Cutie Pies Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 126 votes
Cutie Pies Logo
Desserts
Bakery & Pastries

Choose My State

NY

Cutie Pies Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Cakes $30

Chiffon Cake

Price may varies

soft, moist, and with a delicate crumb, our chiffon cake a lovely way to end a meal sweetly. light enough as a final course, yet satisfyingly substantial, this dessert is perfect on its own with a cu

Coffee Cakes

Price may varies

designed to complement your favorite cup of joe or tea our coffee cakes and crumb cakes range from simple to especially delish.


Holiday Favorites

Personal Pie Sampler

$20.00

a great way to try more than one flavor, in one nifty step. choose four (3") personal pies and sample away!

Canadian Maple Butter Tart

$35.00

je me souviens! long after your lips caress the last crumb, the super-flaky lard crust and unforgettable, silky filling of our award-winning butter tart will keep your thoughts sweet. in case you're

Coffee Cakes

$30.00

designed to complement your favorite cup of joe or tea our coffee cakes and crumb cakes range from simple to especially delish.

Chiffon Cake

$30.00

soft, moist, and with a delicate crumb, our chiffon cake a lovely way to end a meal sweetly. light enough as a final course, yet satisfyingly substantial, this dessert is perfect on its own with a cu

Cream Pies

$35.00

from award-winning coconut cream to the instantly popular guinness-bailey's irish cream flavor, our dairy-rich delights pies are as impressive to look at as they are to eat: piled high with luscious

Bourbon Pecan Pie

$35.00

heaven in every bite! our unsurpassed pecan pie has an inviting, golden filling swirled with fragrant pecans and fragrant with bourbon, all cradled into our signature flaky butter crust. second helpi


Pies $35

Cream Pies

Price may varies

from award-winning coconut cream to the instantly popular guinness-bailey's irish cream flavor, our dairy-rich delights pies are as impressive to look at as they are to eat: piled high with luscious

Fruit Pies

Price may varies

lush, seasonal fruit enveloped in tender pastry, what could be better? from classic apple to strawberry-rhubarb, you may choose a double-crust pie or one topped with rich, not-too-sweet streusel crum

Canadian Maple Butter Tart

Price may varies

je me souviens! long after your lips caress the last crumb, the super-flaky lard crust and unforgettable, silky filling of our award-winning butter tart will keep your thoughts sweet. in case you're

Chocolate-Caramel Pie

Price may varies

a big, beautiful slice of heaven! chocolate cookie crust topped with a lavish layer of rich caramel filling, slathered with bittersweet chocolate ganache, then sprinkled with sea salt for contrast. y

Bourbon Pecan Pie

Price may varies

heaven in every bite! our unsurpassed pecan pie has an inviting, golden filling swirled with fragrant pecans and fragrant with bourbon, all cradled into our signature flaky butter crust. second helpi


Local-Only Delicacies

Cream Pies

$35.00

from award-winning coconut cream to the instantly popular guinness-bailey's irish cream flavor, our dairy-rich delights pies are as impressive to look at as they are to eat: piled high with luscious


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading