Caroline's By The Bay Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 172 votes
Caroline's By The Bay Logo
Burger
Pizza
Sandwiches

Choose My State

NJ

Caroline's By The Bay Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


EntreesServed with soup or salad

Chicken Marsala

$14.95

Sauteed chicken in our porcini mushroom sundried tomato marsala wine sauce

Amanda’s Chicken Picatta

$14.95

Chicken sauteed in our lemon caper butter wine sauce with mushrooms and cherry tomatoes

Orange Chicken & Shrimp Jubilee

$16.95

Chicken and shrimp sauteed in our grab mariner orange basil butter sauce and topped with scallions

10oz Filet Mignon

$21.95

Served with potato and vegetables

Braised Beef

$15.95

Our braised beef topped with our cognac demiglaze with carrots, celery and potatoes

Veal Angelina

$19.95

Veal sauteed in our cognac demi glaze topped with crab,mozzarella and shrimp

Stuffed Pork Tenderloin

$18.95

Pork tenderloin stuffed with spinach, roasted peppers and provolone topped with our porcini mushroom demi glaze

Lemon BBQ Chops

$14.95

Two 6oz. pork chops braised in our lemon BBQ sauce


Entree Sides

Baked Potato

$2.50

Roasted Beet with Gorgonzola

$2.99

Red Roasted Potatoes

$2.50

Garlic Green Beans

$2.99

Glazed Apricot Garlic Ginger Carrots

$2.50

Lemon Butter Asparagus

$2.99

Combo- Vegetables and Potatoes

$4.00


PastaServed with soup or salad

Jessica’s Penne Ala Vodka

$13.95

Penne pasta tossed in our very own vodka blush sauce with peas & prosciutto. Add shrimp 5.00, add chicken 3.00

Rigatoni Bolognese

$14.95

Rigatoni pasta tossed with our homemade short rib meat sauce with celery onion & carrot

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$12.95

Linguini & Clams in Anchovy Sauce

$16.95

Dozen clams sauteed in garlic wine anchovy sauce with cherry tomatoes and scallions tossed with linguini

Seafood Fra Diavlo

$22.95

Clams, mussels, shrimp, scallops sauteed in spicy marinara tossed with linguini. Any one type of seafood from the top $15.95

Lobster Cappallini

$19.95

Lobster meat sauteed in a pesto cream sauce with cherry tomatoes and tossed with angel hair pasta


Hot SandwichesServed with pickle spear. Add chips & coleslaw $1.50 add french fries $1.50 add sweet potato french fries $2.00 add onion rings $2.00 add specialty fry $3.00

8oz Grilled Chicken or Beef Burger

$6.00

Choose your toppings $0.50 cheese cheddar, american, swiss, mozzarella, pepper jack provolone, blue cheese toppings lettuce, tomato, onion, fried onion, mushroom, jalapeno, red pepper, green pepper

Spinach, Bacon, Long Hots or Broccoli Rabe

$1.00

Garlic Bread Chicken or Beef Cheesesteak

$7.50

Our marinated 8oz. sirloin steak or 8oz. chicken breast on crunchy garlic bread with new yorkewr american cheese. Toppings extra $0.50

Beef Cheesesteak

$7.50

Our marinated 8oz. sirloin steak or 8oz chicken breast on crunchy garlic bread with new yorker. American cheese. Toppings xtra $0.50

Roast Pork Italiano

$7.50

Homemade roast pork with sharp provolone spinach, roasted red peppers on long roll with side of au jus. Add long hots 1.00

French Dip

$7.95

Our homemade eye round with provolone on long roll with side of au jus

Grilled Reuben

$7.50

8oz. corned beef, swiss, sauer kraut & russian dressing on grilled rye dressing on grilled rye

Buffalo Flounder

$8.95

4 oz. fried flounder topped with american cheese lettuce, tomato, hot sauce & bleu cheese on brioche bun

Crabcake Seaside

$9.95

5 oz. crab cake topped with lettuce,tomato,onion lemon dill tartar on brioche bun

The Salmon

$9.95

6 oz. salmon filet grilled with lemon pepper & topped with arugula, tomato & lemon dill mayo on brioche bunb

Chicken Toasty

$6.95

Chicken salad, bacon, tomato & swiss on grilled sourdough

Missy Melt

$7.00

Tuna salad, swiss, bacon & tomato on grilled sourdough

Three Cheese Ham & Turkey Meltdown

$7.95

Provolone, cheddar,american,ham & turkey on grilled sourdough

BBQ Beef

$7.95

Our homemade eye round sliced thin, grilled with BBQ sauce wisconsin cheddar and topped with fried onions on a brioche bun

BBQ Pork

$7.95

Our homemade pork loin sliced thin and grilled with BBQ sauce then topped with texas slaw on brioche bun


Cold Sandwich & WrapYour choice of meat, cheese & bread served with pickle spear

Chefs Club

$8.95

Turke, ham, roast beef, swiss cheese on your choice of bread with bacon, mayo lettuce & tomato

Italian Sliders

$6.95

Prosciutto, provolone, salami & cappacola with pesto & red peppers on our fresh homemade rolls

Cold Cutlet Italiano

$7.95

Cold chicken cutlet, sharp provolone, prosciutto & arugula with lemon basil vinaigrette on homemade foccacia

Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato

$7.95

Fresh mozzarella & tomato with a basil mayo on homemade foccacia

Corned Beef Special

$7.95

6 oz. of our homemade corn beef, swiss cheese, coleslaw & russian dressing on rye

Wraps & Sandwiches

$7.50

With cheese lettuce & tomato. Choice of ham, turkey, roast beef, tuna salad, egg salad, mixed cheese

Shrimp Salad

$12.95

Crab Salad

$12.95

Shrimp Salad

$12.95

Crab Salad

$12.95


PizzaRed or white

Plain Pizza 12

$6.25

Plain pizza 16

$10.00


Calzone & Stromboli

Calzone

$5.25

Ricotta and mozzarella cheeses

8” Stromboli

$6.75

Cheese and sauce


Pizza - Toppings

Meats

$2.00

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, meatballs, ground beef

Premium Meats

$2.25 - $3.50

Chicken & steak

Seafood

$3.50 - $6.00

Shrimp, chopped clames,crab

Seafood

$3.00 - $5.00

Shrimp, chopped clams,crab

veggies

$2.00

Broccoli mushrooms, onions, spinach, tomato,artichokes, olives,peppers and longhots


SeafoodServed with soup or salad

Crabcakes

$18.95

Two 5 oz. crabcakes seared & broiled toperfection

Crab & Lobster Imperial

$17.95

A blend of lobster & crab in our special cream mix and baked in oven till golden brown with breadcrumb topping

Shrimp & Scallop Italiano

$19.95

Jumbo shrimp & large scallops sautéed in garlic butter wine sauce with artichoke, spinach & cherry tomatoes

Flounder Francaise

$16.95

2 eggs battered flounder sauteed in a lemon wine butter sauce with spinach & cherry tomatoes

Lemon Dill Salmon

$17.95

8oz Grilled salmon topped with lemon butter dill sauce with cherry tomatoes

Stuffed Calamari

$17.95

2 squid heads stuffed with sausage and shrimp braised in our special seafood marinara

Citrus Tilapia

$14.95

8oz tilapia sauteed in our champagne citrus crab sauce with mixed peppers and scallions

Spicy Combo

$24.95

Shrimp, scallops, calamari mixed with hot pepper paste, garlic & basil broiled in oven

Roasted Garlic Lemon Basil Lobster Tail

Price may varies

8oz Lobster tail broiled with roasted garlic lemon basil butter, served with potato and veggies

Shrimp Scampi

$15.95

Jumbo Shrimp sauteed in lemon garlic butter wine sauce tossed with linguini


Appetizers

Fried Mozzarella

$6.95

5 homemade breaded buffalo mozzarella triangles with side of marinara

Garlic Buds

$6.95

Deep fried pizza dough balls smothered in garlic, oil & parmesan with side of marinara

Chili Con Queso Dip with Chips

$7.95

Our homemade chili mixed with cheddar cheese, topped with scallions, sour cream & served with homemade corn chips

Stuffed Banana Peppers

$6.95

2 large banana peppers stuffed with homemade cheese stuffing and baked in oven

Bruschetta Platter

$7.95

Homemade parmesan crostinis served with a bruschetta salad

Eggplant Rollitini

$7.95

3 egg battered & fried eggplant stuffed with ricotta cheese blend topped with marinara & mozzarella than baked to perfection

Three Cheese Spinach & Artichoke Dip with Crostinis

$8.95

Our special blend of cheeses, spinach & artichokes in a crock & baked served with parmesan crostinis add crab $5.00 extra


Seafood Starters

Deb’s Stuffed Clams

$9.95

6 clams stuffed with spinach, bacon, onions &cheese then baked, served with lemon

Coconut Shrimp

$11.95

5 jumbo shrimp in coconut breading and fried. Served with red pepper jam

Shrimp Cocktail

$10.95

5 jumbo shrimp steamed and served with cocktail sauce & lemon

Scallops and Bacon

$12.95

5 large scallop wrapped in bacon & baked. Served with lemon basil cream sauce

Steamers

$10.00

Dozen middleneck clams steamed & butter & lemon

Clams White

$10.95

Dozen clams sauteed in a garlic white wine sauce & topped with scallions

Mussels Red

$10.95

Two dozen mussels sauteed in a spicy marinara & topped with parsley

Lobster Crab Balls

$9.95

5 lobster & crab hand rolled & breaded, then deep fried & served with lemon scallion dijonaise

Fried Oysters

$10.00

Basket full of fried oysters served with buffalo cocktail sauce


Salads

Garden Salad

$5.95

Caesar Salad

$5.95

Spinach Salad

$6.95

With mushrooms, bacon, red onion, tomatoes & hard boiled egg

Fresh Mozzarella, Basil & Tomato

$8.95

With red onion, tossed with lemon garlic vinaigrette

Waldorf Salad

$7.95

Chicken, grapes, apple, craisins, walnuts in a house blend dressing over mixed greens

Pesto Shrimp Salad

$11.95

5 shrimp dipped in pesto over a bed of cucumber tomato avocado & fresh mozzarella served with lemon basil vinaigrette

Steak & Tomato

$12.95

Thin sliced steak topped on a bed of balsamic tomatoes, red onion, fresh mozzarella & Romaine lettuce.

Crab & Shrimp Salad

$14.95

Steamed shrimp, lump crab mixed with celery & red onion in a lemon in a basil vinaigrette over a fresh garden salad


Soups

French Onion

$5.95

Seafood Soup

$4.00 - $7.00

Chili

$3.00 - $5.00

Soup of the Day

$2.50 - $4.00


Wings, Bites & Tenders

(10) Wings w/blue cheese & celery

$7.95

(20) Wings w/blue cheese & celery

$14.95

(5) Tenders w/blue cheese & celery

$7.95

(10) Tenders w/blue cheese & celery

$14.95

Basket of Bites

$7.95

Extra blue cheese $0.50 xtra celery $0.50 xtra sauce $0.50


Chowders

New England Clam Chowder

$12.95

Scratch made chowder with potatoes, celery, bacon & scallions

Oyster Chowder

$12.95

Scratch made chowder with potatoes, celery, bacon & scallions

Jersey Flounder Chowder

$14.95

Fresh founder cubes stewed in a red seafood broth with potatoes, celery, scallions & peppers


Parmigiana DishesAll dishes served with soup or salad and linguini pasta

Chicken

$14.95

Eggplant

$14.95

Veal

$17.95

Veal

$17.95


BasketsServed with french fries, coleslaw, lemon & pickle

(6) Fried Shrimp

$11.95

(2) Fried Flounder

$10.95

Fish & Chips

$10.95

(4) Chicken Tenders

$9.95

Fried Oysters

$10.95


Specialty Pizza

Margherita

$7.95 - $11.95

Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, pizza sauce and roasted garlic oil

Meatlovers

$11.50 - $16.95

Ham, bacon, pepperoni, sausage and meatballs

Veggie

$11.50 - $16.95

Broccoli, spinach, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions and peppers on our garlic white pie

Sausage Peppers & Onions

$9.00 - $13.95

Our homemade cooked sausage mixed peppers and vidalia onionsand vidalia onions

Hot Sausage, Longhots & Onions

$9.00 - $13.95

Our homemade cooked hot italian sausage, longhota and onions

Crispy Buffalo Chicken

$10.00 - $14.95

Crispy buffalo tenders chopped with our hot sauce and crumbled bleu cheese

South Western Beef

$12.50 - $17.95

Our chopped eye round with peppers, bacon, BBQ sauce, onions, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses

Mediterranean

$12.50 - $17.95

Grilled chicken, mozzarella,feta,red peppers spinach and onions spinach and onions

Tomato Pie

$7.25 - $11.00

An upside down pizza with provolone cheese on the bottom topped with sauce, parmesan cheese and roasted garlic oil

Cheese Steak

$11.00 - $15.95

Our premium steak with american and mozzarella cheeses and onions on our white garlic pizza

Cheeseburger

$11.50 - $16.95

Ground beef, cheddar and mozzarella on our red pie topped with lettuce, tomato and onions

Spinach, Shrimp & Crab

$13.95 - $19.95

Spinach shrimp and crab on our garlic white pie

Clam, Tomato & Artichoke

$12.50 - $18.95

4 Cheese White

$9.95 - $13.95

Provolone, mozzarella, parmesan and ricotta cheeses

Shrimp and Lobster

$14.95 - $22.00

Shrimp and lobster meat with prosciutto & mozzarella on our pesto sauce pizza with grape tomatoes


Sides

French Fry

$4.00

Cheese Fry

$5.00

Loaded Fries

$6.25

Bacon, cheddar, ranch & scallions

Chili Cheese Fry

$5.95

Gravy Fry

$4.75

Onion Rings

$4.75

Garlic Bread

$2.50

Sweet Potato Fry

$4.95

Buffalo Fry

$6.95

Chicken, hot sauce, blue cheese &celery seed

Corn Nuggets

$5.95

Fried Green Beans

$5.95


Kids Menu

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$6.95

Grilled Cheese & French Fries

$6.95

(2) Chicken Tenders & French Fries

$6.95

(3) Fried Shrimp & French Fries

$6.95

Ham & Cheese (Hot or Cold) with Chips & Pickle

$6.95


Desserts

Assorted Desserts

$4.95 - $5.95


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading