Cookie Casa Bakery Menu and Prices

$12.00 - $21.00

our most popular cookie, sprinkled with festive valentine’s hearts!

$12.00 - $21.00

craving red velvet, but don't want a cupcake? this is the perfect solution - a soft, chewy red velvet cookie dotted throughout with chunks of white chocolate. red velvet perfection.

$12.00 - $21.00

crispy around the edges, chewy in the center. a classic.

$21.00 - $12.00

a deep, dark cookie with creamy white chocolate chunks throughout. erin's current favorite.

$21.00 - $12.00

our best selling cookie, but with toasted walnuts. yummy!

$21.00 - $12.00

our sophisticated combo for the true gourmand.

$21.00 - $12.00

erin's grandma's favorite. dark chocolate cookie chock full of peanut butter chips.

$12.00 - $21.00

chewy, decadent, chocolatey.

$21.00 - $12.00

a deliciously tart and tangy lemon cookie.

$42.00 - $21.00

our tart lemon cookie sandwiched with lemon frosting. the perfect balance of sweet & tart.

$21.00 - $12.00

spice up your chocolate craving by ordering this cookie with a kick! just enough heat to enhance the rich chocolate taste.

$21.00 - $12.00

a recipe from erin's grandma - if you love molasses & ginger you'll go crazy for this one.

$21.00 - $42.00

two of grandma becky's molasses ginger cookies paired with our famous vanilla buttercream. sensational!

$21.00 - $12.00

a close cousin to our popular oatmeal peanut butter cookie. all the chewy, oat-y goodness, now with butterscotch chips!

$21.00 - $12.00

an oat-licious, chocolatey combination - soft and chewy like all of cookie casa bakery’s cookies!

$12.00 - $21.00

chewy, thin, salty & sweet combo.

$21.00 - $12.00

oats and raisins, perfectly spiced.

$21.00 - $12.00

if you're a traditionalist and like keeping your peanut butter pure, this is definitely the cookie for you. a perfect, old fashioned version - really peanut buttery!

$21.00 - $12.00

our popular peanut butter cookie sandwiched with your choice of chocolate or peanut butter frosting.

$12.00 - $21.00

a zabel family favorite. tangy sugar cookie subtly spiced.

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). the perfect alternative to a traditional cake. our world-famous chocolate chip cookie - now in cake size!

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). need dessert for your party, but don't want a cake? our celebration cake is here for you - a tasty, sweet cookie studded with rainbow sprinkles.

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). a deep, dark chocolate cookie for your next get-together.

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). you asked, we answered! we've added m&m's to our chocolate chip cookie cake for that extra wow!

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). our soft and chewy peanut butter cookie - sized for sharing!

$42.00

(serves 6-8). not in the mood for brownies or bars? order this gift box filled with good old-fashioned drop cookies. chocolate chip cookies, chocolate peanut butter cookies, snickerdoodle cookies & o

$42.00

(serves 6-8). a sampler of our cookie sandwiches.

$36.00 - $21.00

we've added a little valentine spirit to our original crack bars. sure to melt your sweetie's heart!

$21.00 - $42.00

classic apple pie flavor with the added bonus of an oatmeal crumb topping. sure to be a hit wherever it goes!

$21.00 - $42.00

a recipe from erin's mama. this was erin's go-to recipe as a little girl. golden brown sugar bar with walnuts.

$21.00 - $42.00

all the flavor of that perfect cherry pie and oatmeal streusel, ready for on-the-go eating!

$21.00 - $42.00

the best brownie you'll ever have - rich, dense and oh so yummy.

$21.00 - $42.00

these rich, fudgy, chocolatey, peanut buttery goodies are gluten free and we think they are the best way to end any meal. or start it, we won't judge. (contains dairy)

$21.00 - $42.00

a good old-fashioned lemon bar.

$21.00 - $42.00

our famous chocolate fudge cookie bar: a chocolate cookie crust with fudge filling and topped with chocolate chips and cookie crumbs.

$21.00 - $42.00

our original crack studded with salty peanuts and peanut butter chips.

$42.00 - $21.00

our original crack plus fresh mint flavor and mint chips.

$21.00 - $42.00

rich shortbread crust topped with a sweet and sticky pecan mixture.

$21.00 - $42.00

we added melted white chocolate to this creamy blondie batter and then tossed in semi-sweet chocolate morsels - it's like chocolate chip ice cream in bar form!

$21.00 - $42.00

creamy, white chocolate chunks offset the deep dark chocolate - an excellent pairing.

$42.00

(serves 6-8). features our three most popular bars - sweet and chewy blondies, decadent crack bars and buttery pecan shortbread squares. if you haven't tried cookie casa bakery yet, this is a good pl

$21.00 - $39.00

any of our delicious cupcake flavors, topped with valentine-pink frosting & heart sprinkles.

$45.00 - $45.00

a sweet way to surprise your valentine. hand-frosted with love. chocolate chocolate chip and very vanilla come with vanilla frosting. red velvet has white chocolate cream cheese frosting.

$39.00 - $21.00

a superb vanilla cupcake that will surely impress your taste buds. just as moist and scrumptious as our chocolate chocolate chip recipe! pair with your choice of frosting.

$39.00 - $21.00

the same batter as our popular chocolate chocolate chip cake but in cupcake size. your choice of vanilla, chocolate, coconut, peanut butter, white chocolate cream cheese, orange vanilla, or coffee fr

$39.00 - $21.00

our version of red velvet. moist, delicious, with just the right amount of cocoa flavor, paired with our white chocolate cream cheese frosting.

$39.00 - $21.00

a delicate carrot recipe - we recommend choosing white chocolate cream cheese frosting.

$39.00 - $21.00

a moist vanilla cupcake accented with fresh lemon zest and juice. perfect for citrus lovers!

$39.00 - $21.00

we've added peanut butter to our very vanilla batter. if you like peanut butter you absolutely must try this cupcake.

$18.00 - $18.00

just like our regular sized cupcakes only smaller.

$18.00 - $18.00

mini versions of our peanut butter, carrot, red velvet, and lemon cupcakes.

$42.00 - $22.50

a piece of our original crack is baked into our chocolate chocolate chip cupcake. we then top it with our vanilla or chocolate frosting, another piece of crack, cookie crumbs and a chocolate drizzle.

$22.50 - $42.00

it's the perfect vanilla cupcake with a chocolate surprise in the center! we bake a piece of our original crack in the middle of our very vanilla cupcake for a delicious treat. choose chocolate or va

$42.00 - $22.50

a scrumptious mix of sweet and salty. a piece of peanut butter crack is baked into our chocolate chocolate chip cupcakes and topped with peanut butter or chocolate frosting, cookie crumbs, sweet driz

$40.00

(serves 12-15). unbelievably moist chocolate cake, requested most often with our famous vanilla frosting.

$40.00

(serves 12-15). a superb vanilla cake recipe that will surely impress your taste buds. just as moist and scrumptious as our chocolate chocolate chip recipe! pair with your choice of frosting.

$40.00

(serves 12-15). our version of red velvet. moist, delicious, with just the right amount of cocoa flavor, paired with our white chocolate cream cheese frosting.

$40.00

(serves 12-15). a delicate carrot recipe - we recommend choosing white chocolate cream cheese frosting.

$40.00

(serves 12-15). we've added peanut butter to our vanilla batter. if you like peanut butter you absolutely must try this one.

$40.00

(serves 12-15). a moist vanilla cake accented with fresh lemon zest and juice. perfect for citrus lovers!

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). the perfect alternative to a traditional cake. our world-famous chocolate chip cookie - now in cake size!

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). need dessert for your party, but don't want a cake? our celebration cake is here for you - a tasty, sweet cookie studded with rainbow sprinkles.

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). a deep, dark chocolate cookie for your next get-together.

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). you asked, we answered! we've added m&m's to our chocolate chip cookie cake for that extra wow!

$28.00

(feeds 12-14). our soft and chewy peanut butter cookie - sized for sharing!

$35.00

it doesn't get more american than this. wonderfully tart and sweet, our apple pie is the perfect ending to any meal. warm it up and try it à la mode. we promise it's even better than grandma's!

$25.00

a good 'ole southern treat - only you won’t find corn syrup in cookie casa bakery’s version! this nutty, sweet pie is absolutely delectable. it will win over any pecan pie lover’s heart!

$35.00

tart and tangy with a buttery lattice crust - a beauty to behold. a good cherry pie is hard to come by - but we have mastered it!

$21.00 - $42.00

classic apple pie flavor with the added bonus of an oatmeal crumb topping. sure to be a hit wherever it goes!

$21.00 - $42.00

all the flavor of that perfect cherry pie and oatmeal streusel, ready for on-the-go eating!

$45.00 - $45.00

a sweet way to surprise your valentine. hand-frosted with love. chocolate chocolate chip and very vanilla come with vanilla frosting. red velvet has white chocolate cream cheese frosting.

$12.00 - $21.00

our most popular cookie, sprinkled with festive valentine's hearts!

$21.00 - $36.00

we've added a little valentine spirit to our original crack bars. sure to melt your sweetie's heart!

$21.00 - $39.00

any of our delicious cupcake flavors, topped with valentine-pink frosting & heart sprinkles.

$12.00 - $21.00

craving red velvet, but don't want a cupcake? this is the perfect solution - a soft, chewy red velvet cookie dotted throughout with chunks of white chocolate. red velvet perfection.

$64.00

(serves 6-8). little bites perfect for celebrating the upcoming little one! an assortment of mini cupcakes and mini cookies. boy? girl? surprise? let us know & we'll frost accordingly.

$56.00

(serves 6-8). hosting a wedding shower? we've got you covered! this combo comes with a (5") cake and mini cupcakes - all very vanilla with vanilla frosting for the white on white bridal look.