Fish House Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 81 votes
Fish House Logo

Choose My State

FL MD NY

Fish House Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Fried Shrimp

$8.99

perfectly fried shrimp

Buffalo Fried Shrimp

$9.99

large perfectly fried shrimp, tossed in a spicy buffalo sauce and served with bleu cheese dipping sauce

Coconut Jumbo Shrimp

$13.99

perfectly fried and served with our house mango poppy dipping sauce

Steamed Shrimp

$10.99 - $17.99

"peel & eat" with old bay seasoning

Shrimp

$8.99

with garlic butter

Fried Oysters

$12.99

fresh oysters hand breaded in light cracker meal and fried, served with cocktail sauce

Oysters On The Half Shell*

$14.99 - $7.99

raw or steamed (when available)

Seared Yellowfin Tuna*

$12.99

5oz. of thinly sliced fresh tuna served with wasabi, pickled ginger and soy sauce

Crabcake

$9.99

our own recipe made with lump crabmeat, fried and served with cocktail sauce

Crabmeat Stuffed Mushroom Caps

$9.99

topped with a mixture of cheeses and sherry, then baked

Oysters Key Largo

$10.99

baked with seasoned bread crumbs, butter, sherry & mixed cheeses

Conch Fritters

$8.99

served with cocktails sauce

Steamed Mussels

$10.99

delicately steamed in a white wine, garlic-butter sauce

Fried Calamari

$9.99

lightly breaded, served with marinara sauce

Soft Shell Crab

$11.99

fried or sauteed with lemon, white wine, garlic, butter & paprika

Fried Cracked Conch

$10.99

a caribbean classic. fried conch, served with cocktail sauce

Angels On Horseback

$11.99

large sea scallops, wrapped in bacon and baked

Fried Mozzarella Sticks

$6.99

served with marinara sauce

Clams*

$7.99 - $12.99

raw or steamed (when available)

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

$12.99

we mean "jumbo" shrimp, served with cocktail sauce

Ceviche

$10.99

a keys favorite - fresh fish marinated in lime juice with onions, tomatoes and cilantro

Smoked Fish Dip

$8.99

made from our own smoked fish!

Smoked Fish Appetizer

$7.99

we smoke our own!

Stone Crab Claws-1 Lb.

Price may varies

(season in october 15 - may 15) cold with our homemade mustard sauce or hot with drawn butter.

Fried Shrimp

$8.99

perfectly fried shrimp

Buffalo Fried Shrimp

$9.99

large perfectly fried shrimp, tossed in a spicy buffalo sauce and served with bleu cheese dipping sauce

Coconut Jumbo Shrimp

$13.99

perfectly fried and served with our house mango poppy dipping sauce

Steamed Shrimp

$10.99 - $17.99

"peel & eat" with old bay seasoning

Shrimp

$8.99

with garlic butter

Fried Oysters

$12.99

fresh oysters hand breaded in light cracker meal and fried, served with cocktail sauce

Oysters On The Half Shell*

$7.99 - $14.99

raw or steamed (when available)

Seared Yellowfin Tuna*

$12.99

5oz. of thinly sliced fresh tuna served with wasabi, pickled ginger and soy sauce

Crabcake

$9.99

our own recipe made with lump crabmeat, fried and served with cocktail sauce

Crabmeat Stuffed Mushroom Caps

$9.99

topped with a mixture of cheeses and sherry, then baked

Oysters Key Largo

$10.99

baked with seasoned bread crumbs, butter, sherry & mixed cheeses

Conch Fritters

$8.99

served with cocktails sauce

Steamed Mussels

$10.99

delicately steamed in a white wine, garlic-butter sauce

Fried Calamari

$9.99

lightly breaded, served with marinara sauce

Soft Shell Crab

$11.99

fried or sauteed with lemon, white wine, garlic, butter & paprika

Fried Cracked Conch

$10.99

a caribbean classic. fried conch, served with cocktail sauce

Angels On Horseback

$11.99

large sea scallops, wrapped in bacon and baked

Fried Mozzarella Sticks

$6.99

served with marinara sauce

Clams*

$12.99 - $7.99

raw or steamed (when available)

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

$12.99

we mean "jumbo" shrimp, served with cocktail sauce

Ceviche

$10.99

a keys favorite - fresh fish marinated in lime juice with onions, tomatoes and cilantro

Smoked Fish Dip

$8.99

made from our own smoked fish!

Smoked Fish Appetizer

$7.99

we smoke our own!

Stone Crab Claws-1 Lb.

Price may varies

(season in october 15 - may 15) cold with our homemade mustard sauce or hot with drawn butter.


Daily Homemade Soups & ChowdersCup $4.50 / Bowl $5.99. Our Soups And Chowders Are All Original Fish House Recipes.

Conch Chowder

Price may varies

New England

Price may varies

Lobster Bisque

Price may varies

Clam Chowder

Price may varies

Conch Chowder

Price may varies

New England

Price may varies

Lobster Bisque

Price may varies

Clam Chowder

Price may varies


Entree Fresh Fish PreparationsChoose Your Preparation Below. Grouper Or Yellowtail Snapper, Add $2.

Fish 'n Chips Basket

$12.99

fried catch served in a basket over french fries with tartar sauce and lemon

Fried Catch

$12.99

very lightly breaded with cracker meal and fried

Broiled Or Grilled

$12.99

Blackened Catch

$12.99

baked in the oven using the best spicy cajun style seasoning!

Jamaican Jerk Catch

$12.99

a spicy sweet seasoning

Pan Sauteed Catch

$13.99

house specialty! dusted with flour, dipped in egg wash and sauteed with butter, lemon and sherry, our signature dish!

Matecumbe

$13.99

house specialty! topped with fresh tomatoes, shallots, basil, capers, olive oil and lemon juice, the baked. the fish house's original creation, often copied, but never duplicated! featured on the foo

Baked Stuffed

$14.99

enhanced with our blue crabmeat stuffing and baked

Whole Fish

Price may varies

whole yellowtail snapper when available. choose fried or broiled.


"Shore Lunch"

Fried Chicken Fingers

$8.99

served with honey mustard dipping sauce

Baby Back Ribs

$9.99

1/2 rack of ribs

Pasta Marinara

$8.99

Pasta With Garlic & Olive Oil

$8.99


Shellfish

Clam Strips

$8.99

perfectly clams. served with cocktail sauce

Fried Oysters

$13.99

fresh shucked and hand breaded

Fried Shrimp

$9.99

shelled, split and hand breaded

Coconut Jumbo Shrimp

$14.99

perfectly fried and served with our house mango poppy dipping sauce

Steamed Shrimp Lunch

$18.99 - $11.99

"peel & eat" with old bay seasoning

Sea Scallops - Broiled Or Fried

$14.99

either way they are succulent and sweet!

Fried Combo

$15.99

"catch of the day", shrimp scallops, oysters & clam strips. a perfect seafood sampling!


Sandwiches - From The Sea

Catch Of The Day Fish Sandwich

$10.99

fried, broiled, grilled, blackened or jamaican jerk style

Grouper Sandwich

$12.99

broiled, chargrilled, blackened or jamaican jerk

Yellowtail Snapper Sandwich

$12.99

broiled, blackened or jamaican jerk (in the oven) note: yellowtail snapper in too delicate to be chargrilled

Fried Oyster Sandwich

$11.99

Seafood Fajita Wrap

$12.99

seasoned fish & shrimp sauteed with onions, green & red peppers, rolled in a flour tortilla with tomatoes. served with a side of sour cream

Crabwich

$10.99

homemade crabcakes served on a sesame bun with cocktail sauce

Tuna Salad Sandwich

$7.99

light, delicious, white albacore tuna served on whole wheat bread


Sandwiches - From The Land

Hamburger

$8.99

a full 1/2 lb of ground beef, chargrilled, served with lettuce & tomato

Hamburger

$1.00

add american cheese

Key Largo Burger

$10.99

a fish house creation. chargrilled & topped with mixed cheese, sauteed onions & mushrooms

Chicken Breast Sandwich

$8.99

grilled, blackened or jamaican jerk

Key Largo Chicken Sandwich

$10.99

grilled chicken breast topped with mixed cheeses, sauteed onions & mushrooms

Chicken Fajita Wrap

$10.99

seasoned chicken breast stuffed with onions, green & red peppers, rolled in a flour tortilla with tomatoes. served with a side of sour cream

Sirloin Steak Sandwich

$10.99

6oz. grilled usda choice sirloin, grilled & served on a ciabatta roll with horseradish cream sauce

Key Largo Sirloin Steak Sandwich

$11.99

6oz. aged usda choice sirloin, grilled & topped with mixed cheeses, sauteed onions & mushrooms. served on a ciabatta roll with horseradish cream sauce


Salads

House Salad

$4.50

romaine lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and sliced red onions

Caesar Salad

$7.99

romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese, homestyle croutons and creamy caesar dressing

Caesar Salad

$6.00

with grilled catch of shrimp add

Caesar Salad

$8.00

with grouper or yellowtail snapper add

Caesar Salad

$5.00

with grilled chicken breast add

Cobb Salad

$9.99

in the original brown derby style, romaine lettuce, tomato, crumbled blue cheese, chopped bacon, hard boiled egg and avocado

Cobb Salad

$6.00

with grilled catch of shrimp add

Cobb Salad

$8.00

with grouper or yellowtail snapper add

Cobb Salad

$5.00

with grilled chicken breast add

House Salad

$4.50

romaine lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, cucumber, bell pepper and sliced red onion.

House Salad

$2.50

substitution for cole slaw

"Jean's Greens"

$8.99

a fish house exclusive, family recipe and customer favorite! romaine lettuce, french-fried onion rings, crumbled bleu cheese and homemade catalina dressing

Caesar Salad

$7.99

romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese, homestyle croutons and creamy caesar dressing

Caesar Salad

$13.99

with grilled catch or shrimp

Caesar Salad

$15.99

with grouper or yellowtail snapper

Caesar Salad

$12.99

with grilled chicken breast

Cobb Salad

$9.99

in the original brown derby style. romaine lettuce, tomato, crumbled blue cheese, chopped bacon, hard boiled egg and avocado

Cobb Salad

$15.99

with grilled catch or shrimp

Cobb Salad

$17.99

with grouper or yellowtail snapper

Cobb Salad

$14.99

with grilled chicken breast

Crab And Asparagus Salad

$14.99

a generous serving of blue crabmeat atop a bed of romaine lettuce, surrounded by fresh asparagus, sliced avocado, cucumber and tomato, accompanied by our homemade ginger dressing


Fish House Signature SaladsSalad Dressings: House Mango Poppy, Basil Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese, Catalina, Honey Mustard, Ranch, Thousand Island, Oil & Vinegar

"Jean's Greens"

$8.99

a fish house exclusive, family recipe and customer favorite! romaine lettuce, french-fried onion rings, crumbled bleu cheese and homemade catalina dressing

Crab And Asparagus Salad

$14.99

a generous serving of blue crabmeat atop a bed of romaine lettuce, surrounded by fresh asparagus, sliced avocado, cucumber and tomato, accompanied by our homemade ginger dressing


A La Carte

House Salad

$4.50

romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, bell peppers, carrots and sliced red onion

Cole Slaw

$1.99

French Fries

$1.99

Rice

$1.99

Potato Salad

$10.99

Hush Puppies

$2.99

Black Beans And Rice

$3.99

House Salad

$4.50

romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, bell peppers, carrots and sliced red onion

Cole Slaw

$1.99

French Fries

$1.99

Rice

$1.99

Hush Puppies

$2.99

Black Beans And Rice

$3.99

Steamed Mixed Vegetables

$3.99

Steamed Mixed Vegetables

$1.50

as substitute for a standard side dish

Corn On The Cob

$1.99

Steamed New Red Skin Potatoes

$1.99

Garlic Bread

$2.50


Desserts

Key Lime Pie

$5.99

graham cracker crust, creamy sweet/tart key lime filling, topped with a lightly browned meringue. the authentic florida keys version! homemade daily by chef jose!

Peanut Butter Pie

$4.99

peanut butter filling in a graham cracker crust, topped with real chunks of reese's peanut butter cups with chocolate swirls

Oreo Cheesecake

$4.99

oreo crust holds this creamy cheesecake that is loaded with oreo cookies through out, topped with chocolate and chunks of cookies

Key Lime Pie

$5.99

graham cracker crust, creamy sweet/tart key lime filling, topped with a lightly browned meringue. the authentic florida keys version! homemade daily by chef jose!

Peanut Butter Pie

$4.99

peanut butter filling in a graham cracker crust, topped with real chunks of reese's peanut butter cups with chocolate swirls

Oreo Cheesecake

$4.99

oreo crust holds this creamy cheesecake that is loaded with oreo cookies through out, topped with chocolate and chunks of cookies


Coffee Drinks

Cappuccino

$3.50

Espresso

$2.50

B-52 Coffee

$7.50

irish cream, kahlua & g rand marnier

Caribbean Coffee

$6.50

conch republic rum with a touch of tia maria

Irish Coffee

$6.50

jameson irish whiskey topped with green creme de menthe

Keoke Coffee

$7.00

kahlua, brandy & dark creme de cacao

Jamaican Coffee

$6.50

light rum & kahlua

Mexican Coffee

$6.50

kahlua with a splash of tequila

Nutty Irishman

$6.50

bailey's irish cream & frangelico

Cappuccino

$3.50

Espresso

$2.50

B-52 Coffee

$7.50

irish cream, kahlua & g rand marnier

Caribbean Coffee

$6.50

conch republic rum with a touch of tia maria

Irish Coffee

$6.50

jameson irish whiskey topped with green creme de menthe

Keoke Coffee

$7.00

kahlua, brandy & dark creme de cacao

Jamaican Coffee

$6.50

light rum & kahlua

Mexican Coffee

$6.50

kahlua with a splash of tequila

Nutty Irishman

$6.50

bailey's irish cream & frangelico


Beverages

Iced Tea

$2.25

Coffee Or Hot Tea

$1.75

Spring Water

$2.00

San Pellegrino

$2.50

italian sparkling water

Sodas

$2.25

coca-cola, diet coke, club soda, ginger ale, 7up, tonic water

Fruit Juices

$2.25

berry fruit punch, cranberry, grapefruit, lemonade orange, pineapple

Iced Tea

$2.25

Coffee Or Hot Tea

$1.75

Spring Water

$2.00

San Pellegrino

$2.50

italian sparkling water

Sodas

$2.25

coca-cola, diet coke, club soda, ginger ale, 7up, tonic water

Fruit Juices

$2.25

berry fruit punch, cranberry, grapefruit, lemonade orange, pineapple


White Wine - Dry, Full Intensity

3. Chardonnay

$6.25

rosenblum cellars, vintner's cuvee

4. Chardonnay

$7.50

kendall jackson, 'vintner's reserve', california

3. Chardonnay

$6.25

rosenblum cellars, vintner's cuvee

4. Chardonnay

$8.00

kendall jackson, 'vintner's reserve', california


White Wine - Lightly Sweet To Medium Intensity

11. Pinot Grigio

$8.00

livio felluga, italy

14. Sauvignon Blanc

$7.00

sterling, mendocino country (made with organic grapes)

11. Pinot Grigio

$7.50

villa puccini, italy

14. Sauvignon Blanc

$7.00

sterling, mendocino country (made with organic grapes)


White & Blush Wine - Mildly Sweet, Light To Medium Intensity

21. Riesling

$6.25

sagelands, columbia valley

21. Riesling

$7.50

dr. loosen, germany


Red Wine - Full Bodied

50. Cabernet Sauvignon

$7.00

sonoma junction, sonoma country

50. Cabernet Sauvignon

$7.50

casa lapostolle, rapel valley, chile


Red Wine - Medium Bodied $6.50

60. Merlot

Price may varies

casa viva, chile

65. Pinot Noir

Price may varies

echelon, central coast


Today's CatchChoose Fried, Broiled, Blackened, Jamaican Jerk Or Grilled.

Mahi Mahi

$22.99

dolphin

Grouper

$2.00

add

Yellowtail Snapper

$2.00

add


Today's Catch DeluxeMahi Mahi (Dolphin) $24.99, Grouper Add $2 Or Yellowtail Snapper Add $2. Choose Your Fish And Preparation Style From Below:

Pan Sauteed

Price may varies

house specialty! dusted with flour, dipping in egg wash and sauteed with butter, lemon and sherry, our signature dish!

Black & Bleu

Price may varies

topped with crumbled bleu cheese, & baked. covered with a creamy bleu cheese sauce with a dash of cajun blackening seasoning, wine and garlic.

Matecumbe

Price may varies

house specialty! topped with fresh tomatoes, shallots, basil, capers, olive oil and lemon juice, then baked. the fish house's original creation, often copied, but never duplicated! featured on the fo

Hemingway

Price may varies

lightly breaded and baked, topped with a basil cream, wine and garlic sauce.

Baked Stuffed

$2.00

stuffed with our blue crabmeat stuffing, a standard favorite for years! add


More Fresh Fish

Whole Yellowtail Snapper

Price may varies

when available. choose fried or broiled. per pound

Trio Platter

$24.99

chef's selection of three different local fish on one platter, broiled

Trio Platter

$1.00

blackened or jamaican jerk add

Yellowfin Tuna

$22.99

seared, thinly sliced, served with wasabi, pickled ginger and soy sauce

Steak-Cut Fish

$22.99

broiled or grilled

Steak-Cut Fish

$1.00

jamaican jerk style add


Combination Platters

Broiled Combo

$27.99

"catch of the day," shrimp, scallops, and 1/2 florida lobster tail

Fried Combo

$23.99

"catch of the day," shrimp, scallops, oysters & clam strips

Shrimp & Scallops Scampi

$23.99

large shrimp and scallops in creamy garlic sauce, served over rice or pasta

Shrimp & Scallops Key Lime

$23.99

large shrimp and scallops, sauteed with lime juice, white wine, garlic, butter, mushrooms, scallions & hot sauce. served over rice.

Fried Shrimp & Baby Back Ribs

$20.99

succulent fried shrimp teamed with a 1/2 rack of ribs

Chicken Breast & Baby Back Ribs

$17.99

grilled chicken breast and 1/2 rack of ribs


Shrimp Lover's Corner

Baked Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp

$23.99

with crabmeat stuffing, topped with cheese

Baked Stuffed Large Shrimp

$21.99

with crabmeat stuffing, topped with cheese

Broiled Jumbo Shrimp Platter

$21.99

Jumbo Shrimp

$22.99

blackened or jamaican jerk style

Shrimp Scampi

$20.99

thirteen large shrimp in a creamy garlic sauce. server over rice or pasta

Coconut Jumbo Shrimp

$23.99

perfectly fried and served with our house mango poppy dipping sauce

Fried Shrimp

$17.99

Steamed Shrimp Dinner

$14.99 - $21.99

"peel & eat" with old bay seasoning


Crab & Shellfish Favorites

Crabcakes

$19.99

our own recipe made with lump crabmeat, fried and served with cocktail sauce

Soft Shell Crab

$21.99

fried or sauteed with lemon, white wine, garlic, butter and paprika

Dungeness Club

$23.99 - $32.99

sweet mild flavor, slightly nutty taste with firm leg meat

Snow Crab

$28.99 - $35.99

sweet delicate flavor, snowy white meat with a fibrous texture

Stone Crab Claws

Price may varies

1 1/2 lbs. (season october 15 - may 15) hot with drawn butter or cold with our homemade mustard sauce.

Fried Cracked Conch

$20.99

a caribbean classic. fried conch, served with cocktail sauce

Clam Strips

$14.99

perfectly fried clams, served with cocktail sauce

Fried Oysters

$22.99

fresh shucked & hand breaded

Sea Scallops

$23.99

broiled or fried succulent and sweet either way!

Florida Lobster

Price may varies

fresh in season - broiled.

Florida Lobster

$3.00

for baked stuffed or pan sauteed in lemon, butter and sherry add


From The Land

Chicken Breasts

$15.99

two chicken breasts, grilled, blackened or jamaican jerk style

Baby Back Ribs

$18.99

Filet Mignon

$27.99

grilled eight ounce usda center cut tenderloin

New York Strip

$26.99

grilled twelve ounce usda center cut


Pastas

Linguine

$14.99

with house marinara sauce

Linguine

$14.99

with garlic, butter & olive oil

Mussels Marinara

$18.99

Shrimp Marinara

$20.99

large shrimp with our homemade marinara sauce

Shrimp & Scallops Marinara

$23.99

large shrimp and scallops with our homemade marinara sauce


For The MinnowsChildren Under 12. Served Only To Children Under 12 Years Of Age. Children's Sandwiches Are Served With French Fries. Corn On The Cob, Rice, Coleslaw Or Applesauce May Be Substituted For French Fries.

"Catch Of The Day" Fish Sandwich

$9.99

fried, broiled, blackened or jamaican jerk style

Hamburger

$7.99

a full half pound of ground beef, grilled and served with lettuce & tomato

Hamburger

$1.00

add american cheese

Grilled Cheese

$5.99

served with french fries

Fried Fish Basket

$9.99

catch of the day, light fried served with tartar sauce and french fries

Fried Shrimp

$8.99

served with cocktail sauce, french fries and corn on the cob

Bay Back Ribs

$9.99

1/2 rack served with french fries and corn on the cob

Kraft Macaroni & Cheese

$5.99

served with french fries

Fried Chicken Fingers

$7.99

served with honey mustard sauce, french fries and corn on the cob

Pasta Marinara

$7.99

served with corn on the cob

Pasta With Garlic Butter

$7.99

served with corn on the cob


Red Wine - Medium Bodied

60. Merlot

$6.50

casa viva, chile

64. Pinot Noir

$7.50

acacia, california


Domestic $3.75

Budweiser

Price may varies

Bud Light

Price may varies

Coors Light

Price may varies

Michelob Ultra

Price may varies

Miller Lite

Price may varies

Yuengling Lager

Price may varies

O'doul's Non-Alcoholic

Price may varies


Imported $4.25

Amstel Light

Price may varies

Corona

Price may varies

Corona Light

Price may varies

Presidente

Price may varies

Negra Modelo

Price may varies

Heineken

Price may varies

Blue Moon Belgian

Price may varies

Wheat Ale

Price may varies

Stella Artois Lager

Price may varies


Micro Breweries $4.25

Key West Sunset Ale

Price may varies

Sam Adams Boston Lager

Price may varies

Harpoon India Pale Ale

Price may varies


Liberty Creek $5.50California

Chardonnay

Price may varies

White Zinfandel

Price may varies

Merlot

Price may varies


Barefoot Wines $5.50

California Pinot Grigio

Price may varies

Cabernet Sauvignon

Price may varies


Featured MartinisAsk Your Server For Your Favorite!

Apple Martini

$8.50

vodka, sour apple & a splash of lemon-lime soda

Spiegel Grove

$8.50

coconut rum, bacardi o, bacardi limon, a dash of blue curacao and a splash of sour mix. captain dana's signature drink!

Red Delicious

$9.00

our secret recipe!

Cosmopolitan

$9.00

ketel one citron, cointreau, cranberry juice & lime juice

Great White

$9.00

bailey's, captain morgan & kahlua

Ginger Pear

$9.00

ginger liqueur, pear vodka, fresh squeezed lemon & sour mix. joey's signature drink!


Frozen DrinksA Frozen Concoction To Help You Hang On!

Pina Colada

$6.50

Kahlua Colada

$6.50

Rum Runner

$6.50

Daquiris

$6.50

banana, mango, strawberry or watermelon

Creamsicle

$7.00

bacardi o, strawberry mix, pina colada, an orange slice and maraschino cherries blended together for a refreshing drink!


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading