City Island Diner Menu and Prices
Burger
Sandwiches
Wraps
Choose My State
City Island Diner Menu
Last Update: 2025-03-14
Beverages
Soda
$2.00
0
Juice
$2.50
0
Coffee
$1.00 - $2.50
0
Appetizers
Island Wings
$7.95
0
Chicken Tenders
$7.95
0
Mozzarella Sticks
$7.95
0
Jalapeno Poppers
$7.95
0
Homemade Fried Zucchini Stix
$8.95
0
"Train Wreck" Potato Wedges
$9.95
0
Nachos Grande
$9.95
0
Chicken Quesadilla
$9.95
0
Veggie Quesadilla
$10.95
0
Black Bean and Goat Cheese Empanada
$8.95
0
Chicken Teriyaki Potstickers
$8.95
0
Crispy Calamari
$10.95
0
Sweet Fried Clams
$10.95
0
Baked Clams Oreganato
$10.95
0
Bar Platter
$15.95
Mozzarella sticks, poppers, chicken strips, fries and onion rings.
0
Soups
Cup of Soup
$3.00
Please call restaurant for today's selection.
0
Bowl of Soup
$4.00
Please call restaurant for today's selection.
0
Cup of Chowder
$4.50
0
Bowl of Chowder
$5.50
0
Cup of Chili
$4.95
0
Bowl of Chili
$5.95
0
Bowl of Chili and Chips
$7.95
With cheese and onion.
0
Salad Platters
City Island House Salad
$5.95
Mixed greens with tomato, red onions and carrots.
0
Chicken Caesar Salad
$8.95
Grilled chicken, croutons, Parmesan cheese and romaine lettuce.
0
Spinach Salad
$8.95
Fresh baby spinach, bacon, mushrooms, sliced eggs and dressing.
0
Cobb Salad
$8.95
Turkey, Swiss cheese, bacon, sliced egg, lettuce and tomato.
0
Chef's Salad
$8.95
Roast beef, turkey, ham, American cheese, sliced egg, lettuce and tomato.
0
Greek Salad
$8.95
Feta cheese, tomatoes, peppers, onions, olives, cucumbers and romaine lettuce.
0
Taco Salad
$8.95
Homemade chili with lettuce, tomato, cheese, onion and tortilla chips.
0
Snug Salad
$8.95
Baby spinach, goat cheese, walnuts, tomatoes and red onion.
0
Fresh Fruit Salad
$8.95
Fresh fruit served with cottage cheese and lettuce.
0
Chicken, Tuna and Egg Salad Platter
$8.95
Served with cheese, tomatoes, and crackers on a bed of lettuce.
0
Burgers
All Beef Burger
$5.50
Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
All Beef Burger with Cheese
$5.95
Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
All Beef Burger with Bacon
$6.50
Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
All Beef Burger with Bacon and Cheese
$6.95
Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Titanic Burger
$7.50
10 oz. burger served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Titanic Burger with Cheese
$7.95
10 oz. burger served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Homemade Turkey Burger
$5.95
Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
California Veggie Burger
$5.95
Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Specialty Burgers
Bronx Burger
$8.95
Bacon, American cheese and fried onions. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.
0
Great Lakes Burger
$8.95
Mushrooms, onions and Swiss cheese. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.
0
Cozumel Burger
$8.95
Jalapeno Jack cheese with homemade salsa. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.
0
Southwestern Burger
$8.95
Homemade chili, cheddar cheese and diced onions. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.
0
Pisa Burger
$8.95
Leaning toward pizza. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.
0
Bronx Heroes and Sandwiches
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
$9.95
Fresh roasted in-house. Served with french fries.
0
Aunt Frannie's Homemade Meatball Parmigiana Hero
$8.95
Fresh roasted in-house. Served with french fries.
0
Roast Pork Sandwich
$9.95
Fresh roasted in-house with pepper jack cheese and a side of gravy. Served with french fries.
0
Roast Beef "Balboa" Sandwich
$9.95
Fresh roasted in-house with mozzarella cheese and sauteed onions on garlic bread. Served with french fries.
0
Tropical Chicken BBQ Hero
$9.95
Fresh roasted in-house grilled chicken with mango BBQ sauce, bacon and melted Swiss. Served with french fries.
0
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
$8.95
Fresh roasted in-house. "Philled" with cheese, steak and onions. Served with french fries.
0
Fresh Filet of Fish Sandwich
$9.95
Served with coleslaw, tartar sauce and french fries.
0
Wraps
Antipasto Wrap
$8.95
Ham, salami, mozzarella, eggplant and red pepper. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
California Wrap
$8.95
Turkey, Muenster, tomato, lettuce, olives, and creamy dill dressing. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Chef's Salad Wrap
$8.95
Ham, turkey, roast beef, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and sliced egg. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$8.95
Grilled chicken, lettuce, homemade croutons and Caesar dressing. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Greek Salad Wrap
$8.95
Lettuce, tomato, feta, onions, peppers, olives, cucumbers, and vinaigrette. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Mexican Wrap
$8.95
Homemade chili, cheddar, onions and sour cream. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Roast Beef Wrap
$8.95
Roast beef, lettuce, roasted peppers and herb cheese. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Tuna Salad Wrap
$8.95
Homemade tuna salad, lettuce, tomato and sliced egg. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Vidalia Wrap
$8.95
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, olives and vidalia vinaigrette. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Apple-Nut Veggie Wrap
$8.95
Chopped apples, pineapples, shredded carrots, walnuts, raisins and herb cheese. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Specialty Sandwich Board
Columbia Sandwich
$8.95
Our Italian combo. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Constellation Sandwich
$8.95
Our clam roll. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Courageous Sandwich
$8.95
Chicken cutlet with the works. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Intrepid Sandwich
$8.95
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato and herb mayo. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
The Magic Sandwich
$8.95
Chicken salad and BLT on a bagel. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Mayflower Sandwich
$8.95
Turkey, stuffing and cranberry on rye. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Shamrock Sandwich
$8.95
Corned beef, melted Swiss and coleslaw. Served with pickle.
0
Independence Sandwich
$8.95
Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Paninis
Cuban Panini
$8.95
Roast pork, ham, Muenster cheese, tomato, pickles, onions and special sauce. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Milano Panini
$8.95
Spinach, mushrooms, provolone and roasted peppers. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Delancey Panini
$8.95
Pastrami, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut with homemade mustard relish. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Moonstruck Panini
$8.95
Salami, eggplant, mozzarella cheese and roasted red pepper relish. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Cordon Bleu Panini
$8.95
Breaded chicken, ham and Swiss cheese with Dijon mustard. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Hawaiian Panini
$8.95
Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, pineapple salsa and honey mustard. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Islander Panini
$8.95
Sliced loin of pork, pepper jack cheese and spicy remoulade. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Mediterranean Panini
$8.95
Grilled chicken with homemade Greek salad. Served with coleslaw and pickle.
0
Make Your Own Panini
$8.95
Served on a club roll with coleslaw and pickle.
0
The Basics
BLT Sandwich
$5.25
Served with a pickle.
0
Tuna Salad Sandwich
$5.25
Served with a pickle.
0
Egg Salad Sandwich
$4.50
Served with a pickle.
0
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$5.95
Served with a pickle.
0
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$4.25
Served with a pickle.
0
Tuna Melt Sandwich
$6.75
Served with a pickle.
0
Fresh Turkey Club Sandwich
$8.95
Served with a pickle.
0
Pastrami Sandwich
$7.95
On rye. Served with a pickle.
0
Corned Beef Sandwich
$7.95
On rye. Served with a pickle.
0
Traditional Reuben Sandwich
$8.95
Served with a pickle.
0
Monte Cristo Sandwich
$8.95
Served with a pickle.
0
Sabrett Hot Dog
$5.95
With fries. Served with a pickle.
0
Hot Open Sandwiches
Roast Beef Open Sandwich
$9.95
Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.
0
Roast Loin of Pork Open Sandwich
$9.95
Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.
0
Oven Roasted Chicken Open Sandwich
$9.95
Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.
0
Roast Turkey Open Sandwich
$9.95
Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.
0
Home Style Dinners
Jumbo Cheese Ravioli Dinner
$13.95
Served with homemade meatballs. Served with bread.
0
Roast Loin of Pork Dinner
$13.95
With potato pancakes and sauerkraut. Served with bread.
0
Old Fashioned Roast Beef Dinner
$13.95
With mashed potatoes and vegetable. Served with bread.
0
Roast Turkey Dinner
$13.95
With stuffing, mashed potatoes and vegetables. Served with bread.
0
Roast 1/2 Chicken Dinner
$13.95
With mashed potatoes and vegetables. Served with bread.
0
Corned Beef and Cabbage Dinner
$14.95
With mashed potatoes and carrots. Served with bread.
0
Chicken Sicilian Over Linguine Dinner
$14.95
Served with bread.
0
Traditional Irish Shepard's Pie Dinner
$14.95
Served with bread.
0
Bangers and Mashed Dinner
$13.95
With vegetables. Served with bread.
0
Fresh Calamari Marinara Over Linguine Dinner
$13.95
Served with bread.
0
Broiled Tilapia Oreganata Dinner
$14.95
With rice and vegetable. Served with bread.
0
Shrimp In a Basket Dinner
$14.95
With fries and coleslaw. Served with bread.
0
Fish and Chips Dinner
$14.95
Includes fries, coleslaw and tartar sauce. Served with bread.
0
Sides
Side of French Fries
$3.75
0
Side of Sweet Fries
$4.25
0
Side of Onion Rings
$4.00
0
Side of Hot Vegetables
$4.00
0
Side of Mashed Potatoes
$4.00
0
Side of Coleslaw
$3.75
0
Side of Macaroni Salad
$3.75
0
Side of Homemade Greek Salad
$4.95
0
Side of Homemade Potato Pancakes
$4.00
0
Desserts
Layer Cake du Jour
$4.00
Please call restaurant for today's selection.
0
Apple Pastry Turnover
$2.00
0
Muffin
$2.00
0
Homemade Banana Chocolate Chip Bread
$2.00
0
Lindzer Tart
$2.00
0
DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.
People Are Reading
Popular Brands
-
Applebee's Menu2.7 -
Arby's Menu3.7 -
Burger King Menu3.4 -
Chick-fil-A Menu3.8 -
-
Cook Out Menu1.5 -
-
-
KFC Menu3.2 -
McDonald's Menu2.9 -
-
-
Pizza Hut Menu3.3 -
-
Wendy's Menu2.9 -
-
Red Lobster Menu1.4 -
-
-
