Menu With Price > Menu > Celestino's New York Pizza

Celestino's New York Pizza Menu and Prices

3.9 based on 178 votes

Pizza

Choose My State

Celestino's New York Pizza Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Starters & SidesSide dressing, side sauces, side extras: sauces 2oz side: pesto $1.50, hot sauce $0.75, marinara $0.75, BBQ $0.75. Side 2oz dressing: ranch $0.40, cesar $0.50, balsamic vinaigrette $0.40. Pesto sauce: basil pesto 2oz $1.50. Side cup 2oz: pineapple $0.75,

Classic Garlic Bread

$3.25

Three pieces of garlic bread served with side of marinara

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$4.00

Classic garlic bread with melted mozzarella cheese

Bruschetta Garlic Bread

$5.00

Garlic bread with cheese topped with diced tomato & fresh basil

Side of Meatballs

$4.00

Three meatballs in marinara sauce & finished with drop of parmesan cheese

Salads and SoupSalads & soup finished with parmesan cheese. Choice of ranch dressing or balsamic vinaigrette except for cesar salad

Mixed Greens Salad

$5.95

Mixed greens & red onion

Caesar Salad

$5.95

Romaine lettuce, croutons & caesar dressing. Add grilled chicken any salad $2.5

Minestrone Soup

$3.50

Cup of soup mixed vegetables, beans & pasta in a tomato & chicken broth

Celestino's Specialty Salad

$6.95

Mixed Greens with diced tomato, olive, artichoke, roasted pepper, mozz chz

Spinach Salad

$6.95

Mixed greens with diced tomato, olive, artichoke, roasted pepper, mozz chz

Spinach Salad

$6.95

Mixed greens with diced tomato, olive, artichoke, roasted pepper, mozz chz

Soup & Salad Combo

$6.75

Cup of soup & choice of half cesar or mixed green salad

Entrees & Pasta

Spaghetti Marinara Sauce

$6.50

Thin long pasta covered in marinara sauce

Home-Made Lasagna

$8.50

Layers of pasta, meat sauce, ricotta & mozz cheese

Rigatoni Parmigiana

$7.50

Tube pasta with marinara sauce & melted mozz cheese

Spaghetti Meatballs

$8.50

Marinara sauce & three meatballs

Chicken or Eggplant Parmigiana

$10.00

Breaded chicken or eggplant with marinara sauce, melted mozzarella cheese over rigatoni pasta

Sandwiches

Sandwich Combo Plate

$10.50 - $8.00

Sandwich & half salad or cup of soup choice of mixed greens or cesar salad

Meatball Parmigiana

$7.50 - $5.00

Meatballs & marinara sauce on a toasted french roll w/melted mozz cheese

Chicken Parmigiana

$7.50 - $5.00

Breaded chicken & marinara sauce on a toasted french roll w/melted mozz cheese

Eggplant Parmigiana

$7.50 - $5.00

Breaded eggpllant & marinara sauce on a toasted french roll w/melted mozz cheese

Traditional New York PizzaX-large 18" serves 4-6, medium 14" serves 3-4. Regular pizza toppings: Extra cheese, sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, diced onion, bell pepper, fresh tomato, black olives, pineapple, anchovy, fresh garlic, fresh basil. Each: x-large 2, mediu

Traditional Cheese Pizza

$15.50 - $12.50

Why we're famous: NY crust, great sauce & the best whole-milk mozz cheese

Pepperoni Pizza

$17.50 - $14.00

Traditional cheese pizza topped with pepperoni

Mushroom Pizza

$17.50 - $14.00

Traditional cheese pizza, red sauce & mozz cheese topped with fresh mushrooms

Anchovy & Garlic Pizza

$21.00 - $18.00

Traditional cheese pizza topped with anchovies, garlic & basil

Margherita Pizza

$17.50 - $14.00

Traditional cheese pizza with a crispy crust, little more sauce & fresh basil

Specialty Pizza Toppings Selection

Price may varies

Sun-dried tomato, broccoli, red roasted peppers, real bacon bits, canadian-style bacon, pesto topping or base sauce, artichoke hearts, feta, red onion, fresh spinach. Each: x-large $2.5, medium $2.0

Calzones & Rolls

Cheese Calzones

$6.50

Dough folded & filled with mozzarella & ricotta cheese. Add fillings regular $0.60 each specialty $0.75, chicken $2.00, see choice above under pizza & specialty toppings

Spinach & Feta Calzone

$8.00

Filled with sauteed spinach & garlic, feta, mozzarella & ricotta cheese

Ham & Cheese Calzone

$7.00

Filled with slice ham, mozzarella & ricotta cheese

Sausage Roll

$6.00

Roll with sausage, bell pepper, onion, red sauce & mozzarella cheese

Veggie Roll

$6.00

Choice of any two from regular or specialty pizza toppings above with red sauce & mozz cheese

Artichoke & Pesto Roll

$6.00

Roll filled with artichokes, pesto sauce & mozzarella cheese

Chicken Pesto Roll

$7.50

Roll filled with chicken, pesto sauce, tomato, basil and mozzarella cheese

Pizza SlicesLimited availability choices may vary

Traditional Cheese

$3.00

Red sauce & mozzarella cheese

Pepperoni Slice

$3.25

Traditional cheese with pepperoni

Tom Jones Slice

$3.50

Traditional cheese with sausage, ham, pepperoni

Slice Combo

$6.75

Slice of pizza & half salad or cup of soup choice of cesar or mixed greens or soup, slice must be $3.50 or less

Mushroom Slice

$3.25

Traditional cheese with mushrooms

Olive Special Slice

$3.50

Traditional cheese with olive, artichoke, garlic & basil

Godfather Slice

$3.50

Ricotta base, pesto topping, fresh & sundried tomato

Hawaiian Slice

$3.50

Traditional cheese with ham & pineapple

Specialty Veggie PizzasX-large 18" serves 4-6, medium 14" serves 3-4

Godfather

$22.00 - $18.50

Ricotta base, pesto topping, fresh & sundried tomato

Vegetarian Pizza

$21.00 - $17.50

Red sauce, broccoli, artichoke, roasted pepper, onion, blk olive & mozz cheese

Garden Deluxe Pizza

$22.00 - $18.50

Garlic ranch sauce, broccoli, artichoke, roasted peppers, red onion, mushrooms & mozz cheese

Bruschetta Pizza

$22.00 - $18.50

Pesto base, fresh & sundried tomatos, ricotta topping & mozz cheese

Mediterranean Mushroom

$22.00 - $18.50

Pesto base, sundried tomato, mushrooms, fresh garlic and basil

Olive Special

$21.50 - $18.00

Red sauce, artichoke hearts, black olive, fresh garlic & basil

Sweet Onion Pizza

$20.00 - $16.50

Garlic ranch sauce, red onion, green onions, white onion and mozz cheese

Traditional Mushroom

$17.50 - $14.00

Traditional cheese pizza topped with slice mushrooms

Greek 2 Me

$23.00 - $19.00

Pesto base, fresh spinach, sundried tomato, black olive, red onion, feta & mozz cheese

Pesto Cheese Pizza

$20.00 - $16.50

Pesto base, fresh tomato, mozz cheese, fresh garlic & basil

Specialty Meat PizzasX-large 18" serves 4-6, medium 14" serves 3-4. Pizzas will be made with traditional red tomato sauce unless otherwise stated other sauce options: pesto sauce or base garlic ranch BBQ additional cost will apply

Tom Jones

$21.00 - $17.50

Red sauce & mozz cheese, sausage, canadian-style ham & pepperoni

Classic Supreme

$22.50 - $19.00

Red sauce, mozz cheese, sausage, ham, pepperoni, onion, pepper, mushroom & olives

Smokey Cowboy

$24.00 - $20.00

BBQ sauce, mozz & cheddar cheese, sausage, canadian-style ham, pepperoni & real bacon

Pepperoni Special

$21.00 - $17.50

Red sauce & mozz cheese, fresh tomato, pepperoni, garlic & fresh basil

Chicken Pesto

$23.00 - $19.00

Pesto base & mozz cheese, fresh tomato, grilled chicken, garlic & fresh basil

Hawaiian Pizza

$20.00 - $17.00

Red sauce, mozz cheese, canadian-style ham & pinapple

Oscar Spicy Luau

$21.00 - $17.50

Red sauce, mozz cheese, pineapple, pepperoni, jalapeno & garlic

Chicken Club

$24.00 - $20.00

Garlic ranch sauce, fresh tomato, grilled chicken, bacon & green onion

Buffalo Chicken

$24.00 - $20.00

Garlic ranch sauce & mozz cheese, hot-sauce marinated chicken, real bacon & green onion

Traditional Pepperoni or Sausage

$17.50 - $14.00

Classic red sauce & mozz cheese, choice of pepperoni or sausage

Dessert

Cannoli

$3.50

Fried pastry filled with sweetened ricotta cheese

Choice of Chocolate Chip or Almond

Price may varies

Limit 2 per customer

Drinks Take-Out & Delivery2 Liter bottles

2-Liter Bottle

$3.00

Coke, diet coke or sprite

Bottled Water & Apple Juice

$1.50 - $2.00

Alhambra 12 oz, martinelli's 10oz

Drinks Dine In

Fountain Soda

Price may varies

Coke, diet coke, cherry coke, dr pepper, fanta orange or lemonade

Flavored Iced Teas

Price may varies

Minty green, mango, black tea iced tea

Bottled Water & Apple Juice

Price may varies

Alhambra 12oz, martinelli's 10oz

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.