Chumley's Bar Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 106 votes
Chumley's Bar Logo

Choose My State

IN

Chumley's Bar Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Homemade Soup

$2.45 - $4.95

Made daily from scratch. Ask for today’s selection.

Beer Chili

$2.45 - $4.95

A hearty red chili made with mad anthony auburn lager. Add cheese for $0.75. Meat: cheese $0.75

Fried Breadsticks

$6.45

Soft bread sticks fried golden-brown and sprinkled with shredded parmesan. Served with marinara and queso cheese sauce. Serves 1-2.

Chicken Tenders

$8.45

Juicy strips of chicken tenders in a pepper breading. Served with your choice of ranch, honey mustard or one of our wing sauces. Serves 1-2. Add fries for $1.50. Sauce: ranch, honey mustard one of ou

Spinach-Artichoke Dip

$7.95

A creamy blend of artichoke hearts, spinach and parmesan. Served with tortilla chips and fried pita bread. Serves 1-2.

Quesadillas

$8.45

Grilled tortilla filled with blended cheese and your choice of chicken or black beans. Served with lettuce, tomato, jalapenos, sour cream and salsa all on the side. Serves 1-2

Nacho Platter (Half)

$6.95

Your choice of chicken, chili or taco beef on top of tortilla chips with queso cheese, lettuce, tomato, jalapenos, sour cream, guacamole and a side of salsa. Serves 2-3

Tortilla Chips

$7.48

Hand-cut chips served with homemade salsa, queso cheese sauce and guacamole. Serves 2-3.

BBQ Pulled Pork Nachos

$8.95

Tortilla chips covered with pulled pork, nacho cheese, BBQ sauce and jalapenos. Serves 2-3.

Mozzarella Sticks

$6.95

Fried golden-brown and served with marinara. Serves 1-2.

Potato Skins

$7.95

Four crispy skins loaded with cheese, chili and bacon and topped with sour cream. Serves 1-2.

Calamari Strips

$7.95

Fried strips of batter-coated calamari served with lemon and marinara. Serves 1-2.

Fried Pickle Spears

$6.45

Battered and deep-fried. Served with cucumber sauce. Serves 1-2.

Fried Green Beans

$6.45

Served with ranch. Serves 1-2.

Basket of Tater Tots

$5.95

Lightly-seasoned, golden-brown tots. Serves 1-2.

Basket of O-Rings

$5.95

Beer-battered sweet onions with thousand island. Serves 1-2.

Basket of Fries

$4.95

Choose either hand-cut shoestring fries or skin-on, thick cut steak fries. Serves 1-2.

Basket of Sweet Potato Fries

$5.95

Thin-cut and lightly dusted with brown sugar. Serves 1-2.


Big Salads

Chef Salad

$8.95

Smoked turkey, ham, mixed cheese, tomato, sliced egg and croutons on a bed of lettuce. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, thousand island, french, honey mustard, italian, greek, southwest ranch, fat-free

Caesar Salad

$7.45

Romaine lettuce, shredded parmesan and croutons all coated in caesar dressing. Anchovies optional. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, thousand island, french honey mustard, italian, greek, southwest ranch

Chicken Tender Salad

$8.45

Fried chicken tender slices on a bed of lettuce with tomato, cucumber and blended cheese. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, thousand island, french, honey mustard, italian, greek southwest ranch, fat-fre

Southwest Chicken Salad

$8.95

Strips of seasoned grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, red and green peppers, black beans and mixed cheese. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, thousand island, french, honey musatard, italian, greek,

Raspberry Caesar

$8.45

Romaine, cucumber, walnuts, mandarin oranges, feta cheese and croutons topped in a raspberry vinaigrette. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, thousand island, french, honey musatard, italian, greek, southw

Bleu Cheese Steak Salad

$9.45

Grilled steak, lettuce, tomato, red onion, cucumber and bleu cheese crumbles. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, thousand island, french, honey mustard, italian, greek, southwest ranch, fat-free ranch, fa

Fajita Salad - Chicken

$8.95

Grilled chic ken on a bed of lettuce with tomato, red and green peppers, onion, black beans, mixed cheese and crispy tortilla strips. Sour cream and salsa on the side. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, t

Fajita Salad - Steak

$9.95

Grilled chic ken on a bed of lettuce with tomato, red and green peppers, onion, black beans, mixed cheese and crispy tortilla strips. Sour cream and salsa on the side. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, t

Taco Salad Supreme

$9.95

Seasoned beef, mixed cheese, tomato and black olives on lettuce, topped with sour cream and served in a shell with a side of salsa. Dressing: ranch, bleu cheese, thousand island, french, honey musata


Pub SandwichesOn toasted french bread unless otherwise noted served with potato chips and pickle spear or substitute a priced side from below

Chicago-Style Italian Beef

$7.95

Hot slices of Italian-seasoned beef served with sport peppers and au jus. Add cheese for $0.75 or marinara for $0.50. Extras: cheese $0.75, marinara $0.50

Philly Cheesesteak

$8.95

Our tender Italian beef, chopped and grilled with onions and topped with white cheddar.

Hot Ham and Cheese

$7.45

Loads of thin-sliced ham with the cheese of your choice.

Breaded Tenderloin

$7.95

Hand-breaded and fried golden-brown with your choice of toppings. Served on a bun.

Grilled Tenderloin

$7.95

Lightly seasoned and grilled with the toppings of your choice. Served on a bun.

New York-Style Reuben

$7.95

A heaping mound of lean corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss and thousand island all grilled on rye.

Ribeye Sandwich

$10.95

A juicy 8-oz. ribeye grilled to order. Add cheese for $0.75 or grilled onions, mushrooms or peppers for $0.50. Cheese $0.75, grilled onions $0.50, mushrooms $0.50, Peppers $0.50

Stromboli Sandwich

$7.95

Italian sausage, pepperoni, red and green peppers and marinara topped with mozzarella and baked.

Turkey Club

$7.95

Sliced smoked turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and Swiss stacked on three slices of white or wheat toast. Bread: white toast, wheat toast

Memphis-Style Pulled Pork

$6.95

Succulent hickory-smoked pork, simmered in a tangy BBQ sauce and served on a bun.

Chumley's Fish Sandwich

$7.95

Beer-battered cod, fried golden-brown and topped with American, lettuce and tartar sauce.

Gyros Sandwich

$7.45

Seasoned slices of lamb and beef, sliced tomato and parsleyed onion in a grilled pita. Topped with our fresh cucumber sauce.

Chicago Dog

$4.95

¼ Lb all-beef dog topped with mustard, relish, cucumber, tomato, celery salt and a pickle spear. Style: plain dog $4.45, chili dog $4.95

Wisconsin Beer Brat

$5.45

Beer-boiled bratwurst grilled to perfection and served on a roll. Add grilled onions for $0.50. Meat: grilled onions $0.50

B.L.T. Sandwich

$6.95

Crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on white or wheat toast. Bread: white toast, wheat toast

Grilled Cheese

$4.95

Two slices of your favorite cheese grilled on white or wheat. Bread: white toast, wheat toast


Gourmet BurgersServed with potato chips and pickles pear or substitute a priced side from below

Chumley Burger

$7.45

A half-pound certified angus beef burger served on a toasted bun with your choice of toppings or, choose one of our signature burgers, with any additional toppings of your choice. Toppings: lettuce,

Black n' Bleu Burger

$8.45

Cajun seasoning, bleu cheese crumbles, o-ring

Peanut Butter Burger

$7.70

Creamy peanut butter

Jerk Burger

$8.45

Jerk seasoning, pepper jack

California Burger

$10.45

Bacon. Provolone, tomato, guacamole

BBQ Bacon Cheese Burger

$9.95

BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar

Michigan Burger

$8.20

Green olives, cheddar

Garlic Alfredo Burger

$7.70

Topped with garlic alfredo sauce

Bfd Burger

$10.45

Bacon, american, fried egg

Ragin' Cajun Burger

$8.45

Cajun seasoning, pepper jack

Chili-Cheese Burger

$8.70

Blended cheese, chili

Mushroom Swiss Burger

$8.70

Grilled mushrooms, swiss

Texas Burger

$9.70

Bacon, cheddar, jalapenos

Three-Cheese Burger

$9.70

Cheddar, swiss, provolone

Bacon Cheeseburger

$9.70

Bacon, cheddar

Greek Burger

$8.45

Tomato, onion, feta, cucumber sauce

Pb and J Burger

$7.70

Peanut butter, grape jelly

Atomic Burger

$8.45

Jalapenos, pepper jack, hot sauce

Hawaiian Burger

$9.95

Bacon, pineapple, provolone

Mac n' Cheese Burger

$8.95

Topped with mac n’ cheese

Patty Melt Burger

$8.70

Grilled onions and mushrooms, swiss on rye

Mexican Burger

$9.45

Tomato, onion, guacamole, jalapenos, refried beans, mixed cheese, sour cream

Honey Bacon Burger

$9.20

Bacon, honey, honey mustard

Minnesota Burger

$8.20

Patty stuffed with American cheese

Big Chumley

$12.95

Two patties, lettuce, grilled onion, pickle, American, 1000 Island


Chicken SanwichesServed with potato chips and pickle spear or substitute a priced side from below

Grilled Chicken

$6.95

A plump chicken breast served with your choice of toppings.

Chumley's Chicken

$9.45

Grilled chicken breast smothered with mushrooms, swiss, bacon and honey mustard on toasted marble rye.

Teriyaki Chicken

$7.45

Grilled teriyaki breast topped with roasted pineapple salsa.

Diablo Chicken

$7.95

Grilled chicken breast drenched in hot sauce and topped with red and green peppers and melted pepper jack.

Fried Chicken

$6.95

A juicy 4oz. filet with the toppings of your choice.

Buffalo Chicken

$7.45

Fried chicken filet tossed in your favorite wing sauce. Served with bleu cheese or ranch. Bleu cheese, ranch

Fried Chicken Parmesan

$7.95

Breaded filet topped with marinara, mozzarella and parmesan.


Famous WrapsIn your choice of tomato-basil or flour tortilla served with potato chips and pickle spear or substitute a priced side from below

Chumley Wrap

$8.45

Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, peppers, black beans, blended cheese and southwest ranch. Side: tomato-basil, flour tortilla. Substitute: hand-cut shoestring fries $1.50, steak fries $1.50, sweet p

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$8.95

Grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan and caesar dressing. Side: tomato-basil, flour tortilla. Substitute: hand-cut shoestring fries $1.50, steak fries $1.50, sweet potato fries $2.00, tater tots $2.00,

Chicken Tender Wrap

$8.45

Fried chicken tenders, lettuce, blended cheese with your choice of ranch, honey mustard or one of our wing sauces. Sauce: ranch, honey mustard, one of our wing sauces. Side: tomato-basil, flour torti

Steak and Queso Burrito Wrap

$9.45

Steak grilled with onions and peppers with lettuce, tomatoes and queso cheese sauce. Side: tomato-basil, flour tortilla. Substitute: hand-cut shoestring fries $1.50, steak fries $1.50, sweet potato f

California Wrap

$8.95

Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, guacamole and provolone. Side: tomato-basil, flour tortilla. Substitute: hand-cut shoestring fries $1.50, steak fries $1.50, sweet potato fries $2.00, tater tots $2.00

Teriyaki Chicken Wrap

$7.95

Grilled teriyaki chicken, lettuce, roasted pineapple salsa. Side: tomato-basil, flour tortilla. Substitute: hand-cut shoestring fries $1.50, steak fries $1.50, sweet potato fries $2.00, tater tots $2

Greek Garden Wrap

$6.45

Lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, cucumber, feta and greek dressing. Add gyros meat for $2.00. Meat: gyros meat $2.00. Side: tomato-basil, flour tortilla. Substitute: hand-cut shoestring fries $1


Pub Plates

California-Style Fish Tacos

$7.95

Two soft tortillas filled with deep-fried cod, tomato and cabbage topped with a creamy cilantro-lime yogurt sauce. Served with tortilla chips and a side of salsa.

Chicken or Beef Tacos

$7.95

Two soft tortillas filled with grilled chicken or seasoned beef, mixed cheese, tomato and lettuce with chips ‘n salsa. Add guacamole for $0.75. Substitute steak for $1.00. Extra: guacamole $0.75, sub

California-Style Fish Tacos

$7.95

Two soft tortillas filled with deep-fried cod, tomato and cabbage topped with a creamy cilantro-lime yogurt sauce. Served with tortilla chips and a side of salsa.

Chicken or Beef Tacos

$7.95

Two soft tortillas filled with grilled chicken or seasoned beef, mixed cheese, tomato and lettuce with chips n salsa. Add guacamole for $0.75. Substitute steak for $1.00. Extra: guacamole $0.75, subs

Shrimp Tacos

$8.95

Two soft tortillas filled with grilled shrimp, lettuce, tomato, cilantro and topped with our cilantro-lime yogurt sauce. Served with chips n salsa.

Fish n' Chips

Price may varies

Beer-battered cod filets fried golden-brown with shoestring fries. Served with tartar sauce and cole slaw.

Fajitas - Chicken

$10.95

Chicken, steak or both grilled with onions and peppers and served with 4 tortillas, lettuce, tomato, mixed cheese, guacamole and sour cream with fiesta rice and refried beans. Meat

Fajitas - Steak

$12.95

Chicken, steak or both grilled with onions and peppers and served with 4 tortillas, lettuce, tomato, mixed cheese, guacamole and sour cream with fiesta rice and refried beans. Meat

Fajitas - Combo

$11.95

Chicken, steak or both grilled with onions and peppers and served with 4 tortillas, lettuce, tomato, mixed cheese, guacamole and sour cream with fiesta rice and refried beans. Meat

Vodka Diablo

$8.95

Penne pasta coated in a fiery-hot vodka cream sauce. Add chicken for $2.00 or steak for $3.00. Add a side salad for $2.50. Meat: chicken $2.00, steak $3.00, side salad $2.50


Pizza

Cheese

$5.45 - $9.45

Toppings: pepperoni $0.50, italian sausage $0.50, ham $0.50, bacon $0.50, grilled chicken $0.50, cajun chicken $0.50, jerk chicken $0.50, gyros meat $0.50, red and green peppers $0.50, sport peppers


WingsServed with ranch or bleu cheese and celery and carrot sticks.

Traditional Wings

$5.50 - $11.00

Side: ranch, bleu cheese. Sauces: honey BBQ, chumley mild, garlic alfredo, bourbon glaze, dry jerk rub, dry cajun rub, cherry chipotle, thai peanut, hot BBQ, hot, citrus heat, stupid hot. Half 6, ful

Boneless Wings

$6.50 - $13.00

Boneless served with sauce on side only. Side: ranch, bleu cheese. Sauces: honey BBQ, chumley mild, garlic alfredo, bourbon glaze, dry jerk rub, dry cajun rub, cherry chipotle, thai peanut, hot BBQ,


Dessert

Double Chocolate Cake

$5.95

Multi-layered double fudge cake served with 2 scoops of vanilla ice cream.

Fried Ice Cream

$5.95

Served in a brown sugar-coated tortilla shell with chocolate sauce and whipped cream.


Beverages

20 oz. Soft Drinks and Juice

$1.87

Drink: diet pepsi, sierra mist, mountain dew, dr. pepper, orange juice, cranberry juice, grapefruit juice, lemonade, ginger ale, bottled water

Fresh-Brewed Iced Tea

$1.87

Fresh-Brewed Coffee

$1.87

Decaf Coffee

$1.87


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading