Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 66 votes
Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop Logo

Choose My State

NY

Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Beverages

Bottle Soda

$1.99

Vitamin Water

$2.50

Snapple

$1.99

Nesquik Chocolate Milk

$1.99

Orange Juice

$1.50


Breakfast Plates

Breakfast Plate #1

$5.49

Scrambled eggs, your choice of meat, pancakes, biscuit and hash brown.

Breakfast Plate #2

$4.99

Scrambled eggs, your choice of meat, pancakes and hash brown.

Breakfast Plate #3

$3.99

Pancakes and your choice of meat.

Breakfast Plate #4

$3.99

Scrambled eggs, biscuit and your choice of meat.


Breakfast Sandwiches

Breakfast Sandwich #5

$2.99

Egg and cheese.

Breakfast Sandwich #6

$3.99

Bacon, egg and cheese.

Breakfast Sandwich #7

$3.99

Ham, egg and cheese.

Breakfast Sandwich #8

$3.99

Spinach, tomato, egg whites and cheese.

Breakfast Sandwich #9

$4.29

Sausage, egg and cheese.

Breakfast Sandwich #10.

$4.29

Bacon, egg, grilled peppers, grilled onions and cheese.

Breakfast Sandwich #11

$5.99

Cuban sandwich with pulled pork, ham, egg, pickles, Carolina mustard and Swiss cheese.

#12. Hash Brown

$1.00


Muffins

Muffin

$0.99

Choose a flavor.


Hot Off the Grill

#13. 1/3 lb Burger

$3.59

#14. Cheese Burger

$3.99

#15. Bacon Cheese Burger

$4.59

#16. Pork BBQ Burger

$5.29

#17. Mushroom Swiss Burger

$4.29

#18. Exit 11 Plate

$8.99

Choose any meat and 2 sides.

#19. Veggie Burger

$4.95

#20. Philly Steak Bomber

$6.69

#21. Ruben on Toasted Rye

$5.69

#22. 1/4 lb. Hot Dog

$2.99

#23. Italian Sausage Bomber

$4.89


Colby's Famous BBQ

#24. Pulled Pork

$4.99

#25. Pulled Chicken

$4.99

#26. Carolina BBQ

$5.49

#27. Brisket BBQ

$5.99

#28. Cuban BBQ

$5.99

#29. BBQ Ribs Plate (Half Rack)

$7.99

#29. BBQ Ribs Plate (Full Rack)

$11.99

#30. BBQ Combo

$13.99

1/2 rack of ribs, brisket, & pork.

#31. 1/2 Chicken BBQ

$7.95

Available Saturday and Sunday only.


Fried Favorites

#32. Chicken Fingers

$5.99

#33. Fried Chicken Plate

$8.95

Only available on Thursday-Sunday.

#34. 10 oz. Fish Fry

$9.95

Only available on Friday.

#35. Boneless Chicken Wings

$6.99

#35. Traditional Chicken Wings

$7.99

#36. Mozzarella Sticks

$5.99

#37. Onion Rings

$3.49

#38. French Fries

$2.99


Salad & Sandwich

#39. House Salad

$4.99

#40. Pulled Chicken Salad

$6.99

#41. Citrus Pecan Salad

$6.99

#42. BLT

$4.29

Served on toasted Sourdough.

#43. Egg Salad

$3.99

#43. Tuna Salad

$3.99


Sides

Side Salad

$2.99

French Fries

$2.99

Coleslaw

$2.99

Mac Salad

$2.99

Baked Beans

$2.99

Broccoli Salad

$2.99

Tomato & Cuke

$2.99

Salt Potatoes

$2.99

Mac & Cheese

$2.99


Kids Meal

44. Kids Burger

$5.49

Comes with Smile Cookie and your choice of side and drink.

44. Kids Chicken

$5.49

Comes with Smile Cookie and your choice of side and drink.

44. Kids Grilled Cheese

$5.49

Comes with Smile Cookie and your choice of side and drink.

44. Kids Hot Dog

$5.49

Comes with Smile Cookie and your choice of side and drink.


Ice Cream

Quarts of Hershey's Ice Cream

$8.99


Pies

Pie

$4.99


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading