Menu With Price > Menu > Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop

Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 61 votes

Pizza

Sandwiches

Calzones

Choose My State

Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Fresh SaladsDressings: Italian, ranch, honey mustard, french, thousand island, wild raspberry, sweet & sour.

Small Salad

$3.25

Fresh Garden Salad (Large)

$4.99

Super Salad

$7.25

Greek Salad

$7.25

Club Salad

$7.25

Antipasto Salad

$7.25

Greek Chicken Salad

$8.25

Grilled Steak Salad

$8.25

Chicken Caesar Salad

$8.25

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$9.25

Pasta DinnersAll dinners Served with garlic toast

Penne & Marmara Sauce

$5.25

Add a meatball $1.50, add pepperoni or sausage sauce $1.50.

Meatball Casserole w/Garlic Toast

$6.75

3 Meatballs, melted provolone & mozzarella

Stuffed Shells w/Garlic Toast

$7.25

With ricotta cheese, 4 jumbo shells

Eggplant Parmesan

$7.25

Served over spaghetti w/garlic toast

Chicken Parmesan

$7.25

Served over spaghetti w/garlic toast

Side of Meatballs

$1.75

Available with pasta dinners only

Side of Sausage

$3.25

Available with pasta dinners only

Fun Foods

Meaty Wings

$5.25 - $8.75

Homemade sauces: Buffalo, BBQ, garlic butter, season, salt & garlic butter

Small French Fries

$3.00 - $4.25

Nacho cheese, bacon or beef gravy $2.00

Breadsticks

$4.25

W/ marinara sauce or garlic butter

Cheesy Garlic Toast (1 Pcs)

$1.50

Garlic Toast (1 Pcs)

$0.99

Loaf of Garlic Bread

$3.75

12" Pepperoni Roll or Jalapeno Roll

$7.25

Provolone Wedges

$5.25

Fried Mushrooms

$5.25

Onion Rings

$4.25

Jalapeno Poppers

$5.25

Battered Dipped Zucchini Strips

$4.99

Chicken Tenders w/ Fries

$8.25

Single Cuts (Traditional)

$1.85

Toppings $0.49 extra

Hot Pocket WedgeAll pocket sandwiches made homemade dough & served with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo or homemade italian dressing. Add the works $1.75 Sauteed onions, mushrooms, hot peppers, green onions

Pepperoni

$8.99

Grilled Chicken

$8.99

Turkey

$8.99

Italian

$8.99

Club

$8.99

Veggie

$8.99

Philly Steak

$8.99

Steak

$8.99

Ham

$8.99

Deli SandwichesIncludes pickle and chips.

Rueben

$7.99

Turkey

$7.99

Corned Beef

$7.99

Tuna

$7.99

Gyros and WrapsLamb or beef gyro

Turkey

$5.50

Veggie

$5.50

Grilled Steak

$5.50

Italian

$5.50

Grilled Chicken

$5.50

Chicken Caesar

$5.50

Focaccia SandwichesAll sandwiches served on homemade seasoned square sliced focaccia bread with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo or homemade italian dressing. Add the works $0.99 sauteed onions, mushrooms, hot peppers, green onions

Pepperoni

$7.99

Grilled Chicken

$7.99

Turkey

$7.99

Italian

$7.99

Club

$7.99

Veggie

$7.99

Philly Steak

$7.99

Steak

$7.99

Ham

$7.99

Oven Baked HoagiesAll hoagies served with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & hoagie dressing and mayonnaise. Lt. mayo is also available. Add the works: Sauteed onions, hot peppers, mushrooms & green peppers: half $1.25 ea, whole $1.75 ea. Extra: meat - whole $2.75

Italian

$5.25 - $8.75

Steak

$5.25 - $8.75

Meatball

$5.25 - $8.75

Veggie

$5.25 - $8.75

Eggplant Parmigiana

$5.25 - $8.75

Chicken Parmigiana

$5.25 - $8.75

Ham & Cheese

$5.25 - $8.75

Egg & Pepperoni

$5.25 - $8.75

Turkey

$5.25 - $8.75

Egg & Hot Pepper

$5.25 - $8.75

Egg & Sweet Pepper

$5.25 - $8.75

Cheese Hoagie

$5.25 - $8.75

Philly Steak

$5.50 - $9.25

Fried onions, cheddar cheese, mushrooms

Club

$5.50 - $9.25

Turkey, ham, bacon

Buffalo Chicken

$5.50 - $9.25

Cheeseburger

$5.50 - $9.25

Roethlisberger

$5.50 - $9.25

Hot Sausage

$5.50 - $9.25

Grilled Chicken

$5.50 - $9.50

Fish

$9.50

Sicilian PizzaSquare cut pizza. Topping: Whole 16 cut $2.50, half 8 cut $1.99.

Sicilian Pizza

$13.25 - $9.25

Traditional Red or White PizzaToppings: Pepperoni, sausage, ham, jalapeno peppers, anchovies, green & hot peppers, tomato, extra sauce. New topping - roasted red peppers. Toppings: Small 4 cut $1.50, medium 8 cut $1.85, large 10 cut $2.00, x-large 12 cut $2.25.

Traditional Red or White Pizza

$4.99 - $10.50

Specialty Pizzaoriginal or white. Toppings: Roasted red pepper & chicken, spinach & tomato, steak & mushroom, ricotta & tomato, hawaiian, cheeseburger w/bacon, philly steak, spinach and ricotta, barbecue chicken & bacon, buffalo ranch chicken, greek,

Specialty Pizza

$7.99 - $16.99

Calzones & StombolisCalzones include ricotta cheese. Add the works: sauteed onions, hot peppers, mushrooms & green peppers $1.50, side sauce & garlic butter $0.99.

House (Pepperoni & Sausage)

$9.25 - $8.25

Mushroom & Cheese

$9.25 - $8.25

Veggie Combination

$9.25 - $8.25

Cheese

$9.25 - $8.25

Steak

$9.25 - $8.25

Meatball

$9.25 - $8.25

Italian

$9.25 - $8.25

Pepperoni

$9.25 - $8.25

Spinach

$9.25 - $8.25

Lunch MenuAvailable 11 am-2 pm mon-fri.

Small 1 Topping Pizza & Can of Pop

$6.50

Homemade Focaccia

$6.50

Half Hoagie Gyro or Wrap

$5.50

Pasta

$5.25

With marinara sauce & garlic toast

2 Slices of Cheese Pizza & Small Salad or Fries

$5.50

1 Slice of Cheese Pizza & Small Salad or Fries

$4.50

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.