Fatty's Cafe Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 60 votes
Fatty's Cafe Logo
Cocktails
Coffee
Latin American

Choose My State

NY

Fatty's Cafe Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Goodies

Bowl Of Black Beans

$8.00

sour cream, scallions, tortilla chips, and queso blanco

3 Moon Empanadas

$10.00

beef, cheese, or chorizo

Grilled Shrimp

$12.00

served with choice of dipping sauce

Guacamole

$10.00

the best in town

House Music Salad

$9.00

fresh house salad with house dressing.

House Music Salad

$4.00

add tofu

House Music Salad

$5.00

add chicken

House Music Salad

$6.00

add steak or shrimp


Entrees

16oz Grass Fed Ribeye

$25.00

grilled grass fed, all natural ribeye, served with garlic mash, sauteed mushrooms and onions

Steak Frittes

$17.00

black angus skirt steak topped with shallots and a pat of parsley butter, and of course the frites fries!

Contraband Chicken

$17.00

a true fatty's original! chicken breast stuffed w/ cheddar cheese, pico de gallo and diced habanero pepper, wrapped in bacon and grilled w/ bbq sauce hiding under monterrey cheese, mole sauce served

Marinated Grilled Vegetables

$14.00

served with hummus and pita bread, dusted with parmesan.

Marinated Grilled Vegetables

$4.00

add tofu

Marinated Grilled Vegetables

$5.00

add chicken

Marinated Grilled Vegetables

$6.00

add steak or shrimp

Fatty's Mole Burrito

Price may varies

a big fat tortilla stuffed with rice, black beans, peppers, onions, cheese

Fatty's Mole Burrito

$11.00

veg

Fatty's Mole Burrito

$14.00

chicken

Fatty's Mole Burrito

$15.00

grilled steak or shrimp

Wasabi Salmon

$15.00

grilled salmon filet served in a citrus wasabi caper sauce accompanied by grilled marinated zucchini

300 Meal - Eat Like A Champion, Feel Like A Champion

Price may varies

your choice of protein grilled and served w/zucchini and squash, hass avocado and chimmichuri sauce.

300 Meal - Eat Like A Champion, Feel Like A Champion

$16.00

chicken

300 Meal - Eat Like A Champion, Feel Like A Champion

$17.00

skirt steak or salmon

300 Meal - Eat Like A Champion, Feel Like A Champion

$25.00

ribeye


Burgers And Pressed Sandwiches

The B.F.B.

$12.00

black angus burger, tomatoes, onions and fatty’s special sauce on roll. also available "yard style": jerk spices, cheddar, anejo rum ketchup for an extra buck fitty!

Charity Burger

$15.00

angus burger with avocado, sprouts, garlic aioli, anejo rum ketchup, choice of cheese, mixed greens.

Charity Burger

$2.00

this burger is good for your karma as goes toward a smile on someone’s face somewhere in the world. ask your server for details. thank you!

Chorizo Burger

$14.00

ground chorizo and ground pork seasoned with cayenne, paprika, and garlic topped with a poblano pepper mayo lettuce and tomato, served with sweet potato fries

Jalapeno Turkey Burger

$13.00

sautéed onions and peppers, chipotle mayo, mixed greens

Chavorrayo

$13.00

chicken, avocado, monterrey jack, garlic-aioli, mixed greens

Cubano

$11.00

roasted pork, black forest ham, swiss, pickles, chipotle-mayo, mixed greens

Grilled Cheese Of The Day

$10.00

changes. daily!


Sides

Tostones

$4.00

maduros

French Fries

$4.00

Rice & Beans

$4.00

Sauteed Garlic Spinich

$4.00

Sweet Potato Fries

$4.00

Grilled Asparagus

$5.00

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

$4.00

w/ sour cream and red onion

Tostones Or Maduros

$3.00

Mr Fantasy

$5.00

fresh fuit, yogurt, granola

Rice & Beans

$3.00

Sausage

$3.00

bacon/ham

French Fries

$3.00

Toast

$2.00

english muffin/tortillas


Brunch $17

Two Egg Hook Up

Price may varies

any style with home fries

Polenta Cakes

Price may varies

topped with provolone

Big Fat Pancake Stack

Price may varies

stack of three fluffy pancakes served with a medley of fruit

Breakfast Burrito

Price may varies

scrambled egg, ham, cheese, peppers, and onions stuffed in a flour tortilla

Make Your Own Omelette

Price may varies

two eggs, stuffed with choice of four: onion, mushroom, green pepper, red pepper, spinach, scallion. served with home fries

Huevos Rancheros

Price may varies

2 tortillas, 2 fried eggs, cheese and ranchero sauce

La Pistola

Price may varies

two fried eggs on a bed of rice and beans, served with tortillas

Mofongo

Price may varies

caribbean-style mashed plantains with onion and pancetta, stuffed with choice of shrimp, ground beef, or queso blanco. served with mesclun greens

Dominican Sunrise

Price may varies

2 fried eggs, served with fried dominican queso blanco, salchichon, tostones, and sautéed red onions

Cubano

Price may varies

pressed sandwich of roasted pork, ham, swiss and chipotle mayo. served with mesclun greens and choice of french fries or home fries

The Fatty

Price may varies

egg, sausage, and choice of cheese on an english muffin. served with mesclun greens and choice of french fries or home fries

Ensalada Especial

Price may varies

fatty’s special salad, choice of chicken, steak, shrimp, portobello, or avocado. served with toast or english muffin

Fat’s Hungryman Special

Price may varies

steak & eggs, served with home fries

Brunch Burger

Price may varies

black angus burger served with french fries and mesclun greens


Cocktails

Mojito

$11.00

it's what we're known for. white rum, fresh lime juice and home-grown mint, sugar, muddled to perfection. come and try it! (available in a variety of flavors)

The Fat Guy Margarita

$11.00

our signature marg. 100% agave tequila, fresh squeezed lime juice, triple sec, agave nectar. ask for flavors, sodium or non-sodium

The Personal Sangria

$11.00

a delicious and refreshing sangria with fresh fruit, brandy and wine made per person, to order, red or white.

7 Mile Beach

$11.00

the islands in a glass! dark rum, coconut rum, creme de cacao, amaretto, pineapple and mango juice with a float of banana liqueur.

3 Mile Beach

$10.00

a slightly tamer version of it's big brother. dark rum, pineapple and mango juices

Skinny Jeans

$10.00

organic vodka, fresh blueberry syrup, soda and a blueberry picho

Hipster Apokyalpse

$12.00

our version of a zombie! 3 different rums, pernod, almond liquer, grenadine, pineapple, lime, guava.

Rum Punch

$11.00

exactly what it says! seasonally rotational.

Idle Awhile

$11.00

farmers gin, fresh ginger syrup, cucmber and pepper puree, soda, lemon juice.

Fruit Pinchos!

$5.00

fooze! rotating selection of delicious fresh fruit soaked in a variety of different liquers.

Beer

Price may varies

a seasonally rotating selection of great craft brews (draft and bottled) from local and international sources


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading