Carey Lake Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 92 votes
Carey Lake Logo

Choose My State

NY

Carey Lake Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Calamari

$7.95

Fried or sauteed

Artichoke French

$5.95

Shrimp Cocktail

$8.95

Chicken Fingers

$5.75

Clams Casino 6

$7.95

Stearned Clams

$7.95

Mozzarella Sticks

$4.75

Homemade Onion Rings

$3.95

Garlic Bread

$3.50

Soup

$2.50 - $3.50

Homemade daily selection


Salad and Salad Plates

Dinner Salad

$2.75

Garden Salad

$4.75 - $5.75

Mixed greens with cheese tomato, cucumber and onions.

Caesar Salad

$5.95 - $7.95

Crisp romaine greens tossed with bacon, parmesan cheese, croutons and caesar dressing

Julianne Salad

$7.95

Mixed greens with ham turkey cheese, tomato, cucumber, onion egg


PastaAll entrees served with salad

Pasta Bowl

$9.95

Spaghetti, linguine shells with tomato sauce or oil and garlic choice of one topping meatballs, sausage or mushrooms extra items $1.50

Gnocchi Arugula

$9.95

Sausage, fresh mushrooms, arugula and roma tomatoes sauteed and tossed in garlic white brath

Past Alfredo

$10.95

Our traditional recipe with fresh cream and parmesan cheese add chicken $2.00

Shrimp and Artichoke Scampi

$13.95

Sauteed with garlic in a buttery broth

Lemon Garlic Chicken and Broccoli

$13.95

Fresh boneless neck clams, chopped clams steamed in garlic wine broth

Linguine with Red or White Clam Sauce

$11.95

Six fresh little neck clams, chopped clams steamed in garlic wine broth

Shells Rosa

$11.95

Parma ham, mushrooms, peas sauteed in cream with parmesan cheese

Seafood Fra Diavlo

$15.95

Shrimp, scallops, clams in a spicy tomato sauce over linguine


Steak and MeatAll entree served with salad and two sides

Grilled Frenched Pork Chops (Double)

$15.95

BBQ Ribs (Full)

$14.95

Chicken Francaise (Single)

$12.95

Boneless breast in egg, sauteed in lemon butter and sherry

Chicken Parmigiano

$12.95

Breaded in fresh bread crumbs, baked with mozzarella, tomato sauce

Veal French

$15.95

Medallions of veal dipped in egg sauteed in lemon and sherry

Veal Parmigiano

$15.95

Tender veal breaded in fresh bread crumbs baked with mozzarella tomato sauce

New York Strip Steak Cut from the Loin

$14.95 - $27.95

My fair lady, loin clark gable, loin al capone add sauteed mushrooms $1.00 add sauteed onions $1.00

Steak Formagio

$20.95

Grilled new york strip smothered with melted blen cheese

Steak Diane

$21.95

New york strip coated with coarse black pepper sauteed in brandy with a butter and demiglaze

Slow Roasted Boneless Prime Rib

$14.95 - $27.95

My fair lady, clark gable, al caponeadd sauteed mushrooms $1.00 add sauteed onions $1.00

BBQ Ribs (1/2)

$9.95

Hickory smoked and with our own sauce

Grilled Frenched Pork Chops (Single)

$11.95

BBQ Ribs (Full)

$14.95

Hickory smoked and with our own sauce


SeafoodAll entrees served with salad and two sides

Fried Shrimp

$13.95

5 Jumbo shrimp breaded and fried to a golden brown served with cocktail sauce

Broiled Scallops

$14.95

Broiled to perfection in lemon butter and white wine

Fried Scallops

$14.95

1/2 Pound large scallops breaded and fried to a golden brown served with cocktail sauce

FishermanÂ’s Platter

$15.95

Haddock, scallops and shrimp cooked the way you like fried or broiled

Fish Fry Large

$10.95

Fresh haddock battered, breaded or broiled served with lartar sauce

Fish Fry Small

$8.95

Battered or breaded only served with tartar sauce


Burger and SandwichesServed with homemade potato chips add french fries $1.00

Black Angus Burger

$5.95

1/3 ground black angus beef

Black Angus Burger with Cheese

$6.25

Steak Bomber

$8.95

Shaved steak with peppers, onions, mushrooms and mozzarella on french bread

Buffalo Burger

$7.95

Ground free range bison meat

Italian Patty

$5.95

Sweet italian sausage on hard roll

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$5.95

Boneless chicken breast marinated and grilled, served on a roll with lettuce, tomato and mayo

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

$6.95

Freshly breaded chicken breast with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese

Trash Plate

$8.95

Hot dog or hamburger with homemade macaroni salad homefries

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$6.95

Slow smoked pork with our own bbq sauce served on a hard roll

Fried Haddock

$6.95

Fresh breaded haddock filet served with tartar on a roll

Veggie Burger

$5.95

Grilled garden veggie burger with lettuce tomato and mayo on a hard roll


Extras

Mushrooms

$1.00

Bacon

$1.00

Cheese

$0.30

Hot Sauce

$0.60

Peppers and Onions

$1.50

Gravy

$0.60

Bleu Cheese

$0.60


Specialty SandwichesAdd french fries $1.00

Old Fashion Wraps

$6.95

Chicken, shrimp, roast beef, vegetable made with lettuce, tomato, onion and creamy italian dressing

Open Faced Melts

$6.95

Chicken salad or tuna with swiss cheese on grilled rye

Classic Reuben Melts

$6.95

Corned beef or turkey with sauerkraut, swiss cheese on grilled rye with 1000 island dressing

The Deli Board

$5.95

Ham, turkey or roast beef choice of cheese, lettuce and tomato

Triple Decker Club Sandwich

$6.95

Turkey ham or roast beef with bacon, lettuce, tomato and cheese


Side Orders

French Fries

$2.25

Home Fries

$2.25

Baked Potato

$2.00

BBQ Beans

$2.75

Cottage Cheese

$2.00

Fresh Vegetable

$2.25

Pasta

$3.95

Counts as two

Salt Potatoes

$2.25

Macaroni Salad

$2.25

Coleslaw

$2.00

Applesauce

$2.00

Homemade Potato Chips

$2.00


Kids Meals

Hot Dog

$5.25

Served with french fries or applesauce and soda

Chicken Fingers

$5.25

Served with french fries or applesauce and soda

Grilled Cheese

$5.25

Mozzarella Sticks

$5.25


Desserts

Homemade Ice Cram

Price may varies

Strawberry Shortcake

Price may varies


Beverages

Soda, Iced Tea, Lemonade and Juice

$1.55

Fresh Ground Coffee

$1.25

Gourmet Teas

$1.25

Hot Cocoa

$1.25

Milkshake

$3.75

Root Beer Float

$3.25


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading