Captain Tony's Pizza Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 142 votes
Captain Tony's Pizza Logo
Italian
Pizza

Choose My State

Captain Tony's Pizza Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Pizza - Crustsyour choice

New York Thin Crust

Price may varies

authentic, take a trip to brooklyn without leaving town, made to be folded when you eat it

Pan Pizza

Price may varies

(famous award winning) the original captain's recipe direct from Italy, our specially seasoned dough is baked to a thick golden brown crust

Garlic Pizza

Price may varies

a white pizza with chopped garlic, oil, grated Romano, and mozzarella cheeses, pan or NY thin

Deep Dish

Price may varies

(Chicago style) extra mozzarella makes this pizza a cheese lovers delight, generous toppings provided at regular prices

Party Sheet Pizza

Price may varies

(biggest in town) the largest pan or NY style we make the perfect pizza for parties! toppings are $0.25 each

Stuffed Pizza

Price may varies

a white pizza with double crust filled with mozzarella and served zesty Italian sauce on the side


Gourmet Pizza Specialties

Pesto

Price may varies

a special blend of green basil sauce loaded with mozzarella cheese

Captain's Classic

Price may varies

pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and cheese, no substitutions please

Five Cheese Pizza

Price may varies

mozzarella, cheddar sharp provolone, Romano and ricotta cheese, add your own toppings

White Clam Pizza

Price may varies

white clam sauce, lots of clams and double cheese

Pizza Primavera

Price may varies

a low fat vegetarian delight broccoli red and green peppers, mushrooms black olives eggplant and cheese

Hawaiian Delight

Price may varies

pineapple, ham, black olives, mozzarella and cheddar cheese

Spaghetti and Meatball Pizza

Price may varies

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Price may varies

tender strips or marinated chicken, tangy BBQ sauce cheddar cheese mozzarella cheese

Captain's Feast

Price may varies

our 'classic' plus the addition of cheddar cheese meatballs and black olives

Captain's Mexican Pizza

Price may varies

spicy meat and tomato sauce topped with 3 kind of peppers onions black olives sliced tomatoes, cheddar and mozzarella cheese

Captain's Cattleman

Price may varies

pepperoni, sausage, ham, salami and meatballs, a hearty meat lovers delight

Calzones

Price may varies

turnover shaped pizza dough filled with ricotta Romano and mozzarella cheeses with sauce on the side

Fillings

Price may varies

same as pizza toppings


Toppings

Toppings

Price may varies

half toppings are charged half price and put on half of the pizza pepperoni, salami, ham, sweet red peppers, black olives, spinach, garlic, provolone cheese, sausage, anchovies, hot peppers, broccoli


Pizza Slices

Pizza Slices

Price may varies

additional toppings, available Monday-Saturday, all pizzas are available on whole wheat dough upon request, no extra charge


Wings

Chicken Wings

Price may varies

(order of 10) oven roasted jumbo wings served 10 to an order, 4 varieties, buffalo style our house specialty, BBQ, garlic butter, Cajun

Garlic Bread

Price may varies

(4 piece order) freshly baked bread topped with our own chopped garlic and herbs seasoning butter with delicious mozzarella cheese

Hot Bread Sticks

Price may varies

strips of baked dough, smothered in cheese and garlic and seasoned for a hot taste, spaghetti sauce on the side


Subsextras: fried green peppers, onions, mushrooms, hot peppers or cheese add $0.30

Captain's Supreme

Price may varies

a combination of three meats with lettuce, tomato and dressing

Ham Sub

Price may varies

with lettuce, tomato and dressing

Turkey Breast Sub

Price may varies

with lettuce, tomato and dressing

Roast Beef Sub

Price may varies

Tuna Sub

Price may varies

server with lettuce, tomato and choice of dressing

Steak Sub

Price may varies

tender shaved ribeye steak on a toasted roll with mozzarella choice of BBQ sauce, Cajun spices or buffalo sauce

Meatball Sub

Price may varies

hot, spicy Italian meatball with lettuce sauce and mozzarella

Eggplant Sub

Price may varies

tender, breaded slices of eggplant with sauce and mozzarella

Baked Chicken Breast Fillet

Price may varies

lettuce, tomato and mayo, choice of: BBQ sauce, Cajun spices, buffalo sauce, or tomato sauce with mozzarella


Dinner

Spaghetti

Price may varies

Baked Ziti with Mozzarella

Price may varies

Stuffed Shells

Price may varies

Baked Lasagna

Price may varies

Baked Eggplant Parmesan

Price may varies

Baked Chicken Breast Parmesan

Price may varies

server over spaghetti with mozzarella


Salads

Garden Salad

Price may varies

with dressing

Antipasto Salad

Price may varies

Cheese Fries

Price may varies

over a pound of cheese fries smothered with provolone and cheddar cheese

Regular Fries

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading