Menu With Price > Menu > Dessert First Bakery Cafe

Dessert First Bakery Cafe Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 95 votes
Dessert First Bakery Cafe Logo
Coffee
Desserts
Bakery & Pastries

Choose My State

WI

Dessert First Bakery Cafe Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Everyday

Vanilla Sparkle

Price may varies

Vanilla cake topped with vanilla buttercream

Chocolate Indulgence

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream

Red Velvet

Price may varies

Rich red cake made special with secret df flavoring, topped with cream cheese frosting

Vanilla Raspberry

Price may varies

Vanilla cake topped with raspberry buttercream

Chocolate Flavors

Chocolate Vanilla

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with vanilla buttercream

Chocolate Raspberry

Price may varies

Chocolate cake with raspberry buttercream

Chocolate Cherry

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with cherry buttercream

Chocolate Mint

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with chocolate mint buttercream

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with peanut butter buttercream

Mocha

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with chocolate mocha buttercream

Chocolate Elvis

Price may varies

Chocolate banana cake topped with peanut butter buttercream & a banana chip

Salted Chocolate Caramel

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with salty caramel buttercream & drizzled with more caramel and dusted with sea salt

Dirt Cake

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with vanilla buttercream, rolled in oreo crumbs with gummy worms coming out

S’mores

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with marshmallow buttercream & dusted with graham cracker crumbs

Mexican Hot Chocolate

Price may varies

Chocolate cake with a cayenne kick topped with chocolate cinnamon buttercream

Cookies n’ Cream

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with Oreo cookie buttercream

Lemonade and Fruit Flavors

Peaches ‘n Cream

Price may varies

Peach cake topped with cream cheese frosting

Strawberries ‘n Cream

Price may varies

Strawberry cake topped with cream cheese frosting

Summer Lemon

Price may varies

Lemon cake topped with lemon buttercream

Lemon Tea with Honey

Price may varies

Lemon tea cake topped with honey infused buttercream

Vanilla Raspberry

Price may varies

Vanilla cake with raspberry buttercream

Lemon Raspberry

Price may varies

Lemon cake topped with raspberry buttercream

Lemon Drop

Price may varies

Light lemon cake topped with lemon candy cream cheese buttercream

Pink Lemonade

Price may varies

Lemon cake topped with pink grapefruit buttercream

Strawberry Lemonade

Price may varies

Lemon cake with strawberry buttercream

Peach Lemonade

Price may varies

Lemon cake with peach buttercream

Blueberry Lemonade

Price may varies

Lemon cake with blueberry buttercream

Mango Lemonade

Price may varies

Lemon cake with mango buttercream

Sour Watermelon

Price may varies

Watermelon cake topped with sour watermelon buttercream

Sour Grape

Price may varies

Grape cake topped with sour grape buttercream

Sour Apple

Price may varies

Apple cake topped with sour apple buttercream

Dreamsicle

Price may varies

Orange cake topped with orange buttercream & sugar sprinkles

Electric Blue Raspberry

Price may varies

Vanilla cake topped with blue raspberry frosting.

Pie & Cheesecake Flavors

Apple Pie

Price may varies

Apple cinnamon cake topped with vanilla buttercream and struesel topping

Key Lime Pie

Price may varies

Key lime cake topped with vanilla buttercream & dusted with graham cracker crumbs

Banana Cream Pie

Price may varies

Banana cream cake topped with vanilla buttercream & dusted with graham cracker crumbs

Black Forest

Price may varies

Chocolate cake infused with cherry & topped with vanilla buttercream & chocolate shavings

Peach Cobbler

Price may varies

Peach cake topped with vanilla buttercream and streusel topping

Chocolate Cheesecake

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with cream cheese frosting

Blueberry Cheesecake

Price may varies

Blueberry cake topped with blueberry cream cheese frosting

Strawberry (Raspberry) Cheesecake

Price may varies

Cheesecake cake topped with strawberry or raspberry buttercream

Chocolate Banana Cheesecake

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with banana cream cheese frosting

Coconut & Other Speciality Flavors

Coconut Snow

Price may varies

Vanilla cake topped with coconut buttercream and shredded coconut

Almond Joyful

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with coconut buttercream, shredded coconut and almonds

Lemon Coconut

Price may varies

Lemon cake topped with coconut buttercream & rolled in coconut

Malibu Pineapple

Price may varies

Pineapple-lemon cake topped with coconut buttercream and shredded coconut

Guinness

Price may varies

Chocolate guinness cake topped with guinness buttercream

Amaretto Sour

Price may varies

Amaretto-lemon cake topped with amaretto buttercream

Cranberry Spice

Price may varies

Cranberry cake with a hint of cinnamon & nutmet topped with cinnamon & nutmeg buttercream & dusted with nutmeg

Pumpkin

Price may varies

Rich, spiced pumpkin cake topped with cream cheese frosting and sprinkled with nutmeg

Carrot

Price may varies

Carrot cake topped with cream cheese frsoting.

Egg Nog

Price may varies

Egg Nog cake topped with egg nog buttercream & dusted with nutmeg

Chocolate Candycane

Price may varies

Chocolate cake topped with candycane buttercream and sprinkled with more candycanes.

Maple Piggy

Price may varies

Vanilla cake with bacon drizzled with maple buttercream

Malted Milk Ball

Price may varies

Malted vanilla cake, topped with malted chocolate frosting and a Whopper!

Red Hot Cinnamon

Price may varies

Vanilla cake spiced with cinnamon and cayenne pepper, topped with red hot candy buttercream

Pralines & Cream

Price may varies

Praline cake topped with praline buttercream and chopped pecans

White Tuxedo

Price may varies

Vanilla cake with chocolate buttercream

Black Tuxedo

Price may varies

Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream

Root Beer Float

Price may varies

Root beer cake with root beer buttercream.

Elite FlavorsAdd't charge will apply

Secret Admirer

Price may varies

Chocolate cake filled with a chocolate chip cream cheese mixture topped with a dollop cream cheese frosting & chocolate chunks

Turtle Turtle

Price may varies

Chocolate cake filled with caramel, topped with caramel buttercream, ground pecans and a drizzle of caramel

Samoa

Price may varies

Vanilla cake filled with caramel topped with chocolate caramel buttercream, rolled in toasted coconut & drizzled with chocolate syrup

Gooberlicious

Price may varies

Vanilla cake filled with grape jelly topped with peanut butter buttercream & a dollop of more grape jelly

Butterscotch Rum-yum

Price may varies

Butter rum cake filled with butterscotch topped with butter rum buttercream & drizzled with butterscotch

Caramel Apple

Price may varies

Apple cake filled with caramel topped with caramel buttercream & drizzled with more gooey caramel

Psychedelic Swirl

Price may varies

Multi-colored vanilla cake topped with a swirl of red, yellow and blue cherry cotton candy flavored buttercream

Snickerdoodle

Price may varies

Vanilla cinnamon cake baked with snickerdoodle cookie topped with cinnamon buttercream

Chocolate Cookie Monster

Price may varies

Chocolate cake baked with chocolate toffee crunch cookie ball topped with chocolate toffee buttercream

CupcakesThe prices below are for any of the flavors available during the week. This includes our 4 everyday flavors and our special weekly flavors. If you want a flavor outside of weekly ones there is a minimum order of a dozen and an add't charge.

Cupcakes

$2.25 - $25.00

Cakes

Cakes

$2.25

Mini CupcakesAdditional charges apply for special decorations, ordering below the minimum and special order flavors.

Mini Cupcakes

$10.00

Colossal CupcakesAdditional charges apply for special decorations, ordering below the minimum and special order flavors.

Colossal Cupcakes

$4.25

Mini CheesecakesAvailable with a variety of toppings. Cherry, strawberry, blueberry, raspberry, turtle, chocolate, caramel, etc.

Mini Cheesecakes

$1.75 - $20.00

CookiesPlease inquire about flavors before ordering. Smaller cookie sizes available upon request.

Chocolate Chunk

$1.25

M&M

$1.25

Chocolate Toffee Crunch

$1.25

Oatmeal Chocolate Chunk

$1.25

Peanut Butter

$1.25

Snickerdoodle

$1.25

Chocolate Mint

$1.25

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands