Carlos & Gabby's Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 118 votes
Carlos & Gabby's Logo

Choose My State

NY

Carlos & Gabby's Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Super Starters

Buffalo Fingers

$6.95

tender strips of all white meat chicken, batter dipped and cooked to a golden brown, served with celery sticks and creamy avocado ranch dressing.

Honey BBQ Zingers

$6.95

tender strips of all white meat chicken, batter dipped and cooked to a golden brown. smothered in our delicious honey bbq sauce. served with creamy avocado ranch dressing.

Buffalo Zingers

$6.95

tender strips of all white meat chicken, batter dipped and cooked to a golden brown. smothered in our tangy pepper sauce. served with a creamy avocado sauce.

Wild Wings

$5.95

juicy chicken wings, seasoned and cooked to a golden brown, then spun in your favorite carlos & gabby's sauce: honey barbecue, buffalo style (hot or mild) jamaican style or teriyaki.

Five Alarm Chili With Nachos

$5.95

wake up your taste buds with our sweet and spicy blend of southwest seasonings with ground steak, grilled onion, black beans, fire-roasted corn, roasted peppers and whatever else we can find in the k

Hot Dog

Price may varies

100% beef hot dog grilled to perfection. served on a roll. $2.79, $0.50 extra to add creamy jalapeno sauce, $1.00 extra for chili.

Jalapeno Poppers

$5.95

a classic mexican treat. fresh jalapeno peppers stuffed with tofutti, battered in our homemade cornbread coating and cooked to a golden brown. served with a side of creamy salsa dip.

Creamed Spinach Dip

$4.95

with pita chips if this isn't the best creamed spinach you've ever tasted... then you probably probably tasted better creamed spinach somewhere else. but seriously, it's amazing.


Homemade Soups

Matzo Ball Gumbo

$4.49

fresh veggies, chunks of chicken, mini matzo balls and a delicious vegetable broth.

Fat Free Butter Nut Squash

$4.49

fresh squash & sweet potato pureed with sauteed vegetables in a delicate broth.

Kansas City Steak Soup

$4.49

try a bowl of this old-time kansas city tradition, loaded with strips of juicy steak.


Ensalada(Salads). With your choice of homemade dressings: caesar low-fat balsamic vinaigrette, honey mustard dijon, creamy italian, avocado ranch & thousand island.

House Garden Salad

$7.95

mixed greens with tomato, red onion, shredded carrot and your choice of dressing.

Caesar Salad

$7.95

crisp romaine, diced red onion and garlic croutons, tossed with our creamy caesar dressing. $2.00 extra for grilled chicken $2.49 extra for gilled steak.

BBQ Chicken Salad

$11.95

crisp romaine, ripe tomato, avocado ranch dressing, breaded chicken strips, grilled onion, topped with crispy tortilla strips and a drizzle of tangy bbq sauce.

Tostada Salad Bowl

$8.95

crispy tortilla bowl with mixed greens, red onion, olives, shredded carrot, roasted corn, salsa fresca & guacamole. $2.00 extra for grilled chicken, $2.49 extra for gilled steak.


Burritos

Burrito Classic

$3.49

warm soft flour tortilla wrapped around mashed pinto beans with diced red onions, jalapeno and tangy sauce.

Vegetarian Burrito

$4.99

warm soft flour tortilla wrapped around mexican rice, mashed pinto beans, shredded lettuce, pico-de-gallo and zesty guacamole.

Five Alarm Chili Burrito

$5.99

warm soft flour tortilla wrapped around mexican rice, mashed pinto beans, our zesty homemade chili, jalapeno, creamy sauce and diced red onion.

Bandito Beef Burrito

$5.99

warm soft flour tortilla wrapped around seasoned ground steak, mexican rice, mashed pinto beans, shredded lettuce, pico-de-gallo and zesty guacamole.

Bandito Chicken Burrito

$5.99

warm soft flour tortilla wrapped around grilled strips of chicken, mexican rice, mashed pinto beans, shredded lettuce, pico-de-gallo and zesty guacamole.

The Papa Grilled Grande

$6.99 - $7.49

we start off with a warm flour tortilla and add your choice of filings wrapped around mashed pinto beans, shredded lettuce, pico-de-gallo and tangy taco sauce. then we grill it golden brown. with gri


Fiesta Platters

Chimmichurri Steak Platter

$14.95

tender strips of marinated and grilled argentinean steak. served with crisp homemade onion rings, sauteed veggies, chopped salad and chimmichurri dip.

Grilled Chicken Platter

$12.95

all white meat chicken fillets marinated and char-grilled to perfection. served with crispy shoestring fries, sauteed vegetables and chopped salad.

Boneless BBQ Rib Platter

$14.95

juicy boneless beef ribs slow roasted in our tangy bbq sauce. served with crispy shoestring fries, sauteed vegetables, chopped salad and a side of bbq sauce.


Fajita Platters

Fajita Platters

$14.95

your choice of: carne asada, grilled chicken, bbq shredded beef, shwarma platter.


Taco Spot

The Amigo

$2.79

choose soft or crispy corn tortilla. seasoned ground steak, fresh lettuce, pico de gallo, jalapeno peppers and tangy taco sauce. delicioso.

The Pollo

$2.79

choose soft or crispy corn tortilla. grilled and seasoned strips of chicken, fresh lettuce, pico de gallo, jalapeno peppers and tangy taco sauce. nice.

The Chabibi

$2.79

choose soft or crispy corn tortilla. baby chicken seasoned shwarma style, fresh lettuce, pickles and tahini sauce. taim.

The Asdada

$2.99

choose soft or crispy corn tortilla. tender strips of marinated asada steak, fresh lettuce, pico de gallo, jalapeno peppers and tangy taco sauce.

Carlos' Taco Supreme

$3.49

grilled soft flour tortilla layered with refried beans and wrapped around a crispy corn tortilla shell. then we fill it with your favorite ingredients like crisp lettuce, pico-de-galo, jalapenos, gua


Signature Subs & WrapsOur many delicious sandwiches can be served on either a toasted hoagie or a wrap.

The Philly Steak

$11.95

thin slices of grilled rib eye steak with caramelized onions, peppers & mushrooms. smothered in our famous philly sauce on a toasted hoagie.

Gabby's Favorite

$11.95

thin slices of grilled rib eye steak with caramelized onions, mushrooms & shredded lettuce and ripe tomato with. gabby's special steak sauce on a toasted hoagie.

The Cedarhurst

$9.95

batter dipped chicken breast cooked to a golden brown, served on a toasted hoagie with grilled pastrami, caramelized onion, shredded lettuce, ripe tomato and honey dijon dressing.

The Pollo Del Sol Wrap

$9.95

marinated and char-grilled chicken breast, crisp romaine, pico-de-gallo, grilled onion & pastrami, and roasted red pepper dressing, served on a warm tortilla.

The Turnpike Club

$9.95

oven roasted turkey breast piled high on a toasted hoagie with grilled pastrami, lettuce, ripe tomato, pickles & thousand island dressing.

The Godfather

$9.95

dried italian beef, genoa salami, honey-smoked turkey breast, crisp romaine, ripe tomato, red onion, black olives, sweet pepper rings with creamy italian dressing on a toasted hoagie.

The Buffalo Finger/ Zinger Wrap

$9.95

tender strips of breaded chicken fingers, or tangy zingers, crisp romaine, ripe tomato, avocado ranch dressing, in a warm tortilla.

BBQ Shredded Beef

$12.95

slow cooked brisket, shredded and marinated in our tangy bbq sauce. served with sweet carmelized onions on a toasted hoagie.

Grilled Shwarma Wrap

$8.95

grilled baby chicken and turkey, seasoned shwarma style with grilled onions, pickles and tahina, in a warm tortilla.

The Nashville

$11.95

tender rib eye steak southern fried to a crisp golden brown, served on a hoagie with caramelized onions, shredded lettuce, ripe tomato and home-style southern gravy.

The 24/ 7

$8.95

home style egg omelet piled on a toasted hoagie with grilled veggies, french fries, grilled pastrami and creamy sauce.

Grilled Chicken Wrap

$9.95

marinated and char-grilled chicken breast on a warm flour wrap with crisp romaine, garlic croutons and our homemade creamy caesar dressing.

Grilled Portobello Wrap

$7.95

marinated and grilled portobello mushroom, shredded romaine lettuce and julienne veggies, served with low fat balsamic vinigrette.

The Brooklyn

$11.95

hot corned beef, grilled onions, homemade saurkraut, thousand island dressing on a toasted hoagie.

The Hungry Heifer

$12.95

grilled rib-eye steak, oven roasted turkey, slow-cooked brisket, shredded romaine, red onion, creamy horseradish dip on a toasted hoagie.

The Washington Ave. Club

$9.95

marinated & char-grilled chicken breast, grilled pastrami, shredded romaine, ripe tomato, thousand island dressing on a toasted hoagie.


Flamed Grilled Burgers

Junior Burger

$4.49

quarter pounder flame grilled and served on a soft roll with ketchup and a pickle.

Classic Single Burger

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger, flame grilled and served on a soft roll with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, grilled onion, pickles, and special dressing. $0.75 extra for grilled onions, $0.50 extra for jalapeno sau

Classic Double Burger

$8.95

two 4 oz. steak burgers, flame grilled and served on a soft roll with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, grilled onion, pickles, and special dressing. $0.75 extra for grilled onions, $0.50 extra for jalapen

The Texas Wrangler

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger, flame grilled and served on a soft roll with crisp romaine, ripe tomato, grilled pastrami, homemade onion rings, mesquite bbq and creamy sauce. giddyup pardner.

Panini Burger

$6.95

6 oz. steak burger, flame grilled and served on a panini with shredded romaine, ripe tomato, red onion & pickles. topped with our special dressing.

The Ranchero

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger, flame grilled and served on a soft roll with caramelized onions grilled pastrami and our tangy bbq sauce.

The Magic Mushroom

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger on a soft roll, smothered with fresh grilled mushrooms, caramelized onions and creamy jalapeno sauce.

The La Jolla

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger on a soft roll with crisp shredded lettuce, ripe tomato, jalapenos, refried beans & creamy ranch dressing.


Lowfat Chicken Burgers

Junior Burger

$4.49

quarter pounder flame grilled and served on a soft roll with ketchup and a pickle.

Classic Single Burger

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger, flame grilled and served on a soft roll with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, grilled onion, pickles, and special dressing. $0.75 extra for grilled onions, $0.50 extra for jalapeno sau

Classic Double Burger

$8.95

two 4 oz. steak burgers, flame grilled and served on a soft roll with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, grilled onion, pickles, and special dressing. $0.75 extra for grilled onions, $0.50 extra for jalapen

The Texas Wrangler

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger, flame grilled and served on a soft roll with crisp romaine, ripe tomato, grilled pastrami, homemade onion rings, mesquite bbq and creamy sauce.

Panini Burger

$6.95

6 oz. steak burger, flame grilled and served on a panini with shredded romaine, ripe tomato, red onion & pickles. topped with our special dressing.

The Ranchero

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger, flame grilled and served on a soft roll with caramelized onions grilled pastrami and our tangy bbq sauce.

The Magic Mushroom

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger on a soft roll, smothered with fresh grilled mushrooms, caramelized onions and creamy jalapeno sauce.

The La Jolla

$8.95

6 oz. steak burger on a soft roll with crisp shredded lettuce, ripe tomato, jalapenos, refried beans & creamy ranch dressing.


Mucho Nachos

Nachos Piqueno

$2.99

tri-color nachos with a side of salsa fresca. add jalapeno creamy sauce. $1.00.

Garden Nachos

$4.99

tri-color nachos topped with red onions, fire-roasted corn, black olives, jalapeno peppers and pico de gallo. served with guacamole and salsa fresca.

Nacho Grande

$8.49

tri-color nachos layered with our zesty chili, mashed pinto beans, jalapeno creamy sauce, pico de gallo, red onions, fire-roasted corn and black olives. served with guacamole and salsa fresca. $1.99


The Spud Bar

Original

$3.95

served with a creamy spread.

Creamy Sauce & Chives

$3.95

we told you what's in it already... and chives on top.

Philly Steak

$5.95

stuffed with grilled rib eye steak, sliced razor thin and topped with creamy sauce.

Mixed Vegetable

$4.95

stuffed with garden vegetables and topped with creamy sauce.

Creamed Spinach Dip

$4.95

comes loaded with our delicious spinach dip.

Chili

$5.95

stuffed with our 5-alarm chili and topped with a creamy sauce mild.


Southwest Eggrolls

The Philly Steak

$5.95

thin slices of grilled rib eye steak with caramelized onions. served with a side of avocado ranch dressing.

The Pastrami King

$5.95

grilled pastrami, fried egg and caramelized onions. served with a side of honey dijon mustard.

The Los Alamos

$5.95

we lost the battle at los alamos, but this tasty roll will win your taste buds over. seasoned ground steak, red peppers & fire-roasted corn. served with a side of avocado dressing.

The Chabibi Roll

$5.95

grilled baby chicken and turkey seasoned shwarma-style with grilled onions & tahina dripping sauce.

Grilled Taquito Dog

$5.95

grilled 100% beef hot dog in a crispy flour tortilla with spicy mustard sauce.


On The Sides

Shoestring Fries

$3.49

golden brown, just the way you like 'em. $1.00 extra to add chili, $0.50 extra to add creamy sauce.

Spicy Fries

$3.49

hot to the touch and your tastebuds.

Homemade Onion Rings

$3.49

batter dipped and fried to crispy perfection.

Side Of Guacamole

$4.95

your favorite avocado treat, served up carlos & gabby's style.

Jicamas Slaw

$2.95

a mexican twist on an american favorite.

Mexican Rice

$2.49

this mexican rice is made with rice, onion, green bell pepper, garlic, tomatoes, and spices. surely will enjoy.

Small Chili

$1.00

a zesty chili loaded with beef, beans, bell peppers in a savory sauce with a kick you won't forget.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading