Carnegie Deli Menu and Prices
Deli Food
Sandwiches
Choose My State
Carnegie Deli Menu
Last Update: 2025-03-14
Salad Stars
Sarri's Combination Fish Platter
$37.99
Slices of sturgeon, novie salmon, smoked white fish & baked salmon. served with lettuce, tomato, onion, cream cheese, & a ny bagel or two on the side
0
Central Park
$12.99
Tossed garden salad bowl with tomato, onion, & cucumber. Add grilled chicken breast $17.99
0
Julienne Child Chef's Salad Bowl
$19.99
Roast beef, turkey, swiss cheese & tomato over a tossed garden salad bowl
0
Zorba The Greek
$17.99
Tossed garden salad with tomato, feta cheese, chopped vegetables, & olives. Add grilled chicken breast $22.99
0
Carnegie Deli Salad
$19.99
Salami, turkey, bacon, american cheese, tomato & onion over a tossed garden salad bowl
0
Hail Caesar Salad
$12.99
Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese & croutons with caesar dressing on the side. Add grilled chicken breast $17.99
0
Salad PlattersServed with tossed mixed greens. Sharing add $3.00
George Shrimpton
$23.99
Fresh shrimp salad with hard boiled egg
0
Homemade Chicken, Tuna, Or Egg Salad
$18.99
Prepared fresh daily in our kitchen
0
Hudson Liver
$22.99
Homemade chopped liver
0
Carnegie Whitefish Salad
$20.99
Creamy & delicious
0
Whitey Fish
$23.99
Large chunk of smoked Whitefish
0
Soup
Our Homemade Chicken Soup - Light & Fluffy Matzoh Balls
$9.99
0
Our Homemade Chicken Soup - Matzoh Balls & Golden Noodles
$10.99
0
Our Homemade Chicken Soup - Golden Noodles
$8.99
0
Our Homemade Chicken Soup - Kasha
$7.99
0
Our Traditional Hot Or Cold Borscht
$8.99
Served with sour cream, boiled potato, or chopped vegetables. Add $2.00 per additional item.
0
Soup Of The Day
$7.99
0
Matzah Ball Soup
$5.99
0
Salad Sandwiches
Whitefish Salad
$15.99
0
Chicken Salad
$13.99
0
Shrimp Salad
$15.99
0
Tuna Salad
$13.99
0
Tuna Melt
$16.99
0
Egg Salad
$13.99
0
Classic Deli Sandwiches
The Woody Allen
$29.99
0
Carnegie Famous Reuben
$29.99
Our famous open-style sandwich piled high with your choice of corned beef, pastrami or turkey. Topped with melted finlandia swiss cheese & sauerkraut
0
New York's Best
Milton's Smorgasboard
$29.99
Four freshly baked miniature rolls individually stuffed with shrimp salad, tuna salad, chicken salad, & egg salad served with lettuce, tomato, onion & sweet red pepper
0
Carnegie Deli Corned Beef
$19.99
0
Carnegie Deli Hot Pastrami
$19.99
0
Carnegie Deli Brisket
$19.99
0
Carnegie Deli Roast Beef
$19.99
0
Beef Tongue
$19.99
0
Turkey
$19.99
0
Chopped Liver
$17.99
0
Bologna Or Salami
$17.99
0
Hard Salami
$17.99
0
Blt (Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato)
$17.99
0
Liverwurst
$17.99
0
Gargantuan Combos
Barrys Delight
$29.99
Triple decker turkey, corned beef & tongue served with cole slaw & russian dressing
0
Carnegie Haul
$29.99
Triple decker pastrami, tongue & salami topped with relish
0
Tongues For The Memory
$29.99
Tongue, corned beef & swiss cheese served with cole slaw & russian dressing
0
Beef Encounter
$29.99
Triple decker roast beef, chopped liver & sliced onion
0
Novie On Sunday
$29.99
Novie salmon, sturgeon, cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & capers
0
Bagelicious
$29.99
Novie salmon & cream cheese, served on a jumbo toasted bagel with lettuce, tomato, onion, & capers
0
Fifty Ways To Love Your Liver
$24.99
Chopped liver, hard boiled egg, lettuce, tomato & onion
0
The Mouth That Roared
$24.99
Roast beef, lettuce, tomato & onion
0
Big Macher Turkey Club
$27.99
Triple decker turkey with crisp bacon, lettuce & tomato on white toast
0
Chicken & Bacon Whoopee
$27.99
Triple decker chicken salad with crisp bacon, lettuce & tomato on white toast
0
Jeffrey Ps Tatalah
$27.99
Turkey, corned beef & Swiss cheese on pumpernickel with cole slaw & russian dressing
0
Brisketball
$29.99
Brisket of beef and turkey with lettuce, tomato & onion
0
A Little Treat Before You Eat
Pickled Herring
$7.99
Served with lettuce and tomato
0
Chopped Liver
$16.99
Served with lettuce and tomato
0
Gelfite Fish
$7.99
Served with horseradish, lettuce, and tomato
0
Stuffed Cabbage
$9.99
0
Stuffed Derma
$9.99
0
Kasha Varnishkas
$7.99
0
Specialty Sandwiches - Beetween the Slice
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
$17.99
0
Baked Virginia Ham
$16.99
0
Broiled Or Fried Flounder Sandwich
$17.99
0
Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
Choice Of Melted American, Swiss, Or Cheddar
$9.99
Add tomato $2.00, add bacon $5.00, Extra cheese add $3.00
0
Deli & Egg Sandwiches3 eggs omelet style. Cheese on sandwich add $3.00
Delicatessen Omelette Sandwich
$14.99
Stuffed with pastrami, corned beef & brisket
0
Corned Beef & Egg Sandwich
$13.99
0
Pastrami & Egg Sandwich
$13.99
0
Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$11.99
0
Salami & Egg Sandwich
$12.99
0
Bologna & Egg Sandwich
$12.99
0
Baked Virginia Ham & Egg Sandwich
$13.99
0
Peppers, Onions & Egg Sandwich
$12.99
0
Bacon & Egg Sandwich
$13.99
0
Tongue & Egg Sandwich
$14.99
0
In The Heat Of The Sandwich
Nosh, Nosh Nanette
$24.99
Hot turkey with gravy, cranberry sauce & choice of potato
0
Beefamania
$24.99
Hot roast beef with gravy & choice of potato
0
Lil' Abner
$24.99
Hot brisket of beef with gravy & choice of potato
0
Hamalot
$24.99
Hot virginia baked ham with gravy & choice of potato
0
Cold Cuts PlatterServed with potato salad & cole slaw. Choice of any 3 three meats
Pastrami
$29.99
0
Roast Beef
$29.99
0
Tongue
$29.99
0
Corned Beef
$29.99
0
Brisket
$29.99
0
Turkey
$29.99
0
Burgers, Franks & Other SpecialsSharing add $3.00 add ons add melted cheese $3.00, add sauteed onion $2.00, add crisp bacon strips $5.00
Carnegie s Famous Hamburger
$11.99
0
(3) Three Hamburger Sliders
$12.99
0
Marians Favorite Deli Burger
$13.99
Topped with corned beef or pastrami
0
Rubys Turkey Burger
$11.99
0
Jumbo Veggie Burger
$11.99
0
Frankfurters & More
All Beef footlong
$8.99
Grilled frankfurter on a toasted bun with hot sauerkraut
0
Grilled Knock Wurst Specials
$10.99
Served on a roll with hot sauerkraut
0
Carnegie s Mac & Cheese
$8.99
With corned beef or pastrami bits add $2.00
0
Chicken Tenders
$9.99
Beginners course for the young deli eater
0
The Carnegie Knish & Meat Combo
$25.99
Our homemade potato knish served open style with pastrami or corned beef
0
Mr. Parker's Favorites
Prime Brisket Of Beef Pot Roast
$24.99
In our homemade brown gravy w/ choice of potato & vegetable
0
Homemade Meatloaf
$19.99
Served w/choice of potato & vegetable
0
Baked Short Ribs Of Beef
$23.99
Served w/choice of potato & vegetable
0
Chantys Roast Turkey Dinner
$24.99
Served with stuffing, gravy, sweet potato, fresh vegetables & cranberry sauce
0
Corned Beef Or Pastrami Hash
$19.99
Made to order & topped with one egg any style
0
Roast 1/2 Chicken
$19.99
Served w/choice of potato & vegetable
0
Old Fashioned Chicken In The Pot
$29.99
½ chicken in our homemade consomme soup served with matzoh ball, noodles & fresh vegetables
0
Marians Midnight Specials
$19.99
Two all beef knockwurst specials served with sauerkraut & baked beans
0
Millies Stuffed Cabbage
$20.99
Topped with sweet & sour sauce
0
Chicken Breast Dinner
$19.99
Served w/choice of potato & vegetable
0
Roast Beef Dinner
$22.99
Served w/choice of potato & vegetable
0
Hot Tongue Platter
$22.99
In our famous sweet & sour gravy
0
Treats From The SeaAdd $3.00
Broiled Salmon
$24.99
With a dill butter sauce w/choice of potato & vegetable
0
Broiled or Fried Filet of Flounder
$19.99
A fresh filet with tartar sauce w/ choice of potato & vegetable
0
Deli-Cious Smoked Fish Platters
Ovie Salmon
$26.99
0
Sturgeon
$28.99
0
Baked Salmon
$26.99
0
Chunk Of Large Whitefish
$21.99
0
Sarri's Combination Fish Platter
$37.99
Slices of sturgeon, novie salmon, smoked white fish & baked salmon Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, cream cheese & a NY bagel or two on the side
0
Old Fashioned Favorites
Cheese Blintzes
$15.99
(3) three homemade crepes your choice of: cheese strawberry blueberry served with sour cream or big apple sauce
0
Matzoh Breil
$2.99
Scrambled or pancake style with big apple sauce
0
My Fair Latkes - Potato Pancakes (3)
$15.99
Served with sour cream or big apple sauce
0
Knishes
Our Homemade Giant Knish
$8.99
Choice of potato kasha meat corned beef & pastrami
0
A Little Something On The Side
Our Homemade Giant Knish
$8.99
Choice of: potato - kasha - meat corned beef and pastrami
0
Potato Pancake (1)
$5.99
0
French Fries
$6.49
0
Mashed Potatoe
$4.99
0
Baked Potato
$4.99
With butter & sour cream
0
Fried Potato Skin
$9.99
With cheddar cheese & bacon bits
0
Potato Salad
$4.99
0
Macaroni Salad
$4.99
0
Cole Slaw
$4.99
0
Kasha Varnishkes
$7.99
0
Fried Onion Rings
$7.99
0
Sauteed Onions
$3.29
0
Sauerkraut
$2.49
0
Oven Baked Beans
$4.99
0
Cherry Peppers
$3.99
0
Sweet Red Peppers
$3.99
0
Dill Pickled Tomtatoes
$5.99
0
Sides
Side Of Bacon
$7.99
0
Side Of Turkey Sausage
$6.99
0
Side Of Breakfast Sausage (2 Pcs)
$5.99
0
Thick Cut Virginia Ham Steak
$5.99
0
Side Of Home Fries
$5.99
0
Ny Bagel, Bialy, Baked Roll Or Toast With Cream Cheese
$3.99
0
Buttered Ny Bagel, Bialy, Baked Roll Or Toast
$2.49
0
Cinnamon Toast
$2.49
0
Side Of Sliced Bread
$2.49
2 slices
0
Side Of Cream Cheese
$2.49
0
Desserts
The Classic Plain Cheesecake
$9.99
0
Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake
$11.99
0
Topped With Blueberries Or Cherries
$10.99
0
All Chocolate Cheesecake
$9.99
0
Truffle Torte Cheesecake
$10.99
A combination of our famous chocolate mousse & award-winning cheesecake
0
Gluten Free Cheesecake
$9.99
0
Cakes, Pies, & More
Chocolate Seven Layer
$9.49
0
Chocolate Fudge Layer Cake
$9.49
0
Black Forest Cake
$9.49
0
Chocolate Mousse Cake
$9.49
0
Hershey's 5th Ave Peanut Butter & Chocolate Cream Pie
$9.49
0
Deep Dish Apple Pie
$9.49
Add a scoop of ice cream 3.00
0
Fresh Strawberry Shortcake
$9.49
0
Carrot Cake
$9.49
0
Lemon Coconut Cake
$9.49
0
Red Velvet Cake
$9.49
0
Cream Pies
$9.49
Choice of chocolate, banana, lemon chiffon, or coconut cream
0
Other Desserts
Jumbo Black & White Cookie
$3.49
0
Raisin & Nut Rugelach
$5.99
3 pieces
0
Chocolate Chip Cookies
$4.49
3 pieces
0
Chocolate Babka
$5.99
0
Jumbo Pecan Nut Brownie
$9.49
0
Apple Strudel
$5.49
0
Fresh Fruit Cup
$7.99
0
Fresh Fruit Cup - Small
$4.99
0
Big Apple Sauce
$3.49
0
Rice Pudding
$4.49
0
Vanilla Or Chocolate Ice Cream
$5.99
0
Fruits and Juices
Orange Juice
$3.99
0
Grapefruit, Apple, Cranberry Or Tomato Juice
$3.49
0
Capuccino
$4.49
0
Iced Capuccino
$4.49
0
Espresso, Latte
$4.49
0
Iced Coffee Or Iced Tea
$3.99
0
Cofee - Reg Or Decaf
$2.99
100% columbian, vanilla or hazlenut
0
Tea - Reg, Decaf, Green
$2.99
0
Milk
$2.79
0
Chocolate Milk
$2.29
0
Hot Chocolate
$2.99
0
All Fountain Soda
$3.29
Featuring pepsi products
0
Canned Sodas
$3.49
Dr. browns & pepsi products
0
Ny Style Egg Cream
$3.49
0
Spring Water
$3.29
Sparkling or flat
0
Lemonade
$3.49
0
Vanilla Or Chocolate Shake
$5.99
0
Ice Cream Soda
$5.99
0
DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.
People Are Reading
Popular Brands
-
Applebee's Menu2.7 -
Arby's Menu3.7 -
Burger King Menu3.4 -
Chick-fil-A Menu3.8 -
-
Cook Out Menu1.5 -
-
-
KFC Menu3.2 -
McDonald's Menu2.9 -
-
-
Pizza Hut Menu3.3 -
-
Wendy's Menu2.9 -
-
Red Lobster Menu1.4 -
-
-
