, cheese, jalapenos, banana peppers, feta or bleu cheese crumbles, or any salad dressing. Additi


Pizzas

Gatsby's House Pizza

$12.49 - $14.49

Our cracker crust brushed with garlic & olive oil then layered with mushrooms, diced tomato, onion, feta, artichoke chips, mozzarella cheese, spinach and sprinkled with bacon bits

The Carnivore

$13.49 - $15.99

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon and cheese

Build Your Own Pizza

$5.59 - $9.59

Add any topping to our already great cheese pizza to create your perfect pizza. Add any of these toppings for $1.50 each: ham, sausage, pepperoni, chicken, bacon, green peppers, banana peppers, pinea

Four Cheese

$10.99 - $12.49

Loaded with four different types of cheese

The Super Deluxe

$13.49 - $16.49

Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives and cheese


SidesAdd a side dinner salad to any meal for $1.99

Cole Slaw

Price may varies

Broccoli

Price may varies

Waffle Fries

Price may varies

Potato Chips

Price may varies

Baked Potato

Price may varies

Cottage Cheese

Price may varies

Fries

Price may varies

Onion Rings

Price may varies

Fruit

Price may varies

Load Your Potato or Fries

$1.29


Beverages & Sweet StuffOn coke, tea, lemonade and coffee

Sodas

$1.79

Coke, diet coke, coke zero, mr. pibb, sprite, sprite zero

Coffee

$1.79

Regular or decaf

Red Bull or Sugar Free Red Bull

$4.00

Iced Tea

$1.79

Sweet Tea

$1.79

Lemonade

$1.79

Bottled Water

$1.79

Juices

$2.50

Orange, pineapple, grapefruit and cranberry juices

Cheesecake

$5.49

Topped with your choice of chocolate sauce, raspberry or strawberry glazes


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading