Carl's Tavern Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 99 votes
Carl's Tavern Logo

Choose My State

CO

Carl's Tavern Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Teasers

Deviled Eggs

$7.00

Classic, bleu cheese-bacon and today's mystery flavor

The Business

$8.00

Hand-cut fries, applewood bacon, dubliner white cheddar, buttermilk ranch, scallions

Carl's Wings

$10.00

1# of marinated jumbo wings. Choice of: famous dry rub, sweet chipotle bbq, buffalo, jamaican jerk, tuff guy, ninja

Craft Sausages

$8.00

Ground, cased and cured in house, with grilled peppers and onions, house made left hand milk stout mustard

Fried Green Tomatoes

$7.00

Cornmeal dusted locally grown tomatoes, creole aioli

Pimento Cheese

$10.00

Housemade cheese blend, with grilled bread

Steak Tartare

$15.00

Certified angus beef tenderloin, ribeye and ny strip, house-cured mustard, smoked maldon salt, with grilled bread

Carl's Country Picnic

$35.00

An assortment fried green tomatoes, pimento cheese and grilled bread, craft sausages, deviled eggs, jar of pickles, corn bread

Grilled Artichokes

$13.00

Chargrilled, roasted garlic aioli, grilled lemon

Old-School Onion Rings

$8.00

Hand breaded, carl's sauce & buttermilk ranch

Cast Iron Cornbread

$7.00

Baked to order in a cast iron skillet, served with honey butter

Three Onion Soup Gratin

$8.00

Port wine reduction, crouton, gruyere cheese

Today's Soup

$5.00

Fresh, seasonal & delicious

Catfish Fritters

$13.00

Colorado catfish, potato crusted, creole aioli

Nuggets of Love

$12.00

Beer-braised pork - crispy fried, shishito peppers, cayenne-cider glaze, love

Oysters on the 1/2 Shell

$2.50

Served with housemade cocktail sauce and red wine mignonette

Deviled Eggs

$7.00

Classic, bleu cheese-bacon and today's mystery flavor

The Business

$8.00

Hand-cut fries, applewood bacon, dubliner white cheddar, buttermilk ranch, scallions

Carl's Wings

$10.00

1# of marinated jumbo wings. Choice of: famous dry rub, sweet chipotle bbq, buffalo, jamaican jerk, tuff guy, ninja

Craft Sausages

$8.00

Ground, cased and cured in house, with grilled peppers and onions, house made left hand milk stout mustard

Fried Green Tomatoes

$7.00

Cornmeal dusted locally grown tomatoes, creole aioli

Pimento Cheese

$10.00

Housemade cheese blend, with grilled bread

Steak Tartare

$15.00

Certified angus beef tenderloin, ribeye and ny strip, house-cured mustard, smoked maldon salt, with grilled bread

Carl's Country Picnic

$35.00

An assortment fried green tomatoes, pimento cheese and grilled bread, craft sausages, deviled eggs, jar of pickles, corn bread

Grilled Artichokes

$13.00

Chargrilled, roasted garlic aioli, grilled lemon

Old-School Onion Rings

$8.00

Hand breaded, carl's sauce & buttermilk ranch

Cast Iron Cornbread

$7.00

Baked to order in a cast iron skillet, served with honey butter

Three Onion Soup Gratin

$8.00

Port wine reduction, crouton, gruyere cheese

Today's Soup

$5.00

Fresh, seasonal & delicious

Catfish Fritters

$13.00

Colorado catfish, potato crusted, creole aioli

Nuggets of Love

$12.00

Beer-braised pork - crispy fried, shishito peppers, cayenne-cider glaze, love

Oysters on the 1/2 Shell

$2.50

Served with housemade cocktail sauce and red wine mignonette


LettuceAdd bacon $2, add chicken $5, add steak $9

The Wedge

$9.00

Applewood bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, tomato, buttermilk ranch

Just a House Salad

$5.00

Chopped greens, cucumber, tomato, dubliner white cheddar, croutons, choice of dressing

Mixed Greens Salad

$9.00

Mache, frisee & arugula, gala apples, red onion, marcona almonds, colorado chevre, citrus vinaigrette

Country Spinach

$12.00

Nueske's country ham, haystack mountain chevre, candied pecan brittle, hard boiled egg, apple-bourbon vinaigrette

Steak Salad

$17.00

6oz char-grilled certified angus beef sirloin, grilled romaine hearts, bleu cheese crumbles, roasted red peppers, chimichurri vinaigrette

The Wedge

$9.00

Applewood bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, diced tomato, buttermilk ranch

Just a House Salad

$5.00

Chopped greens, cucumber, tomato, dubliner white cheddar, croutons, choice of dressing

Mixed Greens Salad

$9.00

Mache, frisee & arugula, gala apples, red onion, marcona almonds, colorado chevre, citrus vinaigrette

Country Spinach

$12.00

Nueske's country ham, haystack mountain chevre, candied pecan brittle, hard boiled egg, apple-bourbon vinaigrette

Steak Salad

$17.00

6oz char-grilled certified angus beef sirloin, grilled romaine hearts, bleu cheese crumbles, roasted red peppers, chimichurri vinaigrette


MainGluten free and vegetarian options available

Market Fresh Fish

$

Flown-in fresh, never frozen. Server will provide chef's preparation

Chicken Fried Steak

$17.00

7oz certified angus beef steak, country gravy

Rotisserie Chicken

$16.00

Herb-brined, 1/2 colorado chicken, roasted chicken-sherry jus, smashed potatoes

Baby Back Ribs

$19.00

1/2 slab of slow-cooked, apple-cider brined baby backs, sweet chipotle bbq sauce and house-made cole slaw

Mole Braised Pork

$25.00

12 oz yampa valley farms pork shank, braised in housemade ancho chili mole, served over war eagle mills cheese grits

Fried "Sunday" Chicken

$17.00

Family recipe - fried chicken breast and drumstick, smashed potatoes with country gravy

Lobster-N-Grits

$25.00

War eagle mills cheese grits, blackened maine lobster, tomato-bacon broth

Pan Seared Diver Scallops

$25.00

Sweet pea risotto, 'crispy' hazel dell mushrooms, local pea sprouts, lemon brown butter

Pot Roast

$19.00

Twelve-hour braised certified angus beef chuck roast, country vegetables, smashed potatoes, pan gravy

Chef's Vegetable Tasting

$17.00

A sampling of fresh, local vegetables and vegetarian accompaniments

Chicken Fried Steak

$17.00

7 oz Certified Angus steak, country gravy

Chicken Fried Steak

$17.00

7oz certified angus beef steak, country gravy

Rotisserie Chicken

$16.00

Herb-brined, 1/2 colorado chicken, roasted chicken-sherry jus, smashed potatoes

Baby Back Ribs

$19.00

1/2 slab of slow-cooked, apple-cider brined baby backs, sweet chipotle bbq sauce and house-made cole slaw

Mole Braised Pork

$25.00

12 oz yampa valley farms pork shank, braised in housemade ancho chili mole, served over war eagle mills cheese grits

Fried "Sunday" Chicken

$17.00

Family recipe - fried chicken breast and drumstick, smashed potatoes with country gravy

Lobster-N-Grits

$25.00

War eagle mills cheese grits, blackened maine lobster, tomato-bacon broth

Pan Seared Diver Scallops

$25.00

Sweet pea risotto, 'crispy' hazel dell mushrooms, local pea sprouts, lemon brown butter

Pot Roast

$19.00

Twelve-hour braised certified angus beef chuck roast, country vegetables, smashed potatoes, pan gravy

Chef's Vegetable Tasting

$17.00

A sampling of fresh, local vegetables and vegetarian accompaniments


TrimmingsAll trimmings serve 2-3 people

3 Cheese Mac

$8.00

Twice Baked Potato

$6.00

Green Beans & Bacon

$5.00

Seasonal Vegetables

$5.00

Crispy Brussels Sprouts

$6.00

Grilled Sweet Corn

$4.00

With honey butter

Smashed Potatoes

$4.00

Hand-Cut Fries

$4.00

Sweet Pea Risotto

$6.00

Cheddar Grits

$5.00

With tomato bacon broth

3 Cheese Mac

$8.00

Twice Baked Potato

$6.00

Green Beans & Bacon

$5.00

Seasonal Vegetables

$5.00

Crispy Brussels Sprouts

$6.00

Grilled Sweet Corn

$4.00

With honey butter

Smashed Potatoes

$4.00

Hand-Cut Fries

$4.00

Sweet Pea Risotto

$6.00

Cheddar Grits

$5.00

With tomato bacon broth


SandwichesServed with choice of hand-cut fries or side salad - sub old-school onion rings for $2. Substitute a housemade quinoa - black bean burger or rotisserie chicken at no cost

Just a Plain Burger

$13.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, lettuce, beefsteak tomato, red onion, house-cured pickles

The Howler

$14.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, dubliner white cheddar, caramelized onions, roasted garlic aioli

The Sleeping Giant

$18.00

Hand packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, american cheese, topped with 6oz of our carolina pulled pork, sweet chipotle bbq sauce, cole slaw and house-cured pickles

The Boomer

$14.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, gruyere, hazel dell mushrooms, roasted garlic aioli

Carolina Pulled Pork

$15.00

Served open-faced, sweet chipotle bbq, cole slaw and housemade pickles on top

French Dip

$15.00

Thinly sliced certified angus beef ribeye, caramelized onions, gruyere, toasted baguette, au jus

The Ski Jumper

$15.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, pepperjack, onion ring, applewood bacon, sweet chipotle bbq

The Mother-In-Law

$15.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, bleu cheese, caramelized onions, applewood bacon

The Duke

$15.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, applewood bacon, housemade pimento cheese and fire roasted jalapenos

Carl's Chicken Club

$13.00

Rotisserie chicken, applewood bacon, pepperjack, baby spinach, avocado, chipotle aioli

Reuben

$15.00

Carl's custom-cured pastrami. Gruyere, 1000 island, sauerkraut on toasted marble rye

Just a Plain Burger

$13.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, lettuce, beefsteak tomato, red onion, house-cured pickles

The Howler

$14.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, dubliner white cheddar, caramelized onions, roasted garlic aioli

The Sleeping Giant

$18.00

Hand packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, american cheese, topped with 6oz of our carolina pulled pork, sweet chipotle bbq sauce, cole slaw and house-cured pickles

The Boomer

$14.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, gruyere, hazel dell mushrooms, roasted garlic aioli

Carolina Pulled Pork

$15.00

Served open-faced, sweet chipotle bbq, cole slaw and housemade pickles on top

French Dip

$15.00

Thinly sliced certified angus beef ribeye, caramelized onions, gruyere, toasted baguette, au jus

The Ski Jumper

$15.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, pepperjack, onion ring, applewood bacon, sweet chipotle bbq

The Mother-In-Law

$15.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, bleu cheese, caramelized onions, applewood bacon

The Duke

$15.00

Hand-packed, 6oz certified angus beef patty, applewood bacon, housemade pimento cheese and fire roasted jalapenos

Carl's Chicken Club

$13.00

Rotisserie chicken, applewwod bacon, pepperjack, baby spinach, avocado, chipotle aioli

Reuben

$15.00

Carl's custom-cured pastrami. Gruyere, 1000 island, sauerkraut on toasted marble rye


Hand-Cut Steaks and ChopsChoose any of these sauces: port wine demi glace, chimichurri, brandy-peppercorn, maitre'd butter. Add 6oz shelled lobster to any steak or chop - $17

8oz Filet Mignon

$33.00

Chargrilled, certified angus beef

14oz Ny Strip

$31.00

Chargrilled, certified angus beef

14oz Ribeye

$30.00

Chargrilled, well marbled, certified angus beef

Double-Cut Pork Chop

$23.00

Apple-cider brined yampa valley farms pork, cider glaze

Lamb T-Bones

$27.00

Two, locally raised, 8oz summit creek ranch lamb chops


Craft

Signature "Man"hattan

$15.00

We start with hand-selected barrels of 10-year four rose's bourbon, bottled at barrel strength - uncut and unfiltered in all its glory. Then we expertly blend it with giuseppe carpano's antica vermou

Midnight in Kentucky

$12.00

W.l. Weller 'antique' 107 proof, averna amaro, regan's orange bitters, 'kentucky' simple syrup

Arriba Margarita

$10.00

Carl's tavern 'double reposado' herradura, grand marnier, agave nectar, fresh squeezed orange and lime juice

Rocky Mountain Mule

$10.00 - $35.00

Leopold bros 'silver tree' colorado vodka, gosling's ginger beer, fresh lime juice. Id deposit required for copper mug

Carl's Old Fashioned

$11.00

Buffalo trace carl's tavern single barrel, luxardo cherries, orange bitters, sugar cube

The Jezebel

$11.00

Hendrick's gin, st. Germaine elderflower liqueur, fresh lemon juice, blood orange bitters

A Port in a Storm

$12.00

Flor de cana 12 year rum, domaine canton ginger liqueur, fresh ginger, lemongrass, lime juice, demerara sugar

The Gypsy

$12.00

Hangar one kaffir lime vodka, fresh juices, muddled blackberry, finished with la marca prosecco

Signature "Man"hattan

$15.00

We start with hand-selected barrels of 10-year four rose's bourbon, bottled at barrel strength - uncut and unfiltered in all its glory. Then we expertly blend it with giuseppe carpano's antica vermou

Midnight in Kentucky

$12.00

W.l. Weller 'antique' 107 proof, averna amaro, regan's orange bitters, 'kentucky' simple syrup

Arriba Margarita

$10.00

Carl's tavern 'double reposado' herradura, grand marnier, agave nectar, fresh squeezed orange and lime juice

Rocky Mountain Mule

$10.00 - $35.00

Leopold bros 'silver tree' colorado vodka, gosling's ginger beer, fresh lime juice. Id deposit required for copper mug

Carl's Old Fashioned

$11.00

Buffalo trace carl's tavern single barrel, luxardo cherries, orange bitters, sugar cube

The Jezebel

$11.00

Hendrick's gin, st. Germaine elderflower liqueur, fresh lemon juice, blood orange bitters

A Port in a Storm

$12.00

Flor de cana 12 year rum, domaine canton ginger liqueur, fresh ginger, lemongrass, lime juice, demerara sugar

The Gypsy

$12.00

Hangar one kaffir lime vodka, fresh juices, muddled blackberry, finished with la marca prosecco


Wine

Featured Wine

$

A special selection, chosen for its uniqueness and exceptionality. Your server will provide the description

Featured Wine

$

A special selection, chosen for its uniqueness and exceptionality. Your server will provide the description


Red Wines

Pinot Noir

$9.00 - $35.00

Thomas henry wines, napa valley, california

Malbec

$8.00 - $31.00

Alberti 154, mendoza, argentina

Old Vine Zinfandel

$8.00 - $31.00

0zv wines, lodi, california

Cabernet Sauvignon

$8.00 - $31.00

Shannon ridge, lake county, california

Merlot

$7.00 - $27.00

"The velvet devil" charles smith wines, columbia valley, washington

Syrah

$9.00 - $35.00

"The crusher", clarksburg, california

Red Wine Blend

$9.00 - $35.00

"Rhiannon" rutherford ranch vineyards, california

Pinot Noir

$15.00 - $59.00

2009 sanford, santa rita hills, california

Pinot Noir

$9.00 - $35.00

Thomas henry wines, napa valley, california

Malbec

$8.00 - $31.00

Alberti 154, mendoza, argentina

Old Vine Zinfandel

$8.00 - $31.00

0zv wines, lodi, california

Cabernet Sauvignon

$8.00 - $31.00

Shannon ridge, lake county, california

Merlot

$7.00 - $27.00

"The velvet devil" charles smith wines, columbia valley, washington

Syrah

$9.00 - $35.00

"The crusher", clarksburg, california

Red Wine Blend

$9.00 - $35.00

"Rhiannon" rutherford ranch vineyards, california

Pinot Noir

$15.00 - $59.00

2009 sanford, santa rita hills, california


White Wines

Prosecco

$7.00 - $31.00

La marca, italy

Chardonnay

$9.00 - $35.00

Byron winery, santa barbara county, california

Riesling

$8.00 - $31.00

Fess parker, santa barbara county, california

Sauvignon Blanc

$7.00 - $27.00

William hill, central coast, california

Pinot Grigio

$7.00 - $27.00

Due torri, delle venezie, italy

Chardonnay

$12.00 - $47.00

Laguna ranch vineyards, russian river valley, california

Prosecco

$7.00 - $31.00

La marca, italy

Chardonnay

$9.00 - $35.00

Byron winery, santa barbara county, california

Riesling

$8.00 - $31.00

Fess parker, santa barbara county, california

Sauvignon Blanc

$7.00 - $27.00

William hill, central coast, california

Pinot Grigio

$7.00 - $27.00

Due torri, delle venezie, italy

Chardonnay

$12.00 - $47.00

Laguna ranch vineyards, russian river valley, california


Colorado DraftsProudly-keeping the taps lined with our finest local brews

Craft Seasonal

$

Colorado's finest of the season

Denver Pale Ale

$4.00

Great divide brewing co.- Denver

90 Schilling

$5.00

Odell brewing co.- Fort collins

Mama's Little Yella Pils

$5.00

Oskar blues brewing - lyons

Budweiser

$4.00

Anheuser busch - Fort collins

Agave Wheat

$5.00

Breckenridge brewery- breckenridge

"Amputator" Ipa

$5.00

Butcherknife brewing co.- Steamboat springs

Milk Stout (Nitro)

$5.00

Left hand brewing co. - Longmont

Craft Seasonal

$

Colorado's finest of the season

Denver Pale Ale

$4.00

Great divide brewing co.- Denver

90 Schilling

$5.00

Odell brewing co.- Fort collins

Mama's Little Yella Pils

$5.00

Oskar blues brewing - lyons

Budweiser

$4.00

Anheuser busch - Fort collins

Agave Wheat

$5.00

Breckenridge brewery- breckenridge

"Amputator" Ipa

$5.00

Butcherknife brewing co.- Steamboat springs

Milk Stout (Nitro)

$5.00

Left hand brewing co. - Longmont


Bottles of Beer

Budweiser Beers

$3.50

Coors Beers

$3.50

Miller Lite

$3.50

Fat Tire

$4.00

Victoria

$4.00

Dos Xx Lager

$4.00

Blue Moon

$5.00

Colette Farmhouse Ale

$5.00

Mirror Pond Pale Ale

$5.00

Odell Ipa

$5.00

Heineken

$5.00

Stella Artois

$5.00

Stella Cidre

$5.00

Omission Pale Ale

$5.00

La Fin Du Monde

$6.00

Funkwerks Saison

$6.00

Yeti Stout

$8.00

22 ounce

Budweiser Beers

$3.50

Coors Beers

$3.50

Miller Lite

$3.50

Fat Tire

$4.00

Victoria

$4.00

Dos Xx Lager

$4.00

Blue Moon

$5.00

Colette Farmhouse Ale

$5.00

Mirror Pond Pale Ale

$5.00

Odell Ipa

$5.00

Heineken

$5.00

Stella Artois

$5.00

Omission Pale Ale

$5.00

La Fin Du Monde

$6.00

Funkwerks Saison

$6.00

Yeti Stout

$8.00

22 ounce


Cans

American Lager of the Week

$3.00

Dale's Pale Ale

$4.00

Modus Hoperandi Ipa

$4.00

Apricot Blonde Ale

$4.00

Boddington's

$5.00

American Lager of the Week

$3.00

Dale's Pale Ale

$4.00

Modus Hoperandi Ipa

$4.00

Apricot Blonde Ale

$4.00

Boddington's

$5.00


Happy HourDaily 4-6

$2 Off All Wells House Wines and Drafts

Price may varies

Well Shots

$4.00

Domestic Bottles

$3.00

American Lager of the Week

$2.00

Wings

$0.50

Oysters on the 1/2 Shell

$2.00

$2 Off All Wells House Wines and Drafts

Price may varies

Well Shots

$4.00

Domestic Bottles

$3.00

American Lager of the Week

$2.00

Wings

$0.50

Oysters on the 1/2 Shell

$2.00


Lunch SpecialitiesServed with Choice of Hand-Cut Fries OR Side Salad Sub Old-School Onion Rings For $2

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$11.00

Hand-breaded chicken tenders, shredded romaine, diced.tomato, housemade blue cheese dressing

Carl's Grilled Cheese

$10.00

Dubliner white cheddar, Gruyere, Applewood bacon, beefsteak tomato on fresh sourdough bread

Chicken Salad

$13.00

Rotisserie chicken, pecans, grapes, celery heart, avocado, pesto aioli on Harvest Moon Bakery sourdough

BLT

$9.00

Applewood bacon, romaine heart, beefsteak tomato, pesto aioli, fresh sourdough

Blackened Catfish Sandwich

$10.00

6 oz Colorado catfish filet, baby spinach, shaved red onion, beefsteak tomato, Creole aioli


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading