Elm Street Restaurant & Tavern Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 82 votes
Elm Street Restaurant & Tavern Logo

Choose My State

CO

Elm Street Restaurant & Tavern Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Oysters on the Half Shell - Half Dozen

$9.95

Oysters on the Half Shell - Full Dozen

$18.85

Shrimp Cocktail

$10.25

Six gulf shrimp chilled and served with a spicy cocktail sauce

Florida Crab Cakes

$8.25

A blend of crab meat and herb seasoned breading served with a creamy garlic sauce

Crab Stuffed Mushrooms

$8.65

Choice mushroom caps filled with a blend of crab meat baked in a creamy garlic sauce

Pan Blackened Prime Bites

$11.25

Tender pieces of beef pan blackened with cajun spices and served with au jus sauce

Beer Battered Chicken Strips

$8.25

Hand battered chicken strips fried and served with a southwest ranch dip

Nachos Fiesta

$7.65

White tortilla chips smothered with cheese, beans, tomatoes, black olives and peppers then topped with sour cream. Chicken add $3.00, steak add $4.00


Soups and Salads

Clam Chowder

$6.25

Chef's Soup of the Day

$5.95

Tavern Dinner Salad

$6.25

Fresh greens topped with cherry tomatoes, sweet red onions, pepperoncini and provolone cheese

Spinach Steak Salad

$11.65

Fresh spinach topped with sweet red onions, cranberries, bacon bits, almonds, feta cheese, and seared steak strips tossed in a balsamic herb vinaigrette

Caesar Salad

$7.35

Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with our caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and herb roasted dressing

Caesar Salad - Chicken or Steak

$10.85

Caesar Salad - Shrimp

$12.25

Southwest Salad - Chicken or Steak

$11.25

Served with lettuce, beans, tomatoes, olives, tomato basil tortilla strips and cheddar cheese with a jalapeno ranch dressing

Southwest Salad - Shrimp

$12.65

Served with lettuce, beans, tomatoes, olives, tomato basil tortilla strips and cheddar cheese with a jalapeno ranch dressing

Citrus Salmon Salad

$11.65

Mixed greens topped with tomatoes, mandarin oranges, sweet red onions and roasted almonds with a balsamic herb vinaigrette dressing


Lighter Fare

Tavern Burger

$8.85

A great 8 oz. burger served with lettuce, tomato, and onion with or without choice of cheese

Bourbon Street Burger

$8.95

Grilled burger with our bourbon sauce and sweet red onions

Black and Blue Mushroom Burger

$9.25

An original burger topped with fresh mushrooms and blue cheese crumbles

Cactus Burger

$9.35

A grilled burger topped with onions, green chili and provolone cheese

OB's Favorite Prime Rib Sandwich

$11.65

Thinly sliced layers of prime rib and provolone cheese served in our Kaiser bun that is lightly dusted with coarse salt

Mesa Verde Chicken Sandwich

$8.25

Pan blackened chicken topped with green chili, provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato served in a bun

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

$8.65

A seasoned chicken breast with marinara sauce, provolone and parmesan cheese served on a hoagie roll


Taste of the Southwest

Quesadilla

$8.25

Filled with cheese, topped with green chili, jalapenos peppers and fresh peppers with a garlic sauce

Steak or Chicken Quesadilla

$11.65

Fajitas

$9.85

Marinated onions and fresh peppers on a sizzling skillet served with wild rice, beans, warm tortillas and all the fixings

Steak or Chicken Fajitas

$11.85

Stacked Chicken Enchiladas Verdes

$9.65

Two layers of corn tortillas with chicken, pinto beans, lettuce and cheese then topped with green chili sauce and cheese with wild rice and beans

Crab and Shrimp Chimichanga

$13.65

A blend of crab meat, baby shrimp, green chilis, jalapenos and provolone cheese with a creamy garlic sauce deep fried in a tomato basil tortilla served with wild rice and beans

Boardertown Burrito

$8.85

Stuffed with ground beef, lettuce, onions, cheddar cheese, tomato bits and our Cabo sauce


Pasta Dinners

Chicken Fettuccini

$13.25

Grilled chicken and sauteed mushrooms served over fettuccini noodles with alfredo sauce

Crab and Shrimp Linguini

$16.25

A blend of crab meat and three gulf shrimp on a bed of linguini with tomato bits and a creamy garlic sauce

Salmon and Artichoke Linguini

$15.65

Herb marinated salmon, artichoke hearts and sun-dried tomatoes served over linguini with a creamy dill sauce

Shrimp and Bay Scallops

$16.25

Shrimp and bay scallops sauteed in white wine, olive oil and herbs served over linguini with a tomato basil sauce and feta cheese

Pasta Primavera

$11.85

Fresh garden vegetables served over fettucini noodles with a tomato basil marinara sauce


Seafood PlattersOur platters are served with cole slaw and a choice of french fries, pinto beans or wild rice. Add $1.50 for a baked potato

Fish and Chips

$12.65

Two alaskan white fish beer battered and fried to a golden brown served with tartar sauce

Crab Cake and Shrimp Platter

$15.85

Two southern crab crakes and four grilled shrimp served with a cocktail sauce

Fantail Shrimp Platter

$14.65

Six hand-battered gulf shrimp lightly fried to a golden brown and served with a cocktail sauce

Seafood Saute Platter

$15.35

Atlantic salmon filet, three bay scallops and three Gulf shrimp served over a bed of wild rice with a creamy dill sauce

Combination Jumbo Platter

$15.65

Three fantail shrimp, a crab cake and a beer-battered alaskan white fish served with a cocktail sauce


Dinners

Chicken and Crab Meat

$16.85

A seasoned chicken breast topped with fresh spinach and a blend of crab meat then topped with a creamy garlic sauce

Baja Chicken

$15.85

Pan blackened chicken and gulf shrimp topped with green chilies and fresh peppers finished with our cabo sauce

Captain's Boat

$18.85

A medley of shrimp, scallops, crab meat and fresh fish baked in a creamy dill sauce with an herb parmesan bread crust

Shrimp and Scallops au Gratin

$18.25

Sauteed in white wine and garlic served on a bed of spinach with a creamy garlic sauce and topped with a parmesan herb crust

Cajun Catfish

$15.65

A catfish filet pan blackened served with a red pepper hollandaise sauce giving this dish a nice taste of the south

French Cut Pork Chop

$21.65

French cut choice center tenderloin grilled and served with our bourbon sauce and sauteed sweet red onions

Sirloin Steak

$15.85

Select 10 oz choice center cut sirloin grilled just the way you want it


Surf-n-Turf

Prime Rib and Shrimp Surf-n-Turf

$23.50

Choice cut 6 oz prime rib and four grilled shrimp

Prime Rib and Crab Leg Surf-n-Turf

Price may varies

Choice cut 6 oz prime rib with a half pound of king crab legs


Tavern Specialties

Crab Stuffed Shrimp

$17.95

Our bay shrimp stuffed with crab meat are topped with parmesan cheese then baked and served over our creamy garlic sauce

Crab Stuffed Prime Rib

$22.85

An herb seasoned prime rib wrapped around a blend of crab meat and finished with a creamy garlic sauce

Prime Rib - 8 oz Cut

$19.65

Slowly roasted cut of choice prime rib in our special blend of seasonings

Prime Rib - 12 oz Cut

$24.00

Slowly roasted cut of choice prime rib in our special blend of seasonings

Prime Rib - Full Pound

$32.00

Slowly roasted cut of choice prime rib in our special blend of seasonings

King Crab Legs

Price may varies

Serving a half pound or full pound


Side Orders

Cole Slaw

$2.00

Tavern Salad

$4.50

Warm Loaf of Bread

$2.00

Pinto Beans

$2.00

Wild Rice

$2.00

Baked Potato

$2.75

Onion Rings

$3.25

French Fries

$2.00


Children's Menu

Burger

$4.75

Chicken Fingers

$4.25

Three Golden Fried Shrimp

$5.65

Linguini Marinara or Alfredo sauce

$3.85

Cheese Quesadilla

$3.85

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$4.00

Corn Dog

$3.95


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading