Cayuga Lake Creamery Menu and Prices
Choose My State
Cayuga Lake Creamery Menu
Last Update: 2025-03-14
Ice Cream
Hard Ice Cream Or Sorbet
$2.75 - $9.25
0
Wine Sorbet/ice Cream
$3.15 - $4.95
0
Soft Serve Custard
$2.30 - $5.00
0
Add-ons
Waffle Cone Or Dish
$0.75 - $1.25
0
Gluten Free Cone
$0.75
0
Sprinkles
$0.25
0
Dip Top
$0.50
0
Candy, Nuts Or Sauce
$0.75
0
Sundaes And More
Sundaes
$5.25 - $8.75
0
Brownie Sundae
$7.50
0
Seasonal Sundae
$5.50
0
Banana Split
$10.95
0
Cayuga-uga Sundae
$15.25
0
Slice Of Ice Cream Pizza
$3.15
0
Take Out
$3.99 - $8.99
0
6 pack Ice Cream Sandwich
$8.99
0
Drinksadd malt $0.90
Ice Cream Soda
$5.50
0
Float
$5.00
0
Shake
$6.00
0
Soda/lemonade
$1.75 - $2.10
0
Coffee
$1.75 - $2.00
0
Iced Coffee
$1.75 - $2.00
0
Hot Tea
$1.60
0
Bottled Water
$1.25
0
16 Oz. Milk
$1.75
0
Hot Chocolate
$1.60
0
Hot Chocolate Float
$5.00
0
Iced Tea
$1.60 - $1.75
0
Homemade Flavors - Every DayOur Homemade Ice Cream Is Made On The Premises In Small Batches For Excellent Quality Control. We Start With A 14% Butterfat Mix From Our Dairy, Upstate Farms. We Then Add The Finest Ingredients Available-From Down The Road And Around The World-To Create Our Flavors. These Flavor Categories Are Available Every Day (flavor May Be A Variation Of The Category)
Vanilla
Price may varies
0
Chocolate
Price may varies
0
Mocha
Price may varies
0
Peanut Butter
Price may varies
0
Coffee
Price may varies
0
Fruit
Price may varies
0
Homemade Flavors - Complete List Of FlavorsAll flavors are not always available. If you are taking a trip up to the Creamery for a specific flavor, please call to make sure it is in stock
Banana
Price may varies
Banana ice cream made with fresh bananas
0
Banana Nut Fudge
Price may varies
Our fresh banana ice cream with walnuts and fudge swirl
0
Banoreo
Price may varies
Our fresh banana ice cream with Oreo
0
Beary Cotton Candy
Price may varies
Cotton Candy flavored ice cream with Gummy Bears
0
Black Raspberry
Price may varies
Made with black raspberry puree
0
Blue Hawaiian
Price may varies
Coconut based ice cream with Blue Curacao Liquor
0
Blueberry
Price may varies
Blueberry ice cream chockful of blueberries
0
Blueberry Almond
Price may varies
Blueberry ice cream with almonds
0
Blueberry Cheesecake
Price may varies
Cheesecake flavored ice cream with blueberry swirl and graham cracker pieces
0
Butter Pecan
Price may varies
Delicious buttered pecans in butter pecan ice cream
0
Butterscotch
Price may varies
Butterscotch ice cream with butterscotch swirled throughout
0
Cake Batter Supreme
Price may varies
Made with yellow cake mix and a fudge swirl
0
Cantaloupe
Price may varies
Made with locally grown cantaloupes
0
Cherry Jubilee
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with dark cherry halves and chocolate chunks
0
Cherry Vanilla
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with lots of maraschino cherry halves
0
Chilifest Chocolate (Seasonal)
Price may varies
Chocolate ice cream with chili powder
0
Chipitty Chocolate
Price may varies
Our chocolate ice cream with chocolate chunks
0
Chocolate
Price may varies
A dark chocolate ice cream using the finest Dutch cocoa and dark chocolate
0
Chocolate Almond
Price may varies
Our chocolate ice cream with roasted almonds
0
Chocolate Cheesecake
Price may varies
Chocolate cheesecake flavored ice cream with graham cracker pieces
0
Chocolate Chunk
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chunks
0
Chocolate Marshmallow
Price may varies
Our chocolate ice cream with a marshmallow swirl
0
Chocolate Mint Cookie
Price may varies
Chocolate ice cream with chocolate mint cookies
0
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
Price may varies
Chocolate ice cream with swirls of chocolate and peanut butter with delicious peanut butter pretzel balls added throughout
0
Chocolate Raspberry Cheescake
Price may varies
Cheescake flavored ice cream with raspberry and fudge swirl and graham craker pieces
0
Cinn-ful
Price may varies
Cinnamon ice cream with pralines and a caramel swirl
0
Cinnamon
Price may varies
ice cream flavored with ground cinnamon
0
Coconut
Price may varies
Creamy coconut based ice cream with shredded coconut
0
Coconut Almond Fudge
Price may varies
Coconut ice cream with almond pieces, chocolate chunks and chocolate fudge swirl
0
Coffee
Price may varies
If you're a coffee lover you will love this strong coffee flavored ice cream with freshly ground coffee 'specs' added
0
Coffee Cup
Price may varies
A light coffee ice cream with chopped peanut butter cups added throughout
0
Coffee & Toffee
Price may varies
A light coffee ice cream with Heath® Candy Bar pieces added throughout
0
Cookie Dough
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with cookie dough pieces and chocolate chunks
0
Cookies & Cream
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with cream filled chocolate cookie
0
Cotton Candy
Price may varies
Cotton Candy flavored ice cream with either pink or blue food coloring
0
Creme Caramel
Price may varies
Caramel based ice cream with a caramel swirl
0
Crunchy Grasshopper
Price may varies
Ice cream with Creme de Menthe for flavor and chocolate mint cookie pieces throughout
0
Dark Cherry Sorbet
Price may varies
Made with pureed bing cherries
0
Egg Nog (seasonal)
Price may varies
Egg nog ice cream with nutmeg
0
Fluffer Nutter
Price may varies
Our scrumptious peanut butter ice cream with a marshmallow swirl
0
German Chocolate
Price may varies
German chocolate based ice cream with German chocolate chunks, coconut and pecan pieces
0
Gianduia
Price may varies
Chocolate ice cream with hazelnut pieces and chocolate chunks
0
Ginger Snap
Price may varies
Our premium ice cream made by juicing fresh ginger root and adding pieces of ginger snap cookies
0
Good Life Ginger
Price may varies
Our premium ice cream made by juicing fresh ginger root from Good Life Farm in Interlaken, NY
0
Green Tea
Price may varies
Green Tea Flavored ice cream
0
Grape
Price may varies
Grape ice cream made with locally grown concord grapes
0
Hazelnut
Price may varies
Hazelnut base with chopped hazelnuts
0
Holiday Cherry Vanilla (seasonal)
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with lots of red and green maraschino cherry halves
0
Irish Cream
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with Irish Cream liqueur
0
Itty Bitty Pb Pieces
Price may varies
Vanilla based ice cream with Reese's Pieces® candies and a peanut butter swirl
0
Jalapeno Popper (seasonal)
Price may varies
A cream cheese flavored ice cream with pureed jalapeno peppers and a raspberry habanero pepper sauce swirl
0
Jittery Snickers
Price may varies
Our coffee ice cream with Snickers candy pieces
0
Junior Mint
Price may varies
Mint ice cream (we use white mint) with lots of chocolate chunks and Junior Mint candies
0
Kahlua Almond Fudge
Price may varies
Our Mocha ice cream with real Kahlua, almond pieces a fudge swirl
0
Key Lime Pie
Price may varies
Made with real key lime juice and graham cracker pieces
0
Lavender
Price may varies
Made with organic lavender
0
Lemon Sorbet
Price may varies
Made with juice of fresh lemons and lemon zest
0
Licorice
Price may varies
A black licorice flavored ice cream
0
Mango
Price may varies
Made with the finest Mango puree
0
Maple Bacon
Price may varies
Maple ice cream using New York State maple syrup and caramelized bacon
0
Maple Chestnut
Price may varies
Maple ice cream with roasted chestnuts from Goosewatch Winery
0
Maple Walnut
Price may varies
Maple ice cream using New York State maple syrup and walnuts
0
Mint Chocolate Chunk
Price may varies
Mint ice cream (we use white mint) with lots of chocolate chunks
0
Mocha Almond Fudge
Price may varies
Our mocha ice cream with almond pieces and a fudge swirl
0
Mocha Chocolate Chunk
Price may varies
Mocha Ice Cream loaded with chocolate chunks
0
Mud Pie
Price may varies
Mocha Ice Cream with graham cracker pieces and fudge swirl
0
Mudslide
Price may varies
Made with Kahlua, vodka and Irish Creme Liqueur
0
No Doze
Price may varies
Mocha ice cream with pieces of chocolate covered coffee beans
0
Nut Brown Ale
Price may varies
Beer flavored ice cream made with Ithaca Brewery Nut Brown Ale
0
Nutty Nut Brown Ale
Price may varies
Nut Brown Ale ice cream with honey roasted peanuts
0
Orange Pineapple
Price may varies
An orange pineapple flavored ice cream with a pineapple swirl
0
Orange Sorbet
Price may varies
Made with Orange juice and orange zest
0
Passionate Peanut Butter Cup
Price may varies
Peanut butter ice cream with Reese's peanut butter cup pieces, crushed peanuts and a fudge/peanut butter swirl
0
Peach Cobbler
Price may varies
Made with real peaches and graham cracker pieces
0
Peachy Keen
Price may varies
Made with real peaches
0
Peppermint Candy (seasonal)
Price may varies
Peppermint ice cream with red and green peppermint candies
0
Pina Colada Sorbet
Price may varies
Coconut flavored sorbet with pieces of pineapple
0
Pistachio
Price may varies
Pistachio flavored ice cream with no artificial coloring, and loads of pistachio pieces
0
Pralines & Cream
Price may varies
Delicious candy coated pecans in a butter pecan ice cream base with a caramel swirl
0
Pumpkin
Price may varies
Taste's just like mom's pumpkin pie
0
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Price may varies
Taste's just like mom's pumpkin pie
0
Purple Cow
Price may varies
Black raspberry ice cream with chocolate chunks
0
Red Hot Mama
Price may varies
Cinnamon ice cream with crushed Red Hot candies
0
Red Raspberry
Price may varies
Made with real red raspberries
0
Red, White & Blueberry (seasonal)
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with a strawberry and blueberry swirl
0
Rocky Road
Price may varies
Our rich chocolate ice cream with almonds, mini marshmallows and a marshmallow swirl
0
Rum Raisin
Price may varies
Ice cream with rum soaked golden raisins
0
S' mores
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with mini marshmallows, chocolate chunks, graham cracker pieces plus fudge and marshmallow swirls
0
Sea Salt Caramel
Price may varies
Caramel base ice cream with a caramel swirl and sea salt
0
Snickers
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with Snickers, chocolate chunks, crushed peanuts and caramel swirled throughout
0
Spiced Apple
Price may varies
Tastes like apple pie
0
Strawberrry
Price may varies
Strawberry ice cream with pieces of strawberries
0
Strawberry Cheesecake
Price may varies
Cheesecake flavored ice cream with strawberry swirl and graham cracker pieces
0
Strawberry Shortbread
Price may varies
Vanilla based ice cream with pieces of shortbread cookies and a strawberry swirl
0
The O.C.
Price may varies
Our chocolate ice cream with orange juice, Triple-Sec, and orange zest
0
Tiger Strips
Price may varies
Orange Flavored ice cream with a fudge swirl
0
Tiramisu
Price may varies
Just like the dessert!! Espresso based ice cream with Marsala wine soaked Lady Fingers and chocolate chunks
0
Ultimate Fudge Brownie
Price may varies
Chocolate ice cream with homemade brownie pieces, chocolate chunks and fudge swirled throughout
0
Vanilla Bean
Price may varies
We use the finest Madagascar vanilla and vanilla "specs" to make this awesome flavor
0
Vanilla Fudge
Price may varies
Our vanilla ice cream with a fudge swirl
0
Vanilla Malt W/ Whoppers
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with malt powder and whoppers
0
Watermelon Sorbet
Price may varies
A very refreshing flavor made with fresh watermelon
0
WCRT
Price may varies
White chocolate ice cream with white chocolate chunks and red raspberry swirled throughout
0
White Gold
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with cookie dough pieces, white chocolate chunks and caramel swirled throughout
0
White Out
Price may varies
Vanilla ice cream with white chocolate chunks
0
White Russian (seasonal)
Price may varies
If you like the drink you're sure to like this flavor made with real Vodka and Kahlua, and white chocolate chunks
0
Wine Sorbets
Americana Vineyard Barn Raising Red Dark Cherry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Americana Vineyard Sweet Rosie Strawberry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Buttonwood Grove Winery Reisling Orange Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Buttonwood Grove Winery Blackberry Briar Blackberry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Cayuga Ridge Estate Winery Cranberry Essence Orange Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Cobblestone Farm Winery Merlot Dark Cherry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Goose Watch Winery Strawberry Splendor Strawberry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Goose Watch Winery Melody Lemon Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Lucas Vineyard Riesling Orange Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Montezuma Winery Cranberry Bog Orange Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Montezuma Winery Northern Harrier Dark Cherry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Sheldrake Point Vineyard Summer Blush Chocolate Ice Cream
Price may varies
0
Sheldrake Point Vineyard Reisling Raspberry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Six Mile Creek Vineyard Dolce Vita Raspberry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Swedish Hill Vineyard Doobie Blues Orange Sorbet
Price may varies
0
King Ferry Winery Merlot Raspberry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
King Ferry Winery Mystere Raspberry Sorbet
Price may varies
0
Food
1/4 Lb Hamburger or Vegi-burger
$5.25
0
Chicken Sandwich
$5.75
Crispy, Grilled or Buffalo
0
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
$6.25
0
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich
$6.25
0
Fried Haddock Sandwich
$6.75
0
Pulled Pork Sandwich
$5.75
0
Fried Clam Basket or Clam Roll
$5.50
0
Garden Salad
$5.25
0
Crispy Chicken Salad
$7.50
0
BLT
$5.25
0
Hofmann Hot Dog
$3.50
Red or White
0
Chili Dog
$4.25
0
Cheese Dog
$4.25
0
Chili Cheese Dog
$5.00
0
Grilled Cheese
$3.00
0
Macaroni And Cheese
$3.75
0
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
$5.75
0
Hot-zzarella Cheese Sticks
$6.50
0
Sweet Potato Fries
$4.00
0
Onion "Straws"
$4.25
0
Fried Green Beans
$3.00
0
French Fries
$2.50
0
Chili Cheese Fries
$4.00
0
Nachos & Cheese
$3.75
0
DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.
People Are Reading
Popular Brands
-
Applebee's Menu2.7 -
Arby's Menu3.7 -
Burger King Menu3.4 -
Chick-fil-A Menu3.8 -
-
Cook Out Menu1.5 -
-
-
KFC Menu3.2 -
McDonald's Menu2.9 -
-
-
Pizza Hut Menu3.3 -
-
Wendy's Menu2.9 -
-
Red Lobster Menu1.4 -
-
-
