Menu With Price > Menu > Fish Tales Market & Eatery

Fish Tales Market & Eatery Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 78 votes

Sandwiches

Seafood

Choose My State

Fish Tales Market & Eatery Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Soups & Starters

Red Conch Chowder

$3.50 - $4.95

White Lobster Bisque

$3.50 - $4.95

Conch Fritters

$8.95

Fried Calamari

$8.95

Ahi Yellowfin Tuna

$12.95

seared, sliced with seaweed salsa & wasabi sauce

Buffalo Shrimp

$9.95

1/2 # Steamed Shrimp

$10.95

Dz. Steamed Clams

$9.95

Our Smoked Fish Spread

$7.95

Ceasar Salad

$4.95 - $10.95

Add Grilled Chicken or Fish to either a Ceasar or Johnny's Salad

Johnny's Salad

$4.95 - $10.95

romaine with tomatoes, onions, croutons & our homemade Johnny's dressing (ranch, blue cheese & a little Italian mixed in)

Fried Fish Fingers

$6.95

Specialty Sandwiches

Johnny's Rambler & Fries

$9.95

fried dolphin on grilled swirled rye with melted american cheese, tomato, tartar

German Fish Sandwich & Fries

$9.95

fried dolphin on grilled swirled rye with cole slaw & melted muenster cheese

George's "Bavarian" Fish Sandwich & Fries

$10.95

grilled dolphin topped with sauteed mushrooms, onions & melted muenster cheese on our new pretzel roll

Our "Bavarian Burger" & Fries

$8.95

Our Specialty Sandwichesadd cheese to any sandwich $1. all served with lettuce, and tomato & a side of our homemade cole slaw. add fries, potato salad, black beans & rice or new potatoes for an additional $1

Fried, or Grilled "Catch Of The Day"

$8.95

Grilled Ahi Yellowfin Tuna

$12.95

Fried or Grilled Chicken Breast

$7.95

1/4# All Beef Hot Dog

$5.95

Steak Sandwich

$10.95

8oz. choice certified angus new york strip

Clam Po Boy

$9.95

fried clam strips on a sub topped with our slaw

Char-Grilled Burger

$4.95

Platterswith choice off french fries, new potatoes, potato salad or black beans & rice with a side of cole slaw. ask about our daily specials!

Fried Scallops

$12.95

Fried Shrimp

$12.95

Fried Coconut Shrimp

$13.95

Fried or Grilled "Catch Of The Day"

$10.95

Grilled Ahi Yellowfin Tuna

$14.95

Fried Chicken Fingers

$8.95

Fried Fish Burrito

$10.95

Our Fish of the Day fried and wrapped in a flour tortilla with sour cream & topped with our homemade salsa & melted cheese

Fried Clam Strips

$9.95

Fried Calamari

$10.95

10 Oz. New York Strip Steak

$11.95

(Certified Angus Beef)

Stone Crab & Lobster In Season

*Don't forget to ask about our Daily Specials!!!

*AND FOR THE KIDS...$5.95 WITH FRIES

Price may varies

*FRIED CHICKEN FINGERS; FISH FINGERS, GRILLED CHEESE OR HOT DOG

Homemade Desserts

Key Lime Pie

$3.75

Our Homemade Ice Cream Mud Pies

$3.75

chocolate cookie crust, topped with chocolate sauce & whipped cream. choose from coffee, chocolate almond or chocolate chip

Now Featuring Homemade "Desserts by Nadia"

Price may varies

ALSO FRESH BAKED COOKIES

$1.50

CHOCOLATE CHIP OR OATMEAL RAISIN

Drinks

Bottled Water

$1.25

Fresh Brewed Tender Leaf Iced Tea

$1.25

Fresh Roasted Whole Bean Millstone Coffee

$1.25

Fountain Soda

Coke

$1.75

*Free refill with all fountain sodas

Diet Coke

$1.75

Sprite

$1.75

Fruit Punch

$1.75

Raspberry Tea

$1.75

Pink Lemonade

$1.75

Draft Beer

Coors Light

$2.95

Fat Tire

$4.50

Key West Sunset Ale

$4.50

Paulaner Octoberfest Lager

$4.50

Tucker "Fest Bier"

$4.50

*our Beer of the Month

$4.50

Bottled Beer

Budweiser

$2.95

Bud Light

$2.95

Michelob Ultra

$2.95

Miller Light

$2.95

O'doul's

$2.95

Heineken

$3.95

Corona

$3.95

Corona Light

$3.95

Wines By The Glassask about our "wine of the month"

Chardonnay

$4.50

Pinot Grigio

$4.50

White Zinfandel

$4.50

Cabernet

$4.50

Check Out Our Market

Price may varies

certified angus beef, choice & prime steaks (rib eye, new york, tenderloin) pork, lamb, homemade sausage, freshest seafood around. we will cook your catch; smoke your catch; or ship your catch

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.