Carnegie on 57 Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 66 votes
Carnegie on 57 Logo

Choose My State

NY

Carnegie on 57 Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


SaladServed with garlic bread lunch

Carnegie Mixed Greens

$7.99

Fresh blended greens with tomatoes, olives cheddar jack cheese homemade croutons

Loaded Taco Salad

$9.99 - $12.99

Fresh blend green topped with seasoned beef, sliced black olives, jalos, tomatoes and cheddar jack cheese served in a tortilla shell bowl

Fresh Blend Greens

$11.99 - $14.99

Provolone, portico salami, roasted re peppers, onions, olives hard boiled egg and banana peppers

Carnegie Ceasar

$9.99

Add chicken $13.50 add shrimp $16.50

Carnegie Chicken Ceasar

$9.99

Pub Steak Salad

$10.99 - $14.99

Sliced steak, red onion, roasted red peppers, crumbly bleu, Idaho fries, pilled high on mixed greens

Spring Craisin Chicken Salad

$8.99 - $11.99

Fresh greens with grilled chicken, raisins, strawberries, cheddar jack cheese, almonds tomato and parmesan cheese

Fresh Spinach Salad

$8.99 - $11.99

Fresh spinach, topped chopped egg, bacon bits, strawberries, almonds, red onion and croutons served with warm bacon vinaigrette

Asian Salmon Salad

$14.99

Fresh green with pan seared jail island salmon with citrus five spice, red peppers, almonds and chow mien noodles


Small Plates

Soup of the Day

$2.99 - $4.99

Maple Glazed Double Cut Bacon

$10.99

Double cut bacon strips with black pepper and pure maple syrup

Roman Aspargus

$8.99

Grilled asparagus topped with a fried egg and fontina and bacon

Boneless Chicken Tenders

$7.99

5 With BBQ sauce

Poutine

$6.99

Handcut idaho fries topped with mozzarella and housemate beef gravy

Maryland Crab Cakes

$12.99

Fresh lump crabmeat, red onion, peppers and panic breadcrumbs served with remoulade

Calamari Fritti

$9.99

With region and red sauce

Angles on Horseback

$14.99

Bacon wrapped jumbo scrip stuffed with horseradish served with one mustard and fresh lemon

Clams Casino

$9.99

Traditional homemade casino on the half shell topped with pancetta butter

Polpette By Johnny Meatballs

$8.99

4 Grilled hand pressed meatballs with homemade red sauce

XXL Onion Ring Platter

$6.99

With spicy dipping sauce

Fried Mozzerella

$7.99

Served with homemade marinara

Nacho Supreme

$8.99

Freshly make nacho chips topped with ground beef, black olives, jalos, diced red onions, smothered with melted cheddar jack cheese and pico de gallo

Cheese, Chicken or Beef Queso

$10.99

Large flour tortilla generously stuffed with cheddar jack cheese, freshly made pico gallo and your choice of chicken or beef of just cheese

Northside Greens

$8.99

Prosciutto, camelized onions, diced cherry peppers, garlic and white wine, topped with romano cheese

Carnegie's Turkey Club

$8.99

Roast turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon and mayo, piled high on your choice of bread

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$8.99

Grilled chicken breast with Apple wood smoked bacon and homemade race with lettuce in a grilled garlic herb wrap

Meatball Sandwich

$8.99

Grilled hoagie stuffed with three of our award winning meatballs, red sauce and fresh mozzarella

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$8.99

Grilled chicken, lettuce tomato asiago cheese caesar dressing in a garlic herb wrap

The Reuben

$9.99

Traditional corned beef, swiss cheese, sauerkraut and 1,000 island dressing served on grilled rye bread

Philly Cheese Steak

$9.99

Slow roasted eye of round with mushrooms, onions and peppers topped with melted cheddar jack served on a hoagie roll

Open-Face Rib Eye Steak Sandwich

$9.99

Hand sliced rib eye steak served open face on grilled Italian bread topped with frizzed onions

Tuscan Panini

$9.99

Fresh spinach, capital, salami, provolone and roasted red onion on grilled pita bread

Karen's Fried Egg with Greens

$9.99

Grilled, Northside greens, fried egg and capital on a grilled egg roll

Connie's Turkey and Cranberry

$8.99

Oven roast turkey breast, lettuce and cranberry mayo on grilled white bread


Artisan PizzaChoice of flatbread $10.99 or traditional $14.99

Garlic 4 Cheese

Price may varies

Rubbed with garlic butter, topped with mozzarella, asiago, parmesan and fontina cheeses

Margahetta

Price may varies

Brushed with garlic and herb butter topped with fresh basil, mozzarella cheese and sliced roam tomato

Buffalo Bleu Cheese

Price may varies

Served mild or hot, topped with grilled chicken, diced celery, mozzarella and crumbly bleu cheese

New York Veggie

Price may varies

Homemade tomato sauce, red and green peppers, onion, tomato broccoli, mushrooms and mozzarella

Build Your Own Pizza

Price may varies

Our own homemade tomato sauce, mozzarella plus your choice of two toppings. Sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onions, mushrooms, banana peppers, black olives, bacon, meatballs, prosciutto, tomato, salami,


CalzonesFillings: Pepperoni, sausage, black olives, banana peppers, mushrooms, onions, red peppers, brocoli, red sauce, chicken, bacon, jalopeno, meatballs, orosciutto, tomato, salami, garlic, cherry peppers. Jumbo $2.95 small $1.00

Bob's Jumbo Calzone

$21.99

Stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella and 2 complimentary fillings

Calzone for One

$10.99

Stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella and 2 complimentary fillings


Jumbo Chicken WingsBreaded or naked

10 Wings

$10.99

Mild, hot, garlic parmesan, BBQ, chargrilled

20 Wings

$18.99

Mild, hot, garlic parmesan, BBQ chargrilled


Steak BurgersAll burgers come with Idaho fries. Can add sweet potato fries $1.00

Black Angus Roman

$8.99

Topped with a fried egg

Black & Bleu Burger

$9.99

Rubbed with paul prudhomme's black magic seasoning and topped with crumbly bleu cheese

Portobello & Swiss

$10.99

Topped with sliced portobello mushrooms and melted swiss cheese

Carnegie's Cheddar Bomb

$8.99

Smothered with a crisp melted cheddar cheese black angus burger

Black Angus Burger

$8.99

Topped with american cheese


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading