Carmella's Pizzeria Middletown Menu and Prices

$1.79

$1.89

$1.99

$1.99

$1.89

$7.39

Baked golden brown and served with a side of marinara sauce.

$8.99

Includes 10-12 wings baked to perfection, served plain, spicy, teriyaki, BBQ, honey BBQ or east-west (a tasty combination of BBQ and teriyaki) with your choice of ranch or blue cheese.

$8.29

Half a pound of wings baked to perfection, served plain, spicy, teriyaki, BBQ, honey BBQ or east-west (a tasty combination of BBQ and teriyaki) with your choice of ranch or blue cheese.

$2.99

Mouth watering garlic bread served with a side of our homemade basil marinara sauce.

$4.79

Mozzarella, Parmesan, crumbled blue cheese and goat cheese.

$6.99

Roasted garlic foccacia bread with marinara dipping sauce.

$6.39

A side of three homemade meatballs smothered in basil marinara sauce.

$9.95

Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper rings.

$9.95

Pepperoni, salami, ham, provolone, artichokes and croutons. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, cro

$9.95

Ham, turkey, American cheese, artichokes and hard boiled egg. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, c

$9.95

Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper rings.

$9.95

Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper rings.

$9.95

Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper rings.

$9.95

Roasted shrimp with Cajun spices served with mixed greens. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, crou

$9.95

Baked chicken glazed with apricot marmalade and roasted almonds. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives

$9.95

Caramelized pineapple and honey roasted sour apples. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons a

$9.95

Seasoned tuna, sliced red onion, cilantro and capers. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons

$9.95

Baked chicken breast golden brown and tossed with Buffalo ranch dressing. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, bla

$9.95

Served with artichokes and feta cheese. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pep

$9.95

Baked chicken breast, Dijon ranch, cilantro, basil and shaved prosciutto. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, bla

$9.95

Roasted garlic and fresh lemon. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper ring

$13.29 - $20.29

Fresh basil, mascarpone, goat cheese and Parmesan. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Pepperoni, sausage, chourico, ham, bacon and meatballs. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, peppers and black olives. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Ham, pineapple and extra mozzarella. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Prosciutto, spinach, broccoli, roasted garlic and Parmesan. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Pepperoni, sausage, chourico, bacon, peppers, mushrooms, onions and black olives. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Sweet shrimp, pesto, red onion, tomato and mascarpone. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Sweet Italian sausage, pesto, goat cheese and caramelized onions. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Baked chicken, pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, and mushrooms. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Garlic oil, feta, goat, mascarpone, Parmesan along with mozzarella. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Garlic oil, crumbled bacon, with garlic butter and mozzarella cooked then topped with lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Garlic oil, American cheese, shaved steak, cooked mushrooms, caramelized onions and roasted peppers. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Garlic oil, American cheese, shaved steak, cooked mushrooms, caramelized onions, crumbled blue cheese and hot sauce. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Brushed with garlic oil and loaded with spinach and feta cheese and Parmesan. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Garlic oil, baked chicken, roasted garlic, feta cheese, tomatoes and rosemary. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Baked chicken, Buffalo ranch sauce, hot sauce, crumbled blue cheese and fresh cilantro. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

BBQ sauce, baked chicken, red onion and tomatoes. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$13.29 - $20.29

Our own Buffalo ranch sauce, baked chicken, red onions, crumbled blue cheese, banana peppers and fresh cilantro. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella.

$9.19 - $12.49

$9.29

Stuffed with a mixture of ricotta, mozzarella, Parmesan, provolone and red sauce, baked to perfection then brushed with garlic oil and dashed with Parmesan served with a side of homemade marinara.

$12.95

Turn a specialty pizza into a calzone. Stuffed with a mixture of ricotta, mozzarella, Parmesan, provolone and red sauce, baked to perfection then brushed with garlic oil and dashed with Parmesan serv

$8.89

Shaved steak, onions, mushrooms, hot sauce, blue cheese, American cheese and tomato.

$8.89

Oven roasted chicken, Parmesan, provolone, romaine, tomatoes, crisp bacon and Caesar dressing.

$8.89

Sweet shrimp, Cajun spice, tamari, cilantro, banana pepper, provolone, tomatoes, lettuce and hot sauce.

$8.89

Oven baked breaded tenders, provolone, goat cheese, tomatoes and Buffalo ranch.

$8.89

Balsamic marinated chicken, cucumbers, feta cheese, red onions, tomatoes and provolone.

$8.89

Baked ham, caramelized pineapple, mozzarella cheese, roasted peppers and sliced red onion.

$8.89

Roasted chicken breast, candied onions, spinach, provolone and tomato.

$8.89

The favorites from the salad with provolone, spinach and Greek dressing chicken marmalade - baked chicken, lettuce, tomato, provolone, almonds, apricots and honey mustard.

$12.99

Homemade marinara infused with roasted garlic, fresh basil and spices. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$12.99

Our homemade meatballs. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$12.99

Plump sweet Italian sausage links. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$12.99

Pasta tossed with prosciutto, chicken, spinach, roasted garlic, diced tomatoes, and broccoli and in a chicken basil olive oil broth. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$12.99

Baked breaded eggplant, mozzarella and marinara. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$12.99

Pasta with oven roasted shrimp, sweet peppers, tomatoes and mushrooms in a mascarpone rose marinara sauce. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$12.99

Four jumbo shells stuffed with ricotta and fresh herbs topped with marinara and mozzarella. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$12.99

Baked breaded chicken, mozzarella and marinara. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$12.99

Mozzarella, Parmesan, ricotta and mascarpone. Tossed and oven baked. Topped with Parmesan and basil.

$8.29

Genoa, ham, cooked salami, pepperoni and provolone.

$8.29

Sliced white meat and provolone.

$8.29

Baked ham and provolone.

$8.29

Sliced paper thin and topped with provolone.

$8.29

Albacore tuna with a touch of mayonnaise and provolone.

$8.29

Tomato, olives, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, spinach, broccoli and provolone cheese.

$8.29

Served with mushroom, onions and American cheese.

$8.29

Homemade and topped with our own marinara sauce and provolone.

$8.29

With sweet Italian sausage with meatballs. Homemade and topped with our own marinara sauce and provolone.

$8.29

Sausage and sweet peppers with marinara and provolone.

$8.29

Baked breaded tenders, our own marinara sauce and provolone.

$8.29

Baked breaded eggplant, our own marinara sauce and provolone.

$8.29

Baked with onions, peppers, marinara and provolone.

$8.29

Baked breaded chicken tenders, lettuce, tomato and provolone.

$8.29

Crisp bacon, lettuce and tomato.

$8.29

Black Angus burger cooked medium well for safety served with your choice of cheese.

$8.29

Flavorful black pastrami served with melted Swiss cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Genoa, ham, cooked salami, pepperoni and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Sliced white meat and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Baked ham and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Sliced paper thin and topped with provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Albacore tuna with a touch of mayonnaise and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Tomato, olives, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, spinach, broccoli and provolone cheese. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Served with mushroom, onions and American cheese. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Homemade and topped with our own marinara sauce and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Sausage and sweet peppers with marinara and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Baked breaded tenders, our own marinara sauce and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Baked breaded eggplant, our own marinara sauce and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Baked with onions, peppers, marinara and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Baked breaded chicken tenders, lettuce, tomato and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Crisp bacon, lettuce and tomato. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$7.39 - $8.29

Black Angus burger cooked medium well for safety served with your choice of cheese. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$8.29

Flavorful black pastrami served with melted Swiss cheese. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese.

$1.00

Your choice of flavor.

$0.99

$1.99

$1.59

$1.79

$3.99

$2.99