Favorites Pizzeria Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 68 votes
Favorites Pizzeria Logo

Choose My State

NY

Favorites Pizzeria Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


SaladsAll salads are made fresh to order with crisp lettuce, fresh tomatoes and served with a roll and your choice of dressing: Italian, ranch, 1000 islands, french, blue cheese, f/f ranch, f/f italian, parmesan peppercorn, creamy caesar, creamy italian, rivier

Chef

$5.50 - $7.75

Black olives & mozzarella

Julienne

$7.75 - $9.75

Black olives, green olives, mushrooms, sweet peppers, turkey, ham & mozzarella

Tuna Julienne

$7.75 - $9.75

Black olives, green olives, mushrooms, sweet peppers, tuna & mozzarella

Grilled Chicken

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled chicken, black olives & mozzarella

BBQ Chicken

$7.75 - $9.75

BBQ chicken, black olives & mozzarella

Greek Chicken

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled chicken, black olives, green peppers & feta cheese

Italian Tossed

$7.75 - $9.75

Black olives, green olives, sweet peppers, roasted peppers, pepperoni & mozzarella tossed in italian dressing

Summer Salad

$7.75 - $9.75

Mixed greens w/ crumbled blue, shredded carrot, mandarin oranges, dried cranberries, glazed nuts & char grilled chicken

Grilled Steak

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled rib eye, black olives & mozzarella

Taco

$7.75 - $9.75

Seasoned beef, cheddar cheese, black olives, tortilla chips, salsa & sour cream

Fiesta Chicken

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, black olives, tortilla chips, salsa & sour cream

Chicken Finger

$7.75 - $9.75

Chicken fingers, black olives & mozzarella

Bacon

$7.75 - $9.75

Crisp bacon, black olives & mozzarella

Santa Fe Steak

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled rib eye, cheddar cheese, black olives, roasted peppers & red onion

Asian Chicken

$7.75 - $9.75

Mixed asian greens w/ shredded carrot, sliced cucumber, mandarin oranges, dried cranberries, glazed nuts & crisp honey garlic chicken

Antipasto

$7.75 - $11.75

Black olives, green olives, sweet peppers, hot peppers, roasted peppers, pepperoni, salami, cappicola & sliced cheese

Open Chicken Souvlaki

$9.75

Grilled souvlaki chicken on a bed of crisp lettuce, fresh tomatoes, sliced onions & feta cheese served with a grilled pita & side of greek dressing. Extras: meat $2.00, cheese $1.00, dressing $0.75


Jumbo Chicken WingsAll wings & fingers are served w/ blue, celery & your choice of sauce: mild, medium, hot, extra hot, BBQ, honey BBQ, honey mustard, honey garlic, butter garlic, oriental seseme, caribbean jerk & teriyaki extra blue cheese $.75, extra celery $.

Jumbo Chicken Wings

$8.75 - $32.75


Chicken Fingers

Chicken Fingers

$8.75 - $29.75

Baked Chicken Fingers

$7.25 - $13.75


Boneless Buffalo WingsServed w/ blue cheese, celery & your choice of sauce

Boneless Buffalo Wings

$8.75 - $31.75


Wraps & PitasServed with your choice of chips & pickle or chips & pickle

Wraps & Pitas

$7.75

Taco

Grilled Chicken

$7.75

Tuna

$7.75

Steak

$7.75

Chicken Finger

$7.75

Veggie

$7.75

Assorted

$7.75

Greek Chicken

$7.75

Turkey

$7.75


Men Menu

Cheeseburger

$8.25

With Fries

Gyro Sandwich

$8.25

Served on a grilled pita w/ sliced tomato, onions, tzatziki sauce & your choice of fries or chips & pickle

Quesadillas

$6.25

Served w/ salsa & sour cream. Add grilled chicken or steak for $2.00


Subs & HoagiesServed on a toasted roll with your choice of cheese. Specify : lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, mayo or dressing

Ham

$7.25 - $9.25

Turkey

$7.25 - $9.25

Steak

$7.25 - $9.25

Sausage

$7.25 - $9.25

Assorted

$7.25 - $9.25

Pizza

$7.25 - $9.25

Chicken Finger

$7.25 - $9.25

Grilled Chicken

$7.25 - $9.25

Cappicola

$7.25 - $9.25

BLT

$7.25 - $9.25

Cheese Burger

$7.25 - $9.25

Roast Beef

$7.25 - $9.25

Tuna

$7.25 - $9.25

Salami

$7.25 - $9.25

Cheese Veggie

$7.25 - $9.25

Pepper & Egg

$7.25 - $9.25

Western Omelette

$7.25 - $9.25


Oven Fresh PizzaFavorite's: our classic pizza dough topped w/ tomato sauce, romano, mozzarella & your choice of toppings. New york style: hand tossed thin crust pizza baked on the stone oven w/ corn meal. Old fashioned: traditional pizza dough topped w/ tomato sauce,

Cheese Pizza

$10.25 - $12.25

Items 14" pie $1.25, 16" Pie $1.50


Deep Dish Pan PizzaFresh pizza dough topped w/ tomato sauce, romano, mozzarella, your choice of toppings & baked in a deep dish pan

Cheese Pizza

$10.25 - $13.00

Items: 12" pie $1.25, 14" pie $1.50, 16" pie $1.75


Calzones

Cheese Pizza

$13.50

Fresh pizza dough stuffed with mozzarella, romano & ricotta cheese then baked to a golden crisp. Additional Items $1.75


Strombolis

Cheese Pizza

$14.50

Fresh pizza dough seasoned with a blend of olive oil, garlic, romano cheese, loaded with mozzarella all rolled up and baked to perfection. Additional items $2.25

Topping Selection

Price may varies

Toppings include:Pepperoni, mushrooms, black olives, green olives, hot cherry peppers, mild banana peppers, roasted red peppers, fresh green peppers, jalapeno peppers, white onions, red onions, sausa


Favorite's Specialty Pizza

Steak & Cheese Deluxe

Price may varies

White pizza w/ rib eye steak, lettuce, tomato & onion

Steak Hoagie

Price may varies

White pizza loaded w/ steak & sauteed mushrooms & onion

Sicilian

Price may varies

Lite sauce, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, sweet pepper & hot pepper

Veggie

$15.25 - $34.00

White pizza w/ tomato, broccoli, black olives, sweet peppers & mushroom

Chicken Finger

Price may varies

White or red pizza w/ chicken fingers & your choice of sauce

Healthy Lite

Price may varies

White pizza w/ Romano cheese & choice of 3 veggie toppings

BBQ Chicken

Price may varies

White pizza w/ grilled chicken smothered in BBQ sauce

Meat Lovers

Price may varies

Red pizza loaded w/ pepperoni, sausage & meatballs

Cheese Lovers

Price may varies

White pizza w/ mozzarella, cheddar, romano, feta & swiss american

Greek Lovers

$13.25 - $30.00

White pizza w/ spinach, black olives & feta cheese

Hawaiian

Price may varies

White or red pizza loaded w/ ham & pineapple

Broccoli & Cheddar

Price may varies

White pizza loaded w/ broccoli & cheddar cheese

Tomato Ricotta

Price may varies

White pizza w/ sliced tomatoes, ricotta cheese & mozzarella

Spinach Ricotta

$12.50 - $27.00

White pizza covered w/ spinach, ricotta cheese & mozzarella

Philly Steak

Price may varies

White pizza w/ rib eye steak, sauteed mushrooms, onions & green peppers

Chicken Ranchero

Price may varies

White pizza smothered w/ grilled chicken & 3 cheese ranch sauce

Supreme

Price may varies

pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, sausage, green peppers & black olives

Honey Garlic Chicken & Bacon

Price may varies

W/ sesame seeds & scallions

The Works

$16.25 - $36.00

Pepperoni, mushrooms, sweet peppers, hot peppers, onions & black olives


Favorite's Specialty SubsExtras: Meat $1.50 $2.50, cheese $0.75, eggs $1.00, blue cheese $0.75

The Original Hoagie

$7.75 - $9.75

Rib eye steak, melted cheese w/ sauteed mushrooms & onions

The Royal

$7.75 - $9.75

Italian sausage & cappicola, grilled & covered w/ melted cheese

The Captain

$7.75 - $9.75

Rib eye steak & cappicola, grilled & covered w/ melted cheese

Steak in the Grass

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled rib eye w/ sauteed spinach

Sausage Supreme

$7.75 - $9.75

Sausage w/ grilled peppers & onions

Chicken Hoagie

$7.75 - $9.75

Souvlaki chicken w/ grilled onions & covered w/ melted cheese

Meatball Parmesan

$7.75 - $9.75

Meatballs in our homemade tomato sauce & baked w/ mozzarella

Eggplant Parmesan

$7.75 - $9.75

Breaded eggplant cutlets in tomato sauce & baked w/ mozzarella

Chicken Parmesan

$7.75 - $9.75

Breaded chicken covered in Sauce & baked w/ mozzarella

Veal Parmesan

$7.75 - $9.75

Breaded veal cutlets covered in sauce & baked w/ mozzarella

Chicken Souvlaki

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled souvlaki chicken w/ feta cheese & Greek dressing

The South-side Hoagie

$7.75 - $9.75

Chopped sirloin w/ grilled onions & covered w/ melted cheese

The Italiano

$7.75 - $9.75

Assorted baked w/ red roasted peppers & provolone cheese

The Turkey Deluxe

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled turkey, bacon, red roasted peppers, melted mozzarella & special sauce

The Lancer

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled rib eye w/ melted cheese, crisp bacon & sweet vidalia dressing

The Lake Road

$7.75 - $9.75

Italian sausage, cappicola, grilled onions, banana peppers & mozzarella cheese

The Oriental Express

$7.75 - $9.75

Crisp honey garlic chicken w/ cucumbers, asian slaw & oriental sesame dressing

The Julius Caesar

$7.75 - $9.75

Marinated grilled chicken tossed w/ caesar dressing served on a garlic roll

The Heater

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled fajita chicken w/ hot sauce, hot peppers & melted cheese

The Super Steak

$7.75 - $9.75

Chopped sirloin grilled w/ onions, hot peppers, mushrooms & melted cheese

The Philly

$7.75 - $9.75

Your choice of chopped steak or chicken w/ green peppers, onions & melted cheese

Steak & Egg

$7.75 - $9.75

Grilled rib eye & fried eggs

The Cordon Bleu

$7.75 - $9.75

Fried chicken w/ grilled ham & swiss

Chicken Club

$7.75 - $9.75

Choice of grilled or crispy chicken w/ bacon & melted cheese

The Gambler

$7.75 - $9.75

Chopped sirloin grilled w/ cappicola, onions, hot peppers & melted cheese

BBQ Chicken Ranchero

$7.75 - $9.75

BBQ chicken, bacon, melted cheese & ranchero sauce

The Western BBQ

$8.75 - $10.75

Bacon cheeseburger topped w/cheddar cheese, onion rings & BBQ sauce

The Pittsburgher

$8.75 - $10.75

Cheeseburger w/ sauteed onions, french fries. Cheddar cheese & riviera dressing

Jimmy The Greek

$8.75 - $10.75

Chopped sirloin & gyro meat w/ grilled onions, tomato, feta & tzatziki sauce

The C.B. Triple

$8.75 - $10.75

Steak, sausage & cappicola grilled w/ onions, sweet peppers & mushrooms

The Dagwood

$8.75 - $10.75

Roast beef, turkey breast, ham, bacon & swiss cheese. Baked w/ sweet onion sauce

The Combo

$8.75 - $10.75

Chopped sirloin & sausage w/ grilled onions, peppers & melted cheese

The Stinger

$8.75 - $10.75

Grilled rib eye w/ chicken fingers & your choice of sauce

The Purple Eagle

$8.75 - $10.75

Chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, onion rings & french fries w/ crisp bacon

The Big Favorito

$8.75 - $10.75

Only for big appetites

The Grinder

$8.75 - $10.75

Grilled onions, mushrooms, red peppers & spinach w/ chicken or steak & melted cheese


Dinners

Chicken Wing Dinner

$9.75

8 Jumbo wings served with celery, blue cheese, fries & a side salad

Pasta Dinner

$9.75

Your choice of spaghetti gnocchi ravioli or penne served with homemade sauce

Pasta Dinner w/ meatball

$10.75

Fish Dinner

$9.75

Beer battered, breaded, or baked haddock served w/ cole slaw & fries

Shrimp Dinner

$8.75

8 Fried shrimp served with a side salad & fries

Chicken, Veal or Eggplant Parmesan Dinner

$12.75

Breaded cutlets baked w/ sauce & cheese. Served with garlic bread & your choice of pasta

Roast Beef on Weck

$8.75

A heaping portion of roast beef served on a fresh weck roll w/ fries & horseradish


Daily Specials

Party Tray

$52.00

W/ 1 item & 50 wings

½ Tray or Lg Pie

$28.00

W/ 1 item & 20 wings

Party Tray

$42.00

W/ 1 item & 30 wings

1/2 Tray

$42.00

W/ 1 item & 50 wings

Party Tray

$45.00

W/ 1 item & 20 fingers

½ Tray or Lg Pie

$25.00

W/ 10 fingers

Small Pie

$18.00

W/ 1 item & 10 wings


Snacks & Sides

French Fries

$3.25

Garlic Bread

$4.00

Garlic Bread

$5.50

W/ cheese

Cheesy Spinach Bread

$6.00

Battered Mushrooms

$5.00

Onion Rings

$5.00

Mozzarella Sticks

$5.00

Deep Fried Cauliflower

$5.00

Jalapeno Poppers

$5.00

Pizza Rolls

$5.50


Desserts

Fried Dough

$4.75

Golden fried dough tossed in powdered sugar

Fried Cheesecake

$4.75

Smooth & creamy cheesecake wrapped in a crispy shell w/ berry sauce

Funnel Fries

$4.75

Tasty & delicious funnel cakes served with powdered sugar


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading