Captain's Tavern Menu and Prices

4.9 based on 365 votes
Captain's Tavern Logo
Seafood
Sushi

Choose My State

FL

Captain's Tavern Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Starters

Gravlax

$12.00

house cured salmon, capers, onion, honey dijon sauce w/ warm toast

Tuna Carpaccio

$10.00

olive oil, sea salt, caper, onions, parmesan, warm toast

Cracked Conch

$11.00

seasoned, dredged in flour, quickly fried

Blue Crab Fritters

$10.00

Ipswich Steamers

$14.00

broth & drawn butter

Lobster & Mango Cocktail

$19.00

basil herb dressing

King Crab Cocktail

$19.00

Vietnamese Spring Rolls

$8.00

(4) fried w/ shrimp, crab & dipping sauce

Potato Skins

$5.00

Potato Skins

$1.00

melted cheddar cheese add

Scallop Ceviche

$12.00

citrus juices & herbs


Appetizers

Shrimp Cocktail

$10.00

cocktail sauce

Topless Clams 6/12

$9.00

cocktail sauce

Topless Oysters 6/12

$9.00

horseradish, cocktail sauce

Russian Oysters

$18.00

topped w/ egg white, yolk, sour cream, green onions, lump fish caviar

Seared Sesame Tuna

$12.00

cracked pepper, sesame seeds, wasabi, pickled ginger, soy sauce

Black Skillet Mussels

$12.00

pan roasted, garlic butter

Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato

$10.00

olive oil, balsamic reduction, onion, basil

Fried Calamari Salad

$13.00

thai style - tomatoes, onions, herbs, sweet chili sauce

Smoked Fish Spread

$10.00

jalepeno, crisp plantain chips

Conch Salad

$11.00

diced conch, orange & lime juice, onion, peppers, herbs, spices

Topless Northern Oysters

$2.50

horseradish, cocktail sauce

Oysters 2 Ways

$15.00

rockefeller & crab meat w/ cream cheese

Escargot

$12.00

garlic butter, puff pastry

Rings And Things (Calamari)

$11.00

lightly breaded, fried w/ marinara

Mussels Provencal

$12.00

red sauce, onions, spices

Stuffed Mushrooms

$10.00

seafest crab stuffing, cheese

Lobster & Mango Cocktail

$19.00

basil herb dressing

King Crab Cocktail

$19.00

Northern Oysters

$2.50

Tuna Carpaccio

$10.00

olive oil, sea salt, caper, onions, parmesan, warm toast

Blue Crab Fritters

$9.00

Roasted Tomato Caprese Salad

$10.00

fresh mozzarella, arugula, balsamic reduction, basil chiffonade

Lobster Nuggets - Thai Style

$15.00

fried chunks of lobster, tomato, onions, herbs, sweet chili sauce

Ipswich Steamers

$14.00

broth & drawn butter

Salmon Tartare

$12.00

shallots, capers, chives. lemon juice, tomato, avocado

Soft Shell Crab

$10.00

seasoned, dredged in flour, quickly fried over carrot and cilantro salad

Gravlax

$12.00

house cured salmon, capers, onion, honey dijon sauce w/ warm toast

Vietnamese Spring Rolls

$8.00

(4) fried w/ shrimp, crab & dipping sauce

Shrimp Cocktail

$10.00

cocktail sauce

Smoked Fish Spread

$10.00

jalepeno, crisp plantain chips

Topless Oysters

$16.00 - $9.00

horseradish, cocktail sauce

Oysters Rockefeller

$16.00

baked w/ creamed spinach, pernod, anisette

Black Skillet Mussels

$12.00

pan roasted, garlic butter

Rings And Things (Calamari)

$11.00

lightly breaded, fried w/ marinara

Coconut Shrimp

$9.00

citrus dipping sauce

Potato Skins

$5.00

Potato Skins

$1.00

melted cheddar cheese add

Stuffed Mushrooms

$10.00

seafest crab stuffing, cheese

Conch Salad

$11.00

diced conch, orange & lime juice, onion, peppers, herbs, spices

Mussels Provencal

$12.00

red sauce, onions, spices

Crab Cake

$11.00

mango pineapple salsa

Topless Clams

$16.00 - $9.00

cocktail sauce

Conch Fritters

$10.00

cocktail & tarter sauce

Topless Cold Water Oysters

$2.50

horseradish, cocktail sauce

Fried Oysters

$11.00

lightly breaded & fried

Russian Oysters

$18.00

topped w/ egg white, yolk, sour cream, green onions, lump fish caviar

Fried Calamari Salad

$13.00

thai style - tomatoes, onions, herbs, sweet chili sauce

Escargot

$12.00

garlic butter, puff pastry

Clams Casino

$10.00

diced red & green peppers, onion, bacon, spices

Seared Sesame Tuna

$12.00

cracked pepper, sesame seeds, wasabi, pickled ginger, soy sauce

Spicy Octopus Salad

$10.50

sliced octopus, asian slaw, spicy sauce, sesame seeds


Soups, Chowders & More

England Clam

$6.00

Key West Conch

$6.00

Salad & Soup

$10.00

house salad & soup

Salad & Soup

$2.00

lobster bisque add

Soup Of The Day

$6.00

Maine Lobster Bisque

$8.00

Soup & Fried Fish Sandwich

$12.00

fresh fish pieces & your choice of soup

Soup & Fried Fish Sandwich

$2.00

lobster bisque add


Salads

House

$5.00

lettuce, tomato, cucumber & carrots

Fresh Fruit

$8.00

seasonal fresh fruits, green salad, cottage cheese, banana bread

Shrimp And Crab Louie Salad

$11.00

egg, tomato, cucumber, black olives, 1000 island dressing

Caesar

$6.00

crisp romaine tossed with our classic dressing

Caesar

$10.00

topped with grilled chicken or dolphin

Caesar

$13.00

topped with fried oysters

Crab Salad

$11.00

lump crab meat, salad greens, fruit, banana bread

Fresh Tuna

$11.00

yellowfin tuna, made into fresh tuna salad

Shrimp

$11.00

steamed shrimp, mayo, celery, spices on a green salad

Greek Salad

$10.00

romaine, iceberg, greek olives, feta cheese, pepperoncini, tomato

Captain's

$10.00

grilled dolphin or chicken on a large salad of lettuce, onions, peppers, cucumber, tomato and croutons

Lobster

$19.00

maine lobster chunks, mayo, spices & herbs over ribbons of lettuce

Blackened Tuna

$13.00

lettuce, tomatoes, olives, peppers & feta cheese

Oyster Caesar

$13.00

caesar salad, fried oysters enough

Oyster Caesar

$1.25

for two extra oyster

Gourmet Greens

$5.00

tender baby greens

Arugula Salad

$9.00

arugula, gorgonzola, pear, candied pecans

Caesar

$6.00

crisp romaine tossed with our classic dressing

Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato

$10.00

olive oil, balsamic reduction, onion, basil


Sandwiches

Maine Lobster Roll

$19.00

maine lobster salad, shredded lettuce on a toasted roll

Grilled Dolphin

$9.00

fresh dolphin fillet grilled topped with mushrooms, onions and melted cheese

Sizzling Reuben

$9.00

corn beef, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing & swiss cheese served open face on rye

Oyster Po Boy

$10.00

fresh oyster lightly fried served on a toasted roll with remoulade also available with shrimp or ipswich clams

Bahama Mama

$9.00

lightly fried filet of sole, american cheese, sliced tomatoes, tarter sauce, on grilled bahama bread

Grilled Tuna Melt

$9.00

fresh yellowfin tuna salad topped with swiss and cheddar cheese

Grilled Chicken Breast

$8.00

french fries and coleslaw

Hamburger

$6.00

french fries and cole slaw

BBQ Pulled Pork

$7.00

fries & cole slaw


Pasta

Seafood Alfredo

$12.00

shrimp, scallops, seafest crab, cream sauce, fettuccine

Linguine With Clams

$10.00

marinara sauce or garlic butter w/ fresh clams

Dolphin Puttanesca

$11.00

dolphin, olives, anchovies, tomatoes & capers

Seafood Tortellini

$11.00

cheese tortellini, crab, shrimp & tomato sauce

Heart Smart Pasta

$11.00

shrimp, scallops, artichoke hearts, black olives, tomato, mushrooms, olive oil, garlic, wine sauce w/ whole wheat pasta


Entrées

Trout Macadamia

$12.00

mango butter

Stuffed Salmon

$13.00

with spinach-feta stuffing, creamy dill sauce

Blackened Grouper Reuben

$11.00

grilled w/ cajun spices, 1000 island dressing, sauerkraut, swiss chesse, rye bread

Meatloaf

$10.00

mashed potatoes & gravy

Fish Tacos

$11.00

fried fish, chipotle mayo, cabbage & mango salsa

Lobster Ravioli

$14.00

mushrooms & sherry cream

Tilapia Florentine

$12.00

creamy spinach sauce

Thai Lobster Salad

$14.00

fried lobster meat, thai chili sauce w/ mixed greens

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$7.00

fries, cole slaw

Shrimp Gumbo

$12.00

chicken, sausage, white rice

Lobster Thermidor

$39.00

maine lobster chunks, bechamel - white wine, shallots, tarragon, mustard

King Crab Legs

$29.00

1 lb. steamed w/ herb butter

Crispy Branzino

$25.00

whole mediterranean seabass w/ spicy asian tamarind sauce, jasmine rice

Fresh Skate Wings

$23.00

pan seared - preserved lemon butter, capers

Tuna Niçoise - Mediterranean Style

$25.00

olive oil, onions, garlic, tomatoes, anchovies, black & green olives, herbs, spices

Pan Seared Shrimp

$23.00

roasted tomato jam, grilled vegetables, polenta

Shrimp & Scallops Meli Melo

$23.00

chicken broth, preserved lemon butter, worcestershire, onions, thyme, twice cooked potatoes

Thai Green Curry Shrimp

$23.00

* green curry, red pepper, bamboo shoots, green peas, herbs, jasmine rice

Pan Seared Snapper W/ Thai Spices

$23.00

lemon grass, kaffir lime, garlic, jasmine coconut rice

Cajun Dolphin

$21.00

cajun spices topped w/ fried garlic, shallots, tomato, capers, balsamic vinegar, parsley

Pan Seared Grouper

$23.00

preserved lemon, julienne carrot, green peas, polenta

Jumbo Lobster Tail

$39.00

grilled, drawn butter

Dijon Roasted Snapper

$23.00

crème fraiche, dijon mustard, shallots, capers w/ creamed spinach topped tomato

Seared Scallops With Grilled Cauliflower

$23.00

capers, raisins, almonds, drizzled w/ balsamic glaze

Petite Filet Mignon & Seared Scallops

$25.00

grilled filet w/romesco sauce (contains almonds), scallop w/ tomato ginger vinaigrette & mashed potatoes

Shrimp With Vegetables

$21.00

stir fried w/ carrots, mushrooms, snow peas, bok choy, onions, peppers w/ jasmine rice

Yellowtail Matecumbe

$22.00

diced tomatoes, basil, shallots, vinegar, olive oil, lemon juice, onions, capers

Miso Glazed Salmon

$23.00

miso, sesame oil, honey, soy sauce over green beans, asparagus, tomato

Curried Shrimp & Scallops

$23.00

shrimp, sea scallops, island curry sauce, yellow rice

Branzino Fillet

$23.00

choice of meli melo or lemon caper butter


Fresh Seafood - Grilled, Broiled, Baked & Fried

Snapper

$12.00

Grouper

$12.00

Farm Raised Catfish

$9.00

Salmon

$12.00

Sea Scallops

$13.00

Bay Scallops

$10.00

Dolphin

$11.00

Scrod

$10.00

Yellowtail

$12.00

Tuna

$13.00

Tilapia

$10.00

Sole/Flounder

$11.00


Fresh Seafood - Lightly Breaded & Quickly Fried

Oysters

$13.00

Ipswich Belly Clams

$17.00

Calamari

$11.00

Coconut Or Breaded Shrimp

$12.00


Fresh Seafood - Toppings

Island Style

$2.00

onions, peppers, celery, mushrooms, tomatoes, olives, spices, wine.

Honey Mustard

$1.00

local honey, spicy brown mustard.

Sumptuous Style

$2.00

topped w/ melted cheddar, mushrooms & parsley

Yum Yum Sauce

$2.00

green onions, sesame seeds, lemon grass, chives w/ teriyaki sauce

Blackened

$1.00

Vera Cruz

$2.00

* onions, peppers, tomatoes, capers, olives


Beer

Budweiser

$3.50

Michelob Ultra

$3.50

Coors Light

$3.50

Key West Sunset Ale

$4.00

Pabst Blue Ribbon

$3.50

Becks Dark

$4.00

germany

Amstel Light

$4.00

holland

Stella Artois

$4.00

belgium

Negro Modelo

$4.00

mexico

Bud Light

$3.50

Miller Lite

$3.50

O'Doul's

$3.50

nonalcoholic

Sam Adams

$4.00

Becks

$4.00

germany

Bass Ale

$4.00

uk

Red Stripe

$4.00

jamaica

Kirin Ichiban

$4.00

japan

Corona

$4.00

mexico

Amstel Light

$4.00

holland

Becks Dark

$4.00

germany

Bud Light

$3.50

Coors Light

$3.50

Heineken

$4.00

holland

Key West Sunset Ale

$4.00

Michelob Ultra

$3.50

Negro Modelo

$4.00

mexico

Pabst Blue Ribbon

$3.50

Stella Artois

$4.00

belgium

Bass Ale

$4.00

uk

Becks

$4.00

germany

Budweiser

$3.50

Corona

$4.00

mexico

Heineken Light

$4.00

holland

Kirin Ichiban

$4.00

japan

Miller Lite

$3.50

O'Doul's

$3.50

nonalcoholic

Red Stripe

$4.00

jamaica


Chowder & Bisque

Key West Conch

$6.00

England Clam

$6.00

Lobster Bisque

$8.00


Lightly Breaded Quickly Fried

Ipswich Belly Clams

$20.00

Combination Platter

$23.00

fish, scallops, shrimp, oysters, clams

Soft Shell Crabs

$22.00

Crispy Snapper (Whole Fish)

$25.00

spicy asian tamarind sauce, jasmine rice

Farm Raised Catfish

$15.00

Butterfly Shrimp

$20.00

panko bread crumbs & fried

Cracked Conch

$19.00

Oysters

$20.00


Baked To Perfection

Stuffed Shrimp

$22.00

seafest crab stuffing yellow rice or baked potato

Shrimp Scampi

$20.00

white wine, butter, garlic, parmesan w/ rice or linguine

Scrod Supreme

$19.00

margarine, bread crumbs

Stuffed Dolphin

$23.00

seafest crab stuffing, cheddar cheese

Tuna Balsamico

$25.00

balsamic onions & shallots w/ wasabi mashed potatoes

Flounder Imperial

$23.00

crab meat, onions, peppers, shallots, seasoned bread crumbs, cream, dill sauce


Seafood Pasta

Seafood Jambalaya

$21.00

shrimp, scallops, andouille sausage, tasso ham, spicy jambalya seasoning w/ rice or linguine

Paella

$21.00

shrimp, scallops, mussels, clams, chorizo sausage

Seafood Alfredo

$19.00

shrimp, scallops, seafest crab, cream sauce, fettuccine

Seafood Marinara

$19.00

shrimp, scallops, seafest crab, red sauce, linguini

Seafood Risotto

$20.00

sea scallops, shrimp, shiitaki mushrooms, asparagus, arborio rice

Shellfish AJ

$19.00

clams, shrimp, mussels, squid, clam juice, butter, garlic, linguine


Fresh Seafood

Snapper

$20.00

Grouper

$20.00

Yellowtail

$20.00

Salmon

$20.00

Tilapia

$16.00

Tuna

$24.00

Sea Scallops

$23.00

Dolphin

$19.00

Swordfish

$23.00

Hog Fish

$20.00

Scrod

$19.00


Toppings

Island Style

$2.00

onions, peppers, celery, mushrooms, tomatoes, olives, spices, wine.

Yum Yum Sauce

$2.00

green onions, sesame seeds, lemon grass, chives w/ teriyaki sauce

Meli Melo

$2.00

chicken broth, preserved lemon butter, worcestershire, onion, thyme

Honey Mustard

$1.00

local honey, spicy brown mustard.

Vera Cruz

$2.00

* onions, peppers, tomatoes, capers, olives

Sumptuous Style

$2.00

topped w/ melted cheddar, mushrooms & parsley

Oregano

$1.00

spiced bread crumbs, oregano, parmesan, wine

Imperial Stuffing

$6.00

crab meat, onions, peppers, shallots, seasoned bread crumbs, cream

Blackened

$1.00

A La Paulo

$3.00

white wine, mushrooms, garlic


Favorites

Cedar Plank Salmon

$23.00

sun-dried tomato aioli

Pompano Macadamia

$23.00

macadamia nut crust, mango chutney butter, gourmet greens

Yellowtail Macadamia

$24.00

macadamia nut crust, mango chutney butter, gourmet greens

Shrimp Macadamia

$22.00

macadamia nut crust, mango chutney butter, gourmet greens

Pan Roasted Sea Bass

$29.00

shallots, shiitake mushrooms, basil, tomatoes

Lump Crab Cakes

$25.00

sautéed golden brown, asian slaw, mango, pineapple salsa

Red King Crab Legs

$29.00

1 lb. steamed w/ herb butter

Grilled Dolphin With Tropical Fruit Salsa

$22.00

over black beans, mango pineapple salsa, crisp plantains

Poached Salmon

$23.00

dill sauce, fresh steamed vegetables


Captain's Choice

Admiral's Platter

$30.00

broiled - lobster, fish, stuffed shrimp, shrimp scampi, scallops, oyster rockefeller

Jamaican Style Yellowtail (Whole Fish)

$25.00

simmered w/ orange juice, allspice, thyme, tomato, onions, scallions w/ rice & peas

Catalana Seafood

$28.00

clams, mussels, shrimp, squid, fish, lobster, portuguese red sauce, andouille sausage, spices, garlic bread

Caribbean Snapper (Whole Fish)

$25.00

grilled whole w/ rice & peas, plantains

Snapper Ginger (Whole Fish)

$25.00

fried, asian ginger sauce


Lobster

Maine Lobster

Price may varies

Florida Lobster Tail

Price may varies

Whole Florida Lobster

Price may varies


Land Lovers

Porterhouse

$27.00

grilled, onion rings

Filet Mignon

$29.00

grilled, mushrooms w/ asparagus

Churrasco

$23.00

chimichurri, pickled onions, yellow rice & plantains

Surf & Turf

$32.00

top sirloin, 8oz. florida lobster tail

Cowboy Rib Eye

$27.00

grilled, onion rings

Strip Steak

$26.00

grilled, mushrooms

Reef & Beef

$23.00

top sirloin, shrimp scampi

Rack Of Lamb

$30.00

marinated, grilled, honey dijon glaze, vegetable medley

Macadamia Chicken Breast

$17.00

macadamia crusted, mango chutney butter, yellow rice & plantains


Sides

Sautéed Spinach

$2.50

Steamed Broccoli

$2.50

Sweet Potato Fries

$2.00

Steamed Carrots

$2.50

Vegetable Medley

$6.50


Dessert

Apple Pie

$5.00

Bread Pudding

$6.00

with rum sauce

Pecan Pie

$6.00

w/ chocolate chips

White Chocolate Crème Brulee

$6.00

Banana Cream Pie

$6.00

Chocolate Mousse Cake

$6.00

Key Lime Pie

$5.00

Rum Cake

$5.00

White Chocolate Brownie

$6.00


Sashimi

Tuna

$10.00

maguro

Salmon

$10.00

sake

White Tuna

$10.00

escolar

Yellowtail

$11.00

hamachi

Mackerel

$8.00

saba

Red Clam

$9.00

hokkigai


Sushi

Tuna

$6.00

maguro

Salmon

$6.00

sake

White Tuna

$6.00

escolar

Squid

$5.00

ika

Eel

$6.00

unagi

Shrimp

$6.00

ebi

Crabstick

$5.00

kani

Smelt Roe

$4.00

masago


Combination Platter

Sushi Comboat

$15.00

6pcs sushi nigiri and california roll

Sushi Comboat

$20.00

10 slices sashimi and california roll

Sushi Sashimi Comboat

$25.00

8pcs nigiri, 6 slices sashimi and california roll


Appetizers, Soup & Salad

Edamame

$6.00

Wakame

$6.00

Tataki Tuna

$12.00

seared outside with ponzu and sesame seeds, negi

Gravlax (Salmon Lox)

$12.00

cured in olive oil, salt, crushed pepper, wine and dill. onion, capers, caviar, with dill mustard and creamy horseradish sauce

TigerÂ’s Eye

$10.00

baked nori wrap squid stuffed with salmon, asparagus, avocado, spicy mayo and eel sauce

Spicy Octopus Or Conch

$9.50

sliced cumber, lemon, with kimchee spicy sauce, negi, sesame seeds and seaweed on top

Ceviche (Tuna Or Salmon Or Mixed)

$12.00

red onion, mango, cilantro, ginger, jalapeno, lime juice, chili sauce


Chef DaleÂ’s Special Soup

Spicy Miso Soup

$12.00

miso, garlic chili sauce, tom yum, shrimp, bok choy, onion, shitake, negi basil served with fried crispy rice balls


CaptainÂ’s Sushi Specials

California.

$3.50 - $6.50

crabstick, avocado, cucumber and smelt roe

Tekka

$3.50 - $5.00

tuna roll

Kappa

$3.50 - $5.00

cucumber roll

Tuna Or Salmon Cali

$3.95 - $8.50

california tuna or salmon

Vegetable

$3.50 - $7.00

assorted vegetables

JB (Bagel)

$4.50 - $8.00

salmon, cheese, cucumber, scallion

Salmon Skin

$3.50 - $7.00

broiled salmon skin, cucumber, scallion

Spicy Tuna

$3.75 - $7.50

tuna, cucumber, scallion and kimchee sauce

Philly

$4.50 - $8.50

salmon lox, cheese, cucumber, scallion

Boston

$8.00 - $4.50

boiled shrimp, cucumber, lettuce, mayo

Ethan Cole Eel

$4.50 - $8.00

eel and cucumber roll

JB Tempura

$9.50

fried crispy jb tempura with spicy mayo and eel sauce

Spider

$10.00

fried softshell crab, roe, avocado, asparagus

Jada

$9.50

shrimp tempura, avocado, crabstick, tempura flakes with spicy mayo and eel sauce

Dragon

$10.00

shrimp tempura, cheese, cucumber and avocado on top

Shrimp Tempura

$9.50

shrimp tempura, crabstick, avocado and smelt roe on top

Volcano

$9.00

california, baked mixed seafood on top

Dancing Eel

$11.00

california eel with roe and scallion on top

Sunshine

$10.00

crabstick, cucumber, cheese topped with salmon

King Crab

$12.00

shrimp tempura, crabmeat, avocado, topped with shrimp

Rainbow

$10.00

california roll, topped with tuna, salmon, whitefish, avocado

Kani-Su (Riceless)

$10.50

crabstick, avocado, smelt roe, cucumber wrap with lite kimchee and rice vinegar

Miami Nice (Riceless)

$10.50

tuna or salmon, avocado, cheese, carrots, lettuce, crabstick, wrapped in cucumber skin with kimchee and ponzu sauce

CaptainÂ’s

$19.00

florida lobster meat, asparagus, tempura crunch, masago, spicy mayo and avocado on top with tower of wakame


Seafood Market MenuBased On Availability * Spicy.

Catfish

Price may varies

Cobia

Price may varies

Cod

Price may varies

Clams

Price may varies

Crab Meat

Price may varies

Dover Sole

Price may varies

Flounder

Price may varies

Fluke

Price may varies

Grouper

Price may varies

Haddock

Price may varies

Halibut

Price may varies

Hog Fish

Price may varies

King Crab Legs

Price may varies

Mackerel

Price may varies

Mahi-Mahi

Price may varies

Mangrove Snapper

Price may varies

Mussels

Price may varies

Mutton Snapper

Price may varies

Oysters

Price may varies

Red Snapper

Price may varies

Scallops

Price may varies

Scottish Salmon

Price may varies

Scrod

Price may varies

Sea Bass

Price may varies

Snow Crab Legs

Price may varies

Squid

Price may varies

Stone Crab Claws

Price may varies

Striped Bass

Price may varies

Swordfish

Price may varies

Tilapia

Price may varies

Triple Tail

Price may varies

Trout

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading